Catholic guy dating a JW girl.. Please help..

  • Thread starter Thread starter jnoelbalana14
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve been married to an LDS woman for 14 years, and I did make the mistake of joining the LDS church. I know deep down that it was a mistake and I should have stood my ground and not joined the church, but I love her and I did what I thought was right at the time. Don’t join their church, it will be a huge mistake.
 
Have you got a divorce with her?
Yes it did end in divorce, but worse than that it shook my faith to the core!
All the advice you have been given is sound; get out while you can, Do you really want to love someone with whom you could never be in full comunion with.
Michel
 
Yes it did end in divorce, but worse than that it shook my faith to the core!
All the advice you have been given is sound; get out while you can, Do you really want to love someone with whom you could never be in full comunion with.
Michel
What happened to your children? In what religion they were raised?
 
What happened to your children? In what religion they were raised?
My Daughter is 14 years old and wants to be Baptized into the JW Cult. It breaks my heart * pray that the Holy Spirit guides her to Jesus Christ.
Michel*
 
Hi! I’m a devout Catholic. I’ve recently dated a girl who is a Jehovah’s Witness. We love each other very much but religion is really a barrier. Just yesterday,she decided to broke up until I can fully understand her faith more - an allusion the she wishes me to study and eventually convert to her faith. We love each other so much but she’s afraid that we can’t make it in married life if we are from different religion. I don’t want to lose her and it seems the only hope is that I know is to attend their bible studies but I don’t think I’ll convert to them. Please help… I need your advices. Thanks alot…
JL: Are you able to defend Catholic teachings scripturally? Are you able to refute JW teachings scripturally? If not you better learn. She DECIDED to break up until YOU fully understand her faith. I would say If I need to know your faith fully, you need to know my Catholic faith fully also. Make her take six months of RCIA as a condition for you taking six months instruction in her faith. She will NEVER do so I guarantee it the Watchtower will not allow it. She might say I will AFTER you first take JW instructions. Don’t be fooled by this. Make sure you both start at the same time or have her start first.
 
My Daughter is 14 years old and wants to be Baptized into the JW Cult. It breaks my heart * pray that the Holy Spirit guides her to Jesus Christ.
Michel*

At 14 years old, what means does she have to have any knowledge of JW teachings? Does she not live with you?
 
Can the 2 become one and stay one as they are so unequally yoked spiritually from the get-go? Seems very difficult - JW’s unbending, pressure driven people
 
Hi there,
So here’s an interesting perspective for you>

I was a JW and married to a non-jw up until I left the religion.

Overall>

She will not be able to attend Mass with you. I do not believe the organization will allow her to go to Mass or take any sort of classes. This is as of say 2005. Things may have changed, but I strongly doubt it.

She is asking for you to do the studying and such.
A) To be fair: The organization doesn’t make these requirements. This is all her and her family. I have seen it happen before. Uhm. Sometimes it “works” and sometimes it ends in disaster. By “works” I mean that the person converts.
B) You can try to do a study, however, unless you are very, very well educated in your faith, I strongly recommend to talk with other ex-jws (you are welcome to msg me or I can watch for other topics) to get a heads up on their sticking points especially with regards to the Catholic faith. The reason is that understanding the context of the verses they use to debate key points is hands down essential to not getting sucked into it. If you don’t understand, for instance, Colossians and John and Romans, oy. All they have to do is show you 3 verses and they have possibly planted a bug in your head about the divinity of Jesus. The Catholic Ex Jw site is good. I was on there today just browsing through, hadn’t been there in a long while. Not super active, but there are some positively brilliant people on there who you may be able to catch. Jehovahs-witness.net is another decent place for getting the lowdown on things. You are more than welcome to msg me, it’s been awhile, but heh, I remember many things fairly well. The latter website btw has a number of anti-Catholics. But overall, I think you would find some very useful people who could help you grasp the finer points and maybe even help her.
C) Here’s a thought too> If you help HER to start thinking outside of the box, you may find yourself in a completely different predicament. If she leaves her religion, she is up against losing her entire family and her friends. She would basically be starting life over. So, be kind. If she is dating a non-believer, it sounds to me like she’s not that ‘strong’ to begin with. She may have some doubts or she may just be testing the waters. I.e. if she’s not letting the organization tell her who to date, she may find herself questioning other things that they tell her. If that starts to happen, her world will basically unravel. And you will have this love of your life in many, many ways starting life over. Things that others take for granted are suddenly an issue. Politics, mortality, faith in self and faith in others. Planning for the future, working, college/career, kids. Family life.
ugh!

Best wishes in this, I know it isn’t easy.
 
Hi! I’m a devout Catholic. I’ve recently dated a girl who is a Jehovah’s Witness. We love each other very much but religion is really a barrier. Just yesterday,she decided to broke up until I can fully understand her faith more - an allusion the she wishes me to study and eventually convert to her faith. We love each other so much but she’s afraid that we can’t make it in married life if we are from different religion. I don’t want to lose her and it seems the only hope is that I know is to attend their bible studies but I don’t think I’ll convert to them. Please help… I need your advices. Thanks alot…
She just wants you to convert. Please don’t stay with her. Go find a nice Catholic girl to fall in love with. Not a plan, my friend.
 
My advice to you my friend…RUN as far as you can. Believe me…I have experience with a close family member being married to a oneness believer. It’s not fun…for any of the family.
 
I have been thinking about you. I have to add…these cult people are AMAZING manipulators. That is how they get people to convert. Manipulation. My brother didn’t see it, but I wonder if he sees it now that they are married. She coverted to Catholicism to appease everyone, but I don’t think she converted her heart to it. Now I dare say after marriage she is trying to pull herself and my brother out of the Catholic faith. She isn’t a JW, but a oneness Pentecostal Apostolic believer. I believe my brother fell for her because she had a fire of God.

She wants you to study JW for 3 years. Don’t take that study lightly. There hope is that they will brainwash you and indoctrinate you with their beliefs.

I myself could have NEVER married out of the faith. My husband being Catholic was a pre requisite lol!! God blessed me with an amazing man who shares my faith. I love Christ and his true Church to marry out of it.

Sending prayers your way.
 
I have not read all… just until the page n° 5.

I think that most people have made categorical judgements even without knowing about the real aims of the OP’s girlfriend, their reactions… Manipulative girl? She thinks “You must convert, so you will be able to get my flesh”? Please! Be respectful! To make a whore from a non-catholic girl is the same thing that most protestant do with catholics! It has been (at catholic conferences) said again and again to me that I was something like a beast because I was protestant, and I was, but I would never have had this well from someone who has not inside authentic light.

I will give you an advice that has been useful for me. If I have maculated my life, it has been because I have not acted towards God how shoulded be according to His Value. I don’t think that your girlfriend is a horrible thing. But you must to know how pretty are your beliefs. Don’t less to love her, maybe you won’t be able to be her boyfriend nor her spouse but you will be able to be her best friend (in a real truth, not just as a game). But love God more than another. Maybe it is not the time to close you, it is time to open you, but first to God. 😉
 
Hi! I’m a devout Catholic. I’ve recently dated a girl who is a Jehovah’s Witness. We love each other very much but religion is really a barrier. Just yesterday,she decided to broke up until I can fully understand her faith more - an allusion the she wishes me to study and eventually convert to her faith. We love each other so much but she’s afraid that we can’t make it in married life if we are from different religion. I don’t want to lose her and it seems the only hope is that I know is to attend their bible studies but I don’t think I’ll convert to them. Please help… I need your advices. Thanks alot…
Jehovah’s Witnesses are a mess. Rather than start with their outrageous beliefs, inconsistent history, etc. just start out with accepting this fact: they don’t celebrate birthdays, or Christmas. Who would want to date someone that can’t celebrate birthdays?
 
I have not read all… just until the page n° 5.

I think that most people have made categorical judgements even without knowing about the real aims of the OP’s girlfriend, their reactions… Manipulative girl? She thinks “You must convert, so you will be able to get my flesh”? Please! Be respectful! To make a whore from a non-catholic girl is the same thing that most protestant do with catholics! It has been (at catholic conferences) said again and again to me that I was something like a beast because I was protestant, and I was, but I would never have had this well from someone who has not inside authentic light.

I will give you an advice that has been useful for me. If I have maculated my life, it has been because I have not acted towards God how shoulded be according to His Value. I don’t think that your girlfriend is a horrible thing. But you must to know how pretty are your beliefs. Don’t less to love her, maybe you won’t be able to be her boyfriend nor her spouse but you will be able to be her best friend (in a real truth, not just as a game). But love God more than another. Maybe it is not the time to close you, it is time to open you, but first to God. 😉
Protestants aren’t out to brainwash everyone. Major difference.
 
jnoelbalana14, I don’t know if you are still following the answers to your question or not, but if you are, PLEASE do not continue this relationship. Offer thanks to Our Lady and Our Savior that your gf broke it off.

My mother (Methodist) married my father (JW) 60 years ago. She recently told my sister and me that it had been 60 years of pure torture. She said that if her parents had understood the JW belief, they would never have allowed her to marry one. My siblings and I were raised with extreme anti-Catholic bigotry because of my father’s beliefs. Thankfully, the Holy Spirit led my sister into the Church. I will be received at Easter, and our brother is now studying Catholicism. This week, my father viciously attacked my nieces and nephew because of their Catholic belief.

You can’t imagine the pain you will endure if you continue with this young lady. I pray you will heed all the good advise you have gotten on this site.
 
jnoelbalana14, I don’t know if you are still following the answers to your question or not, but if you are, PLEASE do not continue this relationship. Offer thanks to Our Lady and Our Savior that your gf broke it off.

My mother (Methodist) married my father (JW) 60 years ago. She recently told my sister and me that it had been 60 years of pure torture. She said that if her parents had understood the JW belief, they would never have allowed her to marry one. My siblings and I were raised with extreme anti-Catholic bigotry because of my father’s beliefs. Thankfully, the Holy Spirit led my sister into the Church. I will be received at Easter, and our brother is now studying Catholicism. This week, my father viciously attacked my nieces and nephew because of their Catholic belief.

You can’t imagine the pain you will endure if you continue with this young lady. I pray you will heed all the good advise you have gotten on this site.
I know it’s off topic, but I just have to say it.

WELCOME HOME!
 
Hello guys! I really appreciate your replies. 🙂

Well, don’t worry, I’ll hold on to my faith. What bothers me more is how to save my JW girlfriend from JW cult. I know this will not be a easy task but I know it will be worth it. 🙂
 
jnoelbalana14, I don’t know if you are still following the answers to your question or not, but if you are, PLEASE do not continue this relationship. Offer thanks to Our Lady and Our Savior that your gf broke it off.

My mother (Methodist) married my father (JW) 60 years ago. She recently told my sister and me that it had been 60 years of pure torture. She said that if her parents had understood the JW belief, they would never have allowed her to marry one. My siblings and I were raised with extreme anti-Catholic bigotry because of my father’s beliefs. Thankfully, the Holy Spirit led my sister into the Church. I will be received at Easter, and our brother is now studying Catholicism. This week, my father viciously attacked my nieces and nephew because of their Catholic belief.

You can’t imagine the pain you will endure if you continue with this young lady. I pray you will heed all the good advise you have gotten on this site.
Good post:thumbsup:👍👍 Welcome home.

God bless

jesus g
 
Hello guys! I really appreciate your replies. 🙂

Well, don’t worry, I’ll hold on to my faith. What bothers me more is how to save my JW girlfriend from JW cult. I know this will not be a easy task but I know it will be worth it. 🙂
If you truly think that your GF is open minded enough. Here is a book you might want to use.

The Catholic Answer to the Jehovah’s Witnesses, A Challenge Accepted by Louise D’Angelo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top