Catholic Ladies and Confession

  • Thread starter Thread starter TinaG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TinaG

Guest
Hi!

I’m trying to understand what you believe, in my unbelievably defective way, and by this question I mean no offense. I just have a real hard time wrapping my head around the idea that a lady has to confess ALL her worst sins to a man, even if he is a priest. My girlfriends and I confess stuff to each other that we would rather die than tell to a man. There are older women in our church who sort of hear women’s confessions, although it is not a sacrament with us, and we do the same with younger women. We confess to God directly, of course, but then He knew it all already. If I had to do this, I feel like it would be humiliating and degrading and like I am exposing myself to this man in a way that is most inappropriate. I would expect this to be sort of a universal feeling among women. Surely you look at it some other way but I am sorry it is beyond me, and I would appreciate it if you would help me understand where you are coming from.

Thanks:o

-Tina
 
Hey! How are you? To answer your question. Sin is a matter of one` s conscience. I personally go to Confession monthly, because I feel that God rewards my effort to express my sorrow. I also grow closer to Him through His sacraments. Believe me I know a few priests, they really do not obsess with what you say. I often say to God as a little prayer before I enter the Confessional.“Lord you were humble enough to die for us on the cross. May I be humble enough to see your ways Lord.” God bless you always!
Richard
 
We don’t see the priest as merely a man. In the sacrament of reconciliation (or any sacrament) he is actually representing Jesus. So we’re not confessing to the priest so much as to Jesus. And before you say “but God knows all my sins anyway”, yes of course he does. But going to confession is really for yourself. Saying your sins out loud, acknowledging your wrongs and promising to do better, makes it more “real” somehow. Not just some vague thought in your head.
 
Hi tina

Honestly what you bring up has never occurred to me. Since I’ve been catholic my whole life I feel no reservations about confessing my sins to a man.

Anyways the priest is just a representative of Jesus. As Catholics we believe we are confessing directly to Him through the priest.

Priests have heard everything under the sun so anything we say won’t shock them.

I’m realizing more and more how hard it is for other Christians to take in Catholic practices. I thank God I was born Catholic because it seems so much easier. I don’t know if you are in the process of conversion or not but I admire all converts because it seems they go through so much to accept Catholicism 👍👍
 
Hi Tina, There was a time in my life when I wasn’t living my faith and when I came back that first Confession was a big one. I have to admit I was definately nervous and scared, but after getting it all out and off my chest it was like the weight of the world was taken off my shoulders. As Catholics we believe that in the Confessional the priest is Christ’s representative. He has the power through his ordination to forgive our sins. (Whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound in Heaven…) Once you are in the confessional the fear is gone and only love and forgiveness remain.

I look at Confession now, not as a burden or a chore, but as a beautiful gift from God. I receive the Sacrament often and I truely believe that the more often one confesses the stronger they become in their daily life as a christian. Personally, it makes me more aware of my actions toward others and keeps my mind and heart centered on God. Not to mention the fact that it’s just plain relieving to unburden oneself. You give all of that regret, guilt and fear over to Jesus and he gives you peace in return.
 
Could I ask why it would be degrading for a woman to confess to a man, but not for *men *to confess to a man?

Aren’t men and women equal in the eyes of God?

Isn’t Jesus the God/man?

I actually would have thought that, all things considered, women would want to be seen as equal, and not told that they needed to have ‘special treatment’ as if they were somehow either so fragile that their little psyches could not stand the horror of showing their sins to a man, or so evil that the poor man could not bear to have his illusions of womanhood ‘shattered’ by the truth of knowing that they could sin.

And I’m a woman. A 53 year old woman who has been going to confession for the last 46 years now. I never worried about being degraded or humiliated by confessing ‘to a man’. I just worried about knowing I had offended Jesus, being sorry, and wanting to be forgiven. . .🤷
 
That IS a good question… I haven’t really thought about it either. I guess that’s why there’s confessionals 🙂

Personally I’ve confessed some awful things to priests, and they never batted an eye, just gave me some life-changing advice and consolation, and then God absolved me of my sins.

Confession is absolutely wonderful!!! I can tell you with certainty that I would be going to hell without it.:o
 
I’m trying to understand what you believe, in my unbelievably defective way, and by this question I mean no offense. I just have a real hard time wrapping my head around the idea that a lady has to confess ALL her worst sins to a man, even if he is a priest. My girlfriends and I confess stuff to each other that we would rather die than tell to a man.
You are telling your sins to God.

I am having a hard time wrapping my head around why this is an issue. The priest is acting sacramentally in persona Christi. I don’t even think of it as telling my sins to a particular person, but to Christ. The priest is trained pastorally to assist every sinner in healing and in conversion. The priest is bound by the seal of confession. You can also confess anonymously.
There are older women in our church who sort of hear women’s confessions, although it is not a sacrament with us, and we do the same with younger women
I would never tell a woman at my church anything personal. I would not confess anything to a woman I didn’t want the rest of the world to know about.
We confess to God directly, of course, but then He knew it all already. If I had to do this, I feel like it would be humiliating and degrading and like I am exposing myself to this man in a way that is most inappropriate.
There is nothing humiliating or degrading about receiving the grace of God. And, I don’t know what you mean by inappropriate.
I would expect this to be sort of a universal feeling among women.
Nope.
Surely you look at it some other way but I am sorry it is beyond me, and I would appreciate it if you would help me understand where you are coming from.
This isn’t any different than going to a male doctor for female exams. The doctor is a trained professional and is there to help make you well or to examine what is wrong. I don’t find this degrading, humiliating, or inappropriate and it’s** a lot **more personal and exposing than confession with a male priest.

The doctor is there to heal you physically. The priest is there to heal you spiritually. No difference.
 
This isn’t any different than going to a male doctor for female exams. The doctor is a trained professional and is there to help make you well or to examine what is wrong. I don’t find this degrading, humiliating, or inappropriate and it’s** a lot **more personal and exposing than confession with a male priest.

The doctor is there to heal you physically. The priest is there to heal you spiritually. No difference.
That’s a very good analogy 1ke 👍
 
Hello Tina.

Confession is supposed to be humbling. It’s not supposed to be humiliating, but a little anxiety is normal. You have to remember it’s not the confession that is embarrasing it’s the sins you’ve committed that are embarrasing. Of course the best way to avoid feeling embarrased about something is to just not to do anything you’ll be ashamed of later. Usually easier said than done. . 😃

Priests have a gift from God. Called Holy Orders. This gift allows the Priest to hear a confession and forgive you on behalf of God. Yes the priest is there and he hears you, but it’s really God working through Him. Although the Priest hears you, I think it’s kind of like a “in one ear, out the other” sort of thing. It’s not their job to sit there and judge you or visualize the things that you have done, they are simply a channel to God.

God knew He wasn’t going to be able to be there in person to hear your confession, so He sent a man that He trusts to sit in for Him and do His work. God placed His power in this man and gave him the ability to forgive sins in His name. God trusted this man so much that He told him in John 20:23 “Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.” If God can put His trust in this man. Well, then I guess he’s cool with me too. 👍
 
Hi Tina - interesting question.

I think it starts with Jesus telling the apostles that they had the power to bind and loose and the power to forgive sins. We do not know why he gave this authority to only men…but we have to trust him. Personally, I would rather be able to confess anonymously to a male priest than face to face with a woman I know. I actually have the reverse anxiety. My husband grew up in the church of Christ denomination and unfortunately confessions among friends and fellow church members were mostly turned into emotional and spiritual blackmail. It was a very toxic environment.
Priests have vowed to take their knowledge of confessions to the grave. They are protected by law. Often in my husband’s old church…members and preachers would use their own hubris to justify revealing other people’s sins. If someone was disagreeing about scripture or visiting a new church…their sins might suddenly be printed in the bulletin. So toxic and sad. These shenanigans do not take place in the Catholic Church where confession is a holy and sacred thing.
So, your point is interesting to me since I have the opposite fear. As a woman of 26 I can tell you that every priest I have ever confessed to has truly acted as a father towards me, with stern but loving advice. I am nearly floating on my feet after confession. That wonderful lightness
 
Hi Tina,
It is a good question. And a question many people pose.
Find a CD talk by Matthew Kelly called “The Seven Pillars of Catholic Spirituality”: lighthousecatholicmedia.org/store/products/seven_pillars_of_catholic_spirituality

They’ll be the best $3.00 you’d spend. (cheaper than Starbucks).

The first pillar he talks about is confession. Is explained in a very simple way that us (non-theologians) can understand.

Keep asking questions. St. Thomas did too, and he when he understood the answers he became one of the great evangelizors of orient.
 
…If I had to do this, I feel like it would be humiliating and degrading and like I am exposing myself to this man in a way that is most inappropriate. I would expect this to be sort of a universal feeling among women. Surely you look at it some other way but I am sorry it is beyond me, and I would appreciate it if you would help me understand where you are coming from.

Thanks:o

-Tina
What makes you think that men don’t feel the same way? 😊
 
Hi!

I’m trying to understand what you believe, in my unbelievably defective way, and by this question I mean no offense. I just have a real hard time wrapping my head around the idea that a lady has to confess ALL her worst sins to a man, even if he is a priest. My girlfriends and I confess stuff to each other that we would rather die than tell to a man. There are older women in our church who sort of hear women’s confessions, although it is not a sacrament with us, and we do the same with younger women. We confess to God directly, of course, but then He knew it all already. If I had to do this, I feel like it would be humiliating and degrading and like I am exposing myself to this man in a way that is most inappropriate. I would expect this to be sort of a universal feeling among women. Surely you look at it some other way but I am sorry it is beyond me, and I would appreciate it if you would help me understand where you are coming from.

Thanks:o

-Tina
Tina,

great question!

**Jesus taught us to confess our sins to his Apostles & their successors. After His death & Resurrection Jesus appeared to the Apostles saying;

“And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and saith unto them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost: 23whosesoever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whosesoever sins ye retain, they are retained.” (Jn 20:22-23)
**
Notice Jesus “breathed on them” & gave them the power to remit or retain sins!

Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!

mark
 
Hi!

Thank you for your answers. I think I can appreciate your position better now.🙂

You see the “sacrament of confession” in a far better light than I had imagined. I can see that we could really get into the theology on this one! Wow!

Thanks again for your answers!

-Tina
 
I doubt I can answer all of these at once, and some I think I will not answer at all because other posts flesh them out. Some are complete answers in themselves, and some, I think, need to be answered.
Saying your sins out loud, acknowledging your wrongs and promising to do better, makes it more “real” somehow. Not just some vague thought in your head.
Agreed. Typically I confess to the one I offended. I would like to think you confess to others outside the confessional as part of normal human interaction.
Could I ask why it would be degrading for a woman to confess to a man, but not for men to confess to a man?
Aren’t men and women equal in the eyes of God?
Are you then arguing for the ordination of women, same-sex marriage, etc.? I think not. Is it right for a woman to bare her soul before a man she is not married to in an intimate circumstance, when she is revealing deep secrets? Men and women are equal but not the same, and there are appropriate boundaries.

Much of the argument presented points not to the man as man but as the priest as standing in the place of Christ, which is beyond the scope of this thread.
I would never tell a woman at my church anything personal. I would not confess anything to a woman I didn’t want the rest of the world to know about.
I am sorry you have such a low view of women. As a Catholic do you not pray to Mary? Women can be trustworthy to keep confidences. Or are women so idiotic and untrustworthy? Do all Catholics so despise women? Not from other things I have read.

Again, thank you for your answers.

-Tina:)
 
Tina, God bless you and I am glad you have found some of your answers here.

Women do not hear confessions in the Catholic Church because Jesus decided that…it was not because they are inferior or because they can’t keep a secret :mad: as another poster said. Don’t let that get you off track. God has given women many gifts and responsibilities; this just isn’t one of them. Women cannot be members of the priesthood, that just isn’t how God has chosen women to serve his Church. But that does not diminish their purpose or holiness.
It was after all, women that stayed with Jesus at the foot of the cross. We are still called to do that today.
 
Is it right for a woman to bare her soul before a man she is not married to in an intimate circumstance, when she is revealing deep secrets? Men and women are equal but not the same, and there are appropriate boundaries.
Hello Tina, you’ve asked a good question. I will tell you that, as a convert from evangelical Protestantism myself, the Sacrament of confession is truly a wonderful, liberating thing.

With regard to your statement above, if you are speaking of the confessional, then rest assured that it’s neither required nor encouraged to share any “intimate” details of your sins. They can and should be confessed in straightforward but appropriately modest language. I am also a huge proponent of confession from behind the screen and not face-to-face, especially for women. In this way the appropriate boundaries are preserved.

God bless,

David
 
Tina, God bless you and I am glad you have found some of your answers here.

Women do not hear confessions in the Catholic Church because Jesus decided that…it was not because they are inferior or because they can’t keep a secret :mad: as another poster said. Don’t let that get you off track. God has given women many gifts and responsibilities; this just isn’t one of them. Women cannot be members of the priesthood, that just isn’t how God has chosen women to serve his Church. But that does not diminish their purpose or holiness.
It was after all, women that stayed with Jesus at the foot of the cross. We are still called to do that today.
🙂

Last at the cross and first at the tomb, while the men were afraid and then were sleeping in. Yes.

Not to be argumentative but I regard the priesthood as belonging to all Christians, per 1 Peter. Discussing views on church leadership is another thing, for another thread sometime. I agree there are leadership functions in the church reserved for men.

When you offend your brother or sister, do you go to them and confess it? Do they forgive you? Or is that something reserved for between you and the clergy?

-Tina:)
 
Hello Tina, you’ve asked a good question. I will tell you that, as a convert from evangelical Protestantism myself, the Sacrament of confession is truly a wonderful, liberating thing.

With regard to your statement above, if you are speaking of the confessional, then rest assured that it’s neither required nor encouraged to share any “intimate” details of your sins. They can and should be confessed in straightforward but appropriately modest language. I am also a huge proponent of confession from behind the screen and not face-to-face, especially for women. In this way the appropriate boundaries are preserved.

God bless,

David
Ah, good. You return a good answer to something I had asked, with the wisdom of hindsight, rather sloppily. The idea of telling a celibate priest tantalizing details of a woman’s sexual life might be pouring fuel on a fire, especially if he himself has a struggle with fantasies. I would worry about this. What if the woman has to confess lust after the priest to the priest she is confessing to? That sort of thing is what I meant by inappropriate earlier but expressed poorly. But you are saying the confession is much more general and less specific than I supposed.

Many thanks, again!

-Tina:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top