Catholic or Protestant Burial?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Th0t
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Th0t

Guest
Does it matter what kind of burial service a lost loved one gets?

Does it have to be specific?
 
Well, you would think a Catholic would want their commendation to be from the Church - and there is NOTHING like a Catholic funeral (as I have heard multiple times from non-Catholic friends and relatives 😉 )
But theologically, in terms of impact on ones afterlife, no, it doesn’t make a difference. Not sure if that’s what you meant.
 
No, of course I’d like a Catholic burial lol

but I yeah I meant theologically.

Thank you.
 
Th0t said:
Does it matter what kind of burial service a lost loved one gets?
Click to expand...
Perhaps. If a person dies in a state of perfect Grace then it would not matter at all to the deceased. Otherwise, the person would (hopefully) spend some “time” in purgatory, in which case the prayers of the Faithful on earth could be beneficial (because we on earth are part of the Communion of Saints, and may offer prayers on the behalf of others).

A Catholic funeral would encourage such prayers. Protestants generally reject the idea of purgatory and the Communion of Saints, so you would likely find that much less spiritual support would be encouraged at a protestant ceremony. Thus, the deceased may be deprived of supporting prayers if laid to rest by a protestant minister.

Also, a Catholic funeral is a sacramental, which does impart some degree of Grace. The Church has not specifically defined the impact of this Grace, but it should not be ignored or neglected.

It might matter on a more personal and emotional level to the survivors, regardless of the underlying theology.
 
Th0t said:
Does it matter what kind of burial service a lost loved one gets?

Does it have to be specific?
Click to expand...
Well a Catholic of course should have a Catholic burial but if you mean does it make any difference to the person’s salvation the answer is no.
You are already dead and either condemned to Hell or saved (Puragtory/Heaven) by the time you are buried.
 
Th0t said:
Does it matter what kind of burial service a lost loved one gets?

Does it have to be specific?
Click to expand...
I’ve been to many funerals protestant and Catholic and it does make a difference. At a Catholic funeral the Mass is for the repose of the soul of the deceased. We pray that he be relieved of the pains of purgatory and be accepted into heaven.

At protestant funerals they throw the deceased in a hole and forget his soul. It’s very sad.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top