I like that one too because it reminds me of my mother.
I was taken aback to read some article on Catholic music in which the author specifically singled it out as an example of insipid sentimentality and proceeded to whine about how bad it was.
All I know is that my mother and a lot of other devout ladies liked it just fine.
That author needs to quit imposing his musical prejudices on others.
Edited to add, Thanks to this post, i’ve now found the Youtube trove of old Marian hymns that I remember from childhood in addition to “Immaculate Mary” and “Bring Flowers of the Fairest”…stuff like “Mother Dear Oh Pray For Me”, and “Mother Dearest, Mother Fairest” and “On This Day, Oh Beautiful Mother”. Ah, the good ol’ days.