Catholic-safe yoga practices?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maxirad
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Maxirad

Guest
Yoga is frequently suggested for health issues these days, but reservations have been expressed in Catholic circles. How can a faithful Catholic do yoga without falling into a spiritual trap? I can’t say yoga hasn’t been suggested for my personal medical issues, but I want my Catholic faith to remain intact.
 
I’ve taken it for many years. I’m a believing, daily-Mass-going, knowledgeable Roman Catholic. In all the places I’ve taken it (YMCA, local yoga center, community ed class) there’s been pretty much NO focus on the spirituality of the thing, except for some harmless love-yourself and inner peace aphorisms that start and end class (the barrage of self-therapy stuff thrown at us in every day life is much more pervasive). If it seems to go over the top (again, rarely if ever) I say a nice prayer during that time. Then on with the stretching, which is great for the body–for the entire person! I love yoga, although I love Pilates more 🙂
 
Stretching is good for the body. If there are no elements of “spirituality”, it’s fine. I occassionally do yoga, and actually while I’m holding the poses I pray!
 
“The basic doctrines of the Vedanta and Saukhya systems are monistic Pantheism, intuition as the supreme means to reach truth, metempsychosis, the world of sense is only a very little part of the category of things, the theory and method of salvation strictly intellectual. These systems developed from the Upanishads. The final development is the Yoga. Yoga, i.e. “one who fits himself, or exercises”, refers to the exercises practiced to free the soul from the body, which to it is like a string to a bird. Some of these exercises were: to rid one’s self of moral faults (though the masters do not agree as to what these faults are); to sit in certain painful postures, check the breath, and reduce thought to a minimum by staring at the tip of the nose; to place the soul in a particular part of the body, and so gradually acquire mastery over it, or, rather, let the soul, the true self, acquire mastery over the body; to stave and learn to subsist on air or even without it; to concentrate thought by meditation, i.e. to think of nothing. Thyana, the highest state of which is the cataleptic trance samadhi, in which the mind is suppressed but the soul is in full activity. In this state the person is a mahatma, i.e. master-soul and can enjoy a temporary release from the body which it leaves to go roaming about, performing wonderful feats on material nature and controlling other less powerful souls. This latter was the secret of the Yoga’s real power and was supposed to be done by a transfer of soul. When the soul re-enters the body, the Yoga wakes and is like other people. By repeated exercises the soul can become so strong that is secures perpetual release from the body, thus, according to the older Yoga teaching, it flies to heaven where it enjoys great happiness, riding in a celestial car attended by lovely women and music; but with the latter Yogas, on breaking all bodily bonds it formed immediate absorption into the Supreme Soul.”

newadvent.org/cathen/14626a.htm
 
“The basic doctrines of the Vedanta and Saukhya systems are monistic Pantheism, intuition as the supreme means to reach truth, metempsychosis, the world of sense is only a very little part of the category of things, the theory and method of salvation strictly intellectual. These systems developed from the Upanishads. The final development is the Yoga. Yoga, i.e. “one who fits himself, or exercises”, refers to the exercises practiced to free the soul from the body, which to it is like a string to a bird. Some of these exercises were: to rid one’s self of moral faults (though the masters do not agree as to what these faults are); to sit in certain painful postures, check the breath, and reduce thought to a minimum by staring at the tip of the nose; to place the soul in a particular part of the body, and so gradually acquire mastery over it, or, rather, let the soul, the true self, acquire mastery over the body; to stave and learn to subsist on air or even without it; to concentrate thought by meditation, i.e. to think of nothing. Thyana, the highest state of which is the cataleptic trance samadhi, in which the mind is suppressed but the soul is in full activity. In this state the person is a mahatma, i.e. master-soul and can enjoy a temporary release from the body which it leaves to go roaming about, performing wonderful feats on material nature and controlling other less powerful souls. This latter was the secret of the Yoga’s real power and was supposed to be done by a transfer of soul. When the soul re-enters the body, the Yoga wakes and is like other people. By repeated exercises the soul can become so strong that is secures perpetual release from the body, thus, according to the older Yoga teaching, it flies to heaven where it enjoys great happiness, riding in a celestial car attended by lovely women and music; but with the latter Yogas, on breaking all bodily bonds it formed immediate absorption into the Supreme Soul.”

newadvent.org/cathen/14626a.htm
Yoga is an element present to a whole, or broken off from a more complete form, of primitive worship to various ‘gods’. Although the Church understands that people of all religions are just trying to reach God, because only He IS God, these primitive forms of worship do not contain the whole truth within themselves, and therefore, cause the soul to meditate upon knowledge that is fragmented/partial/incomplete. Just because Yoga is broken from the whole - physical exercises split from any ‘spiritual’ endeavours - does not mean the physical form has been disconnected, totally. If all elements are as entwined as the above post suggests then it would seem that in some part, when taking on Yoga, even just physical exercises, one is taking part in a ritual belonging to some other religion. No one really knows the derivation of Yoga, except that we know the practice dates back to before Christianity; yet, because we know this, we can understand that it does affect the human system at the lower-level force than that of the intellect, more akin to animal-instinct, and when people invite this level of ‘being’, into their reality, this leaves themselves open to Satan. IMO.
 
“The basic doctrines of the Vedanta and Saukhya systems are monistic Pantheism, intuition as the supreme means to reach truth, metempsychosis, the world of sense is only a very little part of the category of things, the theory and method of salvation strictly intellectual. These systems developed from the Upanishads. The final development is the Yoga. Yoga, i.e. “one who fits himself, or exercises”, refers to the exercises practiced to free the soul from the body, which to it is like a string to a bird. Some of these exercises were: to rid one’s self of moral faults (though the masters do not agree as to what these faults are); to sit in certain painful postures, check the breath, and reduce thought to a minimum by staring at the tip of the nose; to place the soul in a particular part of the body, and so gradually acquire mastery over it, or, rather, let the soul, the true self, acquire mastery over the body; to stave and learn to subsist on air or even without it; to concentrate thought by meditation, i.e. to think of nothing. Thyana, the highest state of which is the cataleptic trance samadhi, in which the mind is suppressed but the soul is in full activity. In this state the person is a mahatma, i.e. master-soul and can enjoy a temporary release from the body which it leaves to go roaming about, performing wonderful feats on material nature and controlling other less powerful souls. This latter was the secret of the Yoga’s real power and was supposed to be done by a transfer of soul. When the soul re-enters the body, the Yoga wakes and is like other people. By repeated exercises the soul can become so strong that is secures perpetual release from the body, thus, according to the older Yoga teaching, it flies to heaven where it enjoys great happiness, riding in a celestial car attended by lovely women and music; but with the latter Yogas, on breaking all bodily bonds it formed immediate absorption into the Supreme Soul.”

newadvent.org/cathen/14626a.htm
The sources supporting the linked article appear to date from 1892 to 1912, long before what today’s health clubs market in the health and physical fitness arenas. Moreover, “Yoga” is used here in the sense of an individual attaining a mystic reality, not someone in leotard searching for flexibility. The full article is about the long-discredited idea of “Theosophy,” not exercise.
 
The sources supporting the linked article appear to date from 1892 to 1912, long before what today’s health clubs market in the health and physical fitness arenas. Moreover, “Yoga” is used here in the sense of an individual attaining a mystic reality, not someone in leotard searching for flexibility. The full article is about the long-discredited idea of “Theosophy,” not exercise.
Yeah we’re so much wiser now. Let’s just ignore what those who went before us tried to teach us.
 
Yoga is frequently suggested for health issues these days, but reservations have been expressed in Catholic circles. How can a faithful Catholic do yoga without falling into a spiritual trap? I can’t say yoga hasn’t been suggested for my personal medical issues, but I want my Catholic faith to remain intact.
And beware of any superstitious uber-Catholics who will, contrary to the Catechism, spookily tell you that holding your body in a particular position is inviting the Evil One in.

That’s just gaga, lala, superstitious nonsense.
 
And beware of any superstitious uber-Catholics who will, contrary to the Catechism, spookily tell you that holding your body in a particular position is inviting the Evil One in.

That’s just gaga, lala, superstitious nonsense.
Many of these people you just insulted, include priests, who have spoken about such dangers, and in particular, too, exorcists.
 
And beware of any superstitious uber-Catholics who will, contrary to the Catechism, spookily tell you that holding your body in a particular position is inviting the Evil One in.

That’s just gaga, lala, superstitious nonsense.
Yeah, satan would NEVER desire to deceive the faithful into thinking something evil is actually totally fine and acceptable, Gee what would he get out of that? LOL
 
There is absolutely nothing evil about doing yoga exercises.

As in anything, spiritual danger is the result of why you’re doing such an activity.

Even playing golf can become evil if it becomes an obsession to the point of letting everything go.

If you’re looking for ecstasy or some other spiritual phenomenon. you’re opening yourself to danger, even if it’s in Catholicism. Priest have been demonically possessed. We wouldn’t stay away from Catholicism because of them.

I’ve been doing yoga exercise for over 20 years and the benefits are real.

Even my Discalced Carmelite Spiritual advisor, does yoga as do many monks and nuns.

We are Christ centered and union with Jesus is our desire.

If you can’t separate Hindu spirituality from your yoga exercise routine, you probably have a problem with faith to begin with and should focus on getting your faith in order first.

Jim
 
There is absolutely nothing evil about doing yoga exercises.

As in anything, spiritual danger is the result of why you’re doing such an activity.

Even playing golf can become evil if it becomes an obsession to the point of letting everything go.

If you’re looking for ecstasy or some other spiritual phenomenon. you’re opening yourself to danger, even if it’s in Catholicism. Priest have been demonically possessed. We wouldn’t stay away from Catholicism because of them.

I’ve been doing yoga exercise for over 20 years and the benefits are real.

Even my Discalced Carmelite Spiritual advisor, does yoga as do many monks and nuns.

We are Christ centered and union with Jesus is our desire.

If you can’t separate Hindu spirituality from your yoga exercise routine, you probably have a problem with faith to begin with and should focus on getting your faith in order first.

Jim
Many disagree:

ewtn.com/expert/answers/yoga.htm

The bottom line is, that if someone has visited a Yoga website, then they are incorporating all that Yoga entails. If there are physical exercises that people can do which do not come under Yoga then why go to a Yoga website.
 
The intent of “Yoga” is for you to contort your body into the shapes of various Hindu gods. If that doesn’t ward you off I doubt much else will.
 
Many disagree:

ewtn.com/expert/answers/yoga.htm

The bottom line is, that if someone has visited a Yoga website, then they are incorporating all that Yoga entails. If there are physical exercises that people can do which do not come under Yoga then why go to a Yoga website.
Yeah. EWTN misrepresents what the Letter to the US Bishops on Some Aspects of CHristian Meditation, is actually about and used it to condemn Centering Prayer as well as Yoga.

It’s not about Yoga exercise, but forms of Eastern Meditation which a Christian follow.

As the letter states
". The majority of the “great religions” which have sought union with God in prayer have also pointed out ways to achieve it. Just as "the Catholic Church rejects nothing of what is true and holy in these religions,“18 neither should these ways be rejected out of hand simply because they are not Christian. On the contrary, one can take from them what is useful so long as the Christian conception of prayer, its logic and requirements are never obscured.”
As I stated before. It’s the reason why a person is doing yoga or meditation, that is important, not the practice itself.

Our focus is always the desire for union with Christ. Yoga doesn’t not prohibit this, but in fact as the body and mind become healthy, is conducive toward contemplative prayer.

Jim
 
No, that’s not the intent. :rolleyes:

Jim
That is absolutely the intent along with whatever spiritual occurrences come along with it. If you don’t know what Yoga is, perhaps you shouldn’t practice it. You also advocate “centering prayer” which is also spiritually dangerous.
As I stated before. It’s the reason why a person is doing yoga or meditation, that is important, not the practice itself.
Going through the motions of Hindu worship has spiritual consequences regardless of intent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top