Catholic School Halloween

  • Thread starter Thread starter gracelovefaith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gracelovefaith

Guest
My son goes to catholic school. I guess when my husband dropped him off yesterday morning and watched the kids costume parade, his teacher was dressed as a witch. When he told me this I laughed and said I knew it! Anywho, when I worked in the public school system 10 years ago, there was a costume policy- you had to be a charachter from a book and bring the book with you to school to read to another kids that day. There was restriction on horror costumes. I wonder why there wasn’t a restriction on costumes at this private catholic school. On top of that, the trunk a treat event in the evening was nice, but I couldn’t help but wonder why they are playing Katy Perrys California Girl. Might as well be playing 50 cents loly pop…
To public school we go… as he’s getting mixed messages here, he might as well go to public school. And I thought I wanted to be a private catholic school teacher… not where I live, they might see that I am catholic and loving it! BTW you gotta get that book- Catholoic and loving it. I’ll stay in healthcare and pray while I work.
 
Too bad… 😦

We’re really super blessed at our school… the Kindergarteners dress up and march - they had their “Saints Parade” yesterday…
Next week the fifth graders have the “Saints Wax Museum”… they dress up and have to stand like statues and had to write up information plaques about their saint… the whole school walks through their “museum” to read about the saints…
 
My two children passed through the Catholic School system here in Ontario (Canada).
I was always bothered by the stress put on Halloween with virtually no mention of All Saints Day and All Souls Day.
From what they told me over the years not even one teacher mentioned that Halloween is nothing but the Eve of the big celebration. :mad:

I’ve changed since then. Now the teachers and principles would hear from me each and every year.
 
I think that this is worth a complaint. Catholic parents should have a reasonable expectation that Catholic schools are, well, Catholic. Thanks be to God I do not have much problem on this score. Our dress up day is limited to dressing as a Saint and occurs on, hold on now, All Saints Day.

This stuff is so simple it is amazing that some educators can’t get it right.
 
I was chatting with a 30 something priest friend this afternoon and said “Happy Halloween.” “Not for traditional me,” was the response. Then he told me that Sunday they will have a Saints Ball where the kids will all be expected to dress as saints and no horror, witches, zombies, etc. Interesting little discussion ensued.

Of course he’s from a Polish parish in Ontario and he still wears a cassock and sisters still wear a habit and the families are very traditional. Very unlike my parish where few kids come to church at all. He’s got more altar servers than we have kids in church.
 
Too bad… 😦

We’re really super blessed at our school… the Kindergarteners dress up and march - they had their “Saints Parade” yesterday…
Next week the fifth graders have the “Saints Wax Museum”… they dress up and have to stand like statues and had to write up information plaques about their saint… the whole school walks through their “museum” to read about the saints…
Now THAT is really cool! 👍
 
I where the kids will all be expected to dress as saints and no horror,
.
I told my wife that for our All Saints Carnival I wanted to go as John the Baptist’s Head on a platter. This worked great as she took my son and left me home to watch football.
 
The little Catholic school where I teach does All Saints in a BIG way!

We start w/ All School Mass. Then the kids go back to homerooms and prepare for their saint presentations. Some do monologues, some do posters, some written reports etc. Lots of parents come to watch (and take pictures!).

After lunch, the kids are in teams (7th and 8th graders are team leaders for the younger ones) and the teams go all around campus participating in different game and craft stations - St. Francis relay race, stuff a saint, all sorts of fun things! The 6th graders lead the games and crafts.

It’s a huge production and lots of fun.
 
The Catholic school in our town is abysmal. Huge classrooms with 30 plus kids, weak teachers, zillions of volunteer hours, generally considered substandard as the kids are not very competitive or good readers, bland and drab.

My son goes to a Lutheran school and LOVES it! So do we. I wouldn’t put my son at our Catholic school on a dare. The kids at the Lutheran and Anglican schools can whip the Catholic school kids soundly.
 
Having been a Catholic school student, teacher and public school teacher and parent, I totally empathize. I would try to start by giving the teacher the benefit of the doubt- maybe she WAS a book character- Miss Viola Swamp, for example? While that maybe wouldn’t have been the most prudent choice, it is possible.

And then, perhaps, take the best of the best ideas people post here with how other schools observe the holy days/holiday and present them to your school’s administration. Explain your discomfort, and let them sit with it. There’s a good chance, that when you point out the bigger picture of their mission and your expectations as a Catholic parent, that they will revamp their schedule for next year. (And take a second look at the rest of this year;)

Good Luck!
 
Having been a Catholic school student, teacher and public school teacher and parent, I totally empathize. I would try to start by giving the teacher the benefit of the doubt- maybe she WAS a book character- Miss Viola Swamp, for example? While that maybe wouldn’t have been the most prudent choice, it is possible.
Hey, I have a great idea for a Bible costume that lets one dress as a witch. Combine an Ewok with a broom and a pointy hat and dress as the witch of Endor!
 
If you haven’t already, please let the priest and principal know why you are withdrawing your son. It’s important that you give them the opportunity to improve!
 
Yub-yub! Hey, they helped the rebels overthrow the Empire. You just HAVE TO give 'em props for that!
Hey, I have a great idea for a Bible costume that lets one dress as a witch. Combine an Ewok with a broom and a pointy hat and dress as the witch of Endor!
 
My son goes to catholic school. I guess when my husband dropped him off yesterday morning and watched the kids costume parade, his teacher was dressed as a witch. When he told me this I laughed and said I knew it! Anywho, when I worked in the public school system 10 years ago, there was a costume policy- you had to be a charachter from a book and bring the book with you to school to read to another kids that day. There was restriction on horror costumes. I wonder why there wasn’t a restriction on costumes at this private catholic school. On top of that, the trunk a treat event in the evening was nice, but I couldn’t help but wonder why they are playing Katy Perrys California Girl. Might as well be playing 50 cents loly pop…
To public school we go… as he’s getting mixed messages here, he might as well go to public school. And I thought I wanted to be a private catholic school teacher… not where I live, they might see that I am catholic and loving it! BTW you gotta get that book- Catholoic and loving it. I’ll stay in healthcare and pray while I work.
I would go and talk with the principal too, before deciding to go over to public school. I honestly think a good Catholic can dress as a witch for Halloween, though, so I might be biased, although as a teacher I would probably choose something different. About the song, definitely a bad idea, but maybe you could find out if they realized it (who was in charge of the music, could the lyrics be understood, etc). Maybe they let someone that shouldn’t have been in charge, be in charge of the music and did not realize who it was/what she was saying. If you feel the school is not teaching the true Catholic faith, that is one thing, but if it is then I would definitely talk with the school, try to help it, before going over to public school. Are they going to be celebrating All Saints next week? Dd’s school let them have a little Halloween party Fri, but they talk about saints throughout the year and have been talking about saints last week and will be having All Saints day activities this coming week (including 5th grade having presentations about saints too). They also talked about “Dia de los Muertos”.
 
The Catholic school in our town is abysmal. Huge classrooms with 30 plus kids, weak teachers, zillions of volunteer hours, generally considered substandard as the kids are not very competitive or good readers, bland and drab.

My son goes to a Lutheran school and LOVES it! So do we. I wouldn’t put my son at our Catholic school on a dare. The kids at the Lutheran and Anglican schools can whip the Catholic school kids soundly.
Well., when your kid is grown and has a relativistic attitude that all religions are equal, this might be why. Hard to believe they are not being taught heretical ideas at the Lutheran school. I hope you are at least following canon 800.1 and trying to make your catholic school better so others are not forced into the same unfortunate situation you find yourself.

“The Christian faithful are to foster Catholic schools, assisting in their establishment and maintenance according to their means.”
 
I don’t see the big deal about the witch costume, or the parade in general. It is an AMERICAN Catholic school after all, and Halloween is as much a cultural holiday as it is religious. Our church director wears a witch costume every single halloween. It’s cute. Big floppy hat and spider glasses.

The music though, for wee ones. A no go.
 
I don’t say this often but you ought to be ashamed of yourself. Truly, you should be totally ashamed of yourself for saying this about my son. Shame on you. You have NO RIGHT to say this, period. I’m putting you on ignore for this and don’t wish to read a post ever again that you put on this board.

First of all, you don’t know the first thing about what is taught in this school, period. You haven’t a clue. And you haven’t a clue what is taught locally in my Catholic school. So you’re blind in a vacuum judging my family’s decision. My son is not being taught theology and heady topics like imputation vs. infusion, he’s a KINDERGARTENER! He’s five for God’s sake. The school is a Christian school. There are teachers there from all churches and they keep their own views to themselves. They are taught the Bible, the stories, about the life of Christ, and about faith. They are not told how to think about theological points, heresies, the papacy, etc. They are not taught to be anti-Catholic or relativistic.

My son can outread the kids at the local Catholic school. And surprise surprise the teachers at the Lutheran school often substitute teach or have taught at the Catholic school! They all tell us the same thing—the Catholic school is watered-down, the classes are enormous, and the kids are far behind the public school kids. Hardly what I want when I pay $$$ for my son’s education! There is a lot of inappropriate behavior there, very clannish, overly-strict in my estimation, and the religous ed is widely known to be lousy. They have teachers who are not even credentialed AND they let parents come in and teach some days when teachers take the day off. Not what I’m looking for.

The kids at the Catholic School are not learning about Arianism, Nestorianism, the history of the papacy, indulgences, Vatican I and II, deep theology, etc.

I’m not in an “unfortunate situation” and canon 800 is not on my radar right now. Nobody is “forced” and the sadness and pity you feel is unwarranted.

Again, I’m disgusted by this post entirely. And it’s folks like you that only keep me away from Catholicism rather than returning to it. The pharisaic sense of superiority, paranoia, anti-Protestant suppositions and paranoid theories, the polemics, and the lack of charity toward someone whom you’ve never met, and the sickening prophecy you’ve made for my little boy as a relativist is beyond the pale of inappropriate. Shame on you! :mad:
Well., when your kid is grown and has a relativistic attitude that all religions are equal, this might be why. Hard to believe they are not being taught heretical ideas at the Lutheran school. I hope you are at least following canon 800.1 and trying to make your catholic school better so others are not forced into the same unfortunate situation you find yourself.

“The Christian faithful are to foster Catholic schools, assisting in their establishment and maintenance according to their means.”
 
gurneyhalleck1,

I apologize, I had assumed you were Catholic, since you referred to the Catholic school as our. Assuming that is the case, if the Lutheren school is not teaching them some level of heresy (e.g. sola-scriptura), then its not much of a lutheran school. Seemed like a safe assumption. I did not question the situation of your Catholic school, seems very unfortunate for a Catholic to have such a poor Catholci school avaiable to them. Finally, the canon applies to all of us, if you are Catholic, it should be on your radar.

I will admit the prediction of the kid being grown and falling for relativistic religion may have been wrong, I apologize that part, but I don’t see it as offensive, as I get a hint of that attitude from you. If thats the case, you probably would think it is a good thing.

In general, I fail to see anything I wrote that was that offensive and excepting the first sentence, everything was directlyt taken from your post (ie the heretical and the unfortunate part).
 
Let’s please remember to be charitable to one another in both our assumptions and responses when participating.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top