Catholic Sex Abuse

  • Thread starter Thread starter YosefYosep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

YosefYosep

Guest
How do you adamantly defend your faith on the subject of the sex abuse scandal?
 
How do you adamantly defend your faith on the subject of the sex abuse scandal?
I would see it like this:

(1) Priests are humans, and they err like the rest of us. Catholics and non-Catholics make a great deal of the fact that they were priests.

(2) Comparatively the proportion of priests involved (is it 4%?) is very much less than then the general statistic.

(3) Sex abuse is wrong regardless of who commit them; that does not make Catholicism wrong.

(4) On the accusation of cover up, this probably is more difficult. Personally I would say the Church is not police and do not have police power to prosecute and to arrest. That should be left to the police. On whether a superior should report the abuse to the police, he cannot if it is on the understanding that it is between the superior and the priest concern. Otherwise what is the purpose of Confession?
 
The scandal is not an issue of faith. So I have nothing to adamantly defend.

About the scandal, I will concede that it is a scandal, but I believe the Church is finally stepping up to the task of dealing with it. At least I hope so.

Alan
 
How do you adamantly defend your faith on the subject of the sex abuse scandal?
By enforcing the fact that sexual abuse is not part of our faith. Certainly their is no teaching of the Church that gives affirmation to such practices.

Obviously, the depravity of these situations can’t be understated and are not restricted to only Catholic clergy (percentages are substantially lower than other groupings). But that said, in terms of Scripture, Our Lord will hold them more accountable for the offense. Certainly, we hold them more accountable as Catholics because of the scandal it causes and distress to the Church. So I don’t really have a problem with protestants holding Catholic priests to a higher standard than other groups.

I try to dismiss the issue to those that use the issue as a religious wedge. I let my brothers in Christ know that I sympathize with their horror because it is real. However, don’t let it become “larger than life”. I would also add that not only hurts the high percentage of good priest because of the act itself, but then further because then people begin to paint them with the same broad brush. I firmly point out that defaming all priests based on the heinous acts of few is highly inappropriate.
 
Sex abuse is one of the gravest sins encouraged by Satan. I will say though that the Church is not to be blamed, but the deranged individual priests that commit this sin are the blame. The Church is pure holy, the individuals of the Church are human, and humans sin.:crying:
 
In defending our Faith, I point out these abusers were going *against *the teachings of the Church.
 
Human beings are sinners. And some of the sins are worse than others. I do think there needs to be a zero tolerance policy for sexual sin. No moving people around if they did something bad.

Now the good news is that most of these cases we hear about now are 20 or 30+ years old. And laws have changed a lot since the time these terrible acts were committed. You have to take into context the time period. Legally, family members of victims were given lesser sentences and free to return home within 2 or 3 days. Sexual abuse was pretty much not talked about, and when it was, abusers were not properly punished. A lot of kids were abused by family members and in Hollywood a lot of little boys were abused by gay men (not saying all gays molest children–I know many gay people who would never touch a child–only that these particular men I’m thinking of happened to be gay). Many people have kept these secrets of being abused for decades and are only now stepping forward.

Over the course of these few decades, laws have been reformed a lot, both secular and church. Steps have been taken to prevent sexual abuse in all areas. Unfortunately, some people still slip through the cracks and get away with things, but we are still learning how to deal with these horrible people.
 
First the abuse of children in any society should always be condemned.
It was the church that originally banned the pedestry that was acceptable in ancient Roman and Greek culture.
The most surprising thing to most people is size of the abuse in the Church.
There ate a low figure of. 300,000 to 3,000,000 children abused annually in the U.S.
In a 50 year period from 1950 to 2004 there were a total of 10,000 cases.
absinthe 4,000 priests or religious out of 140,000 clergy
Even though there was significant monetary psyouts $250,000 to $1,000,000 per case.
This is importantant because child abuse is typically under reported.My. son Masters in CJ
says about 10 to 1
The settlements in the. Church would skew these numbers
In fact theilave been a significant number of false claims
New cases since 2004 are in the single digits
I could go on with about 10 other points.
but I will close with one
Of the 4000 priests 51% had one complaint
Given the serial nature of the pedfillia this suggests something other than that was in play
 
Because the Church is not at fault; it is the actions of a few misguided individuals who are at fault.
Not to mention a minute fraction of individuals. And even fewer have actually been guilty.

There are more sex abuse reports from married protestant ministers/pastors than priests. And more regular folks in society who have been convicted of sex abuse.

People seem to forget that priests are still people, so they will make mistakes, and sometimes, very serious mistakes. But, because the Church is such a large organization and faith, people take any chance they get to attack it. Like when people in school make fun of the smart kid, both when (s)he replies with smart answers, and moreso when (s)he makes a mistake. People love to bully…
 
Most people I speak too, Catholics, other Christians and Catholics that left because of the scandals, it isn’t the 3 or 4% of priests that did it, they understand pedophiles are in all areas, most of them left because of all the non-pedophile Bishops and priests that turned their eyes from it and cared more about appearances than helping those poor lambs that suffered mentally and physically because of it.

That is why I left years ago and for different reasons, found my way back, but it was the callousness, the superiority of them, the obvious “We can’t let them know this” because it might challenge our rules and vocations, etc.

I think you have to understand what others are asking…it is usually not “how could that happen”, it’s how it could have gone on so long by people saying they were “Christ” and others watching them do it.

I also think there were cases that were never told out of shame, I heard stories or part of stories as a youth and didn’t really understand (what was sex back then at 10?) I’m not saying the scandal is much larger, but I know human nature and understand many have kept silent also.
I still read about “bad priests”, some cases in the news now, some a few years old. Never say it’s over, that’s when you start not seeing things again.
 
I had come across a reference that said that the priests involved amounted to less than 1% of priests. Whatever the percentage, it’s a bad thing. As a convert, I sometimes have a problem “defending” my decision to become a Catholic in the first place. But, this sort of thing happens elsewhere. If you were to take all Protestant Churches, including “independant” ones, and lump them together, the problem would be just as bad if not worse. Then our public schools. Who’s to say that they are any better? Sex abuse is nothing new, and it isn’t strictly a Catholic problem. I know it’s hard to come forward after sex abuse happens. I have my own story, although it includes no Catholics. Yet I have told very few people about it. Why? Out of shame and fear that I wouldn’t be believed. There is even the thought of being accused of being to blame for what happened. It’s a tough spot to be in. :sad_yes:
 
I’ve heard priests say 2-4% but that still amounts to a lot of priests. You are correct, it happens everywhere, but what many did in our church to cover it up, I haven’t heard about by others. Moving a priest who is molesting children, church to church?? What was that about?
One priest in CT suffered for turning in a priest he knew was doing things he shouldn’t, everyone loved the accused, but he was correct in doing so. It only went public when others didn’t listen to him to my recollection.

I am married to an officer, I’ve worked with doctors most of my life, I understand fraternity, not ratting out someone, but I have never heard of child abuse in this way being ignored.

Luckily now, we have the Internet, if a parent brings up concerns/charges and they move the priest and not remove him, you can see that, long ago, another district was like another state.

I feel for the priests that carrry the sins of their brothers on their shoulders, as do others, like doctors, teachers, coaches, police…but trust has to earned now and not just expected. I think in the future, more will be cautious, but in time, it will become more normal.

I hope prayer and good solid guidance will help, don’t just take an accusers word but don’t just ignore it either. Maybe better psych tests in the seminary but anyone can lie, you just have to trust with both eyes open.

This was one small example of how complicated one case can get, it shouldn’t have been so drawn out.
nytimes.com/2010/03/25/world/europe/25vatican.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
 
Most people I speak too, Catholics, other Christians and Catholics that left because of the scandals, it isn’t the 3 or 4% of priests that did it, they understand pedophiles are in all areas, most of them left because of all the non-pedophile Bishops and priests that turned their eyes from it and cared more about appearances than helping those poor lambs that suffered mentally and physically because of it.

That is why I left years ago and for different reasons, found my way back, but it was the callousness, the superiority of them, the obvious “We can’t let them know this” because it might challenge our rules and vocations, etc.

I think you have to understand what others are asking…it is usually not “how could that happen”, it’s how it could have gone on so long by people saying they were “Christ” and others watching them do it.

I also think there were cases that were never told out of shame, I heard stories or part of stories as a youth and didn’t really understand (what was sex back then at 10?) I’m not saying the scandal is much larger, but I know human nature and understand many have kept silent also.
I still read about “bad priests”, some cases in the news now, some a few years old. Never say it’s over, that’s when you start not seeing things again.
You bring up some good points. I know many former Catholics. Only one told me she left the Church and went to another denomination because she had been abused by a priest.

Most people I know, including myself, have left because of disagreements with doctrine or social teaching.
 
I was just reading about LA and their scandals, they opened books going back many decades and the stories are heartbreaking.

Priests are people, regular people in most ways…growing up I saw priests that seemed to drink a lot, some swore, some were crabby, some were kind, understanding and holy in many ways. Same with the nuns.

I always wondered if some were burnt out or maybe just went into the priesthood because back then it was more “cushy”, 3 meals, home, maid (they did have help once!) other priests to help say mass, respect…today though, seminarians know they are probably going to be working very hard, not have as much support and under a magnifying glass by others. Neither is a great thing but hopefully the vocations will be stronger and I feel the church will stay strong…but it wont without a lot of growing pains.

I like Pope Francis too…I think we need someone like him now.
 
I’ve heard priests say 2-4% but that still amounts to a lot of priests. You are correct, it happens everywhere, but what many did in our church to cover it up, I haven’t heard about by others. Moving a priest who is molesting children, church to church?? What was that about?
One priest in CT suffered for turning in a priest he knew was doing things he shouldn’t, everyone loved the accused, but he was correct in doing so. It only went public when others didn’t listen to him to my recollection.

I am married to an officer, I’ve worked with doctors most of my life, I understand fraternity, not ratting out someone, but I have never heard of child abuse in this way being ignored.

Luckily now, we have the Internet, if a parent brings up concerns/charges and they move the priest and not remove him, you can see that, long ago, another district was like another state.

I feel for the priests that carrry the sins of their brothers on their shoulders, as do others, like doctors, teachers, coaches, police…but trust has to earned now and not just expected. I think in the future, more will be cautious, but in time, it will become more normal.

I hope prayer and good solid guidance will help, don’t just take an accusers word but don’t just ignore it either. Maybe better psych tests in the seminary but anyone can lie, you just have to trust with both eyes open.

This was one small example of how complicated one case can get, it shouldn’t have been so drawn out.
nytimes.com/2010/03/25/world/europe/25vatican.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
Here is a more thorough description of the case by Jimmy Akin.

There are a few points which need to be considered. One is that very few of the victims were children; most were post-pubescent. Another is that the Church handled these cases much as other institutions did. The psychologists and psychiatrists of the time believed that these people could be “cured,” and so an offender was sent off for treatment, then assigned to a place where he could start again with a “clean slate.”

So, the bishops followed the psychological advice, as did so many others, and this led to a situation which under the increased knowledge of later decades was seen as worse than it would have at the time.

Look at the Fr Murphy case–the police did know about it, and did not prosecute. A lot of time, victim’s families did not want to press charges, since some noteriety would often land on the victim. There are other cases like this as well where the police did know but no prosecution occurred.

It was a mess, and there were times when the bishops were too lenient with abusing priests, and certainly the state of the seminaries was very bad, but much of the problem had died down before the scandal broke in the early 2000’s. The majority of the cases occurred in the 50s, 60s, and 70s.
 
I can’t see the link but can look it up later. I was devastated when I read this not long ago in my neck of the woods. We had a few scandals but this was like a little salt in the wound.

gawker.com/5977011/cross+dressing-show+tunes+loving-connecticut-priest-busted-for-selling-meth-and-laundering-money-through-his-sex-shop

How can this happen, get through seminary, psych tests, have a parish, doesn’t anyone see anything?

Many people will be circling for the next shoe to drop, the church has to be as swift as it could be and fair, but less priests is better than having a body in a church that shouldn’t be there. Quality over quantity for a while. Help the ones who are trying to be a good priest by not having scandal hurt them.
 
the cardinal of montreal said in a t.v interview i thought well,

sex abuse is not a church problem, it is a society problem. it happens even more so in famillies, in hockey rinks, etc. its definately not a catholic church problem,

i think its horrible but you cannot label everyone in that manner, its very obious there were bad apples ,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top