Catholic "UN-Divorce?"/remarriage?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kathryn_Ann
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Kathryn_Ann

Guest
**

Can two Catholics who are divorced from each other (where no Church annulment has yet been sought) somehow “undo” the civil divorce, as a matter of civil record, and still be considered married in the eyes of the Church? Even though no Church annulment was sought or granted, wouldn’t they still somehow need to approach the Church on this matter?

Is there counseling by the Church available for people considering re-marriage to their former spouse where no other partners have entered the picture?

Factors greatly adding to the confusion are that the former husband was verbally and emotionally abusive to his wife, and he was the one demanding the divorce for a number of years. Should the family counsel the young former wife to be suspicious of his sudden, unexplained desire to remarry? Or should everyone, as an act of Christian forgiveness, ignore the previous unsteady temperment of the husband, hoping that his improved behavior and his sudden wish to reconcile and remarry is a sign from God that the marriage should be defended?

I welcome any (name removed by moderator)ut as to what the Church teaching might be in such a challenging situation, where the young wife currently feels that she can never be happy with the former husband and where only now has he managed (ironically, only since the divorce,) to act in a more civil and courteous manner towards her.

Still, a divorce has occurred. Why did he demand it? Can such a person be trusted after such former behavior or will he return to his unsettling ways once remarried? Or should any motives be ignored, paving the way, at any cost, to reconciliation? Most importantly, they share custody of their child, even going on day trips, all three together, and balancing PTA obligations and recitals, with everyone in the extended family attending holidays and events together as usual, choosing to be harmonious for the sake of the child who thrives in school and enjoys hobbies and friends. Everyone dotes on the child, including the father, who has always been a very hard working and excellent provider, and who has continually been a kind and devoted father. Even so, part of being a good parent is showing steadfast respect and courtesy towards the other spouse. One fears that in “forgetting” the divorce entirely, the old storms might return to unsettle a now more serene environment.

The questions remain though: For a young woman to remarry someone formerly verbally and emotionally abusive to her, and who demanded the divorce for so many years, seems contrary to God- given common sense. Yet at the same time, we are to forgive “seventy times seven.”

The question of annulment remains open as well. It would allow both to remarry within the Church at some future time.

Thank you in advance for any wisdom on Church teachings, or gentle advice/thoughts on this.
**
 
If the spouses cannot live peaceably under the same roof, a civil divorce may be morally permissible as a way to justly divide the couple’s assets between them, even if they are still validly married. It is hoped that can be avoided, but it can happen.

If there has been no annulment, the marriage is presumed valid, regardless of whether there is a civil divorce. It is be hoped that if a couple is validlly married, they will eventually reconcile and return to a common conjugal life, even if they were divorced, whether or not the divorce had been obtained for morally permissible reasons.

Remember always that forgiveness and reconciliations are not the same thing. If you forgive the person who robbed your house, you don’t have to prove it by hiring them as a cashier at your store. Positions of trust have to be earned. There is a parallel even on the divine level. When we go to confession, guilt and the eternal consequences of the sin are erased, but the temporal results of the sin remain. The offender who broke the window is forgiven and the relationship is restored on some level, but the window is still broken. There is still damage to be addressed which is a real work to do. That is why Catholics believe in Purgatory and offering spiritual works for the benefit of both the living and the dead.

Were I in the described situation, I would want to have some joint and individual pastoral counselling prior to returning to the common conjugal life. As much as a reconciliation is the desired end, it is necessary to proceed so as to have the best chance that the reconcilation will be real and lasting. That requires forging a new relationship in which emotional and verbal abuse have no place, in which real conflicts are faced and dealt with in an appropriate way. I would need that assurance before restoring the common conjugal life, because I’d have the duty to make sure a second try, a try embarked upon before my child reached adulthood, was enduring.

If your ship ran aground, one would hope you would want it repaired. No one would think you lacked trust in the workmanship of the repair if you wanted to do some short trips before you took the vessel on an around-the-world trip. This is particularly true because of the necessity of protecting your child from getting their hopes up and then rewarding that hope with another divorce. Even if you want to look without leaping, have the prudence to look carefully before taking your child along for another jump.

I hope this does work out for you. Assuming that you and your husband are capable of a fruitful and peaceful marriage, that would be the ideal outcome. God bless you, and good luck!

The process of assessing your marriage in counselling may also give you information concerning the nature of your marriage from its inception. Satisfy yourself that no marriage existed before you seek an annulment.
 
Can two Catholics who are divorced from each other (where no Church annulment has yet been sought) somehow “undo” the civil divorce, as a matter of civil record, and still be considered married in the eyes of the Church?
There isn’t anything to “undo” in the eyes of the Church. The couple would civilly remarry.
Is there counseling by the Church available for people considering re-marriage to their former spouse where no other partners have entered the picture?
A couple can always approach their pastor for counseling of this sort.
Should the family counsel the young former wife to be suspicious of his sudden, unexplained desire to remarry?
Well certainly they should.
Or should everyone, as an act of Christian forgiveness, ignore the previous unsteady temperment of the husband, hoping that his improved behavior and his sudden wish to reconcile and remarry is a sign from God that the marriage should be defended?
Why would you ignore such behavior?

The Church teaches that one may civilly separate from a spouse in situations like this. While reconciliation is certainly the hoped-for outcome, no one should approach reconciliation with an abuser without caution and a slow, careful process of earning back trust.
where the young wife currently feels that she can never be happy with the former husband
I would suggest counseling from a priest and no pressure from family and friends to do something that goes against her better judgment.
The question of annulment remains open as well. It would allow both to remarry within the Church at some future time.
The wife can pursue a decree of nullity if she believes she has grounds. Again, something to discuss with her priest.
 
A quote from Blessed Pope John Paul II

MESSAGE
OF HIS HOLINESS
POPE JOHN PAUL II
FOR THE CELEBRATION OF THE
WORLD DAY OF PEACE

1 JANUARY 2002

NO PEACE WITHOUT JUSTICE
NO JUSTICE WITHOUT FORGIVENESS
​
vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/messages/peace/documents/hf_jp-ii_mes_20011211_xxxv-world-day-for-peace_en.html

My point: when all the canon law and counseling aspects are finished…and the wife has to make the final “yes or no” decision…for these two to have a real chance…two things must happen:

JUSTICE for the wife…she has to receive some real… concrete justice for the wrongs done to her by the husband…but…BUT (and this “BUT”… is JP-II’s great Christ-centered Spirit)…the wife will never attain perfect Justice in this life…so she must offer** FORGIVENESS**.

In other words…if she decides to give it a second try…she has to base her decision on satisfaction that there is some real Justice…but not hold out for perfect justice…in this life…only God can give that …so she has to forgive her husband…to have and attain Peace…and** PEACE** is the only concrete ingredient that will make this marriage work.

For your consideration.
Pax Christi
 
Wow - if the wronged/abused spouse chooses to “remarry” civilly he/she can as they are STILL in married in the eyes of the Church unless a decree of nullity has been granted. However I would strongly advise some pastoral counseling in this area to make sure that the abused is not setting up for more pain.
 
Prudence is a gift of the Holy Spirit. Pray to Him, and seek wise counsel from a priest experienced in counseling marital matters. And keep praying before doing anything else.
 
Can two Catholics who are divorced from each other (where no Church annulment has yet been sought) somehow “undo” the civil divorce, as a matter of civil record, and still be considered married in the eyes of the Church? Even though no Church annulment was sought or granted, wouldn’t they still somehow need to approach the Church on this matter?
As far as i know they would simply “remarry” - a quick check with a priest would help clarify any particulars. The “Civil Divorce” really has no standing in the Church except that, at least in the US the Church requires a civil divorce before proceeding with an annulment application.
Is there counseling by the Church available for people considering re-marriage to their former spouse where no other partners have entered the picture?
I’m sure that the pastor of the couple’s parish would undertake such counseling, or recommend someone.
Factors greatly adding to the confusion are that the former husband was verbally and emotionally abusive to his wife, and he was the one demanding the divorce for a number of years. Should the family counsel the young former wife to be suspicious of his sudden, unexplained desire to remarry? Or should everyone, as an act of Christian forgiveness, ignore the previous unsteady temperment of the husband, hoping that his improved behavior and his sudden wish to reconcile and remarry is a sign from God that the marriage should be defended?
I would NOT recommend ignoring the previous behavior any more than I would suggest ignoring such behavior in a boyfriend/girlfriend.
I would recommend that it be approached as though the marriage had never occurred and determine if, based on what is known of his behavior, she would wish to marry such a man…
Caution is definitely indicated since people with such behavior patterns can be most charming during courtship only to revert to abusive behavior after the wedding.

One can be Christian and forgive without placing one’s self in the line of fire.
In fact, remarriage could actually be the least loving thing that can be done. It only feeds the behavior pattern.
I welcome any (name removed by moderator)ut as to what the Church teaching might be in such a challenging situation, where the young wife currently feels that she can never be happy with the former husband and where only now has he managed (ironically, only since the divorce,) to act in a more civil and courteous manner towards her.
As stated above, this is a very normal behavior pattern for an abuser.
Still, a divorce has occurred. Why did he demand it? Can such a person be trusted after such former behavior or will he return to his unsettling ways once remarried? Or should any motives be ignored, paving the way, at any cost, to reconciliation? Most importantly, they share custody of their child, even going on day trips, all three together, and balancing PTA obligations and recitals, with everyone in the extended family attending holidays and events together as usual, choosing to be harmonious for the sake of the child who thrives in school and enjoys hobbies and friends. Everyone dotes on the child, including the father, who has always been a very hard working and excellent provider, and who has continually been a kind and devoted father. Even so, part of being a good parent is showing steadfast respect and courtesy towards the other spouse. One fears that in “forgetting” the divorce entirely, the old storms might return to unsettle a now more serene environment.
Very possibly…
The questions remain though: For a young woman to remarry someone formerly verbally and emotionally abusive to her, and who demanded the divorce for so many years, seems contrary to God- given common sense. Yet at the same time, we are to forgive “seventy times seven.”
The question of annulment remains open as well. It would allow both to remarry within the Church at some future time.
Thank you in advance for any wisdom on Church teachings, or gentle advice/thoughts on this.
We can only give very general advice - comments on these matters. Each circumstance is unique and it is best to try to get a priest/councilor involved.

But YES CAUTION IS INDICATED

Peace
James
 
retrouvaille.org/

The couple would be wise to schedule the next weekend.
When the wife feels that she is ready for that, it could be a good idea. Still, it is not just the short-term intense communication that needs to happen, but also the long-term rebuilding of trust and the construction of entirely new ways of handling conflicts. I would never reconcile my marriage to someone guilty of abusing me unless I had seen him appropriately handle something that made him angry and sorely tempted to be less than admiring of my qualities as a person. Marriage is easy when you’re admiring each other. It is when you’re angry and not seeing straight that your character and capacity for love shows itself.
 
**(From original poster, Kathryn Ann) to those who have replied:

I am very thankful to each person here who has given such considerate responses to my questions.

I agree with the advice towards caution and prudence. Also, I agree that certain things need to be addressed, such as one responder suggested, in that the style of the abuser can often be one alternating between periods of charm, followed by relapses into old patterns of anger and mistreatment of the spouse.

It is true that while we may never have perfect justice in this world, that we need to test the waters carefully when forgiveness may lead a person to reconsider re-uniting with such a partner whose past proves so troublesome.

A parent often feels helpless when advising a young person in such unique circumstances, longing for all good things to come to a daughter, trying to remain neutral while being asked for wisdom. I was, therefore, relieved to see that all here agreed on caution, that prudence is just as much a gift as that of forgiveness. (I liked the analogy of forgiving the robber but not feeling pressed to hire him as a cashier.)

To live peaceably in these circumstances may require everyone to use as much energy and caution in considering reconciliation as that which was put into the years leading up to the divorce.

In this case, several years of unhappiness would indicate that several years of counseling and prayer would be in order. I liked the other analogies given, especially that of the little boat testing the waters on briefer excursions before setting off for a longer voyage. I think the young man has much work to do in proving himself worthy of undoing the great harm he himself did to the marriage in demanding a divorce, and feel that no amount of charm or temporary initiative will convince me otherwise. That said, taking everything into account here that was so kindly given, I agree that time may be a great factor here, whatever the result.

Not wishing for fairy tale perfection or perfect justice in this world is one very true factor. Another is that our Heavenly Father must surely grieve for all involved, so I do pray for wisdom. All the answers here point to caution, and I am very grateful for the kind thoughts urging a prudent approach.

Kathryn Ann**
 
I suspect that the husband/abuser has tired of searching for a new victim and has returned to the former victim because he knows he can control her. Sorry for that pessimistic viewpoint, but I have done a lot of reading on the dynamic between abuser and victim as well as my personal experience.

Did the victim/wife seek counseling of any kind while they were apart? Did she explore why she was attracted to such a man in the first place? Has she realized that his treatment of her was wrong and that she did not deserve that kind of disrespect? These things take time and diligent effort. It took quite a while before I could even recognize the danger I had put myself in, let alone get angry at the mistreatment I allowed from my boyfriend. I had a block because I never considered myself to be susceptible to that sort of person. On one level, I knew that he had some problems and his actions weren’t loving, but on that other level, I could not be the type of person who became some abuser’s victim. But it doesn’t happen overnight, but quite slowly, and meanwhile you have this person’s very attractive attention and their charm being poured out all over you like warm syrup.

I hope… your daughter, is it? I hope she isn’t back in the warm syrup phase. Please make sure that her eyes are open, that she is not just being charmed back into becoming that victim all over again. I would actually never return to my abuser, so I suspect that she is still in some denial about her ex-husband. If for some reason, I could have been convinced that he really, REALLY understood what he had done and had gotten treatment and the treatment had been successful, then good for him, but I still would have a lot of trepidation about even allowing him into my life, let alone re-marrying him.

Are children involved? That adds another whole layer of complication.

Edited: I see this from your first post: “I welcome any (name removed by moderator)ut as to what the Church teaching might be in such a challenging situation, where the young wife currently feels that she can never be happy with the former husband and where only now has he managed (ironically, only since the divorce,) to act in a more civil and courteous manner towards her.”

This is what she SHOULD be feeling/thinking, it gives me more hope that she is not falling for the warm syrup he may well be pouring all over here, trying to get her back. Often, an abuser sees his victim gaining confidence and self-esteem and it drives him crazy with desire, that he wants to tear her down once more, he wants that strength she is gaining but can only destroy it instead. It is sick and twisted. I hope she will continue to be reluctant to allow this man back into her life. She deserves to be happy and an abuser, unreformed, can never help her get to Heaven.
 
Actually, the wife would be well-advised to petition for a decree of nullity. In the event that it is granted, the husband would be “flagged” by the Church as someone needing a heck of a lot of pastoral counseling (and possibly mental health counseling) before a new marriage (to either the first wife or someone else) would be permitted. She might conceivably be buying herself a bit of an insurance policy, or at least some “adult supervision,” before they started to live together again.
 
I suspect that the husband/abuser has tired of searching for a new victim and has returned to the former victim because he knows he can control her. Sorry for that pessimistic viewpoint, but I have done a lot of reading on the dynamic between abuser and victim as well as my personal experience.

Did the victim/wife seek counseling of any kind while they were apart? Did she explore why she was attracted to such a man in the first place? Has she realized that his treatment of her was wrong and that she did not deserve that kind of disrespect? These things take time and diligent effort. It took quite a while before I could even recognize the danger I had put myself in, let alone get angry at the mistreatment I allowed from my boyfriend. I had a block because I never considered myself to be susceptible to that sort of person. On one level, I knew that he had some problems and his actions weren’t loving, but on that other level, I could not be the type of person who became some abuser’s victim. But it doesn’t happen overnight, but quite slowly, and meanwhile you have this person’s very attractive attention and their charm being poured out all over you like warm syrup.

I hope… your daughter, is it? I hope she isn’t back in the warm syrup phase. Please make sure that her eyes are open, that she is not just being charmed back into becoming that victim all over again. I would actually never return to my abuser, so I suspect that she is still in some denial about her ex-husband. If for some reason, I could have been convinced that he really, REALLY understood what he had done and had gotten treatment and the treatment had been successful, then good for him, but I still would have a lot of trepidation about even allowing him into my life, let alone re-marrying him.

Are children involved? That adds another whole layer of complication.

Edited: I see this from your first post: “I welcome any (name removed by moderator)ut as to what the Church teaching might be in such a challenging situation, where the young wife currently feels that she can never be happy with the former husband and where only now has he managed (ironically, only since the divorce,) to act in a more civil and courteous manner towards her.”

This is what she SHOULD be feeling/thinking, it gives me more hope that she is not falling for the warm syrup he may well be pouring all over here, trying to get her back. Often, an abuser sees his victim gaining confidence and self-esteem and it drives him crazy with desire, that he wants to tear her down once more, he wants that strength she is gaining but can only destroy it instead. It is sick and twisted. I hope she will continue to be reluctant to allow this man back into her life. She deserves to be happy and an abuser, unreformed, can never help her get to Heaven.
I tend to agree wholeheartedly with the overall opinion of taking great caution here. The couple went through much counseling before the divorce and the husband actually became angrier and more aggressive, insisting even more on the divorce. The family continues to, as much as possible, stay out of over advising while being friendly and supportive to all involved. Yes, there is a child involved, who is now thriving in a peaceable environment, and that is why my only advice has been extreme caution. I do believe that time shows us people’s true colors and intentions. I thank you for your (name removed by moderator)ut on this, and everyone’s here. At the same time, I thank God for His showing me His love for the young husband despite his actions. Miracles can happen, people may change, God can move mountains, but we must love everyone involved here, and be very careful not to let two people re-enter a relationship that might very well re-introduce the same problems. All the analogies of people posting answers here have been very helpful. I think that love goes hand in hand with wisdom, prudence and caution. Time will tell, and God our Father holds us all in His hands. Gratefully, K.A.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top