Would you agree that we cannot align our will to God without grace? IOW, the merit is really Christ’s.
Sure, we need grace to be saved but do you think Jesus withholds his grace from anyone? We Catholics believe that God is fair and gives everyone the opportunity to be saved. Some take that opportunity to their merit and others don’t , to their condemnation.
I think, paul you have hit on what may or may not be the subtle difference here. Lutherans believe that our free will is only one way.
This is not a subtle difference. Think about what you just said. How is it possible to have one way free will? A decision is always either / or. If you choose not to reject Christ, aren’t you in fact deciding to embrace him? That’s logic 101.
We cannot on our own choose to follow Christ, or even seek out Christ, because we are completely tied to sin, death, and the devil.
Our view of man is positive. Man was made in the image and likeness of God and everything God made was good. Don’t you see how dark and evil you are painting man? Do you really believe the default position of man is evil? That has not been my experience.
Christ instead seeks us out, through the sacrament of Baptism and hearing the word. Faith is therefore a gift of grace.
We believe that God calls every man to himself.
We can, however, choose to reject grace.
yes, or we can embrace it. One brings condemnation, the other eternal life. There is merit in making the right choice.
Salvation is a gift of grace, for which we can do nothing to add. But again, we can choose to reject grace, by willfully and unrepentantly remaining in our sin. **Choosing not to follow Christ’s commands is willfull sin, and the Spirit will not long abide in one who chooses to not do His commands. **
Salvation is a gift of grace, but we do have something to add: our cooperation. Not rejecting grace is accepting it, is it not?
So, what is the value of good works? To increase merit for our salvation? No, as that is Christ’s merit, fully and completely. The value of good works is toward our fellow man, and to the extent that we do them, we participate in Christ’s merit, out of joyful obedience to His call and command. Does this mean we can choose not to do good works? No, because that is willful disobedience.
There is always merit in the good works we do, if they are in response of the regenerate to His call and command. It is Christ’s merit, working through us.
Jon
So if you fail to do good works, you aren’t saved, right, because that is willful disobedience as you said above. It therefore logically follows that you must do good works to acheive eternal life in heaven.
So to summarize:
Do you believe man is inherently evil? We don’t
.Do you believe that you can do good works in the absence of grace? We don’t
Do you believe that God makes his grace available to all? We do.
Do you believe that good works are meritorious? We do
Do you believe that you must do good works (God’s will) to go to heaven? we do