Catholic vs Protestant view on personal merit

  • Thread starter Thread starter paul_c
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s the key to the answer and to the differences between Catholics and Protestants, methinks.

Paul gave the long answer so I’ll give the short and perhaps oversimplified one :D: Catholics see belief or acceptance of belief as a sort of “work” or merit. Such a viewpoint is problematic for Protestants who, like Catholics, reject the notion that our good deeds (“works”) can earn our salvation.

In other words, Catholics see accepting belief as an active participation, whereas Protestants see it as a passive participation.
It depends, Newbie, on what you mean by passive participation. When talking about justification, Lutherans see this as monergistic. So, yes, we passively receive justification by grace alone through faith in Christ.
But, as Luther says, there is no justification without sanctification, and sanctification in many ways requires our participation. It is synergistic. We respond (and this is an active response) with a new obedience to His call and command to do His will, not out of fear, by out of joy, knowing that Christ’s actions (Grace) are sufficient to save. But make no mistake, we are obligated to respond in our sanctification. Failure to do so is sin.

Jon
 
=thenobes;6706787]Paul,
I believe that any merit (that is worthiness to receive reward from God) is a pure gift of God. I believe that strictly all the merit of all our good acts belong to God. But merit is indeed given to us, no mistake about that.
I agree to the first part absolutely.
If merit is given to us, how do we use it? What is its value?
This question is not provacative, but a true question regarding the Catholic view.
Paul says in Ephesioans that is it is God who works in us to will, and to do. Thus I think that the most spiritual merit we can ourselves obtain on our own is an absence of demerit, or zero demerit, since we are only keeping ourselves from resisting God’s grace in all these regards. We initiate nothing.
Agreed
That being said, works are indeed necessary for salvation, in that the accession of the will to God’s Will allows His Life to work and Live within us. Thus sanctifying us and allowing us to persevere in our faith. Resistance to the Grace to get us to will will cause a weakening of faith and possibly the death of faith.
Though expressed somewhat differently than I did above, I think we are saying essentially the same thing.
In addition the Grace of God to work allows us to produce works that the HS can use toward the sanctification of others. Thus giving us a part of the reward that others receive.
Absolutely, on the first part!! On the second, if the part of the reward you speak of is the joy and celebration of the entire Communion of Saints. (Luke 15:7 -
I say to you, that even so there shall be joy in heaven upon one sinner that doth penance, more than upon ninety-nine just who need not penance. Douay-Rheims)

Jon
 
I agree another poster that this is the primary issue. I think between Catholics and Lutherans, there is very little difference in our notions on merit from a practical application standpoint in our daily lives.

Where the differences lie is primarily in our use of language from a theological standpoint.

If I offer up the following:

“Merit: The reward which God promises and gives to those who love him and by his grace perform good works.

One cannot merit justification or eternal life, which are the free gift of God; the source of any merit we have before God is due to the grace of Christ in us.”

Some of our protestant brothers read something like this and come away with: “I agree with this, see even Catholics believe what we do has no impact on our salvation.”

Others will read the same lines and come away with: “No, see the Catholic Church teaches we can work our way into heaven.”

Catholics read the same lines and don’t see either of those things.

Perhaps everyone should read the CCC 2006-2011 as the starting point of “Merit” from the Catholic perspective.

Is there a similar document from the Lutheran perspective?

Chuck
I don’t see either of those in your statement either. I don’t believe the CC teaches one can work one’s way to heaven, and I also don’t believe that what we do has no impact. What we do has some impact.
One starting point might be, in the Lutheran Confessions, the section on good works from the Epitome of the Formula of Concord, linked here.
[bookofconcord.org/fc-ep.php#IV. Good Works.](http://www.bookofconcord.org/fc-ep.php#IV. Good Works.)
 
Would you agree that we cannot align our will to God without grace? IOW, the merit is really Christ’s.
Sure, we need grace to be saved but do you think Jesus withholds his grace from anyone? We Catholics believe that God is fair and gives everyone the opportunity to be saved. Some take that opportunity to their merit and others don’t , to their condemnation.
I think, paul you have hit on what may or may not be the subtle difference here. Lutherans believe that our free will is only one way.
This is not a subtle difference. Think about what you just said. How is it possible to have one way free will? A decision is always either / or. If you choose not to reject Christ, aren’t you in fact deciding to embrace him? That’s logic 101.
We cannot on our own choose to follow Christ, or even seek out Christ, because we are completely tied to sin, death, and the devil.
Our view of man is positive. Man was made in the image and likeness of God and everything God made was good. Don’t you see how dark and evil you are painting man? Do you really believe the default position of man is evil? That has not been my experience.
Christ instead seeks us out, through the sacrament of Baptism and hearing the word. Faith is therefore a gift of grace.
We believe that God calls every man to himself.
We can, however, choose to reject grace.
yes, or we can embrace it. One brings condemnation, the other eternal life. There is merit in making the right choice.
Salvation is a gift of grace, for which we can do nothing to add. But again, we can choose to reject grace, by willfully and unrepentantly remaining in our sin. **Choosing not to follow Christ’s commands is willfull sin, and the Spirit will not long abide in one who chooses to not do His commands. **
Salvation is a gift of grace, but we do have something to add: our cooperation. Not rejecting grace is accepting it, is it not?
So, what is the value of good works? To increase merit for our salvation? No, as that is Christ’s merit, fully and completely. The value of good works is toward our fellow man, and to the extent that we do them, we participate in Christ’s merit, out of joyful obedience to His call and command. Does this mean we can choose not to do good works? No, because that is willful disobedience.
There is always merit in the good works we do, if they are in response of the regenerate to His call and command. It is Christ’s merit, working through us.

Jon
So if you fail to do good works, you aren’t saved, right, because that is willful disobedience as you said above. It therefore logically follows that you must do good works to acheive eternal life in heaven.

So to summarize:

Do you believe man is inherently evil? We don’t

.Do you believe that you can do good works in the absence of grace? We don’t

Do you believe that God makes his grace available to all? We do.

Do you believe that good works are meritorious? We do

Do you believe that you must do good works (God’s will) to go to heaven? we do
 
=paul c;6713190]
So if you fail to do good works, you aren’t saved, right, because that is willful disobedience as you said above. It therefore logically follows that you must do good works to acheive eternal life in heaven.
paul,
How is salvation possible? By the suffering, death, and resurrection of Christ. We receive justification by Grace alone through faith in Christ.
When we are regenerate, we are obligated to obey His commands. Failure to do so is sin, and repeated unrepented sin drives out faith. It fact, repeated, unrepented sin is evidence of no faith.
It is the lack of faith, demonstated by repeated unrepented sin, that condemns.
So to summarize:
Do you believe man is inherently evil? We don’t
Not by creation, no. But by original sin, the fall, man is subject to sin, death and the devil.
.Do you believe that you can do good works in the absence of grace? We don’t
Agreed, at least good in the eyes of God.
Do you believe that God makes his grace available to all? We do.
Yes. “For God do loved the world…”, not a limited or elect few.
Do you believe that good works are meritorious? We do
Not in any way that they add to Christ’s merit for remission of sins and salvation.
Do you believe that you must do good works (God’s will) to go to heaven? we do
We believe that works are evidence of a live, saving faith. Lack of works is evidence of a lack of a dead faith.

Jon
 
Quote:
=paul c;6713190]
So if you fail to do good works, you aren’t saved, right, because that is willful disobedience as you said above. It therefore logically follows that you must do good works to acheive eternal life in heaven.
Sure, salvation is possible by the suffering, death and resurrection of Christ. And sure, we receive grace through faith in Christ when we partake of the sacraments. However, we are obligated to obey his commandments whether we are regenerate (in the state of grace) or not. Failure to do so is sin, no matter what the state of our souls. And sure, repeated unrepetent sin is evidence of a lack of faith because if we truly believed we would work to do God’s will. But sin doesn’t drive out faith. Sin is a sign that the faith is weak. But we are arguing semantics now. If Faith isn’t real without works to support it, you need faith and works to be saved.
Quote:
Do you believe man is inherently evil? We don’t
What you say is true, man is subject to sin and death but I don’t agree that man is subject to the devil. The devil tempts us, but we don’t have to give in. By Grace, available to all men, we are able to overcome sin and I believe on balance, people are more good than evil.
Quote:
.Do you believe that you can do good works in the absence of grace? We don’t
good.
Quote:
Do you believe that God makes his grace available to all? We do.
good
Quote:
Do you believe that good works are meritorious? We do
Our merits do not lessen Jesus’s merit any more than turning on a lightbulb lessens the light coming from the sun.
Quote:
Do you believe that you must do good works (God’s will) to go to heaven? we do
you are trying to protect the faith alone statement but what you are saying without admitting it is that works are required to gain eternal life. If you don’t have works, you don’t have life…There’s no getting around it.
 
=paul c;6713549]Sure, salvation is possible by the suffering, death and resurrection of Christ. And sure, we receive grace through faith in Christ when we partake of the sacraments.
As well as from hearing the word. We agree.
However, we are obligated to obey his commandments whether we are regenerate (in the state of grace) or not. Failure to do so is sin, no matter what the state of our souls. And sure, repeated unrepetent sin is evidence of a lack of faith because if we truly believed we would work to do God’s will. But sin doesn’t drive out faith. Sin is a sign that the faith is weak. But we are arguing semantics now.
Yes, I agree. It is somewhat semantic differences. Remember, we’ve had 500 years of division to develop differing ways to express things - even though in many ways we may be stating the same truth.
If Faith isn’t real without works to support it, you need faith and works to be saved.
So, the real differences between us is as follows:
Catholics: Justification is an ongoing process. Initial justification is by Grace alone through faith in Christ (monergistic). But continuing justification is synergistic, requiring our cooperation and good works toward our salvation, knowing that even these good works are the results of Grace. Grace makes it possible, for those who do as Christ commanded, to merit further grace

Lutherans: Justification is a forensic event. It, like what Catholics call intitial Justification, is by Grace alone through faith (and here is where Lutherans say “alone”), in Christ -monergistic. It is then followed by sanctification (growth in grace), where we responsibly receive His grace by being obedient to His commands, not to add to what Christ has done for our salvation, by as evidence of the Grace through faith that saves.
Grace, Christ’s merit, is soley sufficient for our salvation. Our good works are evidence of our obedience to His commands.
you are trying to protect the faith alone statement but what you are saying without admitting it is that works are required to gain eternal life. If you don’t have works, you don’t have life…There’s no getting around it.
Faith alone only describes how we come to be justified. How, paul, does a Catholic come to Initial Justification?

Jon
 
Quote: Paul C
If Faith isn’t real without works to support it, you need faith and works to be saved.
Well, we don’t describe it quite that way. We describe it more like this:
To go to heaven, you must die in the state of grace. You get in the state of grace initially through baptism and you stay that way as long as you avoid mortal sin by loving God and neighbor (i.e., doing good works). If you fall from grace through mortal sin, you can be reconciled to God through the sacrament of reconciliation. Through God’s mercy, you can be reconciled as many times as you need to. You can get additional grace to help you avoid sin through the sacraments.
Lutherans: Justification is a forensic event. It, like what Catholics call intitial Justification, is by Grace alone through faith (and here is where Lutherans say “alone”), in Christ -monergistic. It is then followed by sanctification (growth in grace), where we responsibly receive His grace by being obedient to His commands, not to add to what Christ has done for our salvation, by as evidence of the Grace through faith that saves.
Grace, Christ’s merit, is soley sufficient for our salvation. Our good works are evidence of our obedience to His commands.
This seems largely inconsistent. On one hand, you say that justification is a one time event and that good works have nothing to do with it. Yet you say that justification can be lost (because you agree that OSAS is a false doctrine). How is justification lost in your theology? And if you state that you don’t believe that justification can be lost, then by definition, you believe in OSAS.
Quote: Paul c
you are trying to protect the faith alone statement but what you are saying without admitting it is that works are required to gain eternal life. If you don’t have works, you don’t have life…There’s no getting around it.
Catholics get into the state of Grace by being baptized. This is an act of faith (in infant baptism, the parent’s are the proxy). But you can not stay in the state of grace by simply saying" I believe". You must live out your faith and avoid mortal sin…
 
Now, it might be spin on my part, but if you mean that good works are beneficial to our fellowman, then I wholeheartedly agree. As that is what good works do - they benefit the world, not my merit toward salvation.

Jon
Catholics conceive of salvation to be justification, sanctifcation, and glorification.

For that reason we accept the apostolic teaching that merit does play a role in our salvation, and that of others.

When we do the good works that God have prepared, be increase our own sanctification, and can contribute the salvation of others.
 
Catholics conceive of salvation to be justification, sanctifcation, and glorification.

For that reason we accept the apostolic teaching that merit does play a role in our salvation, and that of others.

When we do the good works that God have prepared, be increase our own sanctification, and can contribute the salvation of others.
Thanks, guano.
I do agree with the last sentence. As you know, Lutherans draw a distinct line between what we view as the monergistic Justification, and synergistic sanctification, even though they are necessarily linked. So, the second sentence makes a Lutheran queasy. I was speaking with my pastor about this not long ago, and we were talking about the relationship of works and merit to salvation. He commented that our good works, while necessary, do not add to “our pile of merits” toward salvation.
Is our participation a requirement of the Christian life? Of course, and absolutely!!

I don’t know, maybe it is all semantics. We, eventually, come to the same realization, that the Christian is saved by the suffering death and resurrection of Christ, and not of our own doing, and that as regenerate Christians, we are required to follow the commands of Christ.

Jon
 
=paul c;6714921]Well, we don’t describe it quite that way. We describe it more like this:
To go to heaven, you must die in the state of grace. You get in the state of grace initially through baptism and you stay that way as long as you avoid mortal sin by loving God and neighbor (i.e., doing good works). If you fall from grace through mortal sin, you can be reconciled to God through the sacrament of reconciliation. Through God’s mercy, you can be reconciled as many times as you need to. You can get additional grace to help you avoid sin through the sacraments.
And we see the role of Confession/Absolution, and the sacraments in a similar way.
This seems largely inconsistent. On one hand, you say that justification is a one time event and that good works have nothing to do with it. Yet you say that justification can be lost (because you agree that OSAS is a false doctrine). How is justification lost in your theology? And if you state that you don’t believe that justification can be lost, then by definition, you believe in OSAS.
Well, I’ve stated often that Lutherans know that we can loose our justification by willfully remaining in repeated, unrepented, sin. Grace alone saves, but we have free will in rejecting that Grace which saves.
Catholics get into the state of Grace by being baptized. This is an act of faith (in infant baptism, the parent’s are the proxy). But you can not stay in the state of grace by simply saying" I believe". You must live out your faith and avoid mortal sin…
I would generally agree. But we live out our lives in faith in response to the gift of grace.

Jon
 
T
I don’t know, maybe it is all semantics. We, eventually, come to the same realization, that the Christian is saved by the suffering death and resurrection of Christ, and not of our own doing, and that as regenerate Christians, we are required to follow the commands of Christ.

Jon
I think it is semantics. Many of our separated brethren use the word “salvation” to refer only to the justification aspect, whereas, when we use it, it encompasses all three aspects.

For example, in the Epistle of Jude we read:

20But you, dear friends, build yourselves up in your most holy faith and pray in the Holy Spirit. 21Keep yourselves in God’s love as you wait for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ to bring you to eternal life.

22Be merciful to those who doubt; 23snatch others from the fire and save them; to others show mercy, mixed with fear—hating even the clothing stained by corrupted flesh.

Can we really “build ourselves up” in faith apart from God’s grace? No. This is a reference to the synergistic sanctification we both acknowledge.

Can ww snatch others from the fire and save them? Can any human being do anything that will result in the salvation of another?

Yet, when we are moved by the Spirit, we can act on behalf of those who are weak in faith, or fallen, and “save” them (contribute to their salvation).

This is a meritorious act.
 
I don’t see either of those in your statement either. I don’t believe the CC teaches one can work one’s way to heaven, and I also don’t believe that what we do has no impact. What we do has some impact.
One starting point might be, in the Lutheran Confessions, the section on good works from the Epitome of the Formula of Concord, linked here.
[bookofconcord.org/fc-ep.php#IV. Good Works.](http://www.bookofconcord.org/fc-ep.php#IV. Good Works.)
“Accordingly, we believe, teach, and confess that our righteousness before God is (this very thing], that God forgives us our sins out of pure grace, without any work, merit, or worthiness of ours preceding, present, or following, that He presents and imputes to us the righteousness of Christ’s obedience, on account of which righteousness we are received into grace by God, and regarded as righteous.”

“For especially in these last times it is no less needful to admonish men to Christian discipline [to the way of living aright and godly] and good works, and remind them how necessary it is that they exercise themselves in good works as a declaration of their faith and gratitude to God, than that the works be not mingled in the article of justification; because men may be damned by an Epicurean delusion concerning faith, as well as by papistic and Pharisaic confidence in their own works and merits.”

So given the first statement why does what we do matter at all?

When one says “**without any work, merit, or worthiness” **does that mean you are to believe that repenting of sin and turning to God is not considered a “work”, or not “our work” but instead God’s work in us or simply not necessary at all?

If we do not participate in our own salvaiton, at least to the degree that we either accept or reject God’s grace, this creates a couple of problems that I don’t know how to resolve.

Fundamentally the issue I have with this type of language is that if we take man completely out of any participation in his own salvation we are logically forced to conclude two things that if I accept as true makes life pretty much meaningless: 1.) We have no free will. 2.) God arbitrarily chooses to save some and damn others.

Chuck
 

Quote:
=paul c;6714921]Well, we don’t describe it quite that way. We describe it more like this:
To go to heaven, you must die in the state of grace. You get in the state of grace initially through baptism and you stay that way as long as you avoid mortal sin by loving God and neighbor (i.e., doing good works). If you fall from grace through mortal sin, you can be reconciled to God through the sacrament of reconciliation. Through God’s mercy, you can be reconciled as many times as you need to. You can get additional grace to help you avoid sin through the sacraments.
That’s good. We’re closing in on agreement.

Quote:
This seems largely inconsistent. On one hand, you say that justification is a one time event and that good works have nothing to do with it. Yet you say that justification can be lost (because you agree that OSAS is a false doctrine). How is justification lost in your theology? And if you state that you don’t believe that justification can be lost, then by definition, you believe in OSAS.
Why do you Lutheran’s insist on using the word “alone” for everything when you clearly don’t mean alone? How can it be Grace alone, Faith alone, Christ alone, Scripture alone. and for works be required to complete Faith? they can’t all be alone. If you would just droop that word, we’d probably be in pretty good alignment. So yes, you need Grace to go to heaven. We agree with that. But you have to cooperate with Grace to go to heaven. Which you also agree with. So its not Grace alone as I understand the word alone.

Quote:
Catholics get into the state of Grace by being baptized. This is an act of faith (in infant baptism, the parent’s are the proxy). But you can not stay in the state of grace by simply saying" I believe". You must live out your faith and avoid mortal sin…
Sure we do. No argument here.

I believe that Lutherans want to guard against pride by saying that everything is from Christ but the danger in that is that people extend it to mean that they have no personal responsibility in their salvation and become complacent. Some extend it to the point that they believe that simply saying they believe in Christ is sufficient for salvation, even if they apostacize at a later date. Catholics know that they can’t earn their way to heaven on their own, just like Lutherans know that they must follow the will of the father to get to heaven, despite the verbage.
 
don’t know, maybe it is all semantics. We, eventually, come to the same realization, that the Christian is saved by the suffering death and resurrection of Christ, and not of our own doing, and that as regenerate Christians, we are required to follow the commands of Christ.
I think it is all just semantics.

Have you read the attached? What do you think?

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-joint-declaration_en.html
 
=clmowry;6715130]“Accordingly, we believe, teach, and confess that our righteousness before God is (this very thing], that God forgives us our sins out of pure grace, without any work, merit, or worthiness of ours preceding, present, or following, that He presents and imputes to us the righteousness of Christ’s obedience, on account of which righteousness we are received into grace by God, and regarded as righteous.”

“For especially in these last times it is no less needful to admonish men to Christian discipline [to the way of living aright and godly] and good works, and remind them how necessary it is that they exercise themselves in good works as a declaration of their faith and gratitude to God, than that the works be not mingled in the article of justification; because men may be damned by an Epicurean delusion concerning faith, as well as by papistic and Pharisaic confidence in their own works and merits.”

So given the first statement why does what we do matter at all?
Hi Chuck,
Part of your answer is in the second paragraph. “remind them how necessary it is…”. ButI’ll also add this:
  1. Nevertheless, by the words mentioned, necessitas, necessarium, necessity and necessary, if they be employed concerning the regenerate, not coercion, but only due obedience is to be understood, which the truly believing, so far as they are regenerate, render not from coercion or the driving of the Law, but from a voluntary spirit; because they are no more under the Law, but under grace, Rom. 6:14; 7:6; 8:14.
11] 6. Accordingly, we also believe, teach, and confess that when it is said: The regenerate do good works from a free spirit, this is not to be understood as though it is at the option of the regenerate man to do or to forbear doing good when he wishes, and that he can nevertheless retain faith if he intentionally perseveres in sins.
12] 7. Yet this is not to be understood otherwise than as the Lord Christ and His apostles themselves declare, namely, regarding the liberated spirit, that it does not do this from fear of punishment, like a servant, but from love of righteousness, like children,
It isn’t like we have a choice in the matter of doing, or not doing, good works. Why? Because failure to do good works is sin, and we can’t retain faith if we intentionally perevere in sin. It is the loss of saving faith that condemns.
Now, we both recognize that the regenerate sin, and we rely on sanctifying grace - the forgiveness of sin through confession and absolution, and the Holy Eucharist to keep us strong in our faith so we can do what He calls us to do.
When one says "without any work, merit, or worthiness" does that mean you are to believe that repenting of sin and turning to God is not considered a “work”, or not “our work” but instead God’s work in us or simply not necessary at all?
If we do not participate in our own salvaiton, at least to the degree that we either accept or reject God’s grace, this creates a couple of problems that I don’t know how to resolve.
The regenerate Christian is made aware of sin through the law. It makes us aware of our sinful nature, and our need for repentance, and Lutherans and Catholics practice similar means in this way. It is synergistic. We choose to submit to the will of the savior and confess our sins. But our actions, important and critical though they may be, are not what saves us. Christ’s actions save us.
Fundamentally the issue I have with this type of language is that if we take man completely out of any participation in his own salvation we are logically forced to conclude two things that if I accept as true makes life pretty much meaningless: 1.) We have no free will. 2.) God arbitrarily chooses to save some and damn others.
And this is a confusion with Calvinism. Lutherans accept neither of these.
Lutherans acknowledge the requirement of our participation in sanctification (growth in grace). But these works are not what has saved us: Christ’s actions (grace alone) makes salvation possible, and our acts do not add to that.
  1. Free will: We have free will, once justified, to reject grace, by choosing to live in repeated, unrepented sin. Prior to justification, we cannot come to Christ because we are in sin. We reject the “I choose to accept Christ…” statements of some Baptists ans evangelicals. Once justified, which we receive by grace through faith, only then is there free will.
  2. God does not arbitrtarily save some and damn others. That is a false doctrine of Calvinism. “For God so loved the world…” not some of it.
Jon
 
I believe that Lutherans want to guard against pride by saying that everything is from Christ but the danger in that is that people extend it to mean that they have no personal responsibility in their salvation and become complacent. Some extend it to the point that they believe that simply saying they believe in Christ is sufficient for salvation, even if they apostacize at a later date. Catholics know that they can’t earn their way to heaven on their own, just like Lutherans know that they must follow the will of the father to get to heaven, despite the verbage.
I think you now realize, paul, that Lutherans do not believe we can reject Christ’s commands and still claim to have a living, saving faith, though you are right that some Christians do. This is a remarkably good statement. Lutherans must guard against falling into cheap grace, and Catholics must guard against the belief that their works are alone can earn them salvation. Where we meet is in your last sentence.
Well said, Paul.

Jon
 
=guanophore;6715029]I think it is semantics. Many of our separated brethren use the word “salvation” to refer only to the justification aspect, whereas, when we use it, it encompasses all three aspects.
And some folks improperly use “faith alone” to mean that we have no responsibility to obey is commands.
For example, in the Epistle of Jude we read:
20But you, dear friends, build yourselves up in your most holy faith and pray in the Holy Spirit. 21Keep yourselves in God’s love as you wait for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ to bring you to eternal life.
22Be merciful to those who doubt; 23snatch others from the fire and save them; to others show mercy, mixed with fear—hating even the clothing stained by corrupted flesh.
Can we really “build ourselves up” in faith apart from God’s grace? No. This is a reference to the synergistic sanctification we both acknowledge.
I agree.
Can we snatch others from the fire and save them? Can any human being do anything that will result in the salvation of another?
Yet, when we are moved by the Spirit, we can act on behalf of those who are weak in faith, or fallen, and “save” them (contribute to their salvation).
This is a meritorious act.
If we allow the Holy Spirit to use our hands and hearts, we can, and the merits of Christ flow through us to strengthen and save others.

Jon
 
It isn’t like we have a choice in the matter of doing, or not doing, good works. Why? Because failure to do good works is sin, and we can’t retain faith if we intentionally perevere in sin. It is the loss of saving faith that condemns.
Now, we both recognize that the regenerate sin, and we rely on sanctifying grace - the forgiveness of sin through confession and absolution, and the Holy Eucharist to keep us strong in our faith so we can do what He calls us to do.
We have the choice on whether to sin or not or to do good works or not. Do you deny this?
The regenerate Christian is made aware of sin through the law. It makes us aware of our sinful nature, and our need for repentance, and Lutherans and Catholics practice similar means in this way. It is synergistic. We choose to submit to the will of the savior and confess our sins. But our actions, important and critical though they may be, are not what saves us. Christ’s actions save us.
We are also made aware of sin through our consciences. As St. Paul said, even those that don’t have access to the law are held accountable to the natural law that resides inside us. Both our actions and Christ’s actions save us. They are synergerstic. Christ actions will not save us if we chose to sin. Similarly, if we do good works for reasons other than love, they will not save us either.
And this is a confusion with Calvinism. Lutherans accept neither of these.
Lutherans acknowledge the requirement of our participation in sanctification (growth in grace). But these works are not what has saved us: Christ’s actions (grace alone) makes salvation possible, and our acts do not add to that.
  1. Free will: We have free will, once justified, to reject grace, by choosing to live in repeated, unrepented sin. Prior to justification, we cannot come to Christ because we are in sin. We reject the “I choose to accept Christ…” statements of some Baptists ans evangelicals. Once justified, which we receive by grace through faith, only then is there free will.
  2. God does not arbitrtarily save some and damn others. That is a false doctrine of Calvinism. “For God so loved the world…” not some of it.
We agree on the Calvinist confusion. But don’t discount Luther’s confusion either.

Afterall, he felt that he could interpret scripture better than all that came before him, adding his own innovations to what the Apostles taught. In fact, he was not above second guessing the Apostles themselves: per his discourse on James that you posted in the other thread. while Lutheran’s are close to Catholics relatively speaking, there is still error

Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top