Catholic worship vs Protestant worship?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nat_c1990
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nat_c1990

Guest
I talked a little bit about this in a different thread but for anyone that didn’t see it, I will explain my situation. My husband and I have both grown up going to Baptist churches most of our lives. A few years ago we moved and had to switch churches, which is when he started going to a non denominational church. The main reason that he really started going there is because they were looking for a bass guitar player. He was apart of the worship team at his previous church and he really enjoys playing music so of course, he took advantage of the opportunity.

Just from what he had told me about the church, it didn’t really seem like my style but I decided to go and give it a try anyway. Most of the people there were very welcoming and friendly. The pastor and his wife in particular have always been very welcoming and loving toward us. The first time I went to the church, everything was fine. I liked the music, everyone was really nice. It was different than what I was used to but I honestly thought that I could possibly see myself going there. But the more that I went there, the more I started to question if it was really the right church for me, and the more uncomfortable I became.

There are a lot of things this church does that I do not agree with. For one, there is no structure whatsoever. If at any time during the service, a member of the church wants to come up in front of everyone and speak, they are allowed to do so. The pastor’s reasoning is that if the Holy Spirit is calling someone to say something, he doesn’t want to interfere with that. Although I think the church has good intentions, I think this is something you have to be really careful with. When you allow anyone and everyone to come up and speak, you really don’t know what is going to come out of their mouth. It could be something that really touches and inspires people, on the other hand, it could be something that really offends people and turns them off. I feel like they should be more careful with who they choose to let represent their church.

One day that I attended the church, a woman decided to get up and speak right in the middle of the worship service. She walked up to the front, grabbed the microphone and proceeded to tell us that there were some people in the room who were worshiping halfheartedly, and that we all need to be on fire for God because this is our time to worship him. On this particular day, I had brought my mom with me as a guest. My mom and I are both very quiet, reserved people. We were in the minority because most of the people there are very outspoken. During this woman’s message, my mom and I both felt very uncomfortable because we couldn’t help but to feel like her comments were somewhat directed toward us. A lot of people at the church will clap and dance during worship, but thats just not my personality or my mom’s either.

I actually have pretty bad social anxiety and a lot of times its a struggle for me to even go to church at all because it makes me really anxious to be around large groups of people. Usually I don’t even sing out loud at church because I’m self conscious. I usually just stand there and try to really think about and reflect on the lyrics of the song. I feel like people are going to be looking at me or judging me if I sing or do anything else. And it kind of confirmed my fears when that lady got up and started making judgmental statements about the way people were worshiping. I felt like she was judging me and looking at me even when I was trying my best to just blend in with everyone, I was still getting judged. Personally I think people like her should be less concerned with looking around the room, worried about what everyone else is doing and more focused on God.

Ill admit it would make me a little uncomfortable when people would start dancing and things like that, but I wasn’t judging them. If thats the way they feel comfortable worshiping, who am I to say something about it? I just tried to not focus on people like that and to concentrate on the reason that I was supposed to be there. I just thought it was really wrong for the lady to insinuate that just because she doesnt see someone outwardly worship at church, that means they don’t worship God. Personally, I’m more comfortable singing to God when I’m at home by myself. That way I don’t have to worry about being judged or having social anxiety. I can just give all my attention to God and not worry about anything else.

My husband and I went to a Catholic church last Sunday and I was pleasantly surprised at how calm and relaxed the environment was. It seemed much more suited for me and my personality, and for my husband’s personality too, to be honest. I didn’t sing along during the hymns but that was mostly because I didnt know any of them. But as far as not wanting to sing because I felt like the people there were judging me, I didn’t feel like that at all. Overall, everyone made me feel very comfortable. I guess I’m just looking for a Catholic perspective on the subject.
 
Welcome to CAF. 👋

Having come from a Pentecostal background (having been Episcopalian before that–long story) I can identify with your difficulties with it.

Worship means different things to different churches for many reasons, but the primary one is how they interpret Scripture, and their feelings. There are as many non-denom churches as their are biblical interpretations, it seems. What you’ll get from one to the other will vary by quite a bit.

I too was targeted for “not being spiritual enough” at my Pentecostal church, so I know just how it feels. It’s not right for anyone to judge anyone’s else’s spirituality, even if the motives are good ones. Don’t let it bother you, but don’t let yourself be subjected to it, either, is my advice.

As for Catholic worship, we attend Mass for 3 reasons: 1) to worship God in spirit and in truth, 2) to hear his word proclaimed (in the readings, Gospel, and the homily), 3) and to participate in the Holy Eucharist, which is holy communion.

Catholic Masses are based on OT temple worship as well as the NT early Church worship. It’s form has been “tweaked” down through the centuries meeting the needs of each generation, but it’s remained basically the same.

I hope you will attend Mass again. I think you’ll find it quite fulfilling for you and your husband. I wish you all the best. I will remember you in my Evening Prayer intentions today. Please say a little prayer for me too. 🙂
 
There is something for every kind of spirituality in the Catholic church, different ministries, apostates, prayer groups, etc. The Mass is one place where One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic exemplified. You can go anywhere in the world and, even if you don’t know the language, know what is going on during the Mass and be able to follow along and Jesus is there Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity. There is some variation because there are different rites but I don’t want to get into that too deeply here but the Mass is a ritual and the rubrics of the Mass are there to keep the main thing the main thing: the focus on Jesus in the Eucharist.

OTOH, the Church is made up of people and we are imperfect. Parishes seem to have different personalities and those seem to change depending on the the pastor. We all have our quirks but we are family and we act like it for better or for worse. 🙂
 
Welcome to CAF. 👋

(…)
**Catholic Masses are based on OT temple worship as well as the NT early Church worship. It’s form has been “tweaked” down through the centuries meeting the needs of each generation, but it’s remained basically the same.
**
I hope you will attend Mass again. I think you’ll find it quite fulfilling for you and your husband. I wish you all the best. I will remember you in my Evening Prayer intentions today. Please say a little prayer for me too. 🙂
Yes! I forgot to add that. I was a part of “the the Mass is a ritual…” Della said it well.
 
I have to agree that the more liturgical worship style has always been where I’ve felt at home. Catholics, Orthodox, many Anglicans, many Lutherans, and a few other Protestant denominations forms of worship are all in that same basic liturgical style and I agree. I’ve been to non-denominational, Baptist, Pentecostal, and a few other non-liturgical denominations services, and they frankly always feel a bit alien to me. I don’t question what their congregants are experiencing, some clearly feel they are feeling the spirit in them, etc. But at the same time I end up uncomfortable more than anything else.
 
Thanks for the replies, guys!

My husband has been studying Catholicism for the past year or so and he says he has known for a while now that he would eventually convert to Catholicism. Growing up Protestant, we both have heard a lot of negative things about Catholics (they don’t believe in Jesus, they worship Mary, they worship statues,etc…) but when we actually started doing the research on our own, we realized that basically everything we have ever been taught about Catholicism was a lie. After attending Mass last Sunday, it just kind of confirmed everything we have learned and we have actually already decided to become members there. I’m really excited about it and I feel like I’m finally where I am supposed to be!
 
Just an FYI, you can’t become a member of a Catholic church without converting (as I’ve been made well aware of where my family goes), but it sounds like you may know that already.

I come from a non-denominational background and I’m sorry for the experience that you had at the one that you describe. Non-denominational churches can really run a full spectrum in styles of worship, so they can’t all be painted with the same brush.

The church that I grew up actually has a worship structure much like the Catholic church. We actually didn’t have any music at all. The one non-denom church in the town I live in now has a small band, but overall it’s a quite reserved service.

I’m glad that you had a welcoming experience at your new church. As a non-Catholic I have been extremely unwelcome at the two Parishes in our town.
 
I have to agree that the more liturgical worship style has always been where I’ve felt at home. Catholics, Orthodox, many Anglicans, many Lutherans, and a few other Protestant denominations forms of worship are all in that same basic liturgical style and I agree. I’ve been to non-denominational, Baptist, Pentecostal, and a few other non-liturgical denominations services, and they frankly always feel a bit alien to me. I don’t question what their congregants are experiencing, some clearly feel they are feeling the spirit in them, etc. But at the same time I end up uncomfortable more than anything else.
Thats how I feel too. When they start dancing around and speaking in tongues thats when I start feeling a bit awkward. Not that I’m doubting their sincerity, only Jesus knows whats in their hearts, which is why I don’t feel its my place to judge. Its just that its not my personality to worship in that type of way. I don’t typically outwardly express my emotions in general. I tend to keep my feelings to myself. If I ever did dance or do any of those things, it would be because I was being led by the Holy Spirit, but I’m not going to do it just because other people want me to do it. I think God wouldn’t want you to do it unless you’re being genuine.

I guess I just expected people to be able to accept that there are different styles of worshiping and that they would be able to accept my way without judging me, just as I don’t judge them. I would never tell someone that they need to sit down and stop being so loud, so what makes it ok for them to tell someone that they need to be more vocal/outgoing and to stop worshiping halfheartedly? It doesn’t, in my opinion.
 
Thats how I feel too. When they start dancing around and speaking in tongues thats when I start feeling a bit awkward. Not that I’m doubting their sincerity, only Jesus knows whats in their hearts, which is why I don’t feel its my place to judge. Its just that its not my personality to worship in that type of way. I don’t typically outwardly express my emotions in general. I tend to keep my feelings to myself. If I ever did dance or do any of those things, it would be because I was being led by the Holy Spirit, but I’m not going to do it just because other people want me to do it. I think God wouldn’t want you to do it unless you’re being genuine.

I guess I just expected people to be able to accept that there are different styles of worshiping and that they would be able to accept my way without judging me, just as I don’t judge them. I would never tell someone that they need to sit down and stop being so loud, so what makes it ok for them to tell someone that they need to be more vocal/outgoing and to stop worshiping halfheartedly? It doesn’t, in my opinion.
I love a structured service as well but the structure may come in different ways. As a Lutheran, I’ve used the hymnals, hymnal supplements, liturgies written out in the bulletin (mostly because the church did not have money to buy any hymnals yet.). Some sing the hymns in the hymnals while others sing gospel or contemporary songs on a screen or blank wall in the church. I visited my brother’s Free Methodist church, and while they may not have all the components of a liturgy, they do have a structure they follow each week in their bulletins.

Probably the craziest service I’ve ever been to was my aunt’s funeral. The pastor was speaking and all of a sudden the whole church erupted with what I think they believed was speaking in tongues…weird. It lasted about 5 minutes, and if it weren’t my aunt’s funeral I would have gotten out of there as quickly as I could!

Just some of the things I’ve experienced,

God bless,

Rita
 
Just an FYI, you can’t become a member of a Catholic church without converting (as I’ve been made well aware of where my family goes), but it sounds like you may know that already.

I come from a non-denominational background and I’m sorry for the experience that you had at the one that you describe. Non-denominational churches can really run a full spectrum in styles of worship, so they can’t all be painted with the same brush.

The church that I grew up actually has a worship structure much like the Catholic church. We actually didn’t have any music at all. The one non-denom church in the town I live in now has a small band, but overall it’s a quite reserved service.

I’m glad that you had a welcoming experience at your new church. As a non-Catholic I have been extremely unwelcome at the two Parishes in our town.
We spoke to the deacon and he answered a lot of questions for us and was very informative and friendly. Did you speak to a deacon or a priest when you went? I hate to hear that you didn’t feel welcome. If you don’t mind me asking, why did you feel that way? Was there something specific that happened or were the members of the church just not very friendly?

It sounds like the non denominational church that you go to would be more suitable for someone like me. The one that I was going to was very small, maybe only 30 members of so, and the majority of people that go there are very extroverted. So, I always felt like I kind of stuck out like a sore thumb because I’m different. I didn’t feel that way at the Catholic church, I felt like I fit in with everyone else.

Its true that just about every Protestant church is different. I’ve been to several Baptist churches and none of them were really the same. Thats another thing I like about the Catholic church. When you go to their church, you know what to expect. Although there will be different people, and some things will be slightly different, everything will basically be the same.
 
Just an FYI, you can’t become a member of a Catholic church without converting (as I’ve been made well aware of where my family goes), but it sounds like you may know that already.

I come from a non-denominational background and I’m sorry for the experience that you had at the one that you describe. Non-denominational churches can really run a full spectrum in styles of worship, so they can’t all be painted with the same brush.

The church that I grew up actually has a worship structure much like the Catholic church. We actually didn’t have any music at all. The one non-denom church in the town I live in now has a small band, but overall it’s a quite reserved service.

I’m glad that you had a welcoming experience at your new church. As a non-Catholic I have been extremely unwelcome at the two Parishes in our town.
To become a member of the Catholic Church is a lot different than just popping in and going out when you feel like it. Anyone is welcome to come to a Catholic Mass, but to be able to receive the Holy Eucharist, one must be Baptized, and believe they are receiving the TRUE Body and Blood of Jesus Christ as He said we would in John, chapter 6. and at the Last Supper. One must be instructed in the Catholic Faith so to know what the Catholic Church really believes and teaches, and not just what some others falsely claim she believes. That is a beautiful journey. I cannot imagine any parish being unwelcome to visitors. Go and find out for yourself. Don’t be afraid to talk to Father and let him know your visiting. Every Catholic Church I have ever been in has been very welcoming, and I have been in them from Maine to Calif. Alabama to No. Dakota and around. You many not understand the Mass right away but that can be explained also. We have NO secrets. Our Mass is not a social event but a solemn worship of Our Lord. It is not a fellowship time, we have plenty of those outside of Mass. That is one of the big differences between us and many denominations.
I would also suggest watching a program on EWTN on Monday nights 7PM CST, called Journey Home. God Bless, Memaw
 
I talked a little bit about this in a different thread but for anyone that didn’t see it, I will explain my situation. My husband and I have both grown up going to Baptist churches most of our lives. A few years ago we moved and had to switch churches, which is when he started going to a non denominational church. The main reason that he really started going there is because they were looking for a bass guitar player. He was apart of the worship team at his previous church and he really enjoys playing music so of course, he took advantage of the opportunity.

Just from what he had told me about the church, it didn’t really seem like my style but I decided to go and give it a try anyway. Most of the people there were very welcoming and friendly. The pastor and his wife in particular have always been very welcoming and loving toward us. The first time I went to the church, everything was fine. I liked the music, everyone was really nice. It was different than what I was used to but I honestly thought that I could possibly see myself going there. But the more that I went there, the more I started to question if it was really the right church for me, and the more uncomfortable I became.
There are a lot of things this church does that I do not agree with. For one, there is no structure whatsoever. If at any time during the service, a member of the church wants to come up in front of everyone and speak, they are allowed to do so. The pastor’s reasoning is that if the Holy Spirit is calling someone to say something, he doesn’t want to interfere with that. Although I think the church has good intentions, I think this is something you have to be really careful with. When you allow anyone and everyone to come up and speak, you really don’t know what is going to come out of their mouth. It could be something that really touches and inspires people, on the other hand, it could be something that really offends people and turns them off. I feel like they should be more careful with who they choose to let represent their church.

One day that I attended the church, a woman decided to get up and speak right in the middle of the worship service. She walked up to the front, grabbed the microphone and proceeded to tell us that there were some people in the room who were worshiping halfheartedly, and that we all need to be on fire for God because this is our time to worship him. On this particular day, I had brought my mom with me as a guest. My mom and I are both very quiet, reserved people. We were in the minority because most of the people there are very outspoken. During this woman’s message, my mom and I both felt very uncomfortable because we couldn’t help but to feel like her comments were somewhat directed toward us. A lot of people at the church will clap and dance during worship, but thats just not my personality or my mom’s either.

I actually have pretty bad social anxiety and a lot of times its a struggle for me to even go to church at all because it makes me really anxious to be around large groups of people. Usually I don’t even sing out loud at church because I’m self conscious. I usually just stand there and try to really think about and reflect on the lyrics of the song. I feel like people are going to be looking at me or judging me if I sing or do anything else. And it kind of confirmed my fears when that lady got up and started making judgmental statements about the way people were worshiping. I felt like she was judging me and looking at me even when I was trying my best to just blend in with everyone, I was still getting judged. Personally I think people like her should be less concerned with looking around the room, worried about what everyone else is doing and more focused on God.

Ill admit it would make me a little uncomfortable when people would start dancing and things like that, but I wasn’t judging them. If thats the way they feel comfortable worshiping, who am I to say something about it? I just tried to not focus on people like that and to concentrate on the reason that I was supposed to be there. I just thought it was really wrong for the lady to insinuate that just because she doesnt see someone outwardly worship at church, that means they don’t worship God. Personally, I’m more comfortable singing to God when I’m at home by myself. That way I don’t have to worry about being judged or having social anxiety. I can just give all my attention to God and not worry about anything else.

My husband and I went to a Catholic church last Sunday and I was pleasantly surprised at how calm and relaxed the environment was. It seemed much more suited for me and my personality, and for my husband’s personality too, to be honest. I didn’t sing along during the hymns but that was mostly because I didnt know any of them. But as far as not wanting to sing because I felt like the people there were judging me, I didn’t feel like that at all. Overall, everyone made me feel very comfortable. I guess I’m just looking for a Catholic perspective on the subject.

1st WELCOME to CAF! 🙂

As a “newbe” here please know that CAF limits the space per post, so my rely will have to be briefer than I’d like to make it.

In reading your very thoughtful post It seemed evident to me that you’re concerns reflect those of a “typical” non-Catholic. They are centered on personal like & wants. NOT a bad thing but vastly different than what we Catholics do.

Because we do really have Jesus Present in our Midst {the Most Holy Eucharist} our Worship centers on, focus on on and evolves around DIVINE Godly Worship. Because God is in our midst; God then in the reason and the focus of our Mass.

Catholic fellowship for the most part is left for activities outside of our Mass [Worship Services]

God Bless you my friend,
Patrick
 
We spoke to the deacon and he answered a lot of questions for us and was very informative and friendly. Did you speak to a deacon or a priest when you went? I hate to hear that you didn’t feel welcome. If you don’t mind me asking, why did you feel that way? Was there something specific that happened or were the members of the church just not very friendly?

It sounds like the non denominational church that you go to would be more suitable for someone like me. The one that I was going to was very small, maybe only 30 members of so, and the majority of people that go there are very extroverted. So, I always felt like I kind of stuck out like a sore thumb because I’m different. I didn’t feel that way at the Catholic church, I felt like I fit in with everyone else.

Its true that just about every Protestant church is different. I’ve been to several Baptist churches and none of them were really the same. Thats another thing I like about the Catholic church. When you go to their church, you know what to expect. Although there will be different people, and some things will be slightly different, everything will basically be the same.
It’s a really long story…

When my wife and I first moved to the town we live in (13 years ago) we looked at one Parrish. The once the Father there found out you weren’t Catholic, he pretty much dismissed you from the conversation and wanted nothing to do with you. Same thing happened to the couple across the street. He also wouldn’t marry us because I’m not Catholic.

We chose to go to my wife’s home Parish 15 min down the road instead. There I was the only non-Catholic, and anywhere our names were (directory, mailbox, etc…) my name was asterisked. At the time of church festival(s) my wife would get the invites and be listed where to volunteer (everyone was) but I wouldn’t. Basically I was given the Heisman “no thanks, we don’t need help if you’re not Catholic”. I got a ton of strange looks when I let people out of the row for communion…

There was other stuff too, but I really don’t want to get into it and hi-jack your thread. Coming from my non-denom background, what seemed to be a culture of exclusivity seemed really strange.

My home church was probably 40-50 people, so still pretty small. It was just laid back. It seems the non-denom church with the rock band is becoming more and more popular, not exactly sure why though. 🤷
 
To become a member of the Catholic Church is a lot different than just popping in and going out when you feel like it. Anyone is welcome to come to a Catholic Mass, but to be able to receive the Holy Eucharist, one must be Baptized, and believe they are receiving the TRUE Body and Blood of Jesus Christ as He said we would in John, chapter 6. and at the Last Supper. One must be instructed in the Catholic Faith so to know what the Catholic Church really believes and teaches, and not just what some others falsely claim she believes. That is a beautiful journey. I cannot imagine any parish being unwelcome to visitors. Go and find out for yourself. Don’t be afraid to talk to Father and let him know your visiting. Every Catholic Church I have ever been in has been very welcoming, and I have been in them from Maine to Calif. Alabama to No. Dakota and around. You many not understand the Mass right away but that can be explained also. We have NO secrets. Our Mass is not a social event but a solemn worship of Our Lord. It is not a fellowship time, we have plenty of those outside of Mass. That is one of the big differences between us and many denominations.
I would also suggest watching a program on EWTN on Monday nights 7PM CST, called Journey Home. God Bless, Memaw
A) You’re explaining traditions and beliefs I already know. I’ve been around the Church for 13 years now.

B) I’ve laid out how I’ve been treated as Mass/in Parrishes on the board before. I’m not sure why any Parrish wouldn’t welcome visitors either. Like I’ve said before, the experiences were/are pretty strange to me. 🤷
 
Just an FYI, you can’t become a member of a Catholic church without converting (as I’ve been made well aware of where my family goes), but it sounds like you may know that already.

I come from a non-denominational background and I’m sorry for the experience that you had at the one that you describe. Non-denominational churches can really run a full spectrum in styles of worship, so they can’t all be painted with the same brush.

The church that I grew up actually has a worship structure much like the Catholic church. We actually didn’t have any music at all. The one non-denom church in the town I live in now has a small band, but overall it’s a quite reserved service.

I’m glad that you had a welcoming experience at your new church. As a non-Catholic I have been extremely unwelcome at the two Parishes in our town.
Interesting, I’ve admittedly never seen a non-denominational church with a more liturgical service. I’ve seen ones with more reserved worship, with minimal hymn style music, but they always are somewhere in the more Baptist or Pentecostal traditions. Mainly focused on the word if they’re not focused on singing. And the structure is never much like Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican (high or low), or Lutheran style services. I’d be interested to see/find such a service and view it if just out of curiosity.
 
A) You’re explaining traditions and beliefs I already know. I’ve been around the Church for 13 years now.

B) **I’ve laid out how I’ve been treated as Mass/in Parrishes on the board before. ** I’m not sure why any Parrish wouldn’t welcome visitors either. Like I’ve said before, the experiences were/are pretty strange to me. 🤷
It happens. The closest Catholic church to where I live currently is one of those that’s not all that welcoming. Maybe I’ve caught them on bad days the times I’ve stopped by, but I tend to be ignored or get looks of suspicion if I’m acknowledged at all. Don’t know why put the people in the parish seem far more preoccupied than many I’ve visited, both Catholic and other Protestant, and not always with God. In terms of distraction in church it’s definitely one where people take calls, are on their phones, come in very late or leave early, etc…

But at the same time I know it’s in no way representative of all Catholic Churches. One of the friendliest churches I’ve been to in recent years was a Catholic Church as well so if you’re interested in the RCC don’t let one “bad” individual church dissuade you.
 
I can only write about the differences I have experienced between Protestant and Catholic worship - in the best tradition of both.

For me, a loved filled Protestant worship is like going on a picnic in the mountains with family and friends and being part of a wonderful picnic, praising God and enjoying the fellowship of like believers.

For me, Catholic worship is like leaving the party, going beneath the tall dark pines and listening to God’s voice in the wind.
 
I talked a little bit about this in a different thread but for anyone that didn’t see it, I will explain my situation. My husband and I have both grown up going to Baptist churches most of our lives. A few years ago we moved and had to switch churches, which is when he started going to a non denominational church. The main reason that he really started going there is because they were looking for a bass guitar player. He was apart of the worship team at his previous church and he really enjoys playing music so of course, he took advantage of the opportunity.

Just from what he had told me about the church, it didn’t really seem like my style but I decided to go and give it a try anyway. Most of the people there were very welcoming and friendly. The pastor and his wife in particular have always been very welcoming and loving toward us. The first time I went to the church, everything was fine. I liked the music, everyone was really nice. It was different than what I was used to but I honestly thought that I could possibly see myself going there. But the more that I went there, the more I started to question if it was really the right church for me, and the more uncomfortable I became.

There are a lot of things this church does that I do not agree with. For one, there is no structure whatsoever. If at any time during the service, a member of the church wants to come up in front of everyone and speak, they are allowed to do so. The pastor’s reasoning is that if the Holy Spirit is calling someone to say something, he doesn’t want to interfere with that. Although I think the church has good intentions, I think this is something you have to be really careful with. When you allow anyone and everyone to come up and speak, you really don’t know what is going to come out of their mouth. It could be something that really touches and inspires people, on the other hand, it could be something that really offends people and turns them off. I feel like they should be more careful with who they choose to let represent their church.

One day that I attended the church, a woman decided to get up and speak right in the middle of the worship service. She walked up to the front, grabbed the microphone and proceeded to tell us that there were some people in the room who were worshiping halfheartedly, and that we all need to be on fire for God because this is our time to worship him. On this particular day, I had brought my mom with me as a guest. My mom and I are both very quiet, reserved people. We were in the minority because most of the people there are very outspoken. During this woman’s message, my mom and I both felt very uncomfortable because we couldn’t help but to feel like her comments were somewhat directed toward us. A lot of people at the church will clap and dance during worship, but thats just not my personality or my mom’s either.

I actually have pretty bad social anxiety and a lot of times its a struggle for me to even go to church at all because it makes me really anxious to be around large groups of people. Usually I don’t even sing out loud at church because I’m self conscious. I usually just stand there and try to really think about and reflect on the lyrics of the song. I feel like people are going to be looking at me or judging me if I sing or do anything else. And it kind of confirmed my fears when that lady got up and started making judgmental statements about the way people were worshiping. I felt like she was judging me and looking at me even when I was trying my best to just blend in with everyone, I was still getting judged. Personally I think people like her should be less concerned with looking around the room, worried about what everyone else is doing and more focused on God.

Ill admit it would make me a little uncomfortable when people would start dancing and things like that, but I wasn’t judging them. If thats the way they feel comfortable worshiping, who am I to say something about it? I just tried to not focus on people like that and to concentrate on the reason that I was supposed to be there. I just thought it was really wrong for the lady to insinuate that just because she doesnt see someone outwardly worship at church, that means they don’t worship God. Personally, I’m more comfortable singing to God when I’m at home by myself. That way I don’t have to worry about being judged or having social anxiety. I can just give all my attention to God and not worry about anything else.

My husband and I went to a Catholic church last Sunday and I was pleasantly surprised at how calm and relaxed the environment was. It seemed much more suited for me and my personality, and for my husband’s personality too, to be honest. I didn’t sing along during the hymns but that was mostly because I didnt know any of them. But as far as not wanting to sing because I felt like the people there were judging me, I didn’t feel like that at all. Overall, everyone made me feel very comfortable. I guess I’m just looking for a Catholic perspective on the subject.
I’m not comfortable with Pentecostal either. Just try a mainline church - such Reformed Evangelical Anglican, Presbyterian, Lutheran, Anglican.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top