Catholic xBox games

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lifeisbeautiful3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lifeisbeautiful3

Guest
If so many games for machines like Xbox are inappropriate (and I suspect we could all agree many are), why isn’t there more demand for wholesome games with Catholic (or at least Christian) ideals represented?
 
Because the people that create them are not interested.

What exactly would make a game Catholic?

Ideas anyone? Any takers? 😉
@Maximilian75, @Cruciferi, @Entwhistler ?
 
Last edited:
Game makers are ‘profit-focused’ and will produce items for which there is demand. So, I guess the real question is why there isn’t sufficient demand with the billion+ Christians we have in the world
 
Maybe something that walks you through a journey to more fully appreciate each book of the Bible. (Though, Revelations could get a little dicey!)
 
Last edited:
Noah: finding the pieces to build an ark ‘Minecraft style’
David: against Goliath
Etc…
 
You can build whatever you want in Minecraft already, there’s nothing to stop you from building an ark.

Fighting Goliath would be a boring game. Just one boss fight.

There have been some Bible-based video games before, and they are almost without exception terrible games. The Bible doesn’t really translate well into a well designed game. What genre of game are you even going to attempt? FPS for the Macabees? Survival horror for the Ten Plagues? Puzzle for Joseph and the Pharaoh? Those stories don’t provide enough narrative for a AAA game and you’d have to take a lot of creative liberties, which, you have to then ask yourself, is something you want in your Bible game. Not to mention all the problems that are almost certainly going to arise because some element of design or game play will offend one particular denomination or the other.

I always thought a western-style RPG surivial game set in the Ancient Near East would be fun, but not because I was to be preached at but because I’d like to explore that world a bit. Which brings me to my final point- that I, as a gamer and Christian, don’t need to be pandered to with faith-based entertainment. I want to play good and fun games, and I can’t really see how’d you make a Catholic (or any other religion) game actually fun to play.

There’s a lot of children friendly games out there for modern consoles. If you are worried about appropriateness for children get a Nintendo, not an Xbox, and play Splatoon as opposed to CoD.
 
A game version of the books of Maccabees perhaps?

I’m not too much of a gamer…
 
To be perfectly honest, when you play a video game, you aren’t doing it to be taught Christian ideals. The point is to have fun. This would be like watching a standard epic movie and be complaining that Jesus wasn’t brought up enough or that Catholic teaching wasn’t referenced. I don’t think that is the purpose of video games.

Now, I would totally agree with the statement that many video games have less than appropriate content. Scantily clad females, unnecessary killing, etc. That should change. And technically that isn’t Christian or Catholic. So you have a point.

But I think it is a bit of a stretch to ask for specifically Catholic themes in the next Lego [Insert Name Here] video game.
 
I’m not suggesting that every single video game should be based on Christian ideals. Merely that it’s interesting/telling that there isn’t a single one.

It would be similarly unfortunate if there weren’t a single movie that helps us better understand Christianity
 
I’m not suggesting that every single video game should be based on Christian ideals. Merely that it’s interesting/telling that there isn’t a single one.

There are tons of them. What’s telling is that not a single one of them is notable for anything other than being boring/awful or having an unusual development cycle, aside I guess from trivia or other minor genres like paint or music programs, which aren’t really major games. The most memorable games include Noah’s Ark 3D, which used the Doom engine (it’s speculated that Id games, developer of Doom, gave the engine to Noah’s Ark’s developers in order to spite some publisher). So it’s probably one of the better ones because the game play is the same as Doom/Wolfenstein 3D, except instead of shooting Nazis/inter-dimensional demons you instead shoot acorns at goats. Another interesting example is the You Testament, which uses a wrestling game engine and both lets you be either gigantic or tiny and has Jesus talking about chakras.

Ironically, many of the Bible-based games for Nintendo Entertainment System, the iconic 80’s console, where unlicensed. Nintendo has had a stringent licensing system in order to prevent very low-quality, broken, or inappriopriate games for being released on the system, not that bad NES or other Nintendo games don’t exist, they do, but they still had to apply for a license from Nintendo and pay royalties. So many Bible-based games for the NES where pirate cash grabs. Later Nintendo systems had more sophisticated hardware that prevented pirated games, however.

So Christian games absolutely exist. They are almost universally bad and people who play games for fun don’t buy them because they are transparent attempts to pander to a Christian audience or they are passion projects made by one guy who’s more concerned about making a preachy game than making a good game. I suspect they were bought by parents/grandparents to give as gifts to extremely disappointed children.
A game version of the books of Maccabees perhaps?
It’s be super violent though. Ancient world based games tend not to be received so well. There’s been a lot of ancient Rome games that have tanked. I think it’s partially because it’s hard to make swordplay translate well into a modern action framework; which is why shooters work well, is because it does translate well into modern tech, but melee almost always fall flat when it’s an option. The only ancient game that’s done really well that I can think of off the top of my head is God of War, which is infamous for it’s gore and sexuality, in which you play as Ares.

How to make a popular video game that isn’t violent has been a question in game development for decades. There are some great games that aren’t violent at all: puzzle, sport, simulation, etc. There are also tons of Indie games that shun violent themes as well. So this isn’t just a question that is wrestled with in Christian circles, it’s a development area that has been explored and is still being explored.
 
Dante’s inferno is a Christianity inspired game. Though at the same time not the most pg.
 
Dante’s inferno is a Christianity inspired game. Though at the same time not the most pg.
That’s an understatement; it’s rated M for violence, gore, nudity, and sexual content. Although for a game set in Hell I suppose that’s to be expected :P. Is it any good? I’ve never played it. Based on the summary though it sounds kinda like Dark Souls, at least plot wise.

Does it have any Christian aspects other than you’re in Hell fighting demons? Because that’s pretty much Doom.
 
It’s basically about a crusader who seeks to redeem himself and save his wife by going through all the stages of hell. There is a bunch of nudity, blood, gore, and the demons are horrific and disgusting looking monsters. But in the game you encounter interesting bosses such as Cleopatra and Julius Caesar. It plays a lot like god of war and it’s pretty old. Good game if you don’t mind the endless violence and weird boners.
 
Hm, doesn’t really sound like my thing. Not that I’m particullary offended by any o that, but I like to explore and have free reign over what I do - things like Fallout and Elder Scrolls. The historical basis sounds interesting (I tried my first modern FPS, Battlefield 1, just because I was going through a WW1 phase and I loved it- looking super forward to Battlefield V now), but I thought the same thing about the first two Assassin’s Creed games and I lost interest in those pretty quick.

It seems to me every other game these days is trying to be the same generic sort of action/adventure game, and I’ve really come to hate that genre because honestly, you played one, you’ve played them all. It’s what ruined RE6 and made them have to reboot it into RE7 (which looks horrifying, yes, but I miss the RE/SH puzzle horror games of yore where the real boss was a piano or a statue you had to clip together). Modern hardware no longer has the limitations that devs had to deal with decades ago, and as a result most games have morphed into the same sort of flashy hours long multistage adventures, which honestly look amazing and have some great art direction and graphics, but are ultimately boring and very interchangeable.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not some sort of purist who insists on the supremacy of Morrowind or anything, and I find a lot of the old turn-based PC games impossible to enjoy, mechanics-wise, but the industry seems to have a major lack of imagination at present. Note this is only for console games, as I don’t use a PC for various reasons. I know there’s some great stuff on Steam, and I’ve to see more of that influence on console games.
Good game if you don’t mind the weird boners.
Not a problem for me, I’m a woman 🤣

In all seriousness that stuff gets my goat way more than violence, if only because it’s such a blatant attempt at pandering to the ‘traditional’ teenage male audience. It’s just such lazy design. “How can we get this game better? Oh, let’s throw some boobs in there!” :roll_eyes: Puh-lease. It was a novelty for Duke Nukem and it should have stayed there. It’s just more of the non-stop objectification of women that is literally everywhere and in many forms (not even sexual form, but anything that demotes women to ‘other’ status). It’s just something that reminds me that being despite half of the human population, women are still seen by marketing/authority organizations/decision makers as outsiders. Your assumption that I was man (although I take no offense at it, don’t worry) proves that male is the default form of human and, as such, is the one that is marketed to, unless it’s a product that is specifically for women.

Like I said, overt female objectification in video games bothers me not because seeing naked women is offensive to me personally, but because it’s just another way of reinforcing that this game was not made with me in mind. Which makes me think of the fact that a lot of modern society was not made with my sex in mind, and that’s a pretty harsh way to be pulled out of escapist immersion.
 
Oh man, I actually played Baldur’s Gate 2 when it came out and I remember loving it. I don’t mind stuff being stat heavy, but I don’t PC game for various reasons: one being that I don’t have the set-up, and another being that over ten years ago I had a borderline WoW addiction (fueled by depression and a really bad, toxic relationship) and I find when I play on a screen it really limits my play time because it’s a shared space with me and I can’t monopolize the screen in that way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top