Catholicism and Satan

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tannhauser
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Tann, thanks for making this post.

Honestly I’m still studying both the protestant and Catholic faiths, and I’m sure there’s Christians in both faiths(yes, Catholics are Christian) that can give well informed answers to your questions.

However I must say this, jesus-is-savior is by far the most anti-catholic ministry I’ve seen on the internet. There is no discussion, no tolerance, absolutly no consideration of the notion that maybe the catholics have any validity at all. The site is filled with worldly paranoia along with sheer hate towards Catholics. I’ve met evangelicals that are far more reasonable and spiritually sound than the moderater of J-I-S. Please seek these ppl out.

Keep on growing and strengthening your faith, but just beware of the people that “help” you along the way.
 
Well… that makes little sense: only referring to Catholic sources.
Let’s say that someone of the opposite sex sues you and claims that you slandered him/her. They and their friends will testify against you and say that you said offensive things about the plaintiff that you did not actually say. How would you feel if you were put in that kind of a situation? It wouldn’t be fair, would it?

That’s why hearsay is not allowed in court!

So why are you doing the same thing to the Catholic Church? Everything on those websites is hearsay unless they can prove that the Church actually said the things claimed, and to do that they need to produce an actual papal encyclical or authentic document.
And actually I know rather a lot about my faith
You clearly don’t, if you think the Immaculate Conception is unbiblical.
 
Well… that makes little sense: only referring to Catholic sources.
I did not say “only” Catholic sources. But, I would think you would begin there in studying the Catholic faith.
I wouldn’t have even considered the question of ‘why do we call the Pope, Holy Father’, if I had not chanced this website.
Well, as was my suggestion, I think doing Catholic bible study would answered that question.
And actually I know rather a lot about my faith, how horribly presumptious of you to assume otherwise, based on a few questions that I have asked.
It isn’t the number, but the basic nature of the questions. Again, I apologize.
I have a Douay Rheims, and a Catechism, and a few Encyclicals; and I attend Church regularly and regular the Sacraments.
That is great!
 
It’s a fabrication. In case you haven’t noticed, not everyone claiming to be “Christian” is such.

Are you saying there is no Father God because the pagan greeks had a father god?

Why do you refer to your father as… uh… your father, if you have but one Father in heaven?
Why do you refer to anyone as holy if only God is holy?

That unction is called Holy Orders and as it is passed on by the imposition of hands (see 1 Tim 4:14), it doesn’t exist outside of the Catholic and Orthodox Churches.

Read 2 Thessalonians 2:15.

And have you even read the Catechism of the Catholic Church? Like any well researched work, it has footnotes, and most of those are to none other than the Holy Bible. Something you’ll discover quite quickly (if you actually care to learn about what it is you are criticizing) is that there is not one Catholic doctrine that has no scriptural support. Just plug whatever you want to search for (like “Assumption of Mary”) in that search box and read what it says, including the footnotes, then check your Bible and see for yourself.

For the same reason that you go to church on Sunday in a church building. Where’s that in the Bible? It isn’t—the Sabbath is Saturday and all of the early Christians worshiped in their own homes. By the way, why do you even have a church building? Why does it have pews and an altar? That’s your Sacred Tradition and you got it from the Catholic Church.

First of all, the Bible does say that Mary is at a special state of enmity with the devil, and that enmity is the same kind that Jesus has against the devil; thus, just as Jesus is without sin, so is Mary. Please read Genesis 3:15 if you don’t believe me. In fact, do it anyway. Read your Bible, not these anti-Catholic websites.

Actually, speaking of which… Where do you get the idea that this particular stack of books is the Bible, and for that matter, that the Bible is the Word of God? According to the Bible, the Word of God is Jesus Christ, not a book. That the Bible is the Word of God is one of those infallible dogmas of the Catholic Church that you borrowed, just like your church building.
keithtruth.com/catholic_misuse_of_genesis_315.html

Apparently Genesis 3:15 should actually be the masculine and refers to Christ, and the Latin Vulgate was mistranslated???
 
keithtruth.com/catholic_misuse_of_genesis_315.html

Apparently Genesis 3:15 should actually be the masculine and refers to Christ, and the Latin Vulgate was mistranslated???
Whether the pronoun in “[he/she] shall crush your head” is masculine or feminine is a red herring because “the Woman” is not a man.

Here is Gen. 3:15 (NRSV–a Protestant translation):

I will put enmity between you and the woman,
and between your offspring and hers;
he will strike your head,
and you will strike his heel.’

Substitute proper names:

I will put enmity between satan and Mary,
and between satan’s offspring and Jesus;
[Jesus or Mary] will strike satan’s head,
and satan will strike Jesus’s heel.’
 
**Another **anti-Catholic website? You really aren’t adding to your credibility.
I agree. Tann, you say you own a catechism and a copy of the DR Bible. Are you reading them? Are there any actual CATHOLIC websites you go to for information other than being a new member here?

Have you tried out things like “scripturecatholic.com” or other such sites, or is your total surfing limited to garbage by non-scholarly sources with such an intense hatred of catholicism that it drives them to the sin of false witness?
 
**Another **anti-Catholic website? You really aren’t adding to your credibility.
Presumably for you any website that doesn’t support Catholic dogma and interpretation is ‘anti-Catholic’; does that then mean that Catholics can only engage with themselves?

I am not here for credibility; I am here to find answers to questions which will hopefully reinforce my faith in the Catholic Church… your responses and churlishness do not reinforce my faith in her people… in-fact, I have found many people on this website to be quite aggressive and demonstrate very little charity: something the Bible speaks a lot about!
 
**Another **anti-Catholic website? You really aren’t adding to your credibility.
To be fair, at least this website gives substantial evidence for their objection (albeit the objection is minor and doesn’t necessarily matter either way), instead of J-I-S.com’s “CATHOLICISM = SATANISM; POPE = DEVIL!! SEEEEEEEEE LOOOOK AT THIS PICTUREEE THAT HAS NO CONTEXT WHATSOEVER!!!”
 
I agree. Tann, you say you own a catechism and a copy of the DR Bible. Are you reading them? Are there any actual CATHOLIC websites you go to for information other than being a new member here?

Have you tried out things like “scripturecatholic.com” or other such sites, or is your total surfing limited to garbage by non-scholarly sources with such an intense hatred of catholicism that it drives them to the sin of false witness?
Actually I didn’t seek this website out because I knew it to be anti-catholic: why would I do such a thing? I came across it because I was looking for websites with information on the King James Bible, and then I came across this man insisting that Catholics are all apart of a cult etcetera.

And, I am sure there are plenty of scholarly websites that dispute Catholic dogma [even if they are objectively wrong].
 
Presumably for you any website that doesn’t support Catholic dogma and interpretation is ‘anti-Catholic’; does that then mean that Catholics can only engage with themselves?
There is a great difference between non-Catholic and anti-Catholic. Anti-Catholic sites are beyond reason, they use no valid sources, they make things up, and do not use scholarly methods or documents. They are like rabid dogs. Full of logical fallacies and undocumented accusations.

There are plenty of non-Catholic sites and groups that have perfectly well-reasoned documents and arguments. There are many non-Catholics on here who I disagree with but with whom I can converse logically and meaningfully.
I am not here for credibility; I am here to find answers to questions which will hopefully reinforce my faith in the Catholic Church… your responses and churlishness do not reinforce my faith in her people… in-fact, I have found many people on this website to be quite aggressive and demonstrate very little charity: something the Bible speaks a lot about!
Pick a topic, one topic, and discuss it. Use your OWN reasoning and not links to anti-Catholic websites. Discuss the merits of various positions.
 
Let’s say that someone of the opposite sex sues you and claims that you slandered him/her. They and their friends will testify against you and say that you said offensive things about the plaintiff that you did not actually say. How would you feel if you were put in that kind of a situation? It wouldn’t be fair, would it?

That’s why hearsay is not allowed in court!

So why are you doing the same thing to the Catholic Church? Everything on those websites is hearsay unless they can prove that the Church actually said the things claimed, and to do that they need to produce an actual papal encyclical or authentic document.

You clearly don’t, if you think the Immaculate Conception is unbiblical.
I am not. All of the points listed refer to real facts about the Church (e.g. we do call the Pope ‘Holy Father’.) I am not saying: this is heretical; I am saying: why is this, and what’s the answer.
  1. The Immaculate Conception is not explicitly stated in the Bible… ‘Hail, full of Grace’ doesn’t implicitly imply that Mary was ‘free from sin’. I am convinced that Mary was free from sin, but at the same time, I’d like to have that corroborated.
 
Actually I didn’t seek this website out because I knew it to be anti-catholic: why would I do such a thing? I came across it because I was looking for websites with information on the King James Bible, and then I came across this man insisting that Catholics are all apart of a cult etcetera.

And, I am sure there are plenty of scholarly websites that dispute Catholic dogma [even if they are objectively wrong].
Oh yes, seeking information on the King James Bible will most defintly bring you to anti-catholic websites due to all the KJB literalists that are, in fact, very anti-catholic.

I suggest you talk to a priest as well as a well-educated, non-hateful evangical, perhaps even have a dinner together—that’d be interesting, I shud do that myself. Just make sure you get a good priest, as some are real dumazzes as has been demonstrated throughly in recent years, same with the the evangelical pastor.
 
Tann, thanks for making this post.

Honestly I’m still studying both the protestant and Catholic faiths, and I’m sure there’s Christians in both faiths(yes, Catholics are Christian) that can give well informed answers to your questions.

However I must say this, jesus-is-savior is by far the most anti-catholic ministry I’ve seen on the internet. There is no discussion, no tolerance, absolutly no consideration of the notion that maybe the catholics have any validity at all. The site is filled with worldly paranoia along with sheer hate towards Catholics. I’ve met evangelicals that are far more reasonable and spiritually sound than the moderater of J-I-S. Please seek these ppl out.

Keep on growing and strengthening your faith, but just beware of the people that “help” you along the way.
Thank-you 🙂
 
I am not. All of the points listed refer to real facts about the Church (e.g. we do call the Pope ‘Holy Father’.) I am not saying: this is heretical; I am saying: why is this, and what’s the answer.
Well, I gave it to you. Nowhere does the Bible say that “Holy Father” is a title that belongs only to God. Jesus does say “call no one father” but then goes on to refer to Abraham as “Father Abraham” and Paul uses the word “father” quite a bit in reference to people other than God. The Lord isn’t contradicting Himself so the only logical conclusion is that “call no one father” is hyperbole. So it’s a tempest in a teapot.
  1. The Immaculate Conception is not explicitly stated in the Bible…
I just gave it to you. If that’s not explicit enough for you then explain why you eat pork when the Bible doesn’t explicitly say you can do that either.
 
Oh yes, **seeking information on the King James Bible will most defintly bring you to anti-catholic websites due to all the KJB literalists that are, in fact, very anti-catholic. **I suggest you talk to a priest as well as a well-educated, non-hateful evangical, perhaps even have a dinner together—that’d be interesting, I shud do that myself. Just make sure you get a good priest, as some are real dumazzes as has been demonstrated throughly in recent years, same with the the evangelical pastor.
Really? I didn’t know this at all. Actually: 1 John 5: 7 ‘And there are three who give testimony in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost. And these three are one.’

Amazing verse, but apparently, and according to the New Internationa Version, this verse was found in no Greek manuscript before the 16th Century… what does that imply I wonder?? Is the original/ early Greek manuscript not going to be better to refer from??

2nd as regard Priests: I find it very difficult to speak to priests privately… especially if I am asking them questions that ‘question Catholic dogma’.
 
The Lord isn’t contradicting Himself so the only logical conclusion is that “call no one father” is hyperbole. So it’s a tempest in a teapot.
Actually, it’s not hyperbole. It’s just that english only has one word for father, where in Israel in the time of Christ there were MANY words for father. Abba is an honorific version of the word father, wherein the the aramaic honorific “A-” renders the title into a singular pronoun (a name). In other words, we are not to call anyone on earth “God the Father”. It is a real command, it just doesn’t mean what a lot of anti-catholic bigots want it to…
 
Whether the pronoun in “[he/she] shall crush your head” is masculine or feminine is a red herring because “the Woman” is not a man.

Here is Gen. 3:15 (NRSV–a Protestant translation):

I will put enmity between you and the woman,
and between your offspring and hers;
he will strike your head,
and you will strike his heel.’

Substitute proper names:

I will put enmity between satan and Mary,
and between satan’s offspring and Jesus;
[Jesus or Mary] will strike satan’s head,
and satan will strike Jesus’s heel.’
I will put enmities between thee and the woman
Sure this very clearly refers to Eve? Especially as in the verse before, **the woman **is used in reference to Eve…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top