P
Pregustator
Guest
I often find myself intrigued by an apparent contradiction in the Catholic “personality”, if you will.
On the one hand, the ideal Roman Catholic is expected to be a cultured, educated, and civilized man of the world, educated in the liberal arts, who knows and appreciates the great works of literature, of the visual arts, of music, and the like. The great Catholic houses of worship of Europe, even (especially, I would say) St. Peter’s and the Vatican are adorned with lavish carnal images; nudes and flesh abound everywhere one looks. And we extol these great works as exemplary of the greatness of the creativity of Catholic-inspired civilization.
The Court of the successor of the Apostle Peter is surrounded by all manner of such grandeur and magnificence; the Vatican is a veritable carnival of sensual splendours, not only in the art which adorns it, but in the rich silks and satins of the colorful costumes of priests and prelates and other numerous papal courtiers.
There is all of that on the one hand.
On the other hand, however, one finds the mystical asceticism of the religious, who view such things as gross extravagances and who extoll poverty as the queen of virtues. Then one finds any number of modern pious Catholics who command the most sober modesty from the rest of us: women must wear skirts that extend below the knee and one must always keep custody of the eyes, and so on, and so forth.
Which is the more correct embodiment of the Roman Catholic personality? The cultured Roman cardinal in scarlet silk revelling in Michelangelo’s magnificent talent, or the demure young Catholic lady in unflattering modest attire who is scandalized by nudes in art?
Is there a kind of Catholic puritanism that makes of the celebrated worldy glories of Roman Catholicism a shame, rather than a point of pride? Do these apparent contradictions represent two legitimate ways of being Catholic and of viewing the world from a Catholic perspective? Or is one right and one wrong?
I’d be interested in reading your thoughts.
On the one hand, the ideal Roman Catholic is expected to be a cultured, educated, and civilized man of the world, educated in the liberal arts, who knows and appreciates the great works of literature, of the visual arts, of music, and the like. The great Catholic houses of worship of Europe, even (especially, I would say) St. Peter’s and the Vatican are adorned with lavish carnal images; nudes and flesh abound everywhere one looks. And we extol these great works as exemplary of the greatness of the creativity of Catholic-inspired civilization.
The Court of the successor of the Apostle Peter is surrounded by all manner of such grandeur and magnificence; the Vatican is a veritable carnival of sensual splendours, not only in the art which adorns it, but in the rich silks and satins of the colorful costumes of priests and prelates and other numerous papal courtiers.
There is all of that on the one hand.
On the other hand, however, one finds the mystical asceticism of the religious, who view such things as gross extravagances and who extoll poverty as the queen of virtues. Then one finds any number of modern pious Catholics who command the most sober modesty from the rest of us: women must wear skirts that extend below the knee and one must always keep custody of the eyes, and so on, and so forth.
Which is the more correct embodiment of the Roman Catholic personality? The cultured Roman cardinal in scarlet silk revelling in Michelangelo’s magnificent talent, or the demure young Catholic lady in unflattering modest attire who is scandalized by nudes in art?
Is there a kind of Catholic puritanism that makes of the celebrated worldy glories of Roman Catholicism a shame, rather than a point of pride? Do these apparent contradictions represent two legitimate ways of being Catholic and of viewing the world from a Catholic perspective? Or is one right and one wrong?
I’d be interested in reading your thoughts.