Catholicism: Splendid or Puritanical?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pregustator
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Pregustator

Guest
I often find myself intrigued by an apparent contradiction in the Catholic “personality”, if you will.

On the one hand, the ideal Roman Catholic is expected to be a cultured, educated, and civilized man of the world, educated in the liberal arts, who knows and appreciates the great works of literature, of the visual arts, of music, and the like. The great Catholic houses of worship of Europe, even (especially, I would say) St. Peter’s and the Vatican are adorned with lavish carnal images; nudes and flesh abound everywhere one looks. And we extol these great works as exemplary of the greatness of the creativity of Catholic-inspired civilization.

The Court of the successor of the Apostle Peter is surrounded by all manner of such grandeur and magnificence; the Vatican is a veritable carnival of sensual splendours, not only in the art which adorns it, but in the rich silks and satins of the colorful costumes of priests and prelates and other numerous papal courtiers.

There is all of that on the one hand.

On the other hand, however, one finds the mystical asceticism of the religious, who view such things as gross extravagances and who extoll poverty as the queen of virtues. Then one finds any number of modern pious Catholics who command the most sober modesty from the rest of us: women must wear skirts that extend below the knee and one must always keep custody of the eyes, and so on, and so forth.

Which is the more correct embodiment of the Roman Catholic personality? The cultured Roman cardinal in scarlet silk revelling in Michelangelo’s magnificent talent, or the demure young Catholic lady in unflattering modest attire who is scandalized by nudes in art?

Is there a kind of Catholic puritanism that makes of the celebrated worldy glories of Roman Catholicism a shame, rather than a point of pride? Do these apparent contradictions represent two legitimate ways of being Catholic and of viewing the world from a Catholic perspective? Or is one right and one wrong?

I’d be interested in reading your thoughts.
 
Is there a kind of Catholic puritanism that makes of the celebrated worldy glories of Roman Catholicism a shame, rather than a point of pride? Do these apparent contradictions represent two legitimate ways of being Catholic and of viewing the world from a Catholic perspective? Or is one right and one wrong?QUOTE]

I think the answer is “both are legitimate.” True asceticism is based on an appreciation of the good that is embodied in the material world. The sad fact is that our sinful nature tends to overdo it and value such things too highly. As a result, moderation, or even asceticism, permits one to truly enjoy what is good and to avoid becoming attached to such things, that is, to use them with gratitude and freedom. The goal, in the language of Bernard of Clairvaux, is an “ordered love”: it is good to love the human body, food, sleep, music and conversation, etc., but it is important that the goods of this world not master us but be subject to our greater love for God and our desire to serve others.

Moreover, one sacrifices what one values, what is good, not what is bad, in order to make a true offering to God. Such an offering is an expression of our gratitude to God and our appreciation of God as our provider, the author and creator of all that is good.

Asceticism, it turns out, permits one to maintain a true appreciation for the good things of creation – we don’t become sated and find our appreciation blunted by overuse – and to avoid having such good things interfere with our commitment to the highest Good.
 
Good question! I don’t know the answer, but I know that catholic means “universal.” It’s large enough to accomodate both.

What I mean is, I don’t know if there is one “catholic personality.” The culture itself is so diverse.
 
When I think of a Catholic, I don’t think of a “civilized man of the world”… I think of the Saints…

I wouldn’t use words like “puritanical”, it’s better to just ask - how well does Catholicism follow the teachings of Christ? that is what is important. Not whether it is puritanical or other.

I think that this isn’t what defines Catholicism, and you’d find Catholic of both types (and others).

God bless
 
I prefer St Josemaria’s focus on the “ordinary” person. Living the Gospel right where we’ve been put, naturally, without “pietism” with a “Catholic” generosity and simple joy.

Banker, bricklayer, homemaker, soldier, neighbor, mother, father, all children of God.

This approach to spirituality (I think that’s the main point of the OP…that is, forms or natures of spirituality) is nevertheless enormously reverential, but doesn’t demand one leave the world to pray, worship, Love. All actions and “ordinary” events are turned into “occasions of loving God and serving others.”
 
Jesus, who showed us the face of God, came as a humble carpenter. It’s easy for us to be dissatisfied with a lowly status, preferring worldly glory. But in the end our heroes or heroines are the Mother Teresa’s and St John of the Cross’s.
 
Hi Pregustator 🙂
I often find myself intrigued by an apparent contradiction in the Catholic “personality”, if you will.

On the one hand, the ideal Roman Catholic is expected to be a cultured, educated, and civilized man of the world, educated in the liberal arts, who knows and appreciates the great works of literature, of the visual arts, of music, and the like. The great Catholic houses of worship of Europe, even (especially, I would say) St. Peter’s and the Vatican are adorned with lavish carnal images; nudes and flesh abound everywhere one looks. And we extol these great works as exemplary of the greatness of the creativity of Catholic-inspired civilization.

The Court of the successor of the Apostle Peter is surrounded by all manner of such grandeur and magnificence; the Vatican is a veritable carnival of sensual splendours, not only in the art which adorns it, but in the rich silks and satins of the colorful costumes of priests and prelates and other numerous papal courtiers.

There is all of that on the one hand.

On the other hand, however, one finds the mystical asceticism of the religious, who view such things as gross extravagances and who extoll poverty as the queen of virtues. Then one finds any number of modern pious Catholics who command the most sober modesty from the rest of us: women must wear skirts that extend below the knee and one must always keep custody of the eyes, and so on, and so forth.

Which is the more correct embodiment of the Roman Catholic personality? The cultured Roman cardinal in scarlet silk revelling in Michelangelo’s magnificent talent, or the demure young Catholic lady in unflattering modest attire who is scandalized by nudes in art?

Is there a kind of Catholic puritanism that makes of the celebrated worldy glories of Roman Catholicism a shame, rather than a point of pride? Do these apparent contradictions represent two legitimate ways of being Catholic and of viewing the world from a Catholic perspective? Or is one right and one wrong?

I’d be interested in reading your thoughts.
Catholic…Splendid or Puritanical…that brought a smile to me 🙂

That is EXACTLY the reason why world is so wrong, because most think of us Catholics as too much of one extreme, and then others the other extreme.

As the great G. K. Chesterton said:
Suppose we heard an unknown man spoken of by many men. Suppose we were puzzled to hear that some men said he was too tall and some too short; some objected to his fatness, some lamented his leanness; some thought him too dark, and some too fair. One explanation (as has been already admitted) would be that he might be an odd shape. But there is another explanation. He might be the right shape. Outrageously tall men might feel him to be short. Very short men might feel him to be tall. Old bucks who are growing stout might consider him insufficiently filled out; old beaux who were growing thin might feel that he expanded beyond the narrow lines of elegance. Perhaps Swedes (who have pale hair like tow) called him a dark man, while negroes considered him distinctly blonde. Perhaps (in short) this extraordinary thing is really the ordinary thing; at least the normal thing, the centre. Perhaps, after all, it is Christianity that is sane and all its critics that are mad – in various ways.
Orthodoxy
So what is the more correct embodiment of the Roman Catholic personality? I would say, like Monica, the Saints. And good luck with classifying them as splendid, puritanical, or what not 😉

God bless.
 
I often find myself intrigued by an apparent contradiction in the Catholic “personality”, if you will.
I don’t think this is a peculiarly Catholic trait - humans are both material and spiritual beings, every last one of us. They are two sides of each person, like two sides of a coin, which may be very different but can’t exist apart. Different people will inhabit different places on the spectrum.

It is a combination that seems to exist in every religion. For example Hindiusm has both ascetic and sensually appealing aspects intermingled, as does Islam (fabulous architecture and art, and for the most part great emphasis on secular learning as well.)

Not excluding the same Protestant Christians who often criticise the supposed riches of the Catholic Church.

Compare the lavishness of St Pauls Cathedral in London and St John the Divine in New York, or even the grand size and scale of many a ‘megachurch’ with its mod-cons (coffee shops, plasma screens and whatnot) on the one hand, with the heroic efforts many of these same church communities make in serving the poorest both in their local areas and overseas.
 
There’s a distinction that needs to be made when viewing the richly adorned church buildings. If we look at the eastern churches we see they strive for an aesthetic beauty to create a sense of heaven and other-worldly. To transport the church goer to another place away from their normal everyday lives. The church bldg and service should be different and set aside from the rest of our daily lives.
When we think of the mass as “heaven on earth” then we can better appreciate the beauty and purpose of the paintings, grand bldgs, icons, and statuary.
Having said that I’ve been to some very humble churches here in the U.S. that had very pious and holy members. The beauty of their lives and traditions showed through in the mass and helped create the sense of heaven on earth when the bldg didn’t.
 
I The great Catholic houses of worship of Europe, even (especially, I would say) St. Peter’s and the Vatican are adorned with lavish carnal images; nudes and flesh abound everywhere one looks. And we extol these great works as exemplary of the greatness of the creativity of Catholic-inspired civilization.

s.
nudes in classical art are not carnal images unless posed in carnal acts or situations, which works like the Sistine Chapel are definitely not. the only people who have a problem with nudes in art are those who have a problem.
 
Do these apparent contradictions represent two legitimate ways of being Catholic and of viewing the world from a Catholic perspective? Or is one right and one wrong?.
Seems to me that the uniquely Catholic sensibility is to enjoy the things of life, yet not be possessed by them. Something about being *in *the world but not *of *the world…

Pax
Ted
 
I feel there are a lot of stereotypes in your post, and if you are thinking that way it may be causing your confusion. For instance, you speak of “demure young Catholic lady in unflattering modest attire who is scandalized by nudes in art.” I feel inclined to make the observation that modest clothing is not necessarily unflattering, and also I don’t understand why you are assuming that a woman who dresses modestly must be scandalized by nudes in art - presuming it is really art, and not pornography, which some modern art crosses into. The human body is a beautiful work of God. A tasteful, artistic nude is not automatically “carnal,” in the sense you are using that word. But we dress modestly because we don’t want to lead people into the sin of lust. I sincerely hope that there are not many people who are led into the sin of lust by looking at the Sistine chapel.

I completely disagree that an “ideal Roman Catholic” has to be highly cultured and educated. An “ideal Roman Catholic” is simply a saint. Some of the saints were highly cultured and educated, others were not. Some of the saints were illiterate. A liberal arts education is not a prerequisite for sanctity. That the Church nevertheless supports the study of the liberal arts and takes a favorable view of intellectual endeavors, is one of the things I love about her.

St. John of the Cross had a Jesuit education. He was very intelligent and studied Latin, Greek, and classical literature and wrote poetry with romantic imagery. Yet he was a great mystic and ascetic.

The world tends to break up into stereotypes and caricatures. They go too far in a particular direction. Without the Holy Spirit guiding, human beings tend to fall into extremes. This can happen within the Church, also, and does happen - but as a whole, the Church is capable of a remarkable breadth and richness, because the Holy Spirit guides her and teaches her. She can gather these seeming contradictions - which seem so only because of the narrowness of our thinking - and hold them together, uniting them in herself: splendor and asceticism, faith and reason, science and miracles, justice and mercy.

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to think about one of the reasons why I love the Church so much! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top