A question to faithful followers of Catholicism. Does your church encourage everybody to read the entire bible and study it faithfully. Also another questions, does your church have bible studies, to give people knowledge of the bible? And last, to faithful catholics, have you yourself read the entire bible and are you knowledgable about it.
I’m a former Protestant now Catholic. So I’ve worn both hats. I’ve read the Bible several times, from cover to cover. Not all of it is very inspiring mind you - some of the genealogical lists of Numbers and Leviticus et al are guaranteed to send you to sleep. If it comes to that, I’m still waiting for a suitable definition of “inspired” if God “inspired” the Bible. Some of it is anything but.
I’m also speaking from an Australian perspective, not US.
Generally speaking the reality is that Protestants know their Bible better than Catholics, at least over here. In Protestant circles private reading and study of the Bible is encouraged, whereas in Catholic circles that’s not a strong trait, or at least not here.
There is an increasing emphasis on Bible studies, with movements afoot to have home groups using the “Little Rock” series for example. But it hasn’t taken off in a big way as yet.
That said, in every mass, there are usually four Bible readings - an OT passage, a responsive Psalm, a NT passage excluding the Gospels (what might be called the Catholic letters), and then a Gospel passage read by the priest. So over a three year period, sincere Catholics would hear the Bible in essence anyway.
But I’ll give you a salient example of Protestant versus Catholic knowledge of the Bible. I went to a two day seminar in July featuring our new Archbishop, who was the speaker on Scripture. He has a doctorate in Luke.
He mentioned at one stage that if you pushed a Rabbi to reduce the Jewish laws to the absolute minimum, he would admit there was only one. Bear in mind that we’re talking Old Testament and not new. The new of course was Christ’s reply to the lawyer - “Love the Lord you God with all your soul, with all your heart and all your mind, and your neighbour as yourself.”
But he was talking Old Testament. He asked us to say what it was. It was of course the phrase, “I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of Egypt. You shall have no other gods before me.”
But he commented that whenever he asked Catholics, they omitted the second bit … “who brought you out of Egypt…” He said Protestants got it every time. But Catholics always seemed to ignore it.
He spent years trying to figure out why Protestants could get it and Catholics not do so. Then finally the penny dropped - someone remarked the catechism didn’t include the bit about “out of Egypt”. He remarked “that’s the power of the catechism.”
From the point of view of the core of the teaching, the bit about Egypt is to us largely irrelevant - the whole point is we should be put God first.
It was an example of Protestants knowing their Bible better than Catholics. But in reality both believe the same thing - “Love the Lord you God with all your soul, with all your heart and all your mind, and your neighbour as yourself.”
We’ve just got different ways of getting to the core of Christ’s teaching.