We may be working this question backwards.
First let me be perfectly clear, pro-choice is by its very nature anti-Christ and anti-Catholic.
But let us move on, the correct question is not:
Can a Catholic be pro-choice?
The question is: What is a Catholic?
A Catholic is someone who is in Union with Rome, or more precisely in Union with the Holy Father.
Therefore if you disagree with the teachings of the Holy Father you are in schism and are not a Catholic.
If you don’t believe that the consecrated host is in fact the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus then you are not Catholic.
If you don’t believe that the Pope is infallible when he speaks from the Chair of Peter then you are not a Catholic.
If you don’t believe that Mary ever virgin was assumed body and soul into heaven then you are not a Catholic.
If you believe it is all right to practice contraception you are not a Catholic. (This is different from being a Catholic and in a moment of weakness committing the sin of contraception.)
If you believe women have a right to murder their babies then you are not a Catholic.
Marsha
