G
GraceDK
Guest
Dear Toby.Odell, Thank you very much for words of wisdom.
The “legalisms” of the church would be something we **want **to do from our hearts and not a must. I want to go to mass on Sundays. I want to go and receive Our Lord’s Body and Blood. I want to fast and abstain. I want to be close to Jesus through His Church. All these “legalisms” will not be things that I must do but things that I **want **to do. Yup… my friends look at things from the wrong angle.
God Bless…
Now I might get “boohed out” but I think your protestant friends have a point.
This thread is very interesting.
Deb writes that Evangelicals tend to think we have a born again experience and that transforms us inside out through the Holy Spirit so we open our eyes and long to live according to God’s will in many areas. This I actually think is very, very true and I sort of had that experience myself.
I also believe that without the personal conversion experience the disciplines will look exactly like rules made by a foreign master… I see every sunday how young people come to Church because they “have to” and how many parishes are falling into decay and tepidity because the “I want” have changed into “I must”.
I think Luther was onto somethintg when he wanted all calculation gone from acts of love and charity.
The Bible is very clear that we must let no one condemn us because of certain days or foods… I find that thoughtprovoking since I am told that if I dont go to Mass I must confess my sin. My what? why? I see why the Church should encourage us to do good and to come together with our congregration out of love and joy and freedom. Actually it should be so gratifying to come to church that it was something that we want to do, not something we have to. And I think rules are made when things dont come natural anymore… when the Church looses its zeal and joy.
So I dont like rules… in fact I think the “you must” takes the sweatness out of many good things… just like it takes the purity out of an act when we do it out of duty without love.
A priest once told me to do an act of contrition after my confession: to do an extra nice charitable thing to some handicapped people I worked with. I cannot tell you how his words disturbed me. I did as much as I could already for those people and now he wanted to corrupt my deeds by me having a hidden agenda… to think of these people’s gratitude towards me while I was calculating my deeds to get on a right standing with the Church just totally turned me off…
So I think your friends are not totally wrong… by making new rules and also having numerous unwritten rules we take the newness and expectation out of Christian life… we also take the herioism away when there is no freedom in which to act. Kierkegaard calls faith the absolute relationship to the Absolute… Barth calls Christianity Revelation. I think they stricke a nerve. if we make rules and rules we cheapen the Gospel…