CC too legalistic

  • Thread starter Thread starter TobyLue
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Odell, Thank you very much for words of wisdom.

The “legalisms” of the church would be something we **want **to do from our hearts and not a must. I want to go to mass on Sundays. I want to go and receive Our Lord’s Body and Blood. I want to fast and abstain. I want to be close to Jesus through His Church. All these “legalisms” will not be things that I must do but things that I **want **to do. Yup… my friends look at things from the wrong angle.
God Bless…
Dear Toby.

Now I might get “boohed out” but I think your protestant friends have a point.
This thread is very interesting.

Deb writes that Evangelicals tend to think we have a born again experience and that transforms us inside out through the Holy Spirit so we open our eyes and long to live according to God’s will in many areas. This I actually think is very, very true and I sort of had that experience myself.
I also believe that without the personal conversion experience the disciplines will look exactly like rules made by a foreign master… I see every sunday how young people come to Church because they “have to” and how many parishes are falling into decay and tepidity because the “I want” have changed into “I must”.
I think Luther was onto somethintg when he wanted all calculation gone from acts of love and charity.
The Bible is very clear that we must let no one condemn us because of certain days or foods… I find that thoughtprovoking since I am told that if I dont go to Mass I must confess my sin. My what? why? I see why the Church should encourage us to do good and to come together with our congregration out of love and joy and freedom. Actually it should be so gratifying to come to church that it was something that we want to do, not something we have to. And I think rules are made when things dont come natural anymore… when the Church looses its zeal and joy.
So I dont like rules… in fact I think the “you must” takes the sweatness out of many good things… just like it takes the purity out of an act when we do it out of duty without love.
A priest once told me to do an act of contrition after my confession: to do an extra nice charitable thing to some handicapped people I worked with. I cannot tell you how his words disturbed me. I did as much as I could already for those people and now he wanted to corrupt my deeds by me having a hidden agenda… to think of these people’s gratitude towards me while I was calculating my deeds to get on a right standing with the Church just totally turned me off…

So I think your friends are not totally wrong… by making new rules and also having numerous unwritten rules we take the newness and expectation out of Christian life… we also take the herioism away when there is no freedom in which to act. Kierkegaard calls faith the absolute relationship to the Absolute… Barth calls Christianity Revelation. I think they stricke a nerve. if we make rules and rules we cheapen the Gospel…
 
Dear Protestant brother.
The Catholic Church… as well as the Bible, does not teach “Faith Alone”.
The only place where Scripture says “Faith alone” is where James says that faith alone cannot save you.

When it comes to one true Church… I dont know how much you know about Catholic ecclesiology, but we have very important teachings on
Apostolic Succession, priesthood and leadership
which are intimately linked with our beliefs both about
Sacred scripture and the Sacraments.

Anyway… good to have you here. Just feel at home 🙂
 
Wow, going back to what Joe5859 on his post #2 said regarding Leviticus, starting with chapter 1,
When anyone of you wishes to bring an animal offering to the lord
Rule #1, such an offering must be from the heard or from the flock… If his holocaust offering is from the heard,
Rule #2, it must be a male
Rule #3, without blemish. To find favor with the Lord he shall
Rule #4, bring it to the entrance of the Meeting Tent,
Rule #5, and there lay his hand on the head of the holocaust so that it may be acceptable to atonement for him.
Rule #6, he shall then slaughter the bull before the Lord, but
Rule #7, Aaron’s sons, the priest, shall offer up its blood by splashing it on the sides of the altar which is at the entrance of the Meeting Tent
Rule #8, Then he shall skin the holocaust and
Rule #9 cut it up into pieces.
Rule #10 After Aaron’s sons, the priest, have put some burning embers on the altar and
Rule #11 laid some wood on them, they
Rule #12 shall lay the pieces of meat,
Rule #13 together with the head and
Rule #14 the suet on top of the wood and embers on the altar,
Rule #15 the inner organs and the shanks, however the offerer shall
Rule #16 first wash with water. The priest shall then
Rule #17 burn the whole offering on the altar as a holocaust, a sweet smelling oblation to the Lord.
When we want to receive our Lord in Holy Communion we must
Rule # 1 be a practicing Catholic who
Rule # 2 is in the state of grace. 1 Cor 11:27
Rule # 3 fast from food for one hour, (however, if a person is sick or suffers from certain illness that he must have some food or nourishment, rule # 3 is waived).

Quite a difference…… so much for legalizism. It seems my friends want to do it their way instead of Gods, which leads to part of todays reading in Deut.4 . "…And now O Israel give heed to the statues and the ordinances whichh I teach you and do them that you may live … Behold I have taught you statues and ordinances as the Lord my God commanded me that you should do in the land which you are entering to take possession of it…
Psalm 147 He send forth his command to the earth… He declares His word to Jacob His statues and ordinances to Israel
and todays Gospel from Matthew: "Whoever then relaxes the** LEAST** of these commandants and teaches men so, shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven…

To me when it Gal speaks about “freedom from the SUPERVISION of the law”, is mistaken to read “freedom from the OBSERVATION of the law”. When we follow the laws, there will be nobody looking over our heads that we MUST do them but we will gladly follow God’s law, not throw them away because we are “free” from them. In other words telling God Himselfs that I will not follow HIS law because He has made me free to do them if **I want **to or not.
 
Going back to Gal “Freedom from the supervision of the law”. At work what is the responsibility of supervisors? They make sure that you are doing the work properly. If you are, then they stop supervising you because they trust you are doing it correctly. Supervisors are not there telling you to stop doing what you are doing. Same thing with the Church. If you stop going to mass on Sundays, stop going to confession when you commit grave sin, of course the Church is telling you that you are not doing the right thing, but if we faithfully and cheerfully go to give worship to Almighty God we are free from the **supervision **of theChurch’s law of going to Sunday Mass. We commit a grave sin and immediately go to confession, we are free from the **supervision **of the Church’s law about going to confession. etc…We are not free from NOT doing those things…
 
Something to think about and expand on please… from a humble protestant.

on the subject of being too legalistic, lets dig deeper with some questions.
Welcome! 👋

Thanks for weighing in to give us a different perspective. I just wanted to piggyback off of a few things you said. 🙂
The Pharisees were all about the Law, yet Christ called them blind. Is it possible that focusing so heavily on the law takes our eyes away from the one who is the Law?
Interesting observation. I think that you are right that it can be a problem for some people (at the very least, it was certainly a problem with the Pharisees). Even today, there are some people that get caught up in a hyper-legalism where they lose sight of exactly why the laws are there in the first place: to bring us closer to God. Even good things can become “idols” that we put in place of God when we fail to correctly prioritize.

But (and I’m sure you would probably agree) the fact that some people focus on the laws without the necessary internal conversion does not therefore mean that the law is unnecessary or meaningless. Jesus told people to do whatever the Pharisees tell them to do, just not what they do, because they preached but didn’t practice (Matthew 23:3). So Jesus’ problem with the Pharisees wasn’t so much that they were legalistic, but that they lacked the internal conversion that would lead them to really live out the law as it was meant to be lived.

Of course, we don’t want the Church to be filled with people only following the letter of the law without really having a conversion of heart.
The Bible never said that the thief on the cross beside Jesus ever upheld the law, nor whether or not he was baptised. The Bible does say he was saved. So why are the legalities so important?
The important difference between the thief on the cross and most of us is that he was at the point of death. The law is there to help us live our day to day life in the way that conforms to the will of God. Certainly, there are exceptions and deathbed conversions. God is not bound by the law. But we should not look to those situations as the norm. That could lead to the line of thinking that we can live whatever type of life we choose and then just repent on our deathbed. That doesn’t always work seeing as how most people die the way they live.
Romans 14 makes it really clear that there is give and take in the way that the Law is observed, depending on the individuals faith (Strong or weak) and their personal conviction from God himself. Conviction comes through meditation of the Word and prayer. How can any of us say that we are the denomination that has the right answers?
Paul does speak of a give and take over the observation of the old Jewish dietary laws. Basically, here he doesn’t want either those who observe the dietary laws or those who don’t to give the other group a hard time because of this particular difference. I don’t think you can stretch this out to the Law in general. The law that murder is wrong applies equally to everyone. It’s not as though we can say, “This group chooses to murder people, and this group doesn’t, but neither group should pass judgment on the other because of this difference”.
If Catholics hat you are saved by FAITH ALONE, then why is the law so important? Shouldn’t we focus on our faith and let our faith guide us?
GraceDK already addressed this. The Catholic Church does not teach that we are saved by faith alone. (If you’re interested in what that means, here’s an article that might give you a better idea of the Catholic teaching on the subject: Aren’t We Saved by Faith Alone?)

Of course our faith is important, as is our relationship with God. But for Catholics, we do not rely only on our subjective experience of faith. The Church was established by Jesus to be just such a guide for us so that we don’t have to guess as to whether the Spirit is really guiding us or if we’re deceiving ourselves. We can check it against Church teaching.

I say all this not in some attempt to “convert” you, but only in an effort to explain the Catholic viewpoint on the subject. So I hope I haven’t offended you, protestantman! 😉
 
Here’s an interesting take from this website:
*Jesus told the leaders of his Church, “Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven” (Matthew 16:19, 18:18). The language of binding and loosing (in part) was a rabinnic way of referring to the ability to establish binding halakah or rules of conduct for the faith community. It is thus especially appropriate that the references to binding and loosing occur in Matthew, the “Jewish Gospel.” Thus the

Jewish Encyclopedia states:
"BINDING AND LOOSING (Hebrew, asar ve-hittir) . . . Rabinnical term for ‘forbidding and permitting.’ . . .
"The power of binding and loosing as always claimed by the Pharisees. Under Queen Alexandra the Pharisees, says Josephus (Wars of the Jews 1:5:2), ‘became the administrators of all public affairs so as to be empowered to banish and readmit whom they pleased, as well as to loose and to bind.’ . . . The various schools had the power ‘to bind and to loose’; that is, to forbid and to permit (Talmud: Chagigah 3b); and they could also bind any day by declaring it a fast-day ( . . . Talmud: Ta’anit 12a . . . ). This power and authority, vested in the rabbinical body of each age of the Sanhedrin, received its ratification and final sanction from the celestial court of justice (Sifra, Emor, 9; Talmud: Makkot 23b).

“In this sense Jesus, when appointing his disciples to be his successors, used the familiar formula (Matt. 16:19, 18:18). By these words he virtually invested them with the same authority as that which he found belonging to the scribes and Pharisees who ‘bind heavy burdens and lay them on men’s shoulders, but will not move them with one of their fingers’; that is ‘loose them,’ as they have the power to do (Matt. 23:2-4). In the same sense the second epistle of Clement to James II (‘Clementine Homilies,’ Introduction [A.D. 221]), Peter is represented as having appointed Clement as his successor, saying: ‘I communicate to him the power of binding and loosing so that, with respect to everything which he shall ordain in the earth, it shall be decreed in the heavens; for he shall bind what ought to be bound and loose what ought to be loosed as knowing the rule of the Church.’” (Jewish Encyclopedia 3:215).
Thus Jesus invested the leaders of this Church with the power of making halakah for the Christian community. This includes the setting of fast days (like Ash Wednesday).

To approach the issue from another angle, every family has the authority to establish particular family devotions for its members. Thus if the parents decide that the family will engage in a particular devotion at a particular time (say, Bible reading after supper), it is a sin for the children to disobey and skip the devotion for no good reason. In the same way, the Church as the family of God has the authority to establish its own family devotion, and it is a sin for the members of the Church to disobey and skip the devotions for no good reason (though of course if the person has a good reason, the Church dispenses him immediately).
*
 
Something to think about and expand on please… from a humble protestant.

on the subject of being too legalistic, lets dig deeper with some questions.

The Pharisees were all about the Law, yet Christ called them blind. Is it possible that focusing so heavily on the law takes our eyes away from the one who is the Law?

The Bible never said that the thief on the cross beside Jesus ever upheld the law, nor whether or not he was baptised. The Bible does say he was saved. So why are the legalities so important?

Romans 14 makes it really clear that there is give and take in the way that the Law is observed, depending on the individuals faith (Strong or weak) and their personal conviction from God himself. Conviction comes through meditation of the Word and prayer. How can any of us say that we are the denomination that has the right answers?

If Catholics hat you are saved by FAITH ALONE, then why is the law so important? Shouldn’t we focus on our faith and let our faith guide us?
So your law is your faith? Isn’t that just another form of legalism?

Do you care about what God wants you to do and to avoid? That’s all that “the law” is. So then, isn’t caring about what God wants you to do and to avoid just legalism?

You ask if it is possible to focus too heavily on the law? What about the opposite? Is it possible to focus to lightly on the law?

Oh, and if you are actually living life as a saved Christian then the example of the thief on the cross is of no use as a guide for your life.
 
Going back to Gal “Freedom from the supervision of the law”. At work what is the responsibility of supervisors? They make sure that you are doing the work properly. If you are, then they stop supervising you because they trust you are doing it correctly. Supervisors are not there telling you to stop doing what you are doing. Same thing with the Church. If you stop going to mass on Sundays, stop going to confession when you commit grave sin, of course the Church is telling you that you are not doing the right thing, but if we faithfully and cheerfully go to give worship to Almighty God we are free from the **supervision **of theChurch’s law of going to Sunday Mass. We commit a grave sin and immediately go to confession, we are free from the **supervision **of the Church’s law about going to confession. etc…We are not free from NOT doing those things…
Hey Toby…
I guess I just wanted to quote this little passage from Scripture to answer what you say about Sunday Mass attendance:

“Therefore do not *let anyone jugde you *by what you eat or drink or with regard to a religious festival, a new moon celebration or a sabbath day. These are a shadow of what were to come; the reality however, is found in Christ (…) Since you died with Christ to the basic principles of this world why, as though you still belonged to it, do you submit to its rules: do not handle! do not taste! do not touch? these are all destined to perish with use, because they are based on human commands and teachings.” (Col 2:19)

You see my problem is not that the Church encourages us to go to Mass, but that it condemns those who don’t as though we still lived under the old law. There is a difference between cultic observances (rituals, kosher, special days ect) and observance of love…The fist cannot save nor condemn anymore. The other one can and does. This a simple fact evidenced by the teachings of Christ in the Gospels…
So too with Mass and fasting and feast days and circumcision… All of these things are good… Mass is good, so is fasting and spiritual exercises but exterior ritual acts should not be used to condemn people… because we are not under the Mosaic law in order to be saved anymore… if we do these things thinking they will save us then we have not understood but we have misused good things… Jesus has shown the higher way that saves: Love, Faith, Repentance…These are the requirements… The law written on the heart instead of on stones or in law books… This is essential and the good news.

“For physical training has some value (my translation says: no value) but godliness/ fear of God has value for all things, holding promise for both the present life and the life to come.” (1 Tim 4:8)

I’d like for you to give me your interpretation of these passages without adding or taking away meaning from them or pointing to other authorities that may or may not dissolve the words here so clearly written.
 
Welcome! 👋

But (and I’m sure you would probably agree) the fact that some people focus on the laws without the necessary internal conversion does not therefore mean that the law is unnecessary or meaningless. Jesus told people to do whatever the Pharisees tell them to do, just not what they do, because they preached but didn’t practice (Matthew 23:3). So Jesus’ problem with the Pharisees wasn’t so much that they were legalistic, but that they lacked the internal conversion that would lead them to really live out the law as it was meant to be lived.[/QOUTE]

I do agree. Without dying to self and being made alive in Christ, following the law is meaningless.

[QOUTE]
Of course, we don’t want the Church to be filled with people only following the letter of the law without really having a conversion of heart.[/QOUTE]

again I absolutely agree

[QOUTE]
The important difference between the thief on the cross and most of us is that he was at the point of death. The law is there to help us live our day to day life in the way that conforms to the will of God. Certainly, there are exceptions and deathbed conversions. God is not bound by the law. But we should not look to those situations as the norm. That could lead to the line of thinking that we can live whatever type of life we choose and then just repent on our deathbed. That doesn’t always work seeing as how most people die the way they live. [/QOUTE]

This is true. It is not the norm. But instead of commanding the Law, Jesus preached in 1 corinthians 10, a believer’s freedom is that “Everything is permissible”, and in Galations it says that Jesus nullified the NEED for the Law. His point was this; if you truly believe in Christ, you will have that inward conversion that the Pharisees did not have, and that your spirit will lead you to do what is right(A slave to righteousness)

Romans 6:15 says, “What then? Shall we sin because we are not under the law? By no means!”
Why would Paul say that? Look at verse 14

In the Old Testament everyone was bound by sin, and thus were slaves to the Law. When Christ suffered and died, he freed us from the burden of sin, thus nullifying the Law. This is why it is called Grace.

[QOUTE]
Paul does speak of a give and take over the observation of the old Jewish dietary laws. Basically, here he doesn’t want either those who observe the dietary laws or those who don’t to give the other group a hard time because of this particular difference. I don’t think you can stretch this out to the Law in general. The law that murder is wrong applies equally to everyone. It’s not as though we can say, “This group chooses to murder people, and this group doesn’t, but neither group should pass judgment on the other because of this difference”.[/QOUTE]

I must dissagree, and say that Paul did mean the law in general. In that chapter Paul goes on to use other examples to make a bigger point. If I am in Christ and he in me, Then how can you tell me that anything I do is sin? The requirement was not the law, but rather am I doing it for Gods glory. When you talk about murder, Christ was murdered and yet he asked God to forgive them. Its Christs decision whether you are justified not the law.

[QOUTE]
GraceDK already addressed this. The Catholic Church does not teach that we are saved by faith alone. (If you’re interested in what that means, here’s an article that might give you a better idea of the Catholic teaching on the subject: Aren’t We Saved by Faith Alone?)

Of course our faith is important, as is our relationship with God. But for Catholics, we do not rely only on our subjective experience of faith. The Church was established by Jesus to be just such a guide for us so that we don’t have to guess as to whether the Spirit is really guiding us or if we’re deceiving ourselves. We can check it against Church teaching.

I say all this not in some attempt to “convert” you, but only in an effort to explain the Catholic viewpoint on the subject. So I hope I haven’t offended you, protestantman! 😉
Sorry, and thank you for correcting me. I do not want to make arguments based on false statements. I personally believe that Faith alone assures my salvation. Yet I also believe that Faith without works is Dead. But I believe that Faith produces works, and only works of Faith(NOT THE LAW) is what God requires.

P.S. very glad to know that conversion is not the issue here. It is not the intention of my questions. Only to sharpen the faith of each other so that God will be praised. I see myself as a foot in the body of Christ. I am here to steady and support the other parts. Again thank you.
 
So your law is your faith? Isn’t that just another form of legalism?

Do you care about what God wants you to do and to avoid? That’s all that “the law” is. So then, isn’t caring about what God wants you to do and to avoid just legalism?

You ask if it is possible to focus too heavily on the law? What about the opposite? Is it possible to focus to lightly on the law?

Oh, and if you are actually living life as a saved Christian then the example of the thief on the cross is of no use as a guide for your life.
Is it possible to focus to lightly on the Law?
No I dont think so. Christ outwardly opposed the law, because he came to replace it. I think that focusing on the Law is what blinded the Pharisees to the truth. Which is more important, Christ or the Law?

The thief on the cross is not a guide for a saved christian, but evidence that the Law is not required. Because he had faith, he was made righteous in the sight of God.
 
Is it possible to focus to lightly on the Law?
No I dont think so. Christ outwardly opposed the law, because he came to replace it. I think that focusing on the Law is what blinded the Pharisees to the truth. Which is more important, Christ or the Law?

The thief on the cross is not a guide for a saved christian, but evidence that the Law is not required. Because he had faith, he was made righteous in the sight of God.
Fascinating. It is not possible to focus too lightly on the law. It is not possible to focus too lightly on the Ten Commandments. Any focus on the Ten Commandments is likely to be too much.

Did Christ replace the Ten Commandments? He certainly never made such a claim.
 
Fascinating. It is not possible to focus too lightly on the law. It is not possible to focus too lightly on the Ten Commandments. Any focus on the Ten Commandments is likely to be too much.

Did Christ replace the Ten Commandments? He certainly never made such a claim.
Yes he did. He absolutely did.
Romans 7:4-6 PLEASE READ

“So, my brothers, you also died to the law through Christ,…”

Romans 8:1 “Therefore, there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ.”

Romans 6:15 “…Shall we not sin because we are not under law but under grace.”

The law was indeed replaced by Christ. Paul also went on to say that the purpose of the Law was so that sin would be recognized as sin. He NEVER EVER said that the Law would ever save anyone.

1 corintians 10: 23 “Everything is Permissible” <<----- If we live in the spirit, than nothing we do can be called into question, neither by man, the Pope, or the law. NOTHING

Why does Romans 8 say that “…for what the LAW was POWERLESS to do in that it was weakened by sin, God did by sending his own Son…”
What was it the Law was powerless to do that Jesus was able to do?
If sin still exists, then the Law is still Powerless save?
 
Dear Protestant man.

To my knowlege both Catholic and Protestant theology teaches clearly that Christ fulfilled the law (and the prophets). He did not replace them. There is a huge difference. Christ did not walk in lawlessness. Saying so would be the utmost misunderstanding.

When we read all the Pauline letters we have a very good view of how Christians should work in the world… Paul mentions a lot of sins that we should avoid in order that we may not forfeit what Christ has won for us … There is no lawlessness for Christians but the law has been taken up on an even higher level… You say “we are not under the law but under grace” that you find in Romans 6 but I urge you to read the whole letter to the Romans. In verse 19 Its written:" before you let your bodies be slaves to impurity and lawlessness, so you became lawless, but now you must let them be slaves to Justice, so that you are made holy (…) now that you have become servants/slaves for God you have the fruit that you are made holy and in the end eternal life. )we are servants in the new life of the Spirit " etc. The NT is also very clear that failure to live in the law of love - Paul mentions a lot of sins that lead to death fx. fornication etc - can end with loosing your salvation that Christ bought for you with His Blood. You have to repend of your sins and I might say, do it continuously… but its written that the law leads to recognition of sins… now its the Love of God, the law of His Justice which is really also love, that makes us repent when we are born again.
Here its important that we distinguish between justification and salvation. For you are right, the Bible says clearly that Christ is our justification and even our Resurrection… But still it is evident that we can throw away his gifts and end up denying Him…

Shalom to you.
 
What about…

The Ten Suggestions?

Oh thats right they’re called

The Ten Commandments.

Romans 7:2
For the married woman is bound by law to her husband while he is living; but if her husband dies, she is released from the law concerning the husband.

Looks like there are still laws.

Romans 7 says

12So then, the Law is holy, and the commandment is holy and righteous and good.

It’s a good read!
 
Help— I need good replies please. I have some Protestants friends who have issues with the CC because they say its “too legalistic”; meaning that the CC teaches that children must be baptized at an early age, one **must **make First Communion, must be confirmed, must go to confessions, etc, etc. Not questioning infant baptism nor anything else just the **legalities **of the CC that certain things “must be done”. They believe that doing those things must come from our hearts and that the CC places too many rules that MUST be done. My first thought was that Jesus instituted these things and who are we to tell Jesus how things must be done. Can somebody give me better answers, maybe with biblical references since they believe in the bible only.

Thanks.
It is not “we” who tell Jesus how these things are to be done, but rather Jesus who tells us how He wants things done.

Jesus said to his church leaders…

“he who hears you, hears me” -Jesus

Jesus speaks through His Church leaders to proclaim exactly what He wants and expects from us, just as He did IN scripture in Acts when the people needed diection and answers, who did they go to? The Church.
 
I guess God might be considered too legalistic also if you believe the following passages:

If you love me, you will obey what I command. John 14:15

Whoever has my commands and obeys them, he is the one who loves me. John 14:21

If anyone loves me, he will obey my teaching. My Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home with him. John 14:23

If you obey my commands, you will remain in my love, just as I have obeyed my Father’s commands and remain in his love. John 15:10

You are my friends if you do what I command. John 15:14

If you know these things, you are blessed if you do them. John 13:17.

I will multiply your descendants as the stars of heaven, and will give to your descendants all these lands; and by your descendants all the nations of the earth shall bless themselves: because Abraham obeyed my voice and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my laws." Genesis 26:4-5
 
I guess God might be considered too legalistic also if you believe the following passages:

If you love me, you will obey
what I command. John 14:15

Whoever has my commands and obeys them, he is the one who loves me. John 14:21

If anyone loves me, he will obey my teaching. My Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home with him. John 14:23

If you obey my commands, you will remain in my love, just as I have obeyed my Father’s commands and remain in his love. John 15:10

You are my friends if you do what I command. John 15:14

If you know these things, you are blessed if you do them. John 13:17.

I will multiply your descendants as the stars of heaven, and will give to your descendants all these lands; and by your descendants all the nations of the earth shall bless themselves: because Abraham obeyed my voice and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my laws." Genesis 26:4-5:thumbsup: If it is “legalistic” to obey Christ then I will be legalistic.
 
Dear Protestant man.

To my knowlege both Catholic and Protestant theology teaches clearly that Christ fulfilled the law (and the prophets). He did not replace them. There is a huge difference. Christ did not walk in lawlessness. Saying so would be the utmost misunderstanding.

When we read all the Pauline letters we have a very good view of how Christians should work in the world… Paul mentions a lot of sins that we should avoid in order that we may not forfeit what Christ has won for us … There is no lawlessness for Christians but the law has been taken up on an even higher level… You say “we are not under the law but under grace” that you find in Romans 6 but I urge you to read the whole letter to the Romans. In verse 19 Its written:" before you let your bodies be slaves to impurity and lawlessness, so you became lawless, but now you must let them be slaves to Justice, so that you are made holy (…) now that you have become servants/slaves for God you have the fruit that you are made holy and in the end eternal life. )we are servants in the new life of the Spirit " etc. The NT is also very clear that failure to live in the law of love - Paul mentions a lot of sins that lead to death fx. fornication etc - can end with loosing your salvation that Christ bought for you with His Blood. You have to repend of your sins and I might say, do it continuously… but its written that the law leads to recognition of sins… now its the Love of God, the law of His Justice which is really also love, that makes us repent when we are born again.
Here its important that we distinguish between justification and salvation. For you are right, the Bible says clearly that Christ is our justification and even our Resurrection… But still it is evident that we can throw away his gifts and end up denying Him…

Shalom to you.
Code:
 I think you are missunderstanding the point.  I never said that the Law does not exist.  I am saying that Jesus replaced the Law.  In the Old Testament, the purpose of the Law was to conquer sin. The problem was, as I pointed out earlier, that it was powerless to do so. This is why Christ had to die on the cross, to do what the Law can not do.
 As you said the purpous of the law is to make sin apparent.  Without the law, how could I know that I am a sinner?  This is still the purpouse of the law today. 
 The title of this thread is what I am debating.  Is it possible that the Catholic church puts so much emphasis on the law that they take away from Christ?  Lets use a hypothetical situation. I have commited adultry.(obvious sin)  I go and confess my sin, because I am **comanded** to do so.  The priest tells me I **must** perform an act of contrition. Isn't their something wrong with this situation?  

 Jesus said that because I am saved, my body is The Temple (capitalized to signify that it is the dwelling place of God, the Holy of Holies). He also commands us to live in the spirit(That he gave us on the day of Pentacost) If I break the law by commiting adultry, then isnt it true that the spirit will convict me to repent?(Notice the difference in that I said **convict** and not **command**)  And if I repent my sins to Christ, not to a priest, then am I still Justified?  If the law is poewrless to do what Christ did, then how can any act of contrition justify your sin?

 In all of this, I am not saying that the Catholic church is wrong to uphold the Law.  What I am saying, is that as a protestant I can still be completely justified and have my salvation.  I do think that the Catholic church puts too much emphasis on the Law. I think that, because of Christ, the replacement to the law lives within me in my Temple.  Christ replaced the written law(what Paul called the Law of sin **Romans 7**) with the Holy Spirit.  Having said that, I do not think that you are wrong by being catholic.  However I do think that it is wrong that catholosism is not willing to accept the protestant reformation as part of the church.
So let me ask you a question. I am a protestant. I believe in that God the Father sent God the Son to die on the cross for my sins. On the Third day he rose and sent the God the Holy Spirit to dwell within us. I live my life as a servant to the Spirit. He has called me to missions, and I answered and fed his sheep. He has called me to minister to my friends and my family and my neighbors, and I answered and fed his sheep. When I sin against God, the Spirit compells me to repent. Christ is the Head of my family and my church. I wish only to be a servant to his poeple so that when people say that I am great, I will know that it is Christ they see in me. So the question is, can you tell me I am not saved, am I not justified?
 
When you say that it is not possible to focus too lightly on God’s law, you are saying that it is not possible to focus too lightly on the truth and the effects of sin - for what is sin but violation of God’s law? You are saying it is not possible to take sin too lightly.

Is that really Christian belief? That it it not possible to take sin too lightly? That no matter how lightly a person takes the reality of sin, it can never be too lightly?
 
So the question is, can you tell me I am not saved, am I not justified?
I would never say you are not saved, nor should any Catholic. God is the Judge. The Church is not in the business of telling us who is not saved, but only some of those who are saved (i.e. the saints).

The Catholic Church does teach that “outside the Church there is no salvation.” However, what that means, positively speaking, is “that all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is his Body.” (Catechism 846). The Church is the Body of Christ and it is through the Church that He continues to offer salvation in time. Thus, we do not say that non-Catholics cannot be saved, we only say that, if they are saved, it is through the Church (and ultimately through Christ) that they are saved, whether they are aware of that or not.

I am curious, protestantman, what you make of Matthew 5:17.
“Think not that I have come to abolish the law and the prophets; I have come not to abolish them but to fulfil them.”
How does this fit in with everything else you have been saying? (I ask this not in anyway to say “Gotcha!” but out of a sincere desire to understand your point of view).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top