CCC1860 - Is it vincible or invincible ignorance?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

Nita

Guest
CCC #1860 **Unintentional ignorance **can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense. But no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man. The promptings of feelings and passions can also diminish the voluntary and free character of the offense, as can external pressures or pathological disorders. Sin committed through malice, by deliberate choice of evil, is the gravest. .
I thought the “unintentional ignorance” here was another way of expressing “invincible ignorance” - just using a more commonly understood word than “invincible”. But, in another thread when I cited CCC 1860 as a reference that the Church teaches invincible ignorance, a poster told me that #1860 was not speaking about “invincible ignorance”, but “vincible ignorance”. ** Is he correct?**
*

I pulled out Fr. Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary. Here are his definitions:
Invincible ignorance:
Lack of knowledge, either of fact or law, for which a person is not morally responsible. This may be due to the difficulty of the object of the knowledge, or scarcity of evidence, or insufficient time or talent in the person, or any other factory for which he is not culpable.

Vincible ignorance:
Lack of knowledge for which a person is morally responsible. It is culpable ignorance because it could be cleared up if the person used sufficient diligence. …

It just seems obvious to me that in #1860, unintentional ignorance = invincible ignorance,
But I could be having some sort of mental block. It wouldn’t be the first time.

Thanks for any help.*
 
I thought the “unintentional ignorance” here was another way of expressing “invincible ignorance” - just using a more commonly understood word than “invincible”. But, in another thread when I cited CCC 1860 as a reference that the Church teaches invincible ignorance, a poster told me that #1860 was not speaking about “invincible ignorance”, but “vincible ignorance”. ** Is he correct?**
Catechism of the Catholic Church: CCC1860a:
Unintentional ignorance can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense.
Invincible Ignorance
Catechism of the Catholic Church: CCC1860b:
But no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man.
Vincible Ignorance
Catechism of the Catholic Church: CCC1860c:
The promptings of feelings and passions can also diminish the voluntary and free character of the offense, as can external pressures or pathological disorders.
I want to say venial sin here, because this doesn’t talk about ignorance.
Catechism of the Catholic Church: CCC1860d:
Sin committed through malice, by deliberate choice of evil, is the gravest.
Mortal sin.

-Prophesy
 
Invincible Ignorance

Vincible Ignorance

I want to say venial sin here, because this doesn’t talk about ignorance.

Mortal sin.

-Prophesy
Thank you Prophesy.
The only one I don’t understand is the “Vincible ignorance”. How can it mean ignorance of any kind when it says “**no one is **deemed to be ignorant…”; the principles (information/knowledge) of the natural law are written in their conscience?
 
Thank you Prophesy.
The only one I don’t understand is the “Vincible ignorance”. How can it mean ignorance of any kind when it says “**no one is **deemed to be ignorant…”; the principles (information/knowledge) of the natural law are written in their conscience?
Because there are things that are bound to natural revelation and things bound to divine revelation.

Example:

We should all know that murder is wrong. → Natural Law

We should go to Mass every Sunday. → Divine Law

-Prophesy
 
Because there are things that are bound to natural revelation and things bound to divine revelation.

Example:

We should all know that murder is wrong. → Natural Law

We should go to Mass every Sunday. → Divine Law

-Prophesy
I guess I still don’t understand. The 2nd CCC sentence only refers to the moral law “principles”, not the acts/offenses that violate these principles. It’s the principles that no one is ignorant of. So I don’t see how there can be vincible ignorance of the principles of moral law.

(Eg. Principle: it’s wrong to take innocent life. (No one can claim ignorance of this.)
Act/Offense: While driving and texting, I hit an innocent pedestrian and he is killed. (Factors can affect culpability.)

The following sentences give factors** in addition to **the “unintentional ignorance” ( first sentence of #1860) that can affect the culpability of acts which violate the moral law principles.

I know there is vincible ignorance, but I just don’t see where it is addressed or included in this particular paragraph.
 
Unintentional ignorance can be either vincible or invincible.

Vincible means that through the effort of the person, the ignorance (lack of knowledge or undestanding) may be overcome. Invincible means that the effort of the person himself is unable to overcome the ignorance.

With regard to the moral law, it cannot be part of unintentional ignorance, unless one is mentally incapable of that level of understanding (an infant or severely mentally impaired.}

However, ignorance of the fact that the church was founded by Christ is vincible, and ignorance of the fact that Christ is God is vincible if God grants one faith.

If one rejects the faith to believe, then that is intentional ignorance. If one suspects, but does not take steps to learn what other moral laws there migh be, that is intentional ignorance.

At least this is how I see it. Hope this helps.

peace
Steve
 
Unintentional ignorance can be either vincible or invincible.

Vincible means that through the effort of the person, the ignorance (lack of knowledge or undestanding) may be overcome. Invincible means that the effort of the person himself is unable to overcome the ignorance.

With regard to the moral law, it cannot be part of unintentional ignorance, unless one is mentally incapable of that level of understanding (an infant or severely mentally impaired.}

However, ignorance of the fact that the church was founded by Christ is vincible, and ignorance of the fact that Christ is God is vincible if God grants one faith.

If one rejects the faith to believe, then that is intentional ignorance. If one suspects, but does not take steps to learn what other moral laws there migh be, that is intentional ignorance.

At least this is how I see it. Hope this helps.

peace
Steve
I would like to add that I believe that one’s lack of diligence in pursuing the truth determines his degree of guilt with regards to ignoranceof a moral truth.

steve
 
Dear sister Nita,

CCC 1860 is not concerned with defining invincible ignorance, but rather the imputability of sin for a grave offense.

The sentence at issue is merely saying that even though one can never be or claim to be ignorant of the moral law, imputability for offenses against the moral law can still be diminished due to promptings of feelings or passions that are often beyond our control.

I hope that helps.

Blessings,
Marduk
I thought the “unintentional ignorance” here was another way of expressing “invincible ignorance” - just using a more commonly understood word than “invincible”. But, in another thread when I cited CCC 1860 as a reference that the Church teaches invincible ignorance, a poster told me that #1860 was not speaking about “invincible ignorance”, but “vincible ignorance”. ** Is he correct?**
*

I pulled out Fr. Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary. Here are his definitions:
Invincible ignorance:
Lack of knowledge, either of fact or law, for which a person is not morally responsible. This may be due to the difficulty of the object of the knowledge, or scarcity of evidence, or insufficient time or talent in the person, or any other factory for which he is not culpable.

Vincible ignorance:
Lack of knowledge for which a person is morally responsible. It is culpable ignorance because it could be cleared up if the person used sufficient diligence. …

It just seems obvious to me that in #1860, unintentional ignorance = invincible ignorance,
But I could be having some sort of mental block. It wouldn’t be the first time.

Thanks for any help.*
 
Dear sister Nita,

CCC 1860 is not concerned with defining invincible ignorance, but rather the imputability of sin for a grave offense.

The sentence at issue is merely saying that even though one can never be or claim to be ignorant of the moral law, imputability for offenses against the moral law can still be diminished due to promptings of feelings or passions that are often beyond our control.

I hope that helps.

Blessings,
Marduk
Thanks Mardukm, and I realized that the point of the paragraph was factors that affect the gravity and culpability of our sins - “unintentional ignorance” being one of those possible factors. I had cited the paragraph just as a cross reference to show that “invincible ignorance” is part of Church teaching - because I thought “unintentional ignorance” was just a different way of saying “invincible ignorance”. But, the response to my post was that CCC1860 was about vincible ignorance, not invincible ignorance. I’m trying to find out if that is right or wrong, because I don’t see where it even addresses vincible ignorance.

Only the first 2 sentences address ignorance:
a) the first sentence refers to “unintentional ignorance” that mitigates or even removes imputability of a grave matter…
So, is this “unintentional ignorance” invincible or vincible – or can it be either?
If it can be both unintentional and vincible, could you give me an example

b) the second sentence says “no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles…”. ’
I don’t see this as referring to any specific type of ignorance. Rather, it rejects that there can be ignorance (vincible. invincible or unintentional) of the principles of moral law; God has written them in the hearts/consciences of everyone.
Other factors might lessen culpability, but not ignorance of the moral principle involved.
(eg. I/he didn’t know it was wrong to kill an innocent person, therefore…)

Anyway, I just don’t see where #1860 (in regards to the ignorance mentioned) is about vincible, and not invicible ignorance. But, if I am wrong I would like to know.

It seems I’m making this molehill into a mountain :o. It may be time to put it to rest.
 
Thanks Mardukm, and I realized that the point of the paragraph was factors that affect the gravity and culpability of our sins - “unintentional ignorance” being one of those possible factors. I had cited the paragraph just as a cross reference to show that “invincible ignorance” is part of Church teaching as a mitigating factor - because I thought “unintentional ignorance” was just a different way of saying “invincible ignorance”. But, the response to my post was that CCC1860 was about vincible ignorance, not invincible ignorance. I’m trying to find out if that is right or wrong, because I don’t see where it even addresses vincible ignorance.

Only the first 2 sentences address ignorance:
a) the first sentence refers to “unintentional ignorance” that mitigates or even removes imputability of a grave matter…
So, is this “unintentional ignorance” invincible or vincible – or can it be either?
If it can be both unintentional and vincible, could you give me an example

b) the second sentence says “no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles…”. ’
I don’t see this as referring to any specific type of ignorance. Rather, it rejects that there can be ignorance (vincible. invincible or unintentional) of the principles of moral law; God has written them in the hearts/consciences of everyone.
Other factors might lessen culpability, but not ignorance of the moral principle involved.
(eg. I/he didn’t know it was wrong to kill an innocent person, therefore…)

Anyway, I just don’t see where #1860 (in regards to the ignorance mentioned) is about vincible, and not invicible ignorance. But, if I am wrong I would like to know.

It seems I’m making this molehill into a mountain :o. It may be time to put it to rest.
 
I decided to pull out Fr. Hardon’s dicitionary and read the “vincible ignorance” entry again. I had cited only the first couple sentences because the entry was so long. After rereading, I do see where ignorance that is “unintentional” (not willed) can be in some of the forms of vincible ignorance that he gives.

For any interested, here is the full text of his definition:
VINCIBLE IGNORANCE. Lack of knowledge for which a person is morally responsible. It is culpable ignorance because it could be cleared up if the person used sufficient diligence.
One is said to be simply (but culpably) ignorant if one fails to make enough effort to learn what should be known; guilt then depends on one’s lack of effort to clear up the ignorance.
That person is crassly ignorant when the lack of knowledge is **not directly willed but rather due to neglect or laziness; as a result the guilt is somewhat lessened, but in grave matters a person would still be gravely responsible. A person has affected ignorance when one deliberately fosters it in order not to be inhibited in what one wants to do; such ignorance is gravely wrong when it concerns serious matters.
(Etym. Latin vincibilis, easily overcome;
ignorantia
, want of knowledge or information)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top