Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Vatican is not an objective source.

***Just because you say it doesn’t make it so. Claiming that all documents stored in the Vatican are not objective sources simply because they are stored in the Vatican is extremely biased, and not at all objective on your part. We do not claim that everything outside of the Church is false or biased. Yet you are extremely prejudiced and biased against anything that is even located on Church grounds.

You claimed there was scientific evidence in prior posts.

***I never claimed that there was evidence in scientific journals. I consider Medicine a science…so do most medical doctors. Without the scientific part of it, there wouldn’t be medicine. Medical doctors did examine Padre Pio.
You would have to quote where I said that there were articles published in scientific journals. You couldn’t find one, as I never said it. And there are objective, academic sources on the stigmata of Padre Pio. You just won’t find them in your scienctific journals…and it would probably be stretching the truth to say your journals are unbiased.
I never said it. I said many times that the evidence can be found if you contact the Vatican…which would be able to point you in the right direction.

Of course, there was something in a quote on the last few pages that quoted Modern Science as stating that science couldn’t prove that the stigmata of Padre Pio wasn’t exactly as Catholics believe.***

I see you’ve started projecting.
If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, quacks like a duck…I pretty much assume it’s a duck. Same with what I assume about you.
 
I see you completely ignored the last 15+pgs where ppl argued there was objective evidence/papers. Me thinks this is telling of your ability to play things down:rolleyes: .
True, and you bickered over that point right along with them, page after page. I simply pointed out that the point you were bickering over is not the main issue. I did give you the credit I felt you deserved - sorry if you feel your logical accomplishment was not given its due.
I figured what I said about miracals being a subjective experience was obvious.

Er, I cited articles dealing with the placebo effect in one of the earleir posts, but I can see how you missed it given your weakness for missing the obvious.

It would be…but its now quite common among academic literature. Check my links or do a search for placebo effect.

How adorably ignorant.😃

Er no.

I really suggest you do some prior research (or at least read the thread in its entirity) next time you post.:rolleyes:

There might be, shame its indistinguishable from autosuggestive disorders/cures.😃
Ok, bear with my lack of knowledge and understanding here, ok?

Alice Jones was not able to walk for 7 years as the result of an accident which physically damaged her leg. She was instantly healed after seeing a vision of Padre Pio. Nobody I have ever heard disputes these basic facts.

You are saying she received a “subjective” healing?

…and that her leg was instantly healed as a result of the “placebo effect” ?

I just want to make sure I understand your position, if possible.
 
True, and you bickered over that point right along with them, page after page. I simply pointed out that the point you were bickering over is not the main issue. I did give you the credit I felt you deserved - sorry if you feel your logical accomplishment was not given its due.

Ok, bear with my lack of knowledge and understanding here, ok?

Alice Jones was not able to walk for 7 years as the result of an accident which physically damaged her leg. She was instantly healed after seeing a vision of Padre Pio. Nobody I have ever heard disputes these basic facts.

You are saying she received a “subjective” healing?

…and that her leg was instantly healed as a result of the “placebo effect” ?

I just want to make sure I understand your position, if possible.
Placebo effect seems the final counter argument for obvious things… like saying there is no evolution because you cannot prove that action and consequence have any bearing to each other…

Placebo effect is utter nonsense, just because some sicknesses heals when one takes a placebo medicine, doesnt have anything to do with miracles, just hopeless people without better explanation
 
Just because you say it doesn’t make it so. Claiming that all documents stored in the Vatican are not objective sources simply because they are stored in the Vatican is extremely biased, and not at all objective on your part. We do not claim that everything outside of the Church is false or biased. Yet you are extremely prejudiced and biased against anything that is even located on Church grounds.
This is as objective as any scientific source there is… that is if you are looking not to limit your view in a subjective manner… if you really want to be objective…

That is proven by the thousands of pages of investigations made on each saint… Vatican does not believe in miracles, just in proven facts (facts are not always scientific)…
 
Thats easy. If academic sources were as bias as you claim, your computer wouldn’t work, your lifespan would be much less, your car wouldnt start etc etc.😃
I am sorry i am not as educated as you on logical terms, but this is a clear fallacy… it does not proof non-bias on issues related to miracles at all, and earlier you didn’t accept medical science as science… hmmm…

On evolution issue, I found it very easy to destroy something without ever even looking at it… i suppose that is what you are doing as well, just based on bias belief not investigation you are stating there are no miracles, This is not a strawman or naked assertion by the way, your bias towards believing in Vatican sources plus all other approving miracles has proven it to be true…

Don’t hide beyond logical terms, it is a fallacy as you know…
 
“Sola scientia” advocate? I don;t know where you got that idea as I don’t at all subscribe to neither the Neo-Darwinist school, nor Behaviourist school of thought. Im actually more of a deconstructionist-Nietzschean to be honest:D

I simply dont categorize subjective evidence as the same as objective evidence.
As a deconstructionist-Nietzschean you should know there are no objective evidence?

How does these two words fit together though? Deconstruction as fit by Derrida seems more related to literature. Nietzsche sounds interesting but you don’t seem to use the hammer hard enough…
 
This is as objective as any scientific source there is… that is if you are looking not to limit your view in a subjective manner… if you really want to be objective…

That is proven by the thousands of pages of investigations made on each saint… Vatican does not believe in miracles, just in proven facts (facts are not always scientific)…
Thank you for your statements which back up my points. Now, if we can just convince the skeptics, it could be wonderful. But, because God knows the value of love and choice, He will never force anyone to accept Him. But we CAN pray for them!!! And maybe God will use a better suited for this project person than myself.
I am glad you and I are on the same side.
 
Actually, using the scientific method we can demonstrate exactly what science claims. We can demonstrate that it is the most effective method for discovering the truth.

You see, science can back up it’s claims. That’s why it is popular. Scientists don’t claim to know everything. The only difference is they don’t claim to know what they can’t possibly know… at least good ones don’t.
Poin taken. This is very good…we have a common ground now. Science can’t prove or disprove miracles, so there is no need for them to publish anything about them. Had they been able to explain what the stigmata was from a scientific point, they would have possibly published it. That would have been quite an article. But the fact is, they could not explain it scientifically. That doesn’t mean they weren’t invited to try to come up with some scientific reason for the stigmata on Padre Pio.

Fact is, they could not scientifically explain it, ergo it was a miracle. Their lack of scientific explanation backs up the claim for it being a miracle.

Just because they could not find scientific evidence to explain it, does not mean that the stigmata does not exist. Meteorological wind exists…but where did it originate from?
 
O? With such conviction in your answer, I am certain you can provide the appropiate academic paper to give weight to your news article’s claims:rolleyes:

You refuse to accept anything if it is not published in the scientific journal that you choose to believe is the correct one…as if nothing scientific exists outside of what is published in said journal. You asked for proof, but deny all of it.

Sorry champ, this thread quickly became about no miracals being recognized in objective academic studies. Either produce one, or you’ve lost.😉
That’s what is said when you have nothing else to say. These are the words of one who is at a loss: “Let’s just not worry about that, because I have nothing to counter it with.”
 
“academic objective evidence” hmm… I guess you mean academic research papers. And I guess by “objective” you are presuming that academic research papers are free from conclusion-warping bias. For example, they would never start out by absolutely excluding divine intervention as a possible explanation for the miracles (not “miracals”) they are studying, because that would assume the proof they were trying to prove.

So basically you are saying there are no academic papers written about Padre Pio’s miracles.

Wrong. There are objective academic papers written about the stigmata of Padre Pio, but probably not in the scientific journals that you consider your Bible. Where they are found is totally irrelevant if they are truthful.
 
True, and you bickered over that point right along with them, page after page. I simply pointed out that the point you were bickering over is not the main issue. I did give you the credit I felt you deserved - sorry if you feel your logical accomplishment was not given its due.
Well considering that was **the only **thing being argued, I’d say that was sorta imporant;)
Ok, bear with my lack of knowledge and understanding here, ok?

Alice Jones was not able to walk for 7 years as the result of an accident which physically damaged her leg. She was instantly healed after seeing a vision of Padre Pio. Nobody I have ever heard disputes these basic facts.
Hmmm might want to be careful with what you call a fact. True, she may have very well been healed, but you’d need alot more than just her testimony to say vision of Padre Pio= miracal healing.
You are saying she received a “subjective” healing?
Im saying her believing its a miracal is subjective.
…and that her leg was instantly healed as a result of the “placebo effect” ?

I just want to make sure I understand your position, if possible.
May very well have been (not alot of details are given in your links). You’d be surprised what the placebo effect can accomplish as well as how often it occurs. For a general explination, read this en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo_effect#Concept . For some very cool examples, check out my links at the beginning of the thread.

Now to be clear, she may very well have experienced a miracal, but without further objective study, theres no way to really tell which is why its so important.
 
Just because you say it doesn’t make it so. Claiming that all documents stored in the Vatican are not objective sources simply because they are stored in the Vatican is extremely biased, and not at all objective on your part. We do not claim that everything outside of the Church is false or biased. Yet you are extremely prejudiced and biased against anything that is even located on Church grounds.
a. The Vatican refuses to publish their “research” to an academic community
b. The Vatican’s research hasn’t been peer-reviewed then
c. The Vatican has a strong interest in not having its claims refuted.

Ergo, theres no reason to assume any of the Vatican’s “research” os objective.
I never claimed that there was evidence in scientific journals.
There would have to be for you to claim they are accepted miracals.
I consider Medicine a science…so do most medical doctors. Without the scientific part of it, there wouldn’t be medicine.
That it is. Its because they follow the scientific method.
Medical doctors did examine Padre Pio.
Good, now produce their academic papers confirming what you said.
You would have to quote where I said that there were articles published in scientific journals. You couldn’t find one, as I never said it.
You just implied it above, or do you not the meaning of what it is to call something scietific?
And there are objective, academic sources on the stigmata of Padre Pio. You just won’t find them in your scienctific journals…and it would probably be stretching the truth to say your journals are unbiased.
For it to be academic, it would ahve to be in a scientific journal.
I never said it. I said many times that the evidence can be found if you contact the Vatican…which would be able to point you in the right direction.
They are neither a scientific, nor academic source.
Of course, there was something in a quote on the last few pages that quoted Modern Science as stating that science couldn’t prove that the stigmata of Padre Pio wasn’t exactly as Catholics believe.
Where?
If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, quacks like a duck…I pretty much assume it’s a duck. Same with what I assume about you.
Indeed. I look forward to your next bunch of self-contradictorary responses.
 
I am sorry i am not as educated as you on logical terms, but this is a clear fallacy… it does not proof non-bias on issues related to miracles at all,
You’re right, it would be a fallacy. Except it was in response to a post claiming academic sources were incredibly bias that they couldn’t be trusted. If that were true, then it would be the worst way to base any technology on as it should never work. The truth is the reverse, its the only form of research that yields results.
and earlier you didn’t accept medical science as science… hmmm…
I sense an unfounded claim. Care to back that up?
On evolution issue, I found it very easy to destroy something without ever even looking at it…
Destroying something out of personal ignorance of a subject is typically a bad idea.
i suppose that is what you are doing as well, just based on bias belief not investigation you are stating there are no miracles, This is not a strawman or naked assertion by the way,
Actually, it is. I never claimed there was no miracals. Nice strawman.
your bias towards believing in Vatican sources plus all other approving miracles has proven it to be true…
Non-sequiter with the above. Cute. It has nothing to do with bias, and has everything to do with understand with using proper definitions and not making up my own.
Don’t hide beyond logical terms, it is a fallacy as you know…
I see you’re employing your philosophy of "destroy something without ever even looking at it… ". Shame that ignorance doesn’t win you arguements.
 
As a deconstructionist-Nietzschean you should know there are no objective evidence?
???

Im a deconstuctionist-Nietzschean, not a philosophical nihilist.
How does these two words fit together though? Deconstruction as fit by Derrida seems more related to literature.
No, “texts”. This includes speech and everything involving language as its all put together like a text.
Nietzsche sounds interesting but you don’t seem to use the hammer hard enough…
How so? Ive been smashing all the unfounded claims so far.
 
That’s what is said when you have nothing else to say. These are the words of one who is at a loss: “Let’s just not worry about that, because I have nothing to counter it with.”
LOL o the irony. So asking to answer instead of dancing around a point is an indication of having nothing to say eh? I can see you are unfamiliar with how arguements work with their o so confusing back and forth of arguement and counter arguement.:rolleyes:
 
???

Im a deconstuctionist-Nietzschean, not a philosophical nihilist.

No, “texts”. This includes speech and everything involving language as its all put together like a text.

How so? Ive been smashing all the unfounded claims so far.
Yeah, i know what it is about…

Not smashing them up very well. More like smashing with very low grounds, that is why i said about the hammer. Nietzsche knew how to use the hammer, you lack a bit…

Smashing up evolution is and was easy… it doesn’t take more then just saying there is no proof that one species can ever develop into another on a big scale… This would take a few million years to disprove or test, so evolution is not a real scientific theory, i think as a skeptic which i think you are trying to be you should know that… If Nietzsche was alive i think he might have pointed that one out…

I kind of gotten the impression that Nietzsche was a nihilist… And i want to know how do you put Derrida and Nietzsche together? Because it sounds cool or because there is something real behind it?

By the way you haven’t smashed up any miracle you have just successfully avoided the subject… By claiming there is no academic source… Which is like claiming there is no creationist source for evolution… Come on… you should try a bit harder… To really disprove them…
 
You’re right, it would be a fallacy. Except it was in response to a post claiming academic sources were incredibly bias that they couldn’t be trusted. If that were true, then it would be the worst way to base any technology on as it should never work. The truth is the reverse, its the only form of research that yields results.
No this is not true… we can be bias on against religion and make good computers… don’t try to be less intellectual then you are… I was talking about Bias Against Religion of course and that doesn’t have too much to do with such issues as computers airplanes, medicine… Try a bit better, clear fallacy and you are caught…
I sense an unfounded claim. Care to back that up?
JNS:My question to you is, what makes this person or organization more trustworthy or knowledgable about TRUTH than those who did the scientific and medical examinations?

You:*

No scientific evidence has been presented.
*

This was between you and Jesus n Cherie, I am sorry if i am mistaken but it sounds like you don’t think medicine is scientific…
Actually, it is. I never claimed there was no miracals. Nice strawman.
O you never claimed so? I see then please check Vatican sources, investigate and find out the objective truth… It is very good for you to say that you never maid such a claim…
Non-sequiter with the above. Cute. It has nothing to do with bias, and has everything to do with understand with using proper definitions and not making up my own.
Yes you are right definition of objective is not quite the same as science though… hmmm… makes me wonder why…

Is it because something outside science can be objective? Or as your favourite Nietzsche might point out, maybe science is not objective but subjective depending on the subjective view point of the researches… Maybe…
I see you’re employing your philosophy of "destroy something without ever even looking at it… ". Shame that ignorance doesn’t win you arguements.
Yes, it is the exactly the methods of yours otherwise you would be all over Vatican already… but since you haven’t looked from their for real evidence, it is a shame that ignorance does not give you any base in arguments… especially when you are ignorant on your own choosing…
 
a. The Vatican refuses to publish their “research” to an academic community
b. The Vatican’s research hasn’t been peer-reviewed then
c. The Vatican has a strong interest in not having its claims refuted.

Ergo, theres no reason to assume any of the Vatican’s “research” os objective.
BTW do you have any non-bias sources to back up this, since i thought they peer review their studies quite roughly… they use the devils advocate on their saints who tries to disprove everything in the process of studying miracles and such… Where is this claim founded or is it a naked assertion?
Indeed. I look forward to your next bunch of self-contradictorary responses.
Yes i do… yours i mean
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top