Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesus N Cherie, he has been using a straw man fallacy against you on this issue, making it look like you said something more then you did to proof his case easier…
I see you missed the post where I specifically quoted her/him.

Again, if you are going to cry fallacy, be sure you are correct.
 
Not according to methods of establishing and evaluating objective reality, but then, that was sorta my point.

According to the Vatican, they are miracals.
Generally, a fact is defined as something that is true, something that actually exists, or something that can be verified according to an established standard of evaluation.[1][2] There is a range of other uses, depending on the context. For example, fact may be argued under authority of a specific pedagogy, such as scientific facts or historical facts*

You seem to have misunderstood your own post… Established standard of evaluation does not mean scientific only… as the last sentence clearly states, Miracles are facts…
I see you havent bothered to read the last 23 pages where I explicitly said in no uncertain terms that I wasn’t the one claiming miracals to be scientific.
If that is the case i don’t know why you still insist on it… please move on
Ask those who claimed they were backed by scientific evidence.
You mean J N C… Please read post 297 and 299 and refute those and then we can have a real argument do not be a coward
Thats not a strawman, at least not the complete definition.
It does not matter You are using a clear fallacy, get rid of it…
I see you have no idea what secular means.
Main Entry: 1sec·u·lar
Pronunciation: \ˈse-kyə-lər\
Function: adjective
Etymology: Middle English, from Anglo-French seculer, from Late Latin saecularis, from saeculum the present world, from Latin, generation, age, century, world; akin to Welsh hoedl lifetime
Date: 14th century
1 a: of or relating to the worldly or temporal b: not overtly or specifically religious c: not ecclesiastical or clerical
2: not bound by monastic vows or rules; specifically : of, relating to, or forming clergy not belonging to a religious order or congregation
3 a: occurring once in an age or a century b: existing or continuing through ages or centuries c: of or relating to a long term of indefinite duration
merriam-webster.com/dictionary/secular
Yes this is the dictionary definition, let’s get back to reality…
I never said you said anything about Islam. I used the Islam statement to show how ridiculous your position that we accept anything with “research” really is.
O this: Why would I have to? You disprove Islamic sources claiming that evolution is an evil Christian-Western plot to discredit Islam. Both have significant backing among pseudo-academics.

sentence of yours on post 307 was not about Islam? How did i miss that, i thought it was your naked assertion of what i might be thinking…
Good. Now you have no excuse for what you just did above.
at least i am not much worse then you, maybe a bit better
Odd, Cherie just mentioned them. I guess you arnt king of these forums eh?:rolleyes:
hmm i never claimed to be a king, maybe this is a naked assertion
The arguement that there were never scientific sources for Pio’s miracals? Its been 23pgs, and nothing has come up except derailment. Youve won the arguement in your mind, but sadly, not in reality.
Academic sources on Pio’s miracles don’t matter anymore, the argument has moved on you must see that already, and i didn’t argue that anyway so you to claim it on me is just a bit ill willed… anyway, i said there are no scientific sources, get over it, and let’s talk but seems you lost your will to really debate already, it is sad you lost the debate in reality a long time ago with me, you cannot debate me according to what somebody else said… you have to debate me on terms of what i said…
 
Generally, a fact is defined as something that is true, something that actually exists, or something that can be verified according to an established standard of evaluation.[1][2] There is a range of other uses, depending on the context. For example, fact may be argued under authority of a specific pedagogy, such as scientific facts or historical facts*

You seem to have misunderstood your own post… Established standard of evaluation does not mean scientific only… as the last sentence clearly states, Miracles are facts…
Your selective reading is truely extrodinairy.

“For example, fact may be argued under authority of a specific pedagogy, such as scientific facts or historical facts”

Unless you renounce the claim that there is scientific/objective evidence for miracals, I believe you’ve just lost.
If that is the case i don’t know why you still insist on it… please move on
You brought it up lol.
You mean J N C… Please read post 297 and 299 and refute those and then we can have a real argument do not be a coward
297 is a link to a site with a bunch of claims of scientific evidence w/o any references. 299 is just you trying to equate the peer-review process to devil’s advocate, something I already refuted. Again, exemplorary selective reading on your part.
[It does not matter You are using a clear fallacy, get rid of it…
Whats a fallacy? From what Ive seen, you dont even know what the word means lol.
[Yes this is the dictionary definition, let’s get back to reality…
What? The reality that you are being intellectually dishonest by re-defining words to suit your own purposes?
[O this: *Why would I have to? You disprove Islamic sources claiming that evolution is an evil Christian-Western plot to discredit Islam. Both have significant backing among pseudo-academics.
[/quote]

sentence of yours on post 307 was not about Islam? How did i miss that, i thought it was your naked assertion of what i might be thinking…

Selective reading ftl. I see how something as ambigious as this “Both have significant backing among pseudo-academics” could be lost on someone as quick-witted as you:rolleyes:
at least i am not much worse then you, maybe a bit better
Youve have yet to show a single fallacy on my part.

juhothenero;4077093hmm i never claimed to be a king said:
O my, dont tell me you dont know what sarcasim is either…lol

juhothenero;4077093Academic sources on Pio’s miracles don’t matter anymore said:
The claim was that scientific evidence exists. That means that academic sources exists on the subject. Given your love of re-definition thou, God only knows what enters your head when someone says “scientific evidence”.
iid there are no scientific sources, get over it, and let’s talk but seems you lost your will to really debate already, it is sad you lost the debate in reality a long time ago with me, you cannot debate me according to what somebody else said… you have to debate me on terms of what i said…

Youve said nothing except sniping at your own strawman. Congrats on defeating the windmill Don Quijote.
[/quote]
 
Your selective reading is truely extrodinairy.

"For example, fact may be argued under authority of a specific pedagogy, such as scientific facts or historical facts
"

Unless you renounce the claim that there is scientific/objective evidence for miracals, I believe you’ve just lost.

Miracles are accepted by an established standard of evaluation, Vatican has established standards… do you really think i am stupid enough to only follow that your standards are only correct ones and i play by your rules, if you want to win me you have at least try to refute my argument, VATICAN HAS ESTABLISHED STANDARDS FOR MIRACLES, MIRACLES ARE FACTS according to definition you posted

The last sentence states two forms of facts: Scientific and historical, These are both establish forms of facts but they are also different forms of facts… Scientific facts != Historical Facts but they are both Facts

Miracles are facts since they have an established standard behind them, that is the Vatican standard… That is not redefining the word that is using the original definition to state all options
You brought it up lol.
Where did i bring it up? please show me? If you don’t have better argument you lost!!! Getting tired of your telling me what i said without a shred of proof…
297 is a link to a site with a bunch of claims of scientific evidence w/o any references. 299 is just you trying to equate the peer-review process to devil’s advocate, something I already refuted. Again, exemplorary selective reading on your part.
I agree with the lack of evidence on this one though, i wondered that by myself too…
Whats a fallacy? From what Ive seen, you dont even know what the word means lol.
you cannot see your own fallacies that is quite regular for humans
Youve said nothing except sniping at your own strawman. Congrats on defeating the windmill Don Quijote.
you disprove those Vatican sources in something else then your screaming for scientific evidence, in post 299 i refuted your argument against them quite well and i will continue with this evidence:

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_constitutions/documents
/hf_jp-ii_apc_25011983_divinus-perfectionis-magister_en.html

  1. The Congregation examines cases of alleged miracles in the following way:
  1. The Relator assigned to this task is to prepare a Position on alleged miracles. They are discussed in a meeting of experts (in the case of healings, in a meeting of physicians), whose votes and conclusions are set forth in an accurate report.
  2. Then the miracles are to be discussed in the special meeting of the theologians and, finally, in that of the Cardinals and Bishops
Refute that please
 
Miracles are accepted by an established standard of evaluation, Vatican has established standards… do you really think i am stupid enough to only follow that your standards are only correct ones and i play by your rules, if you want to win me you have at least try to refute my argument, VATICAN HAS ESTABLISHED STANDARDS FOR MIRACLES, MIRACLES ARE FACTS according to definition you posted

The last sentence states two forms of facts: Scientific and historical, These are both establish forms of facts but they are also different forms of facts… Scientific facts != Historical Facts but they are both Facts

Miracles are facts since they have an established standard behind them, that is the Vatican standard… That is not redefining the word that is using the original definition to state all options
Uggg sigh

Weather something is considered a miracal or not is not being debated. If miracals are based on ***objective and/or scientific ***evidence is.
Where did i bring it up? please show me? If you don’t have better argument you lost!!! Getting tired of your telling me what i said without a shred of proof…
" notice you didn’t care to read my earlier post… Because academic sources and science for that matter is about explaining the unexplained, when a miracle occurs it should be unnatural and unexplained by science… you tell me how these two fit together…"
you cannot see your own fallacies that is quite regular for humans
Shame I know the definition of fallacies.
you disprove those Vatican sources in something else then your screaming for scientific evidence, in post 299 i refuted your argument against them quite well and i will continue with this evidence:

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_constitutions/documents
/hf_jp-ii_apc_25011983_divinus-perfectionis-magister_en.html

  1. The Congregation examines cases of alleged miracles in the following way:
  1. The Relator assigned to this task is to prepare a Position on alleged miracles. They are discussed in a meeting of experts (in the case of healings, in a meeting of physicians), whose votes and conclusions are set forth in an accurate report.
  2. Then the miracles are to be discussed in the special meeting of the theologians and, finally, in that of the Cardinals and Bishops
Refute that please
Refute what? The Vatican is not the standard for objective evidence. Academia is.:rolleyes:
 
About public revelations, here’s what the Vatican says about it in DOGMATIC CONSTITUTION ON DIVINE REVELATION DEI VERBUM SOLEMNLY PROMULGATED BY HIS HOLINESS
POPE PAUL VI ON NOVEMBER 18, 1965
(vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/
documents/vat-ii_const_19651118_dei-verbum_en.html
):
“we now await no further new public revelation before the glorious manifestation of our Lord Jesus Christ”

On believing the Bible, here’s what I got from the CCC:
God is the author of Sacred Scripture. “The divinely revealed realities, which are contained and presented in the text of Sacred Scripture, have been written down under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit.” “For Holy Mother Church, relying on the faith of the apostolic age, accepts as sacred and canonical the books of the Old and the New Testaments, whole and entire, with all their parts, on the grounds that, written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, they have God as their author, and have been handed on as such to the Church herself.” God inspired the human authors of the sacred books. “To compose the sacred books, God chose certain men who, all the while he employed them in this task, made full use of their own faculties and powers so that, though he acted in them and by them, it was as true authors that they consigned to writing whatever he wanted written, and no more.” The inspired books teach the truth. “Since therefore all that the inspired authors or sacred writers affirm should be regarded as affirmed by the Holy Spirit, we must acknowledge that the books of Scripture firmly, faithfully, and without error teach that truth which God, for the sake of our salvation, wished to see confided to the Sacred Scriptures.”

The rest, maybe I’m just wrong. I don’t know. But saying that reporters who don’t report miracles are (and I quote) “Those who hate God! Those who want to deny the existence of God, and keep others from hoping in that which the reporter or editor hates” is a bit strong don’t you think?
 
About public revelations, here’s what the Vatican says about it in DOGMATIC CONSTITUTION ON DIVINE REVELATION DEI VERBUM SOLEMNLY PROMULGATED BY HIS HOLINESS
POPE PAUL VI ON NOVEMBER 18, 1965
(vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/
documents/vat-ii_const_19651118_dei-verbum_en.html
):
“we now await no further new public revelation before the glorious manifestation of our Lord Jesus Christ”

On believing the Bible, here’s what I got from the CCC:
God is the author of Sacred Scripture. “The divinely revealed realities, which are contained and presented in the text of Sacred Scripture, have been written down under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit.” “For Holy Mother Church, relying on the faith of the apostolic age, accepts as sacred and canonical the books of the Old and the New Testaments, whole and entire, with all their parts, on the grounds that, written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, they have God as their author, and have been handed on as such to the Church herself.” God inspired the human authors of the sacred books. “To compose the sacred books, God chose certain men who, all the while he employed them in this task, made full use of their own faculties and powers so that, though he acted in them and by them, it was as true authors that they consigned to writing whatever he wanted written, and no more.” The inspired books teach the truth. “Since therefore all that the inspired authors or sacred writers affirm should be regarded as affirmed by the Holy Spirit, we must acknowledge that the books of Scripture firmly, faithfully, and without error teach that truth which God, for the sake of our salvation, wished to see confided to the Sacred Scriptures.”

The rest, maybe I’m just wrong. I don’t know. But saying that reporters who don’t report miracles are (and I quote) “Those who hate God! Those who want to deny the existence of God, and keep others from hoping in that which the reporter or editor hates” is a bit strong don’t you think?
Thank you for the reference points. I didn’t say that all reporters hated God. And I know from experience…with the newspaper in my own area, that if they do not like what you are saying, they won’t print it…even in the part of the newspapers that are letters. I wrote a letter not too long ago, giving my reasons for not supporting a certain presidential candidate. I could have given reference numbers…which no one else does…and they still wouldn’t have printed my letter. The content was the only thing they had against my letter…and there were no vulgar or strong accusations in it…simply my defense against why I will vote for the other guy, versus their assumption of the reasons I won’t vote for their guy. this happens quite often. And I assume that if they do it for something small, there is no reason not to assume that they do it for something even more pronounced. they do not report on things that they are against. They are biased. I did the scientific research, I did the test. I am trying to get the results of the tests published. I am waiting to hear back from the objective scientific journal that Isambard is speaking of, except…wait…she/he hasn’t told us the name of it yet.

I am sorry if I sounded so harsh in my last post to you. What you were saying sounded sola scriptura to me, like you don’t believe that God is still present in every aspect of His Church, and our lives today. Like He finished His work 2000 years ago, and we have only what the Church was teaching 2000 years ago to go by. Like He didn’t promise He would be with us even to the end of time. Like the Holy Spirit is inactive in today’s world…or yesterday’s world.
If you didn’t mean it that way, I am even more sorry. I will make a real attempt to be more charitable. I am glad you are on this thread.

God bless you,
 
Jesus N Cherie, I accept your apology. Your response to my post made me aware of how anti-miracle I sound. I guess I thought of miracles as the secular world would think of it: regeneration of lost limbs, levitation, etc. I agree with you that the transubstantiation of the Eucharist is one of the many miracles occurring every day under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
 
There are several hundred (perhaps thousands) of academic journals. I personally just use Scholar’s Portal, a academic search engine which brings up certain articles in according to the parameters of my searches.

***Thank you for answering my question./***I]

Er no. Theyd definitately publish research that is controversial. Having Pio’s stigata established as fact would count if they could show that alternative naturalistic explinations were explored.

Maybe. But as you say, they haven’t been published…along with millions of other science or non science facts… or we haven’t been able to come up with an article to reference you to. No one ever implied that there was such an article in one of your science journals. SO WHAT ???

No, that it is unreliable.

You have been saying and giving the impression that the only way you will accept the evidence as credible is if it comes from one of those journals. So what is it about that statement that you are now claiming is unreliable?

No, as more than one copy exists of research papers. Especially now with the majority of research papers made available electronically.

So tell me again why you will refuse to accept something found in the Vatican Library? You have repeated constantly that if it is found in the Vatican Library, it is non objective, or non scientific, or non academic. Make up your mind. Unless you do the research, you have no idea what you will find…but you have pointed out that it is unacceptable to yourself if found by using the Vatican as a mode for finding it. And try to respond to the entire quote, not just call me a liar, strawman or whatever.

Odd thing to say. I couldve sworn you owned a computer…:rolleyes:

What does my owning a computer have to do with this conversation? You keep bringing it up when you obviously have no answer. It would be better all the way around if you said, "I don’t know the answer, so I will say nothing on this matter until I come up with something."

Staying on the side of caution is different from leaving yourself open to having your claims discredited at any time which is one of the dangerous of having your work in academia.

The Vatican has nothing to hide, nor does it have anything to be afraid of. The papers are available to those who want them…they are just housed outside of your scientific journals. The Vatican is not “hiding them” from science. Padre Pio’s stigmata has already been accepted by science to be unexplainable by science as anything that is natural, (which makes it supernatural). Therefore, scientists themselves have decided that there is no need to revisit it. If they wanted to, the Vatican wouldn’t have objections…provided that they could be proven to be HONEST in their research, which would not be difficult to prove if they have been. Any one could come and say anything. Honesty is very important, as heretics are rampant.
You would know that scientists could have access to these papers, if you bothered to contact the Vatican.


Lie alert.
You have just proven my point. Thanks.

Yes, Buffalo’s article was interesting. Since when was expressing intrigue insulting?

Well, I guess if you couldn’t find anything wrong with it to form a rebuttal against it, and you refused to acknowledge this fact, you would say “interesting”. So, in this way, we can take it to mean that you agree with what the article stated. Yes?

Ive yet to change the original subject. People keep trying to side-line the topic or misrepresent what I said. Sorry for knowing how to keep the line of discussion coherent.

Somehow you got the idea that the debate was about my saying that miracles are able to be proven by science. So let me say this yet again miracles are not scientific. Science is used by the Vatican to examine the allegations of miracles for the purpose of finding out if there are natural causes for said miracle. There. Are you satisfied? You can no longer use me or your percieved argument against my words to dodge other people’s questions.

Ive done no such thing.

It’s good to know that this is not the reason for your dodging worthy questions.
 
Jesus N Cherie, I accept your apology. Your response to my post made me aware of how anti-miracle I sound. I guess I thought of miracles as the secular world would think of it: regeneration of lost limbs, levitation, etc. I agree with you that the transubstantiation of the Eucharist is one of the many miracles occurring every day under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
That was really great of you. Thanks. I really am glad that you are on this thread.
May God bless you and all of your intentions.
 
Maybe. But as you say, they haven’t been published…along with millions of other science or non science facts… or we haven’t been able to come up with an article to reference you to. No one ever implied that there was such an article in one of your science journals. SO WHAT ???
Lets get something straight. For something to be a scientific fact, it **has to be **published in a scientific journal and gain acceptance among other scientists.
You have been saying and giving the impression that the only way you will accept the evidence as credible is if it comes from one of those journals. So what is it about that statement that you are now claiming is unreliable?
Ill only accept academic evidence as objective and/or scientific.
So tell me again why you will refuse to accept something found in the Vatican Library? You have repeated constantly that if it is found in the Vatican Library, it is non objective, or non scientific, or non academic. Make up your mind. Unless you do the research, you have no idea what you will find…but you have pointed out that it is unacceptable to yourself if found by using the Vatican as a mode for finding it. And try to respond to the entire quote, not just call me a liar, strawman or whatever.
It is not about research found in the Vatican, but rather research **produced **by the Vatican. By definition, the Vatican is not a academic, scientific, or objective source to get one’s research from unless it specifically deals with catholic dogma. Nothing else.
What does my owning a computer have to do with this conversation? You keep bringing it up when you obviously have no answer. It would be better all the way around if you said, “I don’t know the answer, so I will say nothing on this matter until I come up with something.”
Youre right, that was meant for the previous quote. It was a retort to research “found” in the Vatican. Nvm.
The Vatican has nothing to hide, nor does it have anything to be afraid of. The papers are available to those who want them…they are just housed outside of your scientific journals.
Shame that with this admission, your points below are automatically false.
The Vatican is not “hiding them” from science. Padre Pio’s stigmata has already been accepted by science to be unexplainable by science as anything that is natural, (which makes it supernatural).
No it hasnt. No scientific research has ever been produced
Therefore, scientists themselves have decided that there is no need to revisit it. If they wanted to, the Vatican wouldn’t have objections…provided that they could be proven to be HONEST in their research, which would not be difficult to prove if they have been. Any one could come and say anything. Honesty is very important, as heretics are rampant.
No it hasnt. No scientific research has ever been produced
You would know that scientists could have access to these papers, if you bothered to contact the Vatican.
The Vatican’s “research” was never done with any academic visibility. If it was, the “science experts” employed by the Vatican would be publishing their works.
You have just proven my point. Thanks.
What, that you lied?
Well, I guess if you couldn’t find anything wrong with it to form a rebuttal against it, and you refused to acknowledge this fact, you would say “interesting”. So, in this way, we can take it to mean that you agree with what the article stated. Yes?
Rebuttle agaisnt what? No arguement was presented. Only a website citing no sources.
Somehow you got the idea that the debate was about my saying that miracles are able to be proven by science.
You said there is scientific evidence and this just above…“Padre Pio’s stigmata has already been accepted by science”.
So let me say this yet again miracles are not scientific. Science is used by the Vatican to examine the allegations of miracles for the purpose of finding out if there are natural causes for said miracle.
There is no evidence that the Vatican used science to determine anything.
There. Are you satisfied? You can no longer use me or your percieved argument against my words to dodge other people’s questions.
Ive dodged nothing. You just dont know what words mean. So please, lets get a definition of what science means according to you.
 
Ill only accept academic evidence as objective and/or scientific.
With this you make your point clear… for me we don’t follow the same line i do not think science can be objective on certain issues concerning the whole truth of this world… If you only accept this then we cannot debate, since by your definition you close yourself out of intellectually honest debate…
 
Uggg sigh

Weather something is considered a miracal or not is not being debated. If miracals are based on ***objective and/or scientific ***evidence is.
words objective and scientific don’t mean the same thing…
" notice you didn’t care to read my earlier post… Because academic sources and science for that matter is about explaining the unexplained, when a miracle occurs it should be unnatural and unexplained by science… you tell me how these two fit together…"
this is me answering your earlier post, care to show me where i brought it up?
Shame I know the definition of fallacies.
o good for you seems you just don’t understand it
Refute what? The Vatican is not the standard for objective evidence. Academia is.:rolleyes:
says a person with no evidence what so ever to support his claims… how do you proof this argument to be true? There is two conclusion on it but no premises… don’t say you did it in the last 23 pages, you didn’t i have read them
 
words objective and scientific don’t mean the same thing…
Good thing I never said they did.
this is me answering your earlier post, care to show me where i brought it up?
A post that had nothing to do with it.
o good for you seems you just don’t understand it
Im not the one re-defining words now am I?
says a person with no evidence what so ever to support his claims… how do you proof this argument to be true? There is two conclusion on it but no premises… don’t say you did it in the last 23 pages, you didn’t i have read them
Support my claims? We’ve been through this. Peer-review process, falsifiability etc etc. Selective memory ftl.

Please do enlighten me as to your (re)definition of objective.:rolleyes:
 
With this you make your point clear… for me we don’t follow the same line i do not think science can be objective on certain issues concerning the whole truth of this world… If you only accept this then we cannot debate, since by your definition you close yourself out of intellectually honest debate…
Please, do define truth as you seem to operating outside the dictionary definition.
 
Support my claims? We’ve been through this. Peer-review process, falsifiability etc etc. Selective memory ftl.

Please do enlighten me as to your (re)definition of objective.:rolleyes:
Objectivity is both an important and very difficult concept to pin down in philosophy. While there is no universally accepted articulation of objectivity, a proposition is generally considered to be objectively true when its truth conditions are “mind-independent”—that is, not the result of any judgments made by a conscious entity. Put another way, objective truths are those which are discovered rather than created. While such formulations capture the basic intuitive idea of objectivity, neither is without controversy.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Objectivity_(philosophy

objective truth seems to be a controversial issue, it seems to be that you defining your self was it Deconstruction-Nietzsche should know this kind of basic philosophy…

by the way you still making a lot of assertions without a single shred of proof, one good one being reading me to have said something i most clearly didn’t, it is a getting a bit tiring can you explain to how your definition of objective is better then mine?

I mean can you actually answer even one little question? I suppose it should not be too hard…

remember this: While there is no universally accepted articulation of objectivity
 
Now i will show you your fallacy:

I said: words objective and scientific don’t mean the same thing..

note i used this to refute this:
Weather something is considered a miracal or not is not being debated. If miracals are based on objective and/or scientific evidence is.

Which you respond:
Good thing I never said they did.
I Said:* you disprove those Vatican sources in something else then your screaming for scientific evidence, in post 299 i refuted your argument against them quite well and i will continue with this evidence:

cut out a small portion

Refute that please*
to which you responded: Refute what? The Vatican is not the standard for objective evidence. Academia is.
And later you said:
Support my claims? We’ve been through this. Peer-review process, falsifiability etc etc. Selective memory ftl.

Please do enlighten me as to your (re)definition of objective.:rolleyes:
Explain to me how this is not a fallacy

When you make scientific not same as objective, but scientific defines objective, objectivity defined in scientific terms…

This is a clear fallacy, you are limiting a word overly and making your own definition out of it…

My definition would be:

objective = world without human interaction

Scientific method studies objective

Faith shows objective

Subjective = Limiting objective

According to this definition your objective is to me subjective

How about your definition of objective?
 
Please, do define truth as you seem to operating outside the dictionary definition.
are you that guy who said deconstruction and Nietzsche together in one term? I was just wondering because your trust in dictionaries is overwhelming especially if you know something about philosophy… maybe that was Ateista who defined him/herself according to those words
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top