Challenged to love Myself

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lady_Love
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But Christ did not despise himself. If we are really going to follow Christ don’t we also need to follow His lead? How can I hate or despise what God loves and values so much that He spent all He had to obtain? I might hate my pride and I might hate my sins but I am not supposed to hate myself. Pride can also manifest in the desire to “be the worst” as much as it can in desiring to “be the best.” Although, St. Francis had a period of his life in which he struggled with self-hatred and beat himself, I guarantee he moved beyond that into knowing how special he was in God’s eyes. I bet he eventually even learned to respect and honor the body that was given him as a gift from God. I’m sure that as St. Francis progressed in being redeemed by God that he gained a respect for himself as a child of God. I wouldn’t beat my child and we are always little children at heart so I don’t want to beat myself either.

And as far as the rich man never finding God, Jesus said, “All things are possible with God.”
I think you overlook some things.

As I said, Christ was perhaps the opposite of a self-lover. He did speak of Himself as somewhat ‘special’ in a few rare instances, but this was merely a result of his need to express his Divinity.

From the gospels, we are told to virtually give up caring for ourselves. Again, that needs to be taken within reason (ie, we need to maintain health and hygiene), but the messages are quite clear; serve rather than be served, humble yourself rather than exalting, live for others as opposed to yourself, do not fear evil or death, do not open your mouth against persecution or resist it, lay down your life for others if given the chance, and so on. Any attempts to love ourselves beyond maintaining good health are simply luxuries which although we are entitled to (it’s not directly sinful to engage in them), shouldn’t exactly be encouraged or demanded. If anything, we are called to “give up everything in the name of Christ”. The Saints and Jesus Himself confirm this in many instances. The lower your opinion is of yourself I’d say the better.

I don’t think there’s any pride involved in wanting to be the best at being the worst. St Francis had the very same urge; if he saw someone poorer than himself, he would give whatever he could to bring himself below them. There’s a double goodness involved in this; charity, and humility. I’m not so sure that he ever progressed into dignifying himself; the modern day Franciscans (an order formed by him) are called to take a vow of complete poverty and humility. St Fancis’ desire to suffer and humble himself went so far that he even made it his greatest desire to become a martyr for the purpose of the faith.

I’m not saying that we all need to live like St Francis; God has an individual plan for different people, be it in money, family, relationships, work etc, but he lived his life as an example for others to follow in any way possible, and this seems to be one of those very ways. We need to be contempt with the way God made us in His image, but there is no call to get fancy haircuts, nice clothes, spray perfume on ourselves, or even fully love ourselves and the lives we live. Repentance is a common theme in the gospels that comes only when someone actually hates themselves and their tendency to sin. Unless you’re certain that you’re never going to commit a sin again, you should look at yourself as a miserable sinner who God has the utmost right to smite to death any time He wants. Adopting such a mindset goes a long way in religious life; it pulls us towards charity and purity and more effectively it relieves fear of suffering or trials (if you don’t enjoy your life to begin with, you’re probably not going to buckle too much at trials and burdens when they come your way). If anything it’s a gift, a “cheat-way-out” card given to us by God if we so choose to take it. This is the very idea behind fasting; if we strip ourselves of luxuries or desires, we train our spirits to become more accustomed to suffering and obedience for Christ’s sake.
 
+JMJ+
Thats strange of a priest to advice a soul to feed it passions and risk it growing larger when the exact opposite is what has always been the ascetic way of christians. Did you question him? How could he suggest that a spiritual wound could be healed by material wealth and vanity? It sounds like this priest either had a specific teaching in mind or was lacking in faith or something like that.
Jesus never came to denounce matter nor its role in the spiritual. In fact, He was Incarnated in matter: He became God-and-man.

Physical means can be used to aid spiritual healing, just as spiritual means can be used to aid physical healing. It never has been a either/or for Christianity. The only ones that I can think of who think like that are dualists and Gnostics.

I noticed that you are not Catholic. I think you will understand my defense of the priest’s advice when you understand the doctrine of Transubstantiation, and how that and the doctrine of Incarnation has formed the psyche of the Catholic world view.
 
+JMJ+
Dear sister in Christ.
I think I may have misunderstood your definition of loving oneself. I see today so many people who use the catch phrases of “accept yourself” and “love yourself for who YOU are” being tossed around to basically justify the part of the self that grows from untamed passions, the Ego. We should love ourselves so much that we realise that we are not ours to spoil but Gods possession who in His supreme goodness endowed in Man free will so that we can choose to return to Him. This is Mans anwer to God, to chose by our own free will to neglect our own cravings in honor of god and for the good of our own souls. We dont need to hate ourselves but we must be very careful when talking about these things because we should never accept any passion as a natural part of ones natural self which forms ones character. If I feel I need to love myself this day and mean by it that I should treat myself with a shopping spree, then this is a wrong self love, yet most of us occassionally fall into this behaviour. This strengtens the falsely built up intellectual notion of “Me” that feeds on self glorification and identification with past events and future plans. An essential part of the Christian journey is to free oneself from this false part of Self. To be crucified so that we can Resurrect a new human.

May God bless you and show us all His way and make us willing to walk it
To “neglect” our cravings? Oh goodness, you really are misunderstanding Catholic thought.
 
I believe it’s impossible to love anyone, whether God, neighbor, or ourselves, too much. Love is simply never wrong. The slightest amount of arrogance/self aggrandizement, OTOH, is too much.

To love is to appreciate God and His creation as we should. It could be said, in fact, that Adam idolized the self rather than loving it. Pride is not the same as self-love; it could be said to be it’s opposite, in fact: self-hate, because pride is to be ashamed of who we really are-created beings-exalting oneself above one’s Creator, rejecting our true identity as given by Him. Love is the offspring of humility-the two go hand in hand- while pride produces something different altogether.
 
+JMJ+

To “neglect” our cravings? Oh goodness, you really are misunderstanding Catholic thought.
then explain. I read mostly orthodox theology but also the life of st Francis and i see no compatability with granting oneself unnecessary material luxury and crucifying ourselves. I speak from own actual experience because I have went through a dissolvment of sorts of the ego. To buy unnecessary stuff for yourself is to feed you passions. We shall fight our passions until there is none of them left. I never heard of a saint pleasing his materialist cravings. This sounds to me like some kind of capitalist christianity, a doctrine invented to keep the people buying stuff and the economy spinning while believing they are becoming righteous.
Do you really think Jesus would behave this way? Jesus would behave exactly like e did back then and take no consideration to new theological thinking or the spirit of the age because the problem of Man remains the same through all times.
Of course we can sanctify our bodies, but not by buying unnecessary stuff while leaving our brother starting in the ditch. Matter i sanctified by overcoming the passions, not ignoring they are there. This can be done and many saints have shown the way.
 
What is far more in line with Catholic teaching is a balance between healthy self-esteem and an accurate self-appraisal of one’s flaws. When we value ourselves too highly we become grandiose, narcissistic, and self-centered. When we fail to respect ourselves we become subject to abuse by ourselves and others, and prone to despondency.

We are beloved children of God, but we, no matter how hard we try, or what graces we avail ourselves of, are sinners, and will die sinners. We are not capable of perfection in this life, although we should always strive for it, and not settle for vague “improvement.” There is always room for improvement.
 
What is far more in line with Catholic teaching is a balance between healthy self-esteem and an accurate self-appraisal of one’s flaws. When we value ourselves too highly we become grandiose, narcissistic, and self-centered. When we fail to respect ourselves we become subject to abuse by ourselves and others, and prone to despondency.

We are beloved children of God, but we, no matter how hard we try, or what graces we avail ourselves of, are sinners, and will die sinners. We are not capable of perfection in this life, although we should always strive for it, and not settle for vague “improvement.” There is always room for improvement.
Not capable of perfection? Why? Its a divine commandment for us to be perfect so we must at least try. We are sinners by our own choices. We choose either the righteous or the evil deeds. Only by choosing the righteous can we achieve union with god and thus heavenly afterlife. I say we should strive to give away everything we dont need to survive because it can surely only be an obstacle to salvation no?
Plz explain, this sounds just like protestantism to me and not the teachings of the jewish and Christian fathers of Old. I reject that we are saved by faith alone.
 
Pride is to view one’s inferiority as an imperfection, to hate oneself and any authentic superiority of another being because of that viewpoint, refusing to acknowledge that superiority as a result. That was the sin of Adam. He chose a lesser good, an inferior being, to be his God: he chose himself for that role. And by raising himself he ended up lowering his standards; we are what we worship, and Adam opted to worship created things rather than God.

Love, as opposed to pride, is to accept oneself and others as they are. Love is humble; it always condescends, always accommodates, is always kind, always ready to sacrifice. Pride is the rejection of love; pride is the supplantation of love with self/selfishness. Pride is to be uncontent with who we really are.
 
Maybe a better way to put it is to say that self-love is good and ordered correctly to the extent that we love God first above all else, including ourselves. Otherwise self-love becomes twisted and corrupted into pride.
 
+JMJ+
To buy unnecessary stuff for yourself is to feed you passions. We shall fight our passions until there is none of them left.
This is what I am talking about. That is not the Christian way, but more of the Stoic way. Yes we are called to mortify ourselves, but NOT to kill the passions, but to put them under the control of reason, that they may glorify God.

Read again St. Francis of Assisi’s life, and you will see that his mortifications never killed his passions, but in fact intensified them. Read his poems, for one.
I never heard of a saint pleasing his materialist cravings. This sounds to me like some kind of capitalist christianity, a doctrine invented to keep the people buying stuff and the economy spinning while believing they are becoming righteous.
In the Habit: A History of Catholicism and Tobacco

Remember that, historically, the best alcoholic beverages and food were made by monastic houses? If materialist cravings were so sinful, then why do you think this was so?
Do you really think Jesus would behave this way?
What was Jesus’ first miracle again?
 
Titus 1:15
To the pure, all things are pure; but to those who are defiled and unbelieving, nothing is pure, but both their mind and their conscience are defiled.
 
+JMJ+

This is what I am talking about. That is not the Christian way, but more of the Stoic way. Yes we are called to mortify ourselves, but NOT to kill the passions, but to put them under the control of reason, that they may glorify God.

Read again St. Francis of Assisi’s life, and you will see that his mortifications never killed his passions, but in fact intensified them. Read his poems, for one.

In the Habit: A History of Catholicism and Tobacco

Remember that, historically, the best alcoholic beverages and food were made by monastic houses? If materialist cravings were so sinful, then why do you think this was so?

What was Jesus’ first miracle again?
Sounds weird to me.
Christ said that if you really wannna follow him we should sell all we own and give it to the poor and take up our cross and follow.

So everything I see arguing for it being OK or good for a christian to please himself my acquisition of material wealth sounds suspect and like relativism to me…

We know that when we fulfill a desire, immediately another one is born. And so it goes on and on until we die…

To be pure is to have no evil deeds, no evil thoughts, no desires whatsoever. That is to not be defiled. I never heard a Saint pleasing himself by fulfilling his evergrowing material desires.

Also, I sometimes wonder why the state of catholic monasticism is like it is? It a dying thing really and both monks and nun seems to have become half hermits and half social workers. The whole purpose of monasticism was to get out of “the world”
 
Firstly:
“You shall love the Lord your God with your whole heart, with your whole soul, with all your mind. This is the greatest and first commandment. The second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself” (Mk. 22:37).
St. Thomas Aquinas explains that inordinate self love is the root cause of every sin:
"Every sinful act proceeds from inordinate desire for some temporal good. Now the fact that anyone desires a temporal good inordinately, is due to the fact that he loves himself inordinately; for to wish some good to someone is to love him. Therefore it is evident that inordinate self love is the cause of every sin" (I II, 77, a.4).
Thomas Aquinas argues that inordinate self-love is akin to the capital vice pride, which he holds as “the beginning of all sin”.

In my understanding, the Catholic mystics warn against inordinate self-love rather than a love of oneself as one is in God, his own Image. If we cannot love our deepest identities in God, then how can we ever love God? We are His Image!

I think that the reason we are getting into this cuffufle is because there are many different definitions of self.

What is the “self”? What do you define as “self”?

There are some people who think that their thoughts, feelings, tastes, desires, personal talents are “themselves”. Others consider their jobs to define them, "I am a postman, “I am a bank clerk”.

This is a constructed identity, my idea of who I am. It is a series of thoughts, images and strategies that we begin to develop in early childhood, in conjuction with others. It is not our true self.

None of this is our true self which existed eternally in the Mind of God as an idea, where he loved us in Himself before he created us.

To reach that true self, we need to deny the other self any independent reality apart from God, in whom we find our real self - not in our passing thoughts, ephemeral desires or self-defined occupations. All those things we rely on to find happiness apart from God in whom is our highest beatitude.

So which “self” do we love? Our self as we are in ourselves or our self as we are in God?

This is our true self in God:
"…** It is important to realize that everyone has five kinds of self**.
The first ‘self’, one has in common with a stone, and this is being. The second one shares with plants, and that is growing. The third self one shares with the animals, and this is sensation. The fourth one shares with all other men, and this is that one possesses a common human nature in which all men are one.
**The fifth - which belongs to a person exclusively as his own - is his personality, one’s individual human self, both with respect to one’s nobility and with respect to accident. Now, what is it that leads a person astray and robs him of happiness?
It is exclusively this last self . Because of it a person turns outward, away from God and toward himself, when he should be re-turning inward, and he fashions for himself his own self according to what is accidental. He thoughtlessly makes himself a ‘self’ of his own. In his ignorance he appropriates to this ‘self’ what is God’s. This is the direction he takes, and he eventually sinks into sinfulness**…
One surrenders oneself in happiness or suffering, in action or inaction in such a way that one loses oneself completely and utterly, withdrawing from oneself irreversibly and becoming one in unity with Christ, so that one always acts at his urging and receives all things and views all things in this unity. And **this detached self becomes the same form as Christ about whom the scripture by Paul says, “I live, no longer I, Christ lives in me”. **This is what I call a rightly valued self…"
***- Blessed Henry Suso (1295-1366), German Catholic mystic & Dominican priest ***
Our four other “selves” simply make up what we are as a person made in the image of God within an immortal soul and human body. To love this is to love our Creator and is the foundation of true love for neighbour.

The evil arises from love of the fifth self, which is a constructed identity in terms of its “accidents”, arising from the Fall and our fractured nature which is cut from God.

It is this last self, with respect to “accidents” rather than “nobility”, that is lost through union with God.
 
See “The Three Ages of the Interior Life” by Lagrange. An excerpt:

christianperfection.info/tta39.php
Without falling into the exaggeration of the first Protestants and the Jansenists, we must say that we are born with a will inclined to egoism, to inordinate self-love. This is called the wound of malice; (4) it often manifests itself by a gross egoism, against which one should guard, an egoism that mingles in all man’s acts. It follows that the will, which has become weak by reason of its lack of docility to God, no longer has absolute power over the sensible faculties, but only a sort of moral power or persuasion to lead them to subject themselves.(5) Doubtless after baptism, which regenerated us by giving us sanctifying grace and charity, this wound, like the others, is in the process of healing; but it also reopens by reason of our personal sins.
The principal defect of the will is the lack of rectitude, called self-love or inordinate love of self, which forgets the love due to God and that which we should have for our neighbor. Self-love or egoism is manifestly the source of all sins.(6) From it are born “the concupiscence of the flesh, the concupiscence of the eyes, and the pride of life.” (7) The sensible appetites, which are no longer firmly led, incline man to thoughtlessness, feverish eagerness, fruitless agitation, selfish search for all that pleases, flight from all that is painful, nonchalance, discouragement, in which he sees that his will has lost its strength, and to all sorts of bad examples. (8)
It is clear that self-will, which is defined as that which is not conformed to the will of God, is the source of every sin. Self-will is extremely dangerous because it can corrupt everything; even what is best in one may become evil when self-will enters in, for it takes itself as its end, instead of subordinating itself to God. If the Lord perceives this will in a fast or a sacrifice, He rejects them because He sees therein a divine work accomplished through pride in order to gain approbation. Now, self-will is born of self-love or egoism; it is strong self-love that has become imperious.
On the subject of self-love or egoism, we may fall into two opposing errors: utilitarianism and quietism. Theoretical or practical utilitarianism does not see an evil in egoism, but a power that should be moderated. This doctrine, which reduces virtue to a business transaction, suppresses all morality; it reduces praiseworthy good to the useful and the delectable. This good, the object of virtue and duty, ought to be loved for itself and more than ourselves, independently of the advantages or the pleasure that may result therefrom: “Do what you ought, come what may.” Practical utilitarianism leads to pride, which inclines a person to make himself the center of all who live about him; it is the manifest or hidden pride of the desire to dominate.
On the other hand, quietism (9) condemned all interested love, even that of our eternal reward, as if there were a disorder in Christian hope, from the fact that it is less perfect than charity.(10) Under the pretext of absolute disinterestedness, many quietists fell into spiritual sloth, which is indifferent to sanctification and salvation.(11)
The thought of salvation and eternal beatitude is evidently very useful that we may strive to put to death inordinate love of self, which is the principal defect of our will. It is of this love that St. Augustine wrote: "Two loves have built two cities: the love of self even to the despising of God, the city of the earth; the love of God even to the despising of self, the city of God. One glorifies itself in self, and the other in the Lord. One seeks its glory from men, the other places its dearest glory in God, the witness of its conscience. The one in the pride of its glory walks with head high; the other says to its God: ‘Thou art my glory, and it is Thou who dost lift up my head.’ The former in its victories lets itself be conquered by its passion to dominate; the latter shows us its citizens united in charity, mutual servants, tutelary governors, obedient subjects. The former loves its own strength in its princes; the latter says to God: ‘Lord, Thou art my only strength, I shall love Thee.’ " (12) One would never weary of quoting St. Augustine.
A great purification and Christian training of the will are necessary to obliterate all inordinate self-love; this result is produced in us by the progress of charity, which “unites man to God so that he lives not for himself, but for God.” (13)
Egoism is like a cancer of the will, which ravages it more and more, whereas sanctifying grace should be in it like a strong root which buries itself ever deeper in the soil in order to draw therefrom nourishing secretions and transform them into fruitful sap. We should think of the value of habitual grace, called the “grace of the virtues and the gifts,” because of various proximate principles of meritorious acts springing from it. We would do well to consider that our will should possess a high degree of the virtues of justice, penance, religion, hope, and charity in order that its powers may be vastly increased.
The author of The Imitation thus describes inordinate self-love when he has Christ say: "My son, thou must give all for all, and be nothing of thy own. Know that the love of thyself is more hurtful to thee than anything of the world. . . . If thy love be pure, simple, and well ordered, thou shalt not be in captivity to anything. Covet not that which thou mayest not have. Seek not to have that which may embarrass thee and deprive thee of thy inward liberty. It is wonderful that thou wilt not, from the very bottom of thy heart, commit thyself wholly to Me, with all things that thou canst desire or have. Why dost thou pine away with vain grief? Why art thou so worn with superfluous cares?(14)
 
Also, I sometimes wonder why the state of catholic monasticism is like it is? It a dying thing really and both monks and nun seems to have become half hermits and half social workers. The whole purpose of monasticism was to get out of “the world”
Jesus lived a life both in the world through action but not of it through ceaseless contemplation in the bosom of His Father.
 
The problem I see, Is that we don’t seem to really know what “Love” is. It is very misleading to call pride “self-love” because pride and love are contrary to each other. If we were to identify self-love with what Corinthians definition of love is we would be saying that to love oneself is to be patient, kind, grateful, humble, forgiving, dignified, generous, trusting, slow to anger, and honest with oneself.

Jesus tells us to love others as we love ourselves but if we do not behave toward ourselves as it says in Corinthians how will our neighbor ever experience love.

Pride is opposite of love. It is competitive, destructive, abusive, jealous, arrogant, dominating, humiliating, stingy, testy, suspicious, controlling, etc. It is when someone seeks to be “better” rather than equal. When someone wants to separate and shine more than others or at others expense. It is when you want to advance only yourself. It is when you want to control and steal God’s position. Control is a huge manifestation of pride, it is playing God.

It is important though, to have compassion on the person suffering with pride. The one who beams with arrogance is really just a person desperate to be loved and valued and they think that they have to be “better” in order to be loved. Being beautiful, popular, successful, wealthy, or “the best,” translates in that person’s mind as “I am now lovable” or if I am one of those things I will finally "be lovable.’ So next time you are around a prideful person you will know what they really need, they need to know they are lovable. Lovable beyond measure because they are a child of God and no other reason is necessary.
 
+JMJ+
Sounds weird to me.
Christ said that if you really wannna follow him we should sell all we own and give it to the poor and take up our cross and follow.

So everything I see arguing for it being OK or good for a christian to please himself my acquisition of material wealth sounds suspect and like relativism to me…
Yes, you can say it is relative…relative to the vocation of an individual. You keep on spouting about monastic life. But there is no Sacrament of Monasticism, but there are the Sacraments of Marriage and Holy Orders. Monasticism is an exception, not the rule. Speculate what will happen if those who are married have to follow the vow of poverty of the religious.
We know that when we fulfill a desire, immediately another one is born. And so it goes on and on until we die…
Shamati, my concern is that why do you keep on spouting non-Christian doctrine and then labeling it Christian? That really sounds like some kind of Eastern religion nonsense.
To be pure is to have no evil deeds, no evil thoughts, no desires whatsoever. That is to not be defiled.
I have no qualms about no evil deeds, no evil thoughts, but no desires?! Puritanism.
I never heard a Saint pleasing himself by fulfilling his evergrowing material desires.
What is it with you with going to one extreme and then going to the other? Saints moderate their material desires, not kill them. If this were so, they would have died from not eating anything or from severe penances. If you read the lives of saints, many of them had their spiritual directors moderating their severe penances.
Also, I sometimes wonder why the state of catholic monasticism is like it is? It a dying thing really and both monks and nun seems to have become half hermits and half social workers. The whole purpose of monasticism was to get out of “the world”
OH MY GOODNESS SHAMATI! You REALLY do not know anything about Catholicism and its history of monasticism.

Watch this: The Catholic Church - Builder of Civilization, Episode 7: The Monks

@Lady Love: I am so sorry for deviating from the thread’s topic, but Shamati’s train of thought is really disturbing me.
 
i struggled with this too but with some deep prayer i prayed that i would love myself more and more and slowly but surely it is happening…

jesus said love your enighbour as you love yourself… so he wants us to love ourselves, and it is fully possible if we accept who we are, dont put on a charade and most of all live how god wants us to live, if we do that we can love that we are his servants and living according to his will, bad choices should be regretted but i have learned to literally acknowledge them repent of them right away and move on, if serious than obviously confession but that is a sacrament i dearly look forward to…

i wish you all the best just acknowledge your god given talents and attributes and be content with who you are… its good that you arent trying to be somoene your not because i have done that before and that is when you are left in the dust

god bless
 
The problem I see, Is that we don’t seem to really know what “Love” is. It is very misleading to call pride “self-love” because pride and love are contrary to each other. If we were to identify self-love with what Corinthians definition of love is we would be saying that to love oneself is to be patient, kind, grateful, humble, forgiving, dignified, generous, trusting, slow to anger, and honest with oneself.

Jesus tells us to love others as we love ourselves but if we do not behave toward ourselves as it says in Corinthians how will our neighbor ever experience love.

Pride is opposite of love. It is competitive, destructive, abusive, jealous, arrogant, dominating, humiliating, stingy, testy, suspicious, controlling, etc. It is when someone seeks to be “better” rather than equal. When someone wants to separate and shine more than others or at others expense. It is when you want to advance only yourself. It is when you want to control and steal God’s position. Control is a huge manifestation of pride, it is playing God.

It is important though, to have compassion on the person suffering with pride. The one who beams with arrogance is really just a person desperate to be loved and valued and they think that they have to be “better” in order to be loved. Being beautiful, popular, successful, wealthy, or “the best,” translates in that person’s mind as “I am now lovable” or if I am one of those things I will finally "be lovable.’ So next time you are around a prideful person you will know what they really need, they need to know they are lovable. Lovable beyond measure because they are a child of God and no other reason is necessary.
. Dear Lady Love, I liked this post of yours so much that I had to come by today and thank you for posting it. So…thank you:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top