Charismatic Congregation

  • Thread starter Thread starter FullOfThought
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

FullOfThought

Guest
I recently attended mass at a Church close to what is going to be my new home once we get married. The church has the best elementary school in the area attached, out of the Catholic schools anyway. I was so excited about joining this church family, now there’s no way I’m going back.

They call themselves a “charismatic congregation”. They were up dancing in the aisles, the priest walked around the church during his homily, they sung happy birthday to multiple people… I am shocked.

I know I can be very black&white when it comes to our faith, but this was like a rainbow! It felt they were entertaining each other as opposed to focusing on why we were there.

Does anyone belong to a charismatic congregation? Or has been to one? Maybe they’re more popular than I realize. When I left the Church I actually checked the sign to make sure in was Catholic!!
 
I went to one in 2000 or 2001. It was interesting. I believe it could be defined as a “pentecostal” service. There was a Christian rock band in the back and the priest, in his vestments, smacking congregants on the forehead to heal them. The congregants would fall to the floor and look like they were having seizures.

They were sweet folks but I never returned. Not my cup of tea! 😉
 
I went to one in 2000 or 2001. It was interesting. I believe it could be defined as a “pentecostal” service. There was a Christian rock band in the back and the priest, in his vestments, smacking congregants on the forehead to heal them. The congregants would fall to the floor and look like they were having seizures.

They were sweet folks but I never returned. Not my cup of tea! 😉
What you are describing sounds like a healing service/mass and many parishes hold these services from time to time, even the more traditional ones.

What the OP is describing is nothing that I’ve ever experienced in the Charismatic Renewal movement in the Catholic Church and I think I’d be contacting the Bishop ASAP.
 
It was a small congregation and advertised as “charismatic Catholic.” I decided to check it out just to see. I was told all services there are like that.
 
Not all charismatic parishes are like that. The one that used to be around in my area would generally have people raising their hands when they pray (and sometimes praying in tongues) and they utilized more praise & worship style music, but they definitely weren’t dancing in the aisles singing happy birthday to everyone.
 
Report to the Bishop. Straight away. Find a different parish and make reperation for the sacrilege that goes on there.
 
We used to belong to a parish that was pretty Charismatic. Singing was energetic and joyful, especially at Easter and really very much so on Pentacost Sunday. It was more solemn during Advent and Lent of course, but still the congregation was very much involved. It was at that church that I went through the Life in the Spirit Seminar. Dancing in the aisles was not common there, but I recall one man that used to get “happy feet”. Somehow, it was not disrespectful. In going to other Masses and or daily Mass when he was there, it was evident that he was a very faith filled man. and full of adoration for Our Lord.

I think it is appropriate for you to find a congregation that better fits your personality/needs. Apparently the participants in that Mass had done so. I notice that some posters have a really difficult time with anything different in terms of expression of faith and become quite critical. I guess I feel pretty critical of people who are unable to tolerate the diversity in our Church and demonstrated by the people within it. Nothing wrong with being joyful folks. I think a lot of our saints were such people Stl Francis and St. John of the Cross for starters.

As long as such expressions are not flippant or insincere, I see nothing wrong with exuberant worship.
 
Report to the Bishop. Straight away. Find a different parish and make reperation for the sacrilege that goes on there.
Or perhaps the OP could talk to the pastor first and find out exactly what type of service he/she went to and why this was happening.

Really, it only takes about 2 or 3 posts in these types of threads before someone shouts “THE BISHOP! THE BISHOP!” Sorry, I’m a big believer of addressing the problem at the source first, before going over someone’s head. I believe we owe our clergy enough respect to ask them FIRST about a problem, before running off to the bishop.

In the workplace, the generally accepted and mature way to handle a problem with a coworker or boss is to sit down and discuss the issue with the person you’re having the problem with. If nothing comes of that, then, yes, if the problem is serious enough, you should go to the next in line of authority. But honestly, running off to the supervisor before you even address the problem with the other person is rude and immature.
 
Times when I have seen this done are following Holy Communion. The spirit was of joy and thanksgiving. Not so bad I think.

Oh, and on the happy birthday business, we often used to sing that one Sunday a month for people having birthdays (that month) and the same with anniversaries. This was done at the time that announcements were done after Communion rite was concluded. It was done throughout our Deanery and possibly the Diocese. It was a way of building a loving community.
 
Or perhaps the OP could talk to the pastor first and find out exactly what type of service he/she went to and why this was happening.

Really, it only takes about 2 or 3 posts in these types of threads before someone shouts “THE BISHOP! THE BISHOP!” Sorry, I’m a big believer of addressing the problem at the source first, before going over someone’s head. I believe we owe our clergy enough respect to ask them FIRST about a problem, before running off to the bishop.
You are naive if you think a chit chat with the priest will solve anything. It doesn’t work with minor abuses 98% of the time, what makes you think it will work at a parish like this which styles itself in such a way purposefully? The priest obviously encourages it, and if not, he has set a president which would mean that the congregation demand it. Either way you look at it, the Bishop needs to get involved and it matters not what you think should happen. It is the OP’s duty to report it to the succesor of the Apostles, since the Mass is sacrilegous in its irreverence and disloyalty to the rubrics and to Catholic worship.

If you feel the need, drop a CC to the Parish priest in your email to the Bishop letting him know you have contacted the Bishop. That’s probably good common courtesy.
In the workplace, the generally accepted and mature way to handle a problem with a coworker or boss is to sit down and discuss the issue with the person you’re having the problem with. If nothing comes of that, then, yes, if the problem is serious enough, you should go to the next in line of authority. But honestly, running off to the supervisor before you even address the problem with the other person is rude and immature.
Ok, well, salvation =/= the workplace but lets run with this. If your manager/boss was completley destroying the company by their novelties and doing things expressly forbidden by the company… do you have a nice chit chat with him or do you realize the problem at hand and either quit or go to the higher ups straight away? Hmmm.
 
You are naive if you think a chit chat with the priest will solve anything. It doesn’t work with minor abuses 98% of the time, what makes you think it will work at a parish like this which styles itself in such a way purposefully? The priest obviously encourages it, and if not, he has set a president which would mean that the congregation demand it. Either way you look at it, the Bishop needs to get involved and it matters not what you think should happen. It is the OP’s duty to report it to the succesor of the Apostles, since the Mass is sacrilegous in its irreverence and disloyalty to the rubrics and to Catholic worship.

If you feel the need, drop a CC to the Parish priest in your email to the Bishop letting him know you have contacted the Bishop. That’s probably good common courtesy.

Ok, well, salvation =/= the workplace but lets run with this. If your manager/boss was completley destroying the company by their novelties and doing things expressly forbidden by the company… do you have a nice chit chat with him or do you realize the problem at hand and either quit or go to the higher ups straight away? Hmmm.
You’re entitled to your opinion, I’m entitled to mine, which is that I still think it’s rude and immature to not speak to the priest first. Really, even if you’re convinced it won’t help anything, it also won’t hurt anything to swing by and have that chat with him before you fire off that email to the bishop.

Goodbye.
 
You are naive if you think a chit chat with the priest will solve anything. It doesn’t work with minor abuses 98% of the time, what makes you think it will work at a parish like this which styles itself in such a way purposefully? The priest obviously encourages it, and if not, he has set a president which would mean that the congregation demand it. Either way you look at it, the Bishop needs to get involved and it matters not what you think should happen. It is the OP’s duty to report it to the succesor of the Apostles, since the Mass is sacrilegous in its irreverence and disloyalty to the rubrics and to Catholic worship.

If you feel the need, drop a CC to the Parish priest in your email to the Bishop letting him know you have contacted the Bishop. That’s probably good common courtesy.

Ok, well, salvation =/= the workplace but lets run with this. If your manager/boss was completley destroying the company by their novelties and doing things expressly forbidden by the company… do you have a nice chit chat with him or do you realize the problem at hand and either quit or go to the higher ups straight away? Hmmm.
In most all cases, though, the first question the bishop (or more likely, someone from the diocesan Office of Worship to whom the issue is passed on to) will ask is “What did the priest say when you talked to him about this problem?” If we haven’t taken that step, it will likely just get kicked back. Even if we’re certain we know what the priest’s response is going to be, we still have to take that step if we want to make any headway.

The Church very much subscribes to the principle of subsidiarity in church governance: that which can be resolved at the lowest level should be resolved at the lowest level.
 
We used to belong to a parish that was pretty Charismatic. Singing was energetic and joyful, especially at Easter and really very much so on Pentacost Sunday. It was more solemn during Advent and Lent of course, but still the congregation was very much involved. It was at that church that I went through the Life in the Spirit Seminar. Dancing in the aisles was not common there, but I recall one man that used to get “happy feet”. Somehow, it was not disrespectful. In going to other Masses and or daily Mass when he was there, it was evident that he was a very faith filled man. and full of adoration for Our Lord.

I think it is appropriate for you to find a congregation that better fits your personality/needs. Apparently the participants in that Mass had done so. I notice that some posters have a really difficult time with anything different in terms of expression of faith and become quite critical. I guess I feel pretty critical of people who are unable to tolerate the diversity in our Church and demonstrated by the people within it. Nothing wrong with being joyful folks. I think a lot of our saints were such people Stl Francis and St. John of the Cross for starters.

As long as such expressions are not flippant or insincere, I see nothing wrong with exuberant worship.
“Exuberant worship” can easily cross the line into being irreverant. There’s nothing wrong with being joyful, but dancing in the aisles and singing Happy Birthday during Mass is inappropriate, in my opinion. The focus of the Mass is not on us as individuals, or about “feeling happy”. Mass is not a Broadway show. I’ve been to Masses like this before (though it doesn’t sound like they were quite as showy as this) and I do prefer to attend a Mass at a church where quiet, respectful worship is the culture.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top