Charles Dicken's "A Christmas Carol" and Catholic theology

  • Thread starter Thread starter ag11
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

ag11

Guest
I like the story “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dicken’s. I have the following 3 questions:
  1. Is it ok for a Catholic to enjoy this story?
  2. We do not believe in a ghost of Christmas past, present or future… So therefore is this story OK for us Catholics?
  3. Also, are the ghosts of Christmas past, present or future somehow making this novel into a “science fiction” work?
Thanks
 
NB: there is no apostrophe in Charles Dickens.

Saving Souls by Being Merry This Christmas
Chris Hazell:
The story overwhelmingly hammers the need to love and care for others, which is perhaps explicitly conveyed in Jacob Marley’s famous, chilling exhortation to his partner, Scrooge: “Mankind was my business; charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence, were, all, my business.” And yes, there can be no doubt that these are key responsibilities for us as Christians in this life. Still, there is the subtle call in the story for not only the fulfillment of obligation, but also an exuding of joy—of keeping Christmas well, all year round.

Scrooge not only becomes a man of God, doing good and sharing his wealth with those in need, but he is overwhelmed with the joy that follows when living within the Kingdom of Heaven. Scrooge realizes that being a Christian doesn’t merely entail responding well to life out of obligation, but rather, receiving the joyous gift of friendship with God. We love God, yes, because it’s right and just, but also because there is a tremendous happiness and joy in loving God for his own sake. If we live this out—and truly believe it—then others will see this anchored joy within us. And if they do, by the grace of God, we can melt hardened hearts this Christmas season, and every season.
 
I’ve always found it a beautiful story. I find the term ‘scrooge’ so ridiculous. Scrooge found redemption through love for others. What a beautiful thing to be a Scrooge! It means redemption and love. 🙂
 
  1. Is it ok for a Catholic to enjoy this story?
Absolutely. There is nothing in this story contrary to the faith. Its a fine morality tale.
  1. We do not believe in a ghost of Christmas past, present or future… So therefore is this story OK for us Catholics?
It means its a work of fiction. That doesn’t mean there is anything wrong with it.
  1. Also, are the ghosts of Christmas past, present or future somehow making this novel into a “science fiction” work?
Technically, more like fantasy. And there is nothing wrong with either science fiction or fantasy. Its harmless fiction.
 
I like the story “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dicken’s. I have the following 3 questions:
  1. Is it ok for a Catholic to enjoy this story?
  2. We do not believe in a ghost of Christmas past, present or future… So therefore is this story OK for us Catholics?
  3. Also, are the ghosts of Christmas past, present or future somehow making this novel into a “science fiction” work?
Thanks
1 and 2). Absolutely. There is nothing objectionable about “ghost stories” in the Church, which has never even denied the existence of ghosts.

3). No, not science fiction, as ghosts are neither scientific nor technological, but rather supernatural fantasy.

ICXC NIKA.
 
I love Christmas stories with a ghostly feel. Halloween isn’t the only holiday that is associated with ghosts. Ghostly Christmas stories with a moral truth behind it has that special quality.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top