Chewing gum and communion; appropriate action???

  • Thread starter Thread starter k5thbeatle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Proof of either? I certainly would never chew gum with sugar in it, but what you suggest sounds incorrect.
It seems self-evident to me that if you put something dry into your mouth and then it gets wet, it got the moisture from out of your mouth, and probably isn’t putting any moisture back in.

On the topic of gum being hard on the teeth, this pretty much sums it up:
If your chewing gum contains sugar, you’re essentially “bathing” your teeth in sugar while you chew away. This can contribute to tooth decay. Even if you chew sugar-free gum, there are still risks to your teeth because sugar-free gum often contains acidic flavorings and preservatives that may in fact lead to dental erosion,4 even if it contains cavity-fighting xylitol. Unlike cavities, dental erosion is a process of incremental decalcification, which, over time, literally dissolves your teeth.
 
LOL! Unlikely that anyone will carry a bottle of water into church or into the pew! Let me know if you do!
I know of many people who bring a bottle of water into Mass. Water is permitted before Communion. As far as what is the appropriate action of the EMHC, this needs to be addressed by the Pastor.
 
Taking a long pull of water a while after receiving communion is actually a sign of reverence.
Wow, the nuns must have forgotten to teach us that sign of reverence.

Perhaps you can explain for us how drinking a long pull of water a while after receiving communion is actually a sign of reverence.
 
I always chew gum at Mass. No matter how well I am hydrated, chewing gum makes me sing much better due to mouth moisture.
How do you possibly sing with gum in your mouth? I just! I can’t imagine! I think my voice teacher would give a hundred reasons how having anything in your mouth will negatively impact your voice placement and vowel shape.

Or are you constantly taking it out to sing?!
 
LOL! Unlikely that anyone will carry a bottle of water into church or into the pew! Let me know if you do!
Many times…especially the choir!
I’ve seen people chew gum on the communion line, but didn’t see if they received with the gum under their tongue or removed it just before.
 
Wow, the nuns must have forgotten to teach us that sign of reverence.

Perhaps you can explain for us how drinking a long pull of water a while after receiving communion is actually a sign of reverence.
Not sure if this is what the PP means, but my mother always told us to take to a sip of water when we got home from Mass, before we ate or drank anything else, to make sure that all particles of the host had been “washed down”, so to speak, and not still be lingering in the mouth when we ate or drank anything else.
 
Maybe so, but I still was not taught to do that. I gave never heard of that before.
 
If as an EME or even say as a priest you notice someone coming up for communion chewing gum what is the appropriate thing to do?

Do you say or do anything?
What would Sister do, way back in Catholic school…? Oh yes: If you were caught chewing gum in school, you would be made to wear it on your nose.

:cool: Yeah, sounds like that would work.

:rotfl:

tee
 
LOL! Unlikely that anyone will carry a bottle of water into church or into the pew! Let me know if you do!
lt’s not everyone who brings a bottle of water but it’s common enough as to not raise any eyebrows.
 
There is no prohibition against chewing gum in church. Hopefully one does it discreetly of course.
Boy, there sure was when I was a kid! I think I still have dents in my skull from Sister Mary Louise’s knuckles. 😃
 
Wouldn’t chewing gum break the fast? Unless it’s medically necessary.
 
What would Sister do, way back in Catholic school…? Oh yes: If you were caught chewing gum in school, you would be made to wear it on your nose.
A nun tried to convince us that chewing gum is made from dead horses.
lt’s not everyone who brings a bottle of water but it’s common enough as to not raise any eyebrows.
Same here, and i’m one of them, taking just sips so the Host can be swallowed. i told someone that it was metho, and he wanted to take a whiff. 😃
 
There is no prohibition against chewing gum in church. Hopefully one does it discreetly of course.
Is it no longer considered rude to chew gum in any but the most casual of circumstances? I would think our behavior at Mass should be at at least as high a level as, say, going to a job interview.
 
Water and medications are permitted. Gum is neither water nor medication.

Nor is it something that would get into your mouth by accident, such as a bug, or post-nasal drip.
That has to do with consumption. Someone who starts chewing a stick(s) of gum for say an hour (that’s roughly my average starting time) before Mass isn’t consuming anything if they continue to chew the gum throughout the Mass.
 
Is it no longer considered rude to chew gum in any but the most casual of circumstances? I would think our behavior at Mass should be at at least as high a level as, say, going to a job interview.
First, I don’t “chomp” away. Second just who defines the chewing of gum in public as being rude? The same folks who make a litany of excuses for the rude behavior many of us are exposed to at Mass?
 
Wouldn’t chewing gum break the fast? Unless it’s medically necessary.
Nope. Not as long as one began chewing the gum early enough to wring out all the essence, leaving essentially a piece of inert paraffin.
 
It seems self-evident to me that if you put something dry into your mouth and then it gets wet, it got the moisture from out of your mouth, and probably isn’t putting any moisture back in.
So you have no proof?
On the topic of gum being hard on the teeth, this pretty much sums it up:
I believe I said “sugarless” gum. The reason I asked you is that for many, chewing sugarless gum is actually a very positive thing from an oral health point of view. Many dentists recommend if. Chewing gum stimulates saliva production and flow which is very positive for tooth and gum health, particularly if one is not able to brush after a meal. It also “exercises” one’s gums.

Your original comment was not accurate.
 
How do you possibly sing with gum in your mouth? I just! I can’t imagine! I think my voice teacher would give a hundred reasons how having anything in your mouth will negatively impact your voice placement and vowel shape.

Or are you constantly taking it out to sing?!
Very easily and very well.
 
If you have gum in your mouth at Mass, don’t give it to your dog if he is with you because there are things in gum that can make a dog sick.

My mother used to give our dog her chewing gum when I was a kid, and it was funny watching her chew it. Back then, I think the ingredients weren’t like they use now.

So there are three no-nos: don’t chew gum in church, don’t give it to your dog, and don’t take your dog to church unless he is a therapy dog.

Somebody brought his little dog to church once, and the usher asked him to leave. (The meanie!)
Nothing wrong with chewing gum during Mass. “Therapy dogs” (which typically means someone bought their little fido a vest on eBay) should be left home. SERVICE DOGS are however welcome at Mass.
 
Not sure if this is what the PP means, but my mother always told us to take to a sip of water when we got home from Mass, before we ate or drank anything else, to make sure that all particles of the host had been “washed down”, so to speak, and not still be lingering in the mouth when we ate or drank anything else.
Precisely.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top