Child playing with communion host

  • Thread starter Thread starter missyfatcat
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We had the Latin mass until I was 8 yrs. old. I knew that the Eucharist was really and truly the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ because my dad told me when I was about six yrs.old that when the bell rings and the priest holds up the host and then the chalice the bread and wine are really and truly changing into the body and blood of Jesus
There is a difference in just hearing the words and repeating parrot fashion that the Eucharist is physically the body of Christ, and understanding it. When I was six, the idea of a deity was pretty much in the same realm of Santa Claus.
Transubstantiation must be one of the most misunderstood concepts. To appreciate it, you would have to consider everything from Jesus’ physical form ascending into a spiritual plain, the very existence of a deity, a tripartite deity and elements of physics, such as the composition of matter.

I do not know many six year olds so well versed in theology and physics.

I know many people where I live do not understand it. Most believe it is symbolic. I still have trouble understanding it.
 
The people who think it is symbolic need to read John 6. It is hard to understand for all of us because it is a mystery of our faith. We don’t need to know the physics to appreciate Jesus’ present in the Eucharist. We just need faith! The faith to trust like a little child.
 
The people who think it is symbolic need to read John 6
Thanks for that. I have just read your post where you quoted it. I often wondered where the doctrine came from, so you’ve answered that for me.

I don’t want to bring this thread too far off topic. However, it doesn’t specifically mention in John 6 that a priest actually does this miracle in Mass. The chapter does not specify how the bread of life is going to come down from Heaven. It does not mention anything about Transubstantiation.
 
The people who think it is symbolic need to read John 6. It is hard to understand for all of us because it is a mystery of our faith. We don’t need to know the physics to appreciate Jesus’ present in the Eucharist. We just need faith! The faith to trust like a little child.
True, but then communion would have to be a delusion. You cant buy somebodies flesh and blood from a grocery store. To many people, its symbolic but that does not make it any less important.
 
Thanks for that. I have just read your post where you quoted it. I often wondered where the doctrine came from, so you’ve answered that for me.

I don’t want to bring this thread too far off topic. However, it doesn’t specifically mention in John 6 that a priest actually does this miracle in Mass. The chapter does not specify how the bread of life is going to come down from Heaven. It does not mention anything about Transubstantiation.
Research apostolic succession in the bible.

Why does everything we believe have to be in the bible? The bible doesn’t say the word trinity either. You may want to do some research on scripture and Tradition.
 
True, but then communion would have to be a delusion. You cant buy somebodies flesh and blood from a grocery store. To many people, its symbolic but that does not make it any less important.
Why would it have to be a delusion and why would I want to buy someone’s flesh and blood from a grocery store?

You’ve also gone off the rails with your second comment. The entire focus of the Catholic mass is the Eucharist, the entire focus of a protestant service is scripture. Sure, several times a year they consume grape juice and bread, but it is definitely less important than Communion in the Catholic Church. If Jesus commanded us to “do this in memory of” Him, why only do it several times a year? Seems almost like an afterthought.
 
There is a difference in just hearing the words and repeating parrot fashion that the Eucharist is physically the body of Christ, and understanding it. When I was six, the idea of a deity was pretty much in the same realm of Santa Claus.
Transubstantiation must be one of the most misunderstood concepts. To appreciate it, you would have to consider everything from Jesus’ physical form ascending into a spiritual plain, the very existence of a deity, a tripartite deity and elements of physics, such as the composition of matter.

I do not know many six year olds so well versed in theology and physics.

I know many people where I live do not understand it. Most believe it is symbolic. I still have trouble understanding it.
There is also a big difference in believing and understanding. Apparently many of those highly educated theologians understand Transubstantiation but do not believe. I believed that I was really receiving Jesus when I received my first communion at 7, even though I did not understand how it happened and could not explain it beyond, it is Jesus. 🤷
 
Why would it have to be a delusion and why would I want to buy someone’s flesh and blood from a grocery store?

You’ve also gone off the rails with your second comment. The entire focus of the Catholic mass is the Eucharist, the entire focus of a protestant service is scripture. Sure, several times a year they consume grape juice and bread, but it is definitely less important than Communion in the Catholic Church. If Jesus commanded us to “do this in memory of” Him, why only do it several times a year? Seems almost like an afterthought.
The person I was responding to said that we should use faith to literally convince ourselves we are eating christs flesh and drinking his blood, which would mean you’d have to be in a delusion to think that. I said that because you cannot buy flesh and blood at a grocery store, so knowing that it is in rememberance and a symbol of it does not make it any less important. 😉
 
The person I was responding to said that we should use faith to literally convince ourselves we are eating christs flesh and drinking his blood, which would mean you’d have to be in a delusion to think that. I said that because you cannot buy flesh and blood at a grocery store, so knowing that it is in rememberance and a symbol of it does not make it any less important. 😉
We believe we are eating His flesh and drinking His blood because the bible explicitly says we are. Why do you believe the bible? Oh yeah, because of faith. If you equate faith with delusion then you aren’t a follower of Christ. If you read scripture, many people left our Lord despite SEEING miracles- they didn’t need faith! They witnessed the dead rise, the lame walk, the blind see (insert miracle here). Faith is a gift from God, not a delusion. Contrary to what you believe, thinking that “the Lord’s supper” is symbolic of His flesh and blood is galaxies away from believing the bread and wine truly become His body, blood, soul and divinity. If the Catholic Church is correct, the protestant “Lord’s supper” is a meaningless, unbiblical tradition of men that could potentially lead to their eternal separation from Him. If protestants are correct, Catholics are worshiping a wafer (the “death cookie” as Jack Chic calls it) and are in very serious danger of eternal separation from Him.
 
We believe we are eating His flesh and drinking His blood because the bible explicitly says we are. Why do you believe the bible? Oh yeah, because of faith. If you equate faith with delusion then you aren’t a follower of Christ. If you read scripture, many people left our Lord despite SEEING miracles- they didn’t need faith! They witnessed the dead rise, the lame walk, the blind see (insert miracle here). Faith is a gift from God, not a delusion. Contrary to what you believe, thinking that “the Lord’s supper” is symbolic of His flesh and blood is galaxies away from believing the bread and wine truly become His body, blood, soul and divinity. If the Catholic Church is correct, the protestant “Lord’s supper” is a meaningless, unbiblical tradition of men that could potentially lead to their eternal separation from Him. If protestants are correct, Catholics are worshiping a wafer (the “death cookie” as Jack Chic calls it) and are in very serious danger of eternal separation from Him.
I’m sorry but you don’t understand what I’m saying. Also too, I’ve never heard a protestant saying that catholics worship a wafer?
Where did you get that from?
 
I’m sorry but you don’t understand what I’m saying. Also too, I’ve never heard a protestant saying that catholics worship a wafer?
Where did you get that from?
I understand exactly what you are saying.

I have been told by protestants (albeit only a few) that I worship a piece of bread and that I am an idolater. Most importantly, however, I realize that if the Catholic Church is wrong then I really am WORSHIPING a piece of bread instead of my creator. If that is the case I’m in deep trouble because I am an idolater and a fool.
 
Your husband did right, and not to make a fuss in mass. Certainly talk about he Eucharist at home and educated him on the real presence if he did not already know that. I am sure for kids some confusion come in if at one mass you can recieve in the hand and the other can not. He is 12 he can understand that.

I personally would not give up the Latin Mass. Your son is getting education of both types of mass. If you give up the Latin mass now, he would probably never choose it later. Maybe a little lesson on the translation in the missel so he can follow along would be good. It is natural for any 12 year old not to pay attention all the time in mass, just keep plugging away with the teaching, you will all be blessed!
 
We believe we are eating His flesh and drinking His blood because the bible explicitly says we are.
No it doesn’t. The bible doesn’t mention Transubstantiation.

You also posted this:
Research apostolic succession in the bible.
Why does everything we believe have to be in the bible? The bible doesn’t say the word trinity either. You may want to do some research on scripture and Tradition.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostolic_succession
The more I read, the more I realise how much I disagree with Catholic doctrine.
 
I can’t say one way or the other on how to discipline a child in that sort of situation because I don’t know what they teach children concerning the Eucharist, so it’s hard to say if ‘he should have known better.’ I do know however that if it had been me when I was 12 and my mother- be it God or be it bread- would have slapped the ever love’n taste out of my mouth simply because it was food. Or in this case, was in the appearance of food.
 
True, but then communion would have to be a delusion. You cant buy somebodies flesh and blood from a grocery store. To many people, its symbolic but that does not make it any less important.
Did you read John 6? Read the whole chapter.
 
Thanks for that. I have just read your post where you quoted it. I often wondered where the doctrine came from, so you’ve answered that for me.

I don’t want to bring this thread too far off topic. However, it doesn’t specifically mention in John 6 that a priest actually does this miracle in Mass. The chapter does not specify how the bread of life is going to come down from Heaven. It does not mention anything about Transubstantiation.
Jesus does this at his last supper with the apostles before he is crucified. This is the first mass. He said the exact words that the priest at a Catholic mass says when changing the bread and wine into His Body and Blood. Transubstantiation was the word that theologians chose to best describe the change that is really happening at the mass. Jesus just did not give it a name. But He did it.
 
No it doesn’t. The bible doesn’t mention Transubstantiation.
It doesn’t mention the Trinity either, guess you can’t be Christian? I’m going to need you to tell me where it says in the bible that everything we believe is contained in the bible. While you’re at it, please help me understand what Christians did for the several hundred years before the One, Holy, Apostolic, Catholic Church determined which books would be included in what we now call the Bible, unless of course you can show me where the bible says which books it is supposed to contain. The book didn’t just appear, someone had to have been given the AUTHORITY to lead the Church Militant. The Apostles passed on the authority that Christ gave them.
You also posted this:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostolic_succession
The more I read, the more I realise how much I disagree with Catholic doctrine.
Guess you better reconcile your beliefs?

Scripture Catholic

Bible Christian Society MP3s

Biblical Apologetics MP3s
 
I understand exactly what you are saying.

I have been told by protestants (albeit only a few) that I worship a piece of bread and that I am an idolater. Most importantly, however, I realize that if the Catholic Church is wrong then I really am WORSHIPING a piece of bread instead of my creator. If that is the case I’m in deep trouble because I am an idolater and a fool.
Well those protestants don’t understand what you’re doing. Communion is a big deal, but it does not mean that you’re worshiping the wafer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top