Children as Eucharistic Ministers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter onetruechurch
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For it is innocence which is full and experience which is empty.
It is innocence which wins and experience which loses.

It is innocence which is young and experience which is old.
It is innocence which grows and experience which shrinks.
It is innocence which is born and experience which dies.
It is innocence which knows and experience which does not know.

It is the child who is full and the man who is empty.
Empty like an empty pumpkin and like an empty barrel.

There, God says, that is what I think of your experience.

From The Mystery of the Holy Innocents by Charles Péguy
cin.org/liter/holyinno1.html
 
To Children Extraordinary Ministers of the Eucharist
[/quote]

The title is “Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion”. Why don’t we take a look at the word “Extraordinary”?

ex·traor·di·nar·y adj

  1. *]Beyond what is ordinary or usual: extraordinary authority.
    *]Highly exceptional; remarkable: an extraordinary achievement.
    *]Employed or used for a special service, function, or occasion: a minister extraordinary; an extraordinary professor.

    What sort of situation is so beyond the normal that a child is needed to distribute Holy Communion? the ‘office’ EMHC was not instituted as a teaching tool or to get the laity more ‘involved’ in the Mass! They are to be properly trained (which includes fully understanding what they are doing) and used in “extra-ordinary” circumstances.

    Personally I’d like to see EMHCs done away with completely. More often than not they are misused. An “inconvenience” (e.g. taking ‘too long’ to distribute Communion) is not an “extraordinary” situation.

    Pray for the Church.
 
I with the above poster I had the most horrid experince last week. At the 5pm vigil mass we had a female EM start coughing in her hand and rubbing her nose while she was holding and giving out the holy sacrement. This continued for 5 or 6 people until she stopped coughing. She could have atleast not picked up another Host!
 
40.png
wannabee:
Umm - she’s not old enough to get married.

She’s not old enough to vote

She’s not old enough to drink

She’s not old enough to drive a car

BUT she can administer Communion

Lord ,Jesus Christ , Son of God , have mercy on us
hmmmm and these make for extraordinary qualities? :rolleyes:
 
40.png
A.Pelliccio:
I with the above poster I had the most horrid experince last week. At the 5pm vigil mass we had a female EM start coughing in her hand and rubbing her nose while she was holding and giving out the holy sacrement. This continued for 5 or 6 people until she stopped coughing. She could have atleast not picked up another Host!
This isn’t the theme of the thread.
 
who says that EMHCs are extraordinary people - they are supposed to be ordinary folk who help the Priests because of EXTRAORDINARY need.

I re-iterate - administering Communion should not be the task of a layperson and certainly not a child who is not legally considered an adult.

BTW - I am not a fanatic . I was an EMHC for 13 years . I resigned because I did not agree that we were necessary - other folk are still serving and that is up to them.

Like others here I would be most uncomfortable Receiving from a 10yr old child . Oh and BTW - what happens when she has to reverently consume what remains in her Chalice after Communion ?
 
Like others here I would be most uncomfortable Receiving from a 10yr old child . Oh and BTW - what happens when she has to reverently consume what remains in her Chalice after Communion ?
The same thing any EMHC would do… Though she can’t drive, so it would be safer 😛

And I would to like to see no EMHC needed, but in my diocese, Mass attendance is about 1,600 per Mass… So… While the time may just be an inconvience, it is an EXTREMELY large inconvience… Especially with only 1 Priest…
Pray for our Priests! 👍
 
40.png
CatholicCid:
The same thing any EMHC would do… Though she can’t drive, so it would be safer 😛

OH BOY - wait for Social Services to descend - try explaining to them that she is Consuming the Most Precious Blood of Christ - not alcohol .
 
40.png
wannabee:
Oh and BTW - what happens when she has to reverently consume what remains in her Chalice after Communion ?
This question is very peculiar? What are you possibly thinking?
 
40.png
wannabee:
I re-iterate - administering Communion should not be the task of a layperson and certainly not a child who is not legally considered an adult.
Take your time and read this and show me where administering Holy Communion cannot be the task of a layperson. Show me where it states an age limit.
Chapter VII - Extraordinary Functions of the Lay Faithful

from
Redemptionis Sacramentum
On certain matters to be observed or to be avoided
regarding the Most Holy Eucharist
March 25, 2004

Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments
 
40.png
wannabee:
40.png
CatholicCid:
The same thing any EMHC would do… Though she can’t drive, so it would be safer 😛

OH BOY - wait for Social Services to descend - try explaining to them that she is Consuming the Most Precious Blood of Christ - not alcohol .
I see you are having peculiar thoughts. In all cases an older Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion is present and will consume the Blood of Christ. Very simple.
 
DO YOU MEAN THAT YOU CONSIDER YOUR CHILD , AGE 10, WAS THE EQUAL OF CHRIST WHO TAUGHT IN THE TEMPLE ???
Your going a little overboard there… No offence, but I think a child of age 10 would be a little more mature then the maturity you are showing now…
 
**The Way of the Lamb
**The Spirit of Childhood and the End of the Age

**By John Saward **

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

In the pre-Christian world, children were slain on pagan altars, and now, in the post-Christian world of the affluent West, children are again the object of adult hostility. In the U.S.A. the abuse of children has been called a “national emergency”, while in almost every country on earth the killing of children still unborn has become an ideology of “choice”.

In this challenging book, John Saward examines the work of several Roman Catholic writers, including St. Thérèse of Lisieux, G. K. Chesterton, Charles Peguy, Georges Bernanos and Hans Urs von Balthasar who rose up in defense and celebration of childhood. This is a ground-breaking work in the theology of childhood and the analysis of modernity.

T & T Clark ordering information for UK and worldwide residents (except USA & Canada) ISBN 0 567 08677 1, paperback 192pp

Residents in USA and Canada: orders to Ignatius Press: Published by Ignatius Press, San Francisco.

REVIEWS

“The clarity of Saward’s style, the bounty of his sources, and the profundity of his topic—the sacredness of human life, especially the life of the child—make The Way of the Lamb a tour de force of insight and perspicacity necessary for us all. I highly recommend it.”
—John Cardinal O’Connor, Archbishop of New York

“One of the most original and insightful books of recent years. A singular beauty and intellectual passion describes the elegance of spiritual childhood and the terrible darkness of a world at war against children. Saward’s account of St. Therese of Lisieux is superior to anything written about that new Doctor.”
—Fr. George William Rutler, Author, Crisis of Saints

‘John Saward has written what almost amounts to a manifesto for spritual survival in our time, painting a compelling picture of the crisis of our age.’
Leonie Caldecott, The Catholic Herald

‘John Saward is an unsung hero of contemporary English Catholicism. The beautifully crafted essays on writers of the late-nineteenth and twentieth centuries which make up the substance of this book can and should be read as contributions to scholarly literature. But by means of them John Saward is asking from his readers a deeper and more effective recognition of the everlasting youthfulness of God, Christ, Our Lady and the Church. In an often tired and jaded Western Christendom, it is a plea that will reward heeding.’
Aidan Nichols, Blackfriars, Cambridge, The Tablet

'John Saward writes books of a kind no other British theologian does. What makes him distinctive is the unembarrassed retrieval of certain highly-charged spiritual writers and themes, combined with a firm dogmatic underpinning. This is a doctrinally secure, exuberant Catholicism that proposes to change lives and be counter-cultural.
Robert Ombres OP, New Blackfriars
 
If they are mature, confirmed and trained, fine. They know not to dress like pagan temple prostitutes, good grooming, etc. Personally, though, there seem to be enough from the adult ranks to fill this need. There are already too many of them.

Holy Thursday, I went to another parish for Mass, as I had to drive my husband to a class in another town. The parish used heavy crystal goblets to distribute the Precious Blood. They looked as if they could easily break. Much more disturbing was the fact that one Eucharistic Minister was about 16; dressed sloppily, unwashed hair, baggy pants hanging to show his underwear, shirt untucked; holding this heavy goblet cavalierly by the stem loosely, as if he was at a cocktail party. I wanted to snag the Blood out of his fingers, set it down, then drag the boy off to the restroom for a scrub, a tuck-in, belt adjustment and combing!!!
 
40.png
OutinChgoburbs:
If they are mature, confirmed and trained, fine. They know not to dress like pagan temple prostitutes, good grooming, etc. Personally, though, there seem to be enough from the adult ranks to fill this need. There are already too many of them.

Holy Thursday, I went to another parish for Mass, as I had to drive my husband to a class in another town. The parish used heavy crystal goblets to distribute the Precious Blood. They looked as if they could easily break. Much more disturbing was the fact that one Eucharistic Minister was about 16; dressed sloppily, unwashed hair, baggy pants hanging to show his underwear, shirt untucked; holding this heavy goblet cavalierly by the stem loosely, as if he was at a cocktail party. I wanted to snag the Blood out of his fingers, set it down, then drag the boy off to the restroom for a scrub, a tuck-in, belt adjustment and combing!!!
This is to bad…When my son became a EME (@ 16) he always dressed in a suit and tie and he was well trained…😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top