Christ Conspiracy - Gospels - Truth - Myth

  • Thread starter Thread starter AskSeekKnock24
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AskSeekKnock24

Guest
Hello all,

I have been ardently making my way back to faith in Jesus Christ during the past few months. Along my journey I have been praying constantly for Our Lord to guide me and help lead me to him, and overall I feel as things are heading in the right direction 🙂

However I have been encountering roadblocks here and there, mainly with respect to the various Christ Myth theorists, Flavian Hypothesis’, Roman Invention, Caesar’s Messiah, Homers Odyssey and the Gospel of Mark, etc…

They all basically assert that Jesus never existed and was either a myth borrowed from other religions, a sly joke written by the Flavians, or the Invention of Romans, etc…

Anyways, I have this one nagging thought in regards to all of these theories…

Having read the Gospels, I find that Jesus’ teachings are beautiful, insightful, and not those that seem as if they would just be “made up” to deceive people

What I mean is, it doesn’t seem that the words of which Christ speaks would have been made up by a bunch of myth makers, Romans, Flavians, etc… It just seems too deep and meaningful 🤷

Has anyone else had this sort of thought? I’d love to hear some opinions 👍
 
Her is on thing to keep in mind.

People will because a a lie, but they will not choose to die to defend what they know to be a lie. that said all of the apostels but one were killed for defending the gospel. All they had to do was deny it. they choose to die.

these writtings you mentioned are trash and need to be treated as such.
 
I agree with you, as it would seem rather pointless to die for something that was a lie, myth, etc…

However, I would assume the skeptics would cry that sources (relating to Christian persecution) are unreliable, tampered with, and all that 🤷
 
I agree with you, as it would seem rather pointless to die for something that was a lie, myth, etc…

However, I would assume the skeptics would cry that sources (relating to Christian persecution) are unreliable, tampered with, and all that 🤷
Note that it was not just the early Christians who died for their faith. History is full of accounts of martyrdom, there have been more martyrs in the 20th century than all of the centuries prior put together.

ewtn.com/vnews/getstory.asp?number=26402
 
I am in no way discrediting the suffering and respect of modern day Martyrs, but for validity of Jesus Christ as a real person, they don’t really carry much weight, too far gone from the time period of Christ’s life on earth.
 
I am in no way discrediting the suffering and respect of modern day Martyrs, but for validity of Jesus Christ as a real person, they don’t really carry much weight, too far gone from the time period of Christ’s life on earth.
Serious Christians would answer this with the fact that they have no need to “go back” to prove the historical Jesus, but they believe and indeed experience the Risen Lord in the mystical Body of Christ, The Church.

Christianity is not about searching for historical facts, but about searching for and experiencing the truth of The Savior.
 
I agree, however for a person like me who is just coming back into the faith, it helps to have some historical backing for my belief, so that I can begin to foster that relationship with Christ on a serious level.

I like the way you put that though, and that is sort of what I have been coming to in a sense, that the only thing that really matters are the words of Christ.

It’s just hard when there are so many objections and counterclaims out there which seem fairly reasonable at times 🤷
 
secular historians wrote about him, and the earliest Gospel texts we have don’t leave enough time to come up with such a cohesive story.
 
I am in no way discrediting the suffering and respect of modern day Martyrs, but for validity of Jesus Christ as a real person, they don’t really carry much weight, too far gone from the time period of Christ’s life on earth.
catholic.com/thisrock/quickquestions/keyword/history

8th question down, also i think the Jewish Talmud even speaks of Christ’s existence i can’t confirm that however.
 
=AskSeekKnock24;8000855]Hello all,
I have been ardently making my way back to faith in Jesus Christ during the past few months. Along my journey I have been praying constantly for Our Lord to guide me and help lead me to him, and overall I feel as things are heading in the right direction 🙂
However I have been encountering roadblocks here and there, mainly with respect to the various Christ Myth theorists, Flavian Hypothesis’, Roman Invention, Caesar’s Messiah, Homers Odyssey and the Gospel of Mark, etc…
They all basically assert that Jesus never existed and was either a myth borrowed from other religions, a sly joke written by the Flavians, or the Invention of Romans, etc…
Anyways, I have this one nagging thought in regards to all of these theories…
Having read the Gospels, I find that Jesus’ teachings are beautiful, insightful, and not those that seem as if they would just be “made up” to deceive people
What I mean is, it doesn’t seem that the words of which Christ speaks would have been made up by a bunch of myth makers, Romans, Flavians, etc… It just seems too deep and meaningful 🤷
Has anyone else had this sort of thought? I’d love to hear some opinions 👍
My favorite Author: Archbishop Fulton Sheen and my two favorite popes: Blessed John Paull II, and Benedict XCVI all agree that their can be ONLY ONE truth for every precise
issue.

Because this is logically true even without Faith; I concur !

My friend; Old grandpa * used to say: “when you look for trouble you’re far more likely to find it.” 🙂

I’m personally in favor of study of other Faiths and beliefs AFTER ONE IS FIRMLY GROUNDED IN THE ONE FAITH GOD HIMSELF [NOT SOME MORTAL MAN WITH AN AJENDA] FOUNDED. This is of course fully consistant with OT practices and Teachings. ONLY One God; Only One Faith and ONLY One set of beliefs.

It bolis dow to easly decernable issues:
  1. Either the ENTIRE BIBLE is true [but not always factual], and useful for teaching the Faith [SINGULAR] or it is NOT. God Himself say’s that it is…B]2Tim.3:16 *“All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness,” John.14: 16 to 17 " And I [Jesus now HAVE] will pray the Father, and he will give you another **Counselor, to be with you for ever, ** [The Holy Spirit] …even the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him; you know him, for he dwells with you, and will be in you.: HERE IS JESUS PRAYING TO THE FATHER FRO HIS APOSTLES AND NEW CHURCH: John.17:15 to 19 “I do not pray that thou shouldst take them out of the world, **but that thou shouldst keep them from the evil one. **[16] They are not of the world, even as I am not of the world. Sanctify them in the truth; thy word is truth. ***As thou didst send me into the world, so I have sent them into the world. ****** And for their sake I consecrate myself, that they also may be consecrated in truth.” ***
So the Catholic Church by absolute necessity in-order to accomplish the COMMANDED MISSION given to her [them] by Christ; 1. Has the EVER PRESENT Holy Spirit to guide, and protect ALL of her Teaching on ALL matters of Faith beeif and Morallity." FUTHER, Jesus Himself acts in person as WRANNTY of these truths. NO OTHER FAITH OR CHURCH CAN TRUTHFULLY MAKE THIS CLAIM.
  1. **Who’s in charge…You or God. ** It Has to be one or the other with no possibility of a split. And who do you believe some recent on the scene; “I know better; I know More” than the Bible, The CC and God Himself.:eek: Or do you have FAITH IN GOD?
So it’s really not so complicated is it:shrug:

IF you’d really care to learn wnat AND WHY we catholics hold the views we do just send me a PM and I can help you.

God Bles you!
Pat
 
No human could have ever made up the bible.Jesus’s sayings and actions were beyond any human philospies.Even to this day people still are perplexed by some of the sayings of Jesus.Jesus’s understanding of man and human nature couldn’t have been thought up by mortal man.Jesus told us what man really was.He gave mankind the ability for each individuall to knnow who he really is.We are all interconnected and of the same flesh as Adam.That the differences between each human are very small.
 
Our earliest surviving complete copies date to the 4th c, but scholarship dates the originals to easily within the memories of Jesus’ contemporaries.

The gospels are also full of details that ground their story in history (“In the time of Herod, King of Judea…” “In those days, Caesar Augustus issued a decree that a census should take place…” “Quirinius was governor of Syria…” etc.) and geography.

Remember that a lot of early Christians were expecting the world to end within their lifetimes— I seem to recall that it was something of a shock to them that it didn’t end with the passing of the last of the original Twelve Apostles. But as time passed and they lost more of their “first-generation Christians”, it became more and more important to set down stories, parables, sermons, biographical details, and other important information.

JFK was assassinated nearly 50 years ago. Are there still people around who remember it? The first man on the moon happened over 40 years ago. Are there still people who can tell you about it? Gandhi died over 60 years ago. Does his mark still remain? What if there was some guy who raised the dead, cured the blind and the lame, attracted great crowds with his teachings, and was violently put to death— and then his disciples claimed he rose from the dead and went on to perform their own miracles in his name? Do you think that if such a person hadn’t existed in the first place, let alone behaved in that manner, that spreading the gospels as truth to people who would have known him or heard of him from others, in the area where he had lived and worked, would have been such a good idea?
 
=valentino;8001416]No human could have ever made up the bible.Jesus’s sayings and actions were beyond any human philospies.Even to this day people still are perplexed by some of the sayings of Jesus.Jesus’s understanding of man and human nature couldn’t have been thought up by mortal man.Jesus told us what man really was.He gave mankind the ability for each individuall to knnow who he really is.We are all interconnected and of the same flesh as Adam.That the differences between each human are very small.
VERY TRUE!

Also the Bible’s OT contains much History that is verifiable and a GREAT many prophisies that have been fulfilled.

Historical documents from LONG ago as well as the teaching, beliefs and practices confirmed by Early Church fathers also add creedence to the Bibles authenticity. And why would Ad and BC be universal world-widw were it not founded on Christ?

God Bless,
Pat
 
PJM, Valentino, and Midori

Thank you for your insights 👍

I agree that the content seems too abstract and philosophical to just be “made up” for some purpose or another. It just seems like a round about way of doing things…

I mean, why would all these mythologists, Roman inventors, etc, go through all the trouble to come up with such substance and spiritual insight? 🤷
 
=AskSeekKnock24;8001528]PJM, Valentino, and Midori
Thank you for your insights 👍
I agree that the content seems too abstract and philosophical to just be “made up” for some purpose or another. It just seems like a round about way of doing things…
I mean, why would all these mythologists, Roman inventors, etc, go through all the trouble to come up with such substance and spiritual insight? 🤷
CORRECT !

Also the church grew continously even through severe Roman persecutons. And their is ample historical evidence of this.

God Bless,
Pat
 
Hello all,

I have been ardently making my way back to faith in Jesus Christ during the past few months. Along my journey I have been praying constantly for Our Lord to guide me and help lead me to him, and overall I feel as things are heading in the right direction 🙂

However I have been encountering roadblocks here and there, mainly with respect to the various Christ Myth theorists, Flavian Hypothesis’, Roman Invention, Caesar’s Messiah, Homers Odyssey and the Gospel of Mark, etc…

They all basically assert that Jesus never existed and was either a myth borrowed from other religions, a sly joke written by the Flavians, or the Invention of Romans, etc…

Anyways, I have this one nagging thought in regards to all of these theories…

Having read the Gospels, I find that Jesus’ teachings are beautiful, insightful, and not those that seem as if they would just be “made up” to deceive people

What I mean is, it doesn’t seem that the words of which Christ speaks would have been made up by a bunch of myth makers, Romans, Flavians, etc… It just seems too deep and meaningful 🤷

Has anyone else had this sort of thought? I’d love to hear some opinions 👍
Read this:

peterkreeft.com/topics/christ-divinity.htm
peterkreeft.com/topics-more/resurrection-evidence.htm
 
Hello all,

I have been ardently making my way back to faith in Jesus Christ during the past few months. Along my journey I have been praying constantly for Our Lord to guide me and help lead me to him, and overall I feel as things are heading in the right direction 🙂

However I have been encountering roadblocks here and there, mainly with respect to the various Christ Myth theorists, Flavian Hypothesis’, Roman Invention, Caesar’s Messiah, Homers Odyssey and the Gospel of Mark, etc…

They all basically assert that Jesus never existed and was either a myth borrowed from other religions, a sly joke written by the Flavians, or the Invention of Romans, etc…

Anyways, I have this one nagging thought in regards to all of these theories…

Having read the Gospels, I find that Jesus’ teachings are beautiful, insightful, and not those that seem as if they would just be “made up” to deceive people

What I mean is, it doesn’t seem that the words of which Christ speaks would have been made up by a bunch of myth makers, Romans, Flavians, etc… It just seems too deep and meaningful 🤷

Has anyone else had this sort of thought? I’d love to hear some opinions 👍
Christian philosopher Gary Habermas has written a lot on the evidence for Jesus’ resurrection. Much of his work is very impressive. Try this article to start: garyhabermas.com/books/inbook_to-everyone-an-answer/habermas_case-for-xp-res.htm
 
Hello all,

I have been ardently making my way back to faith in Jesus Christ during the past few months. Along my journey I have been praying constantly for Our Lord to guide me and help lead me to him, and overall I feel as things are heading in the right direction 🙂

However I have been encountering roadblocks here and there, mainly with respect to the various Christ Myth theorists, Flavian Hypothesis’, Roman Invention, Caesar’s Messiah, Homers Odyssey and the Gospel of Mark, etc…

They all basically assert that Jesus never existed and was either a myth borrowed from other religions, a sly joke written by the Flavians, or the Invention of Romans, etc…

Anyways, I have this one nagging thought in regards to all of these theories…

Having read the Gospels, I find that Jesus’ teachings are beautiful, insightful, and not those that seem as if they would just be “made up” to deceive people

What I mean is, it doesn’t seem that the words of which Christ speaks would have been made up by a bunch of myth makers, Romans, Flavians, etc… It just seems too deep and meaningful 🤷

Has anyone else had this sort of thought? I’d love to hear some opinions 👍
Try these pages for issues dealing with the existence of Jesus: tektonics.org/jesusexisthub.html and preventingtruthdecay.org/copycats.shtml
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top