Christ has no religion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jamil_joseph02
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jamil_joseph02

Guest
My friend argued that Christ is of no religion, meaning, Christ came here on earth to proclaim the gospel, help the sick etc. but not to establish a religion. That’s why the bible study we had was a “non-denominational bible study”, she explains. Their concern in their bible study was not to compare or contrast ideas, facts, truths about the faith but simply to proclaim “the gospel”. Christ established a Church, but not a religion, she also argued.

Well, I think, to say that Christ has no religion is to deny that Christ is a Jew, right? I also believe that Christ was indeed the founder of our Catholic religion.

but may I know the position of the Church regarding this matter?
 
That’s why the bible study we had was a “non-denominational bible study”, she explains.
I would point out to your friend that there’s really no such thing as a “non-denominational” anything.

It might be the only church (or whatever) of one denomination, but usually it will be found to fit into one of the existing denominations quite nicely.
 
I’d agree.

I guess how it comes out is how one defines “religion”. Christ didn’t say “I’m starting a new religion, based on my old religion of Judiasm, for those who follow me. My name is Christ, so it makes sense that you all will be called ‘Christians’.”

But, those who follow Christ’s teachings are Christians, those who follow Buddah are Buddists, etc. Since the teachings are different, they’re different religions.

I would argue that since Christ intended people to follow his teachings, his intent was implicit that a new religion come of it. 🤷

It’s a bit different from, say, Luther’s case, in which his original intent was not to form a separate “Religion”, if one accepts the notion that Catholocism and Protestantism are separate religions.
 
Agreed,but what the real argument that they’re making behind this stance is against Authority. A very relativistic standpoint, and that ultimately doesn’t accept Christ as the Center of our life but our own “person” as the final authority.
 
Is the Catholic religion patterned after Judaism?
Very much so.

We believe in One God, the God of Abraham, Moses, and the Prophets.
We worship in the Synogogue (Liturgy of the Word is based on the Synogogue worship at the time of Jesus)
We celebrate similar feasts (Pascua, Penticost)
We use the same Scriptures (Old Testament)
We use the same Symbols (Arc of Covenant=Mary, Seat of Moses=See of Peter)
We gather members in the same way (Circumcision on 8th day=Baptism as infant)
(Bar Mitzva = Confirmation)
 
My friend argued that Christ is of no religion, meaning, Christ came here on earth to proclaim the gospel, help the sick etc. but not to establish a religion. That’s why the bible study we had was a “non-denominational bible study”, she explains. Their concern in their bible study was not to compare or contrast ideas, facts, truths about the faith but simply to proclaim “the gospel”. Christ established a Church, but not a religion, she also argued.

Well, I think, to say that Christ has no religion is to deny that Christ is a Jew, right? I also believe that Christ was indeed the founder of our Catholic religion.
I agree with 1edyson, this is simply a rejection of authority. I don’t know how you can have a Bible study that proclaims the Gospel, but doesn’t compare and contrast ideas. Seems to me that that would just be actually reading the Bible with no one commenting on it…
As with all discussions, defnitions are important. Find out what the person means by “religion”, “gospel”, and “church”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top