Christian, but not Catholic radio programming

  • Thread starter Thread starter tdcjco
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

tdcjco

Guest
Hello,
Let me start by prefacing my question with I am Catholic and always will be. However I have, lately, been listening to a local Christian radio station that offers a number of programs, including sermons and Bible Studies conducted by Christian, but not Catholic, pastors. I really enjoy listening to Chuck Swindoll, he always makes his lessons applicable to everyday life. The problem is I feel a little guilty about listening to non-Catholic teachers. I’ve never heard anything anti-Catholic or been offended by anything that was said. But I just feel like I’m doing something I shouldn’t be doing. Is it wrong to listen to and enjoy non-Catholic programming, for a Catholic?
 
There are a lot of Protestant preachers with good practical life lessons in their sermons. The problem is that Protestantism is rooted in heresy. I’m sorry, but it just is. I think that if one is strong in their understanding of Catholic theology and therefore able to discern between what is good, sound and practical life advice and false doctrine such as once saved, always saved, then maybe they would be ok listening to these preachers. But one must be strong in their Catholic faith. If I want to gain perspective on life lessons, then I would prefer to listen to motivational or business speakers who are not wrapping their message in religion. Certainly there is nothing wrong with that.
 
There are a lot of Protestant preachers with good practical life lessons in their sermons. The problem is that Protestantism is rooted in heresy. I’m sorry, but it just is. I think that if one is strong in their understanding of Catholic theology and therefore able to discern between what is good, sound and practical life advice and false doctrine such as once saved, always saved, then maybe they would be ok listening to these preachers. But one must be strong in their Catholic faith. If I want to gain perspective on life lessons, then I would prefer to listen to motivational or business speakers who are not wrapping their message in religion. Certainly there is nothing wrong with that.
So well put, excellent.:clapping::signofcross:
 
Hello,
Let me start by prefacing my question with I am Catholic and always will be. However I have, lately, been listening to a local Christian radio station that offers a number of programs, including sermons and Bible Studies conducted by Christian, but not Catholic, pastors. I really enjoy listening to Chuck Swindoll, he always makes his lessons applicable to everyday life. The problem is I feel a little guilty about listening to non-Catholic teachers. I’ve never heard anything anti-Catholic or been offended by anything that was said. But I just feel like I’m doing something I shouldn’t be doing. Is it wrong to listen to and enjoy non-Catholic programming, for a Catholic?
You have to be very careful. While it might not be openly anti-Catholic, many of the teachings of non-Catholics are against Catholic teaching. We disagree on many points, or else there would be no difference. For instance, the faith vs. works argument; being ‘saved’ as the only need for Heaven; clergy marriage; and many, many other things.

My uncle was a missionary, and was an amazing and great man. He had a degree in Theology, and brought many many people to Christ. However, he was not Catholic, and taught some things that clashed with Catholic doctrine and truths. I truly believe he will receive his reward in Heaven, if he is not already there (he passed in December; RIP). But I did learn a lot from him, and am eternally grateful to him. He wasn’t ever preaching against the Catholic Church, and perhaps didn’t even think of the Catholic Church when teaching, but nonetheless, it would be easy for me to have been confused if I wasn’t careful. It can easily get mixed up in your head.

There are dozens and dozens of Catholic radio programs out there. I use TuneIn Radio on my phone (and on my computer) to find lots of Catholic radio, from theology, to call-in shows, to bible study, to lectures, etc.

God bless your quest for knowledge!
 
Will be joining the RCC at the Easter Vigil mass. I quit listening to protestant radio last March. I don’t even listen to protestant worship music anymore. IMO I was deceived for so many years, I don’t even want to get close to it anymore. It might be subtle, a few speakers, a few verses taken out of context and the next thing you know you starting having doubts.

I myself am not willing to take that risk. You said you “feel guilty about listening…” That just may be the Holy Spirit telling you the ice is getting pretty thin and to back away.
:eek:
 
You have to be very careful. While it might not be openly anti-Catholic, many of the teachings of non-Catholics are against Catholic teaching. We disagree on many points, or else there would be no difference. For instance, the faith vs. works argument; being ‘saved’ as the only need for Heaven; clergy marriage; and many, many other things.

My uncle was a missionary, and was an amazing and great man. He had a degree in Theology, and brought many many people to Christ. However, he was not Catholic, and taught some things that clashed with Catholic doctrine and truths. I truly believe he will receive his reward in Heaven, if he is not already there (he passed in December; RIP). But I did learn a lot from him, and am eternally grateful to him. He wasn’t ever preaching against the Catholic Church, and perhaps didn’t even think of the Catholic Church when teaching, but nonetheless, it would be easy for me to have been confused if I wasn’t careful. It can easily get mixed up in your head.

There are dozens and dozens of Catholic radio programs out there. I use TuneIn Radio on my phone (and on my computer) to find lots of Catholic radio, from theology, to call-in shows, to bible study, to lectures, etc.

God bless your quest for knowledge!
On the one hand, if I ran across a Christian radio station, I would probably give it a listen. However, knowing what I now know, the doctrinal divide might keep me from listening for long.

Growing up in the Baptist Church, I was always skeptical regarding several of their teachings but assumed they knew better than I. A very good friend of mine is the pastor of the church where I grew up and the thought of visiting there is not a good one.

I don’t imagine that they would be overtly Anti Catholic but they would promote their beliefs that conflict with the Catholic Church. Catholic Radio is a better option. I’m one of those that has unlimited internet on my cell phone and I listen to kexs on Tune in and Ewtn on iheart. While most of the time, their programming is identical, there are times that kexs has their own programming and I prefer it.
 
I think you should listen to Christian radio stations

put it this way there much better than all the secular guff we hear out there

they are our brothers and sisters in Christ

pax +
 
I seem to be having a similar difficulty from time to time. I usually listen to Catholic radio while driving, but occasionally turn to an evangelical station which is right next to it on my radio dial. I believe I am sufficiently secure in my faith to filter out the things that fall outside the teaching of the church, but I still appreciate the focused approach of some of the protestant commentators.

Although I greatly appreciate and support Catholic radio, there are times when the “folksy” tone of some of the programs become a little irritating and I push the next button that takes me to the evangelicals. I wonder if other listeners have similar thoughts.
 
In my dorm bathroom (communal for about 20 people), there’s a radio that’s always playing the “Christian” station. Most of it’s Protestant-type music, but there are also talk shows that I’ve heard bits and pieces of when I’m in there. It’s not the kind of thing I would listen to by choice, much rather seek out the Catholic AM station.
 
In my dorm bathroom (communal for about 20 people), there’s a radio that’s always playing the “Christian” station. Most of it’s Protestant-type music, but there are also talk shows that I’ve heard bits and pieces of when I’m in there. It’s not the kind of thing I would listen to by choice, much rather seek out the Catholic AM station.
In the bathroom?
 
In the bathroom?
Yep. My RA decided it would be best to have a radio in there so that it wouldn’t be “awkward” for two people to be in there at the same time.

Yeah, I don’t quite get it either…
 
I seem to be having a similar difficulty from time to time. I usually listen to Catholic radio while driving, but occasionally turn to an evangelical station which is right next to it on my radio dial. I believe I am sufficiently secure in my faith to filter out the things that fall outside the teaching of the church, but I still appreciate the focused approach of some of the protestant commentators.

Although I greatly appreciate and support Catholic radio, there are times when the “folksy” tone of some of the programs become a little irritating and I push the next button that takes me to the evangelicals. I wonder if other listeners have similar thoughts.
As far as I know, there are no local Catholic radio stations and the only ones I get are from the internet. One is the EWTN feed and the other is kexs, most of which is EWTN. My only complaint is there is too much apologetics and not enough spiritual. Not that there is anything wrong with apologetics but when it is constant, it makes the church look defensive. Defensive looks week. I would prefer a little less defense and more help with my personal spirituality and holiness.

If anyone has any recommendations for Catholic radio accessible on the web, please feel free to share.
 
As far as I know, there are no local Catholic radio stations and the only ones I get are from the internet. One is the EWTN feed and the other is kexs, most of which is EWTN. My only complaint is there is too much apologetics and not enough spiritual. Not that there is anything wrong with apologetics but when it is constant, it makes the church look defensive. Defensive looks week. I would prefer a little less defense and more help with my personal spirituality and holiness.

If anyone has any recommendations for Catholic radio accessible on the web, please feel free to share.
Part of the reason why most Catholic radio stations have so many “apologetics oriented” shows is due to the nature of call-in talk radio shows, which is what most Catholic radio shows are. I generally listen to Immaculate Heart Radio, which is what the Catholic radio station here is part of. Their website is ihradio.org (I believe - it might be .com, but I believe it’s .org - try both to be sure), and they do have streaming. EWTN has 2 radio feeds now - one for the standard talk radio programs that they generally have, and one with more devotionals. Regardless, though, on any of these channels, there are Rosaries, Divine Mercy chaplets, and the Mass streamed over the radio. IHR has shows by Sr. Ann Shields, as well. Plus, all the Catholic radio shows are podcasted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top