Christians must be happy

  • Thread starter Thread starter LoveMercyGrace
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

LoveMercyGrace

Guest
with the joy of Jesus. Let us not fall asleep! says Pope Frances,

How do we understand this in context of a broken person who is going through times of

healing…well, John of the Cross talks of the dark night of the soul or

periods of purgation. Sometimes this healing can be over a period of time, Or one can

have interior struggles but be called by Christ to church in order to receive all the

healing sacraments- but maybe not always feeling happy.

Brother Lawrence in Practice of the Presence of God says he went through very painful

period lasting about 4 yrs. Mother Teresa ( although always charitable) we know was not

always happy. Many of the saints went through periods when they were not always

happy. but the work being done in their soul by the Holy Spirit was/is a necessary

process. So how is all this reconciled…to “must be happy” and the soul’s spiritual

journey- which can at times be a rocky path?

wondering if this is the right forum to post this, but evangelizing seems to fit 🙂

.
 
I think one might be sad in temporal aspects of life but still have an underlying joy in Christ and our trust in Him. And just because we are in mourning for the death of a loved one, it doesn’t mean we have to be so sad that we make others around us completely miserable–we have to stay close to God and thank and praise Him even in the midst of trouble.

And having said that, I still struggle with doing it!
 
with the joy of Jesus. Let us not fall asleep! says Pope Frances,

How do we understand this in context of a broken person who is going through times of

healing…well, John of the Cross talks of the dark night of the soul or

periods of purgation. Sometimes this healing can be over a period of time, Or one can

have interior struggles but be called by Christ to church in order to receive all the

healing sacraments- but maybe not always feeling happy.

Brother Lawrence in Practice of the Presence of God says he went through very painful

period lasting about 4 yrs. Mother Teresa ( although always charitable) we know was not

always happy. Many of the saints went through periods when they were not always

happy. but the work being done in their soul by the Holy Spirit was/is a necessary

process. So how is all this reconciled…to “must be happy” and the soul’s spiritual

journey- which can at times be a rocky path?

wondering if this is the right forum to post this, but evangelizing seems to fit 🙂

.
Personal view only … I love our Pope! But I think sometimes you have to work a little bit to make it through the translations. Happy does not equal joy. They are different things. During childbirth I was filled with joy that this was really happening and I was going to finally meet my munchkin - but since I was doing natural childbirth I didn’t feel one bit happy about it. Ditto for a time during a race when physical pain and exhaustion certainly prevented any happiness but I still found profound joy in exceeding what I thought I was going to be able to do.

Those are physical examples … spiritual ones are more difficult. Joy, itself is difficult to describe, but I clearly remember the times I felt it. And I agree with the saying that Joy is the surest sign of God’s presence. It comes from hope and from faith and from a connection to or a channeling of something much bigger than ourselves.

Not sure if any of that is of any help to anyone, but I appreciate the opportunity to start this morning reflecting on the idea of Joy.

Peace.
 
I don’t see any problem in reconciling these matters.

First of all…the Thread title says Christians must be happy…It is you you have added the modifier…“always” to happy. So it seems you may have heard something that was not actually said.

Secondly - do not confuse the idea of being happy in our faith and in our Lord, with the idea of things being all smiles and roses all the time.

The person who has a specific goal in life…something that gives them great joy, contentment and peace…will sacrifice much, even pain, to pursue that goal. They are happy that they are able to pursue that goal…even though at times the struggles associated with the pursuit causes pain and suffering.
Take for example a person who dreams of running a Marathon. They know that the pursuit of that goal will be painful and involve many “dark nights”. Yet are they unhappy? No - they are happy because they are on the right path…struggling yes…but properly focused and moving forward.
Other examples can be put forth…professional athletes, those who diet and exercise in order to improve their physical health etc…
In each case the person is submitting themselves to a rigid discipline - one that will cause sometimes severe discomfort - in order to pursue a desired goal.

Likewise - the Christian submits themselves to a discipline in order to pursue a goal. In this case the goal is purification - sanctification - unity with God. It is a goal that brings with it happiness and contentment. Yes it is a path that is difficult but one that, for all it’s difficulty, cannot destroy our fundamental happiness.

Peace
James
 
One reference to “Christians must be happy” comes from the CWR , to quote, and is available from other VA news sources as well:

“The life of slumbering Christians is a sad life; it is not a happy life. Christians must be happy with the joy of Jesus. Let us not fall asleep!” — Pope Francis, General Audience, April 24, 2013.

JRKH: Error noted, I added must* always * be happy
you use a great analogy of marathoners who experience pain in their
endeavor of reaching their goal, but an underlying joy. Very helpful, thank you. I have watched a person train for many days, years, and then attended many of the running races. I see the anguish, struggle and pain in their faces as they are coming to the finish line after 25 miles, giving it all they have. Never once have I heard " this is terrible, painful, I am so unhappy!" But when they cross the line, they are happy. sweating, maybe sore but happy. Even those who come in 20th place. Because they still ran the race and reached their goal.
thank you for sharing ref to The Fulfillment of All Desire.
on your post page.

Cradle Journey: Yes I love our Pope too! He became so just very shortly after I returned
to the Catholic faith. So for me, he has been a good spiritual director. The translations are
a ;little difficult and I read he does not prepare a text ahead of time, “this is not his style”
so then I am more happy with this because he speaks from the Holy Spirit.
you write: *spiritual ones are more difficult. Joy, itself is difficult to describe, but I clearly remember the times I felt it. And I agree with the saying that Joy is the surest sign of God’s presence. It comes from hope and from faith and from a connection to or a channeling of something much bigger than ourselves. * :signofcross:

St Frances: thank you for sharing you struggle with this also. “one might be sad in temporal aspects of life but still have an underlying joy in Christ and our trust in Him.”…
Sometimes I think " if I had an outlet, a person to discuss these temporal things it would be easier."
Then I think again and realize…I do, we do, have one to talk to about these things. Jesus is there. So these can become our sharing of the cross and we talk to Him, and he always answers.

Thank you all for your thoughtful and helpful comments.
Blessings~
 
with the joy of Jesus. Let us not fall asleep! says Pope Frances,

How do we understand this in context of a broken person who is going through times of

healing…well, John of the Cross talks of the dark night of the soul or

periods of purgation. Sometimes this healing can be over a period of time, Or one can

have interior struggles but be called by Christ to church in order to receive all the

healing sacraments- but maybe not always feeling happy.

Brother Lawrence in Practice of the Presence of God says he went through very painful

period lasting about 4 yrs. Mother Teresa ( although always charitable) we know was not

always happy. Many of the saints went through periods when they were not always

happy. but the work being done in their soul by the Holy Spirit was/is a necessary

process. So how is all this reconciled…to “must be happy” and the soul’s spiritual

journey- which can at times be a rocky path?

wondering if this is the right forum to post this, but evangelizing seems to fit 🙂

.
That’s an interesting question. The Church teaches that the desire for happiness is instilled in all humans by God-and that our true, full, inexhaustble happiness can be found only in Him. But man was separated from God-we lost communion with Him-at the Fall, where man effectively rejected God as his God. Jesus’ purpose is to rectify this situation by reconciling man with God, so communion can be restored.

But in this life both good and evil are literally known, as was promised that they would be if man were to disobey God by eating of the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. We still suffer from the effects of moral evil- sin-both from others as well as our own. To the extent that we’re not fully sold out to God, to the extent that we don’t love Him with our whole heart, soul, mind, and strength, we’re still attracted by lesser, created, things over Him, trying to find satisfaction/happiness elsewhere, and our justice, integrity, and harmony are therefore incomplete, unperfected.

And even if we are totally sold out to Him, the challenges that both moral and physical evil present us with cause at least some degree of misery daily; joy and happiness are relative values in this life and will be until we’re free of the flesh and things are consummated in the end with the Beatific Vision, the source of unending happiness for us. This is why we can assume that souls in purgatory, on their way to heaven, can’t be totally happy either; their union with God isn’t yet realized, or only imperfectly so. Meanwhile we’re nonetheless meant to strive at improving in these relative values of joy and happiness, learning to overcome our fears and suffering and the evil that’s always present, always trying to pull us down.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top