church history

  • Thread starter Thread starter domestichippie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I appreciate that. This is fast becoming a larger undertaking than I thought. Just footling for resources is taking Me down so many side trails i need focus. One answer leads to more questions. I’m afraid of where God might be leading me. After all, the last Time I had question of this nature I became a christian
Well trust that God will lead where he wants you to be in His time and not ours. 👍

That said - you have indeed asked a very open ended question but I think that with a little time we can all narrow things down. There are so many wonderful people here and each one has a slightly different are of expertise, way of expression, books to recommend etc…
You will soon begin to gravitate toward the ones who are best answering your particular questions and in a way that you understand the best.

Like I said though, Just trust in the God whom you Love and who Loves you.

Peace
James
 
Hi. The main reason I ended up on these forums is because ive been doing a Bible study with the women’s group at my church on James. I was very surprised to find that James was almost cut from the Protestant Bible. My summer reading project is now to read the excluded books. I want to find out if the baby got thrown out with the bath water.

I’m very curious about church history now and want to know when and why certain beliefs got booted. Please regimens me some good resources on this subject.
If you have particular “booted belief” in mind perhaps you could mention one or two. That might help us guide you to the correct historical period and writers.

Peace
James
 
I appreciate that. This is fast becoming a larger undertaking than I thought. Just footling for resources is taking Me down so many side trails i need focus. One answer leads to more queastions. I’m afraid of where God might be leading me. After all, the last Time I had queastion of this nature I became a christian
I commend your efforts. Trust in Jesus and your questions will be answered. John Henry Newman has a great quote about your undertaking and where it leads one when one searches history. God bless you.
 
Hi. The main reason I ended up on these forums is because ive been doing a Bible study with the women’s group at my church on James. I was very surprised to find that James was almost cut from the Protestant Bible. My summer reading project is now to read the excluded books. I want to find out if the baby got thrown out with the bath water.

I’m very curious about church history now and want to know when and why certain beliefs got booted. Please regimens me some good resources on this subject.
There is a famous quote amongst Catholic circles.
“To be deeply knowledgeable in History is to cease to be Protestant”

Look up Igantius of Antioch circa 100AD. Bishop of Antioch, which was the largest Christian community, I think, outside of Rome. He was a contemporary of the Apostle Mark and some say Peter.

3 things are very interesting from his writings. As he is being carted off to Rome to be martyred he writes to the Christians in Antioch and shows 3 pillars of Catholic faith that nearly all protestants ignore/reject.
  1. he urges his fellow Christians to follow their Bishops and Priests - not the bible alone.
  2. He calls the Church “this Kathilokos church” which is Greek for Catholic.
  3. Do not deny the Eucharist as some do
Finally, as you look back at history and compare Pre-Reformation to Post-Reformation Christianity. IF Luther and the Protestant Reformers merely sought to ‘reset’ things or ‘correct’ that which had gotten out of hand… Why has Protestantism deviated from its initial starting point and not just corrected the mistakes but introduced NEW ideas that prior to the reformation didn’t exist? Why do churches continue to ‘reform’ ??
 
If you have particular “booted belief” in mind perhaps you could mention one or two. That might help us guide you to the correct historical period and writers.

Peace
James
Booted belief?
 
Booted belief?
Perhaps some background on where I’m coming from? In addition to some issues with the Eucharist and Mary( I started a thread for these) I have some paganism questions. I ran across a tract that was seemed mostly directed at those who only have a passing knowledge of pagan rites. Before I was a Christian I was a witch. As such I see a lot of similarities in Catholic rituals and praying to saints, as well as holidays. Especially since my patron goddess was Bridget. History of this goddess and saint Bridget seem as if one was connected to the other as a way of "christianizing " pagan worship of a false God.

So that’s big issue for me.

This other is that I came to Christ in a pentacostal church during a worship service. Though I realize the pentacostal church is barely 100 years old I’m attached to the worship style and have a passion and talent for music. This is also my husbands denomination. Being a younger believer I think I’m more open to accepting I don’t know things. Hes harder to bring around study this with me. Even though he s was raised in a devote setting he admittedly has never read our entire Bible. So I have to approach these things gently with him.
 
Perhaps some background on where I’m coming from? In addition to some issues with the Eucharist and Mary( I started a thread for these) I have some paganism questions. I ran across a tract that was seemed mostly directed at those who only have a passing knowledge of pagan rites. Before I was a Christian I was a witch. As such I see a lot of similarities in Catholic rituals and praying to saints, as well as holidays. Especially since my patron goddess was Bridget. History of this goddess and saint Bridget seem as if one was connected to the other as a way of “Christianizing” pagan worship of a false God.

So that’s big issue for me.

This other is that I came to Christ in a pentecostal church during a worship service. Though I realize the pentecostal church is barely 100 years old I’m attached to the worship style and have a passion and talent for music. This is also my husbands denomination. Being a younger believer I think I’m more open to accepting I don’t know things. Hes harder to bring around study this with me. Even though he s was raised in a devote setting he admittedly has never read our entire Bible. So I have to approach these things gently with him.
hhmmm - -

I’m afraid these are areas I’m probably not going to be able to help much with.

I can’t speak to particular issues with St Bridget etc and at this point it might be difficult to say who borrowed what from who “ritual” wise.
I do know that many who have come from a Jewish Background comment on how “Jewish” the mass is, in other words there is no mistaking the influence and continuity of the two faiths.
Also my understanding is that the feast of the nativity commonly referred to as Christmas was placed near the Winter solstice, not because that is when Jesus was born but because a) It provided a celebration for Christians to counter a pagan one and b) it seemed fitting since the solstice marks the beginning of the ascendency of the sun(Son).
It also seems logical that the placement of all souls and all saints day were designed to counter pagan belief/celebrations etc. Halloween is actually a contraction of “All Hallowed Eve” or the Eve of All Saints day.

Peace
James
 
Same as “belief that was dropped”.

Peace
James
Intitially I assumed that the material cut from the Bible was done so because these things didn’t line up with the beliefs Luther had concerning things like Mary, the Eucharist, etc. But it seems Luther did believe these yhings after all. So I’m not exactly sure why the split other than he thought perhaps the corruption of the church was too great.

I also don’t know much about why all the little divisions that came later…but that ill leave for later.

Can someone post a link to a detailed timeline of the church including more recent divisions. I’m a visual person and things like that help. Obviously tootle gives quite few but wondered if anyone had strong recommendation
 
hhmmm - -

I’m afraid these are areas I’m probably not going to be able to help much with.

I can’t speak to particular issues with St Bridget etc and at this point it might be difficult to say who borrowed what from who “ritual” wise.
I do know that many who have come from a Jewish Background comment on how “Jewish” the mass is, in other words there is no mistaking the influence and continuity of the two faiths.
Also my understanding is that the feast of the nativity commonly referred to as Christmas was placed near the Winter solstice, not because that is when Jesus was born but because a) It provided a celebration for Christians to counter a pagan one and b) it seemed fitting since the solstice marks the beginning of the ascendency of the sun(Son).
It also seems logical that the placement of all souls and all saints day were designed to counter pagan belief/celebrations etc. Halloween is actually a contraction of “All Hallowed Eve” or the Eve of All Saints day.

Peace
James
As a pagan I was under the impression the Catholic church studied magic and possibly used it
Though I cant recall specific names I remember in studying magic I ran across a lot of basics, particularly alchemy. Written by priests.
 
Initially I assumed that the material cut from the Bible was done so because these things didn’t line up with the beliefs Luther had concerning things like Mary, the Eucharist, etc. But it seems Luther did believe these things after all.
Yes - Luther did believe in the Eucharist and had great reverence for Mary. The reason he wanted to remove the book of James was because it contradicted his theory of “Faith Alone” and James says that, “Just as the body without the Spirit is dead so faith without works is dead”. I do not know the reason he objected to Hebrews and Jude, but of course Revelations is a difficult book for everyone.
So the changes in the beliefs on the Eucharist and Mary actually came later as the protestant movement continued it’s splitting…
The deletions of the books from the OT is actually a bit more complex. There was a widely used Greek OT in use at the time of Jesus outside of Judea. It is called the Septuagint. The Hebrew OT, not finalized until after Jesus death, contained fewer books. The Christian Church between about 380 and 420(there was only one at this time), meeting in council(s) and under the guidance of the Holy Spirit determined which books to place in the Holy Bible. They came up with a total of 73.
This was the accepted canon for the next 1000 years until Luther decided to deny the “inspiration” of the books that were not in the Hebrew canon and place them in a separate section of the bible between the OT and NT. Later, as a cost saving measure, printers dropped them from the Bible printings altogether…

From this you can see that the history of the Bible is a bit more complex than is often understood by those relying on it.
In Truth, without the offices of the Catholic Church, acting in council and in concert with the Holy Spirit, the Bible we know today would not even exist.
So I’m not exactly sure why the split other than he thought perhaps the corruption of the church was too great.
Whole books have been written on this subject. Yes the corruption issue played a part. Political expediency among German princes played a part. Luther’s brilliant but unstable mind played a part. Bullheadedness on ALL sides played a significant part…:banghead:
I also don’t know much about why all the little divisions that came later…but that ill leave for later.
There are many reasons for this…each split had it’s own reason, but the fundamental reason goes back to the rejection of visible, universal, councilior, akklesial authority and replacing it with the concept of Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.
It is this singular factor that is at the core of most all splits over doctrinal issues for it allows pride rather than humility to become the determining factor in ones position. It explains why Luther, Calvin, Zwingli and others at the time were unable to come to common agreement - pride prevented compromise and consensus building among them.
This is an oversimplification but - as you said - this is a whole other subject and thread…
Can someone post a link to a detailed timeline of the church including more recent divisions. I’m a visual person and things like that help. Obviously tootle gives quite few but wondered if anyone had strong recommendation
I don’t know about “detailed” but THIS one from Wiki is kind of interesting.

Peace
James
 
As a pagan I was under the impression the Catholic church studied magic and possibly used it
Though I cant recall specific names I remember in studying magic I ran across a lot of basics, particularly alchemy. Written by priests.
During the so called “Dark” and even into the “middle” ages and beyond, the Catholic Church in western Europe stood as a guardian and promoter of learning etc. Monasteries were great centers of study and writing. Monasteries were where the bibles were produced before the advent of the printing press.
Of course because they existed in many lands, they also gathered and recorded many tales, ideas, folklore, and yes - alchemy and such from the lands where they existed AND where many of their members were raised.

As far as studying and using “magic” I would have to say that this is a very “ill defined” area. What was considered magic 1000 years ago - or even just 200 years ago might today be nothing more than good, well understood, science, chemistry or medicine…🤷
Alchemy is a particularly rich source for things that - long ago was seen as magical but today are understood for and by their chemical interactions.

Peace
James
 
During the so called “Dark” and even into the “middle” ages and beyond, the Catholic Church in western Europe stood as a guardian and promoter of learning etc. Monasteries were great centers of study and writing. Monasteries were where the bibles were produced before the advent of the printing press.
Of course because they existed in many lands, they also gathered and recorded many tales, ideas, folklore, and yes - alchemy and such from the lands where they existed AND where many of their members were raised.

As far as studying and using “magic” I would have to say that this is a very “ill defined” area. What was considered magic 1000 years ago - or even just 200 years ago might today be nothing more than good, well understood, science, chemistry or medicine…🤷
Alchemy is a particularly rich source for things that - long ago was seen as magical but today are understood for and by their chemical interactions.

Peace
James
This particular book was more than history. Of coursevi don’t have these anymore as they were too great a temptation for me
 
Intitially I assumed that the material cut from the Bible was done so because these things didn’t line up with the beliefs Luther had concerning things like Mary, the Eucharist, etc. But it seems Luther did believe these yhings after all. So I’m not exactly sure why the split other than he thought perhaps the corruption of the church was too great.

Quite true…it stemmed from pride not to look “Catholic”…even when Luther was alive, the splits already started to happen.

There is even a quote from Luther…I will paraphase…he would rather drink wine with papists (catholics)…

As new reformers came about…and new generations succeeded the original reformers…they started to veer away from their catholic roots…so each generation would steer farther and farther and farther away…among the things they would change…the liturgy or manner of worship…no more Eucharist…from the real presence to a symbolic presence, as an example.
I also don’t know much about why all the little divisions that came later…but that ill leave for later.
 
😃

Is your group familiar with the history of how the Bible came about? Maybe start from there…catholicapologetics.info/apologetics/protestantism/wbible.htm
The study we’re doing is mercy triumphs by beth moore. I’m sure some of the group have at least a basic understanding. Though most are not super interested in the history.

I like that the articlepoints out the Bible did not drop from heaven carried by angels. Right now I really wish it had.
 
This particular book was more than history. Of course i don’t have these anymore as they were too great a temptation for me
Understood, and I didn’t mean to imply that the monks simply recorded “history”.
That’s pretty much whet was after and not finding. Thanks.
You are welcome.
The study we’re doing is mercy triumphs by beth moore. I’m sure some of the group have at least a basic understanding. Though most are not super interested in the history.

I like that the article points out the Bible did not drop from heaven carried by angels. Right now I really wish it had.
Yes it might have been easier if the “flaming chariot” that took Elijah had returned later with “The Bible”…But God did not choose this path. Instead The Father chose to leave it up to “The Word”, Jesus to set things up. Jesus chose to stay with us but also to give men both the Holy Spirit as a guide and also a community (Ekklesia - Church) where they could “test the spirits” and with authority to “Bind and Loose” - “Whatever” (Mt 18:15-18).

It’s amazing how, once I began to discern the various references in the NT to “church” as in structure, mode of operation etc. everything just seemed to line up so perfectly with how the RC (and the EO) operated. And “golly-gee-whiz” wouldn’t you know those are the two oldest Christian communities.

I never found anything (and I have challenged many SS non-Catholics to show me) in the Bible equally as compelling to support the principles that many believe to be correct in church structure and governance. (“invisible non-authoritative church” - visible local community only etc.)

Peace
James
 
I like that the articlepoints out the Bible did not drop from heaven carried by angels. Right now I really wish it had.
It would have been a lot easier if it had. One actually has to ask the question why it took so long to assemble all of the scripture writings into one volume. Certainly the works were all done before the end of the first century but it took an additional 250 years for a canon identical to the one used today to be proposed. That was by Bishop Athanasius in 348 AD. Then it took an additional 50 years or so for the actual Bible using that same canon to be assembled as one volume. So why the delay? The answer is one word, Gnosticism. Today I think we grossly underestimate the effect of Gnosticism on the early church. This was a widespread threat to the christian church that potentially could pervert it. As it was it did cause widespread confusion. The Bible canon was an effort to combat Gnosticism by codifying into one book [Biblia] those writings which were suitable for use in the worship liturgy of the church. The test was that the writings had to support the Oral teaching of the church. The Gnostic writings were found wanting in this respect. So in arounfd the year 400 AD Jerome published the Latin translation of the Greek New and Old Testaments in a book that was called the Vulgate, so named because it was in the common language of the people. in Latin the word for ‘common’ is vulgata from which we also get our word ‘vulgar’.

So a lot of effort over a lot of time to codify the scriptures. Most of that time and effort was spent on the New Testament as the universally accepted Old Testament was the Greek Septuagint.
 
The study we’re doing is mercy triumphs by beth moore. I’m sure some of the group have at least a basic understanding. Though most are not super interested in the history.
I looked up Mercy Triumphs…on the book of James. That is a very catholic epistle! Hope you and your friends are aware of that. 😃

For what’s it worth…(and I do not want to derail your study)…here is one by a catholic…for a future study…:D…ebay.com/itm/Faith-Works-Book-James-Scott-Hahn-6-CD-set-/290250096207
I like that the articlepoints out the Bible did not drop from heaven carried by angels. Right now I really wish it had.
You really made me chuckle…:rotfl:
 
I appreciate that. This is fast becoming a larger undertaking than I thought. Just footling for resources is taking Me down so many side trails i need focus. One answer leads to more queastions. I’m afraid of where God might be leading me. After all, the last Time I had queastion of this nature I became a christian
🙂 Yes sometimes God answers our simple questions in superabundance. 🙂

As Newman said, to be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant. Study the early history of the Church from the best sources. You will see Catholicism, not Protestantism.

This pastor did it, and not only did he become Catholic (“oh no, Lord, not THAT!”), but he brought in many of his church members.
catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0077.html
blog.adw.org/2009/03/how-alex-jones-found-truth-in-the-catholic-church/

All any of us can do is be open to the truth wherever it may lead us. God will do the rest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top