Initially I assumed that the material cut from the Bible was done so because these things didn’t line up with the beliefs Luther had concerning things like Mary, the Eucharist, etc. But it seems Luther did believe these things after all.
Yes - Luther did believe in the Eucharist and had great reverence for Mary. The reason he wanted to remove the book of James was because it contradicted his theory of “Faith Alone” and James says that, “Just as the body without the Spirit is dead so faith without works is dead”. I do not know the reason he objected to Hebrews and Jude, but of course Revelations is a difficult book for everyone.
So the changes in the beliefs on the Eucharist and Mary actually came later as the protestant movement continued it’s splitting…
The deletions of the books from the OT is actually a bit more complex. There was a widely used Greek OT in use at the time of Jesus outside of Judea. It is called the Septuagint. The Hebrew OT, not finalized until after Jesus death, contained fewer books. The Christian Church between about 380 and 420(there was only one at this time), meeting in council(s) and under the guidance of the Holy Spirit determined which books to place in the Holy Bible. They came up with a total of 73.
This was the accepted canon for the next 1000 years until Luther decided to deny the “inspiration” of the books that were not in the Hebrew canon and place them in a separate section of the bible between the OT and NT. Later, as a cost saving measure, printers dropped them from the Bible printings altogether…
From this you can see that the history of the Bible is a bit more complex than is often understood by those relying on it.
In Truth, without the offices of the Catholic Church, acting in council and in concert with the Holy Spirit, the Bible we know today would not even exist.
So I’m not exactly sure why the split other than he thought perhaps the corruption of the church was too great.
Whole books have been written on this subject. Yes the corruption issue played a part. Political expediency among German princes played a part. Luther’s brilliant but unstable mind played a part. Bullheadedness on ALL sides played a significant part…:banghead:
I also don’t know much about why all the little divisions that came later…but that ill leave for later.
There are many reasons for this…each split had it’s own reason, but the fundamental reason goes back to the rejection of visible, universal, councilior, akklesial authority and replacing it with the concept of Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.
It is this singular factor that is at the core of most all splits over doctrinal issues for it allows pride rather than humility to become the determining factor in ones position. It explains why Luther, Calvin, Zwingli and others at the time were unable to come to common agreement - pride prevented compromise and consensus building among them.
This is an oversimplification but - as you said - this is a whole other subject and thread…
Can someone post a link to a detailed timeline of the church including more recent divisions. I’m a visual person and things like that help. Obviously tootle gives quite few but wondered if anyone had strong recommendation
I don’t know about “detailed” but
THIS one from Wiki is kind of interesting.
Peace
James