Church says masturbation bad

  • Thread starter Thread starter ErrorCMDR
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
ErrorCMDR said:
Blade and Blood I always love your posts
but I have found that the last place you will find support for www.religioustolerance.org is this site. From good old John Mac to the people who hate that sticker with the signs.

Don’t you know Blade and Blood that site is supported by devil worshipers?
Not the kind of source allot of God fearing people would get medical info from.

Nocturnal emissions huh? hmm… wow considering most people have pretty steamy dreams when they have them. does that mean Unknowingly having sexual thoughts that cause you to release is more appropriate then consciously doing it for medical reasons.

Now it just seems your splitting hairs Caesar517
Click to expand...
:rotfl:

No, they aren’t. I’ve heard that many times and so have they. :rolleyes:

I’ve personally spoke with them about their site, and they are very legitimate. I respect them very much.

They identify themselves as two Unitarians (one agnostic and the other an atheist), one Wiccan, one liberal but unaffiliated Christian, and a Zen Buddhist.

They are not devil worshippers, they are simply of another faith.
 
Blade_and_Blood said:
:rotfl:

No, they aren’t. I’ve heard that many times and so have they. :rolleyes:

I’ve personally spoke with them about their site, and they are very legitimate. I respect them very much.

They identify themselves as two Unitarians (one agnostic and the other an atheist), one Wiccan, one liberal but unaffiliated Christian, and a Zen Buddhist.

They are not devil worshippers, they are simply of another faith.
Click to expand...
Sarcasm don’t leave forums with out it
 
The last thing I need is a “loop hole” from the church on this particular sin… I would never leave the house!

😃
 
Dear ErrorCMDR

Let me ask you a very blunt question. How are you going to get an erection without feeling sexually aroused?

God bless you
TL
 
ErrorCMDR said:
But as Catechism number 2352 states

“By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure.”

so if it is not for Sexual pleasure and is for a health reason. how is it wrong?
Click to expand...
The Holy Office (the CDF) answered the question some years ago as to whether or not masturbation can be done to obtain a specimen for medical analysis (i.e. not for sexual pleasure). The answer was in the negative. It is still masturbation, regardless of the purpose, and so it is still intrinsically evil. Intrinsically evil acts are immoral regardless of intention (purpose) or circumstance (including consequences).

So it does not matter if there were health benefits or not. It is always immoral.

The Catechism states the usual reason that the act is done, but in no way does this imply that the same act done for another purpose may be moral.
 
Ron_Conte said:
The Holy Office (the CDF) answered the question some years ago as to whether or not masturbation can be done to obtain a specimen for medical analysis (i.e. not for sexual pleasure). The answer was in the negative. It is still masturbation, regardless of the purpose, and so it is still intrinsically evil. Intrinsically evil acts are immoral regardless of intention (purpose) or circumstance (including consequences).

So it does not matter if there were health benefits or not. It is always immoral.

The Catechism states the usual reason that the act is done, but in no way does this imply that the same act done for another purpose may be moral.
Click to expand...
Ron , do you have a source for that statement from the CDF? I know that it is true but haven’t seen the document.
 
To the original poster:

**
WAKE UP!!**

I have struggled with this sin enough in the past to tell you that no one does it to clean out their prostrate.
 
TLDenmark said:
Dear ErrorCMDR

Let me ask you a very blunt question. How are you going to get an erection without feeling sexually aroused?

God bless you
TL
Click to expand...
Where you ever a teenager or woke up in the morning? So yes it is possible to get an erection without being sexually aroused

I looked this over and they seem to be talking about using masturbation for Artificial insemination. which is against Church Doctrine… but that is not the use I am talking about

ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFHUMAN.HTM
 
Yes, at times a sinful thing could have a benefit.

But, it is still sinful.

ErrorCMDR, do you really think that you are doing anything here other than wasting bandwidth?

Do you really think that the result of this thread will be justification for masturbation for prostate health, as long as you don’t enjoy it?

:rotfl:
 
If people abided by the church that masturbation is a sin, then all would be blind.:cool:
 
Well with a Priest at least they listen to reason and if he has to go to a bishop
 
I’m a girl and I love masturbating. I do it at about three times a week, but sometimes twice in one day (my record is 5 times in about a 6 hour period). I also have phone sex with my boyfriend quite frequently. is this wrong? what should I do? 😦 😦 😦

HELP!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top