Cleanliness and the Woman's Role

  • Thread starter Thread starter streettaco
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

streettaco

Guest
Recently a friend admonished me for not keeping a clean and organized household for myself and my husband, and she asked me if I could think of a Saint who wasn’t clean and organized… admittedly I have never paid attention to this. Also, what exactly is the wife’s role anyhow? I would think to be a man, one would pick up after oneself!

I guess I viewed cleanliness as a human virtue like punctuality? but not necessarily a spiritual one. What do you think?
 
*As to what a wife’s role is, I think being “clean and organized” is a wonderful thing but it means different things to different people. If you have one or two children,…you will not have the problems with being clean and organized that you would have with say, 6 or 7 children! For a home to be clean and organized with a large family requires the assistance of every single person in the home! And this includes the husband! We are speaking of the “wife’s” role here, not what the maid needs to do!

And if the wife also works, then all work needs to be divided, none of this wife coming home from work and waiting on everyone else! There are wives that are home 24/7 and for some of them their role is easier to define, but it is never to pick up after the other people in the house! (unless we are talking about a baby or toddler).

To be clean is a virtue to strive after, to be sure! But for all of us, not just for “wives.” I don’t believe that I ever heard of being clean and organized as part of the criteria for being a saint. You might ask your friend just who she had in mind!*
 
Recently a friend admonished me for not keeping a clean and organized household for myself and my husband, and she asked me if I could think of a Saint who wasn’t clean and organized… admittedly I have never paid attention to this. Also, what exactly is the wife’s role anyhow? I would think to be a man, one would pick up after oneself!

I guess I viewed cleanliness as a human virtue like punctuality? but not necessarily a spiritual one. What do you think?
Well, I think that sloth is one of the seven deadly sins, right up there with pride, envy, greed, lust, anger and gluttony. However, I am not too sure what your household looks like or what your friend was chastising you for, exactly. I also don’t know how we could know whether all the saints were clean and organized. Some people are just better at organizing than others, but a general balance and harmony in our home helps us to be better able to concentrate, focus and even devote time to prayer and meditation. Ask the Lord to come to your aid in becoming more organized if you believe your friend may have a point. Not too sure where this saying comes from: “Cleanliness is next to Godliness”.
 
Recently a friend admonished me for not keeping a clean and organized household for myself and my husband, and she asked me if I could think of a Saint who wasn’t clean and organized… admittedly I have never paid attention to this. Also, what exactly is the wife’s role anyhow? I would think to be a man, one would pick up after oneself!

I guess I viewed cleanliness as a human virtue like punctuality? but not necessarily a spiritual one. What do you think?
How about Martha’s sister, Mary? It sounds like she wasn’t helping Martha with the cleanliness and organization when Jesus came to visit. Aren’t they both considered saints, nonetheless?

It also depends on how people were raised. Some people were raised in homes where the “white glove” test was done daily. In other homes, that is not so important. And I would expect a husband to at least put away his things (dirty laundry in the basket, tools in the toolbox, dishes in the dishwasher, etc.) rather than expect his wife to.
 
Regarding tidiness, if your living space (house, apt., condo) is too small for all your stuff, then it’s not your fault, or if you’re too weak. Two of the most saintly people I’ve ever known, when they had 4 kids at home, didn’t keep either a rat’s nest, or a “Better Homes’n Gardens” residence: they were so busy ministering to other believers that total (fascist :D) orderliness was not a priority. But cleanliness is essential, regardless of whether there’s some clutter or not (personal hygiene, clean clothes, clean eating implements, etc.).

And my hunch about the adage “cleanliness is next to godliness” would be that it goes back to when God gave Moses instructions on burying excrement, washing hands, etc. Prefacing and interspersed amongst those exhortations, you’ll find repeated “I am the LORD.” Cleanliness is part of the cosmic design. 🙂
 
Hi streettaco,
As one poster has pointed out: you could ask your friend what saints she had in mind!
As I understand it, cleanliness is, ultimately, an inner state. (Matt. 15:1-20).
God Bless,
Colmcille.
 
Recently a friend admonished me for not keeping a clean and organized household for myself and my husband, and she asked me if I could think of a Saint who wasn’t clean and organized… admittedly I have never paid attention to this. Also, what exactly is the wife’s role anyhow? I would think to be a man, one would pick up after oneself!

I guess I viewed cleanliness as a human virtue like punctuality? but not necessarily a spiritual one. What do you think?
Unless your home has rodents and insects running free (and I’m sure it does not), it’s sounds like your “friend” needs to stay concerned with her own matters and not be judging others based on what “her” definition of cleanliness is. Perhaps you could think of a charitable way of telling her this…
 
Were you happy with the way you kept house before your friend said anything? Was your husband happy with the way you two kept house? That’s all that is important. From now on, I think I’d be meeting this friend either at her house or a neutral site.
 
Unless your home has rodents and insects running free (and I’m sure it does not), it’s sounds like your “friend” needs to stay concerned with her own matters and not be judging others based on what “her” definition of cleanliness is. Perhaps you could think of a charitable way of telling her this…
👍 I’m not sure what kind of friend would chastise you so harshly for not keeping your house up to her standards. I don’t think it was any of her business. If your house offends her so much, she should invite you over to hers instead.
 
👍 I’m not sure what kind of friend would chastise you so harshly for not keeping your house up to her standards. I don’t think it was any of her business. If your house offends her so much, she should invite you over to hers instead.
I would change that to “If your house offends her so much, SHE should clean it for you!”👍
 
I would change that to “If your house offends her so much, SHE should clean it for you!”👍
My Grandmother was criticizing my mother (in law) about the dust on her ceiling lights and my mom told her “you know where the rags are.” 😃
 
While I do like the saying “cleanliness is next to Godliness” I will have to say that compared to my mother-in-law and sister-in-law they put me to shame when it comes to a “clean/organized house.” I used to stress about this very much. My husband used to reassure me that I was doing just fine. One day my mother-in-law came by for an unexpected visit. Again I was mortified at the way my house looked so I apologized for it. She said something so kind. She looked at me and said “your house is not dirty. It is just lived in.”
So now I do not stress about it too much. I just do what I can to keep it as clean as I can and trust that if I ever see a rodent running across the floor I will need to re-evaluate what “lived in” looks like and make sure it does not look like the dump.
As to the Mary and Martha story, my priest gave a beautiful sermon on this. We all have to keep the balance between the Mary and Martha inside us all.
I know easier said than done.
 
Recently a friend admonished me for not keeping a clean and organized household for myself and my husband, and she asked me if I could think of a Saint who wasn’t clean and organized… admittedly I have never paid attention to this. Also, what exactly is the wife’s role anyhow? I would think to be a man, one would pick up after oneself!

I guess I viewed cleanliness as a human virtue like punctuality? but not necessarily a spiritual one. What do you think?
You will not find anything in Holy Scriptures nor the Catechism of the Catholic Church that dictates whose job it is to pick the husband’s underwear up off of the floor, if that is what you’re asking. Quite frankly, who does it at your house is none of your friend’s business. I’d talk to your husband about what he thinks, and if he says that the job you do and the priorities that you have are fine, then you can report that back to your friend…as in, “I think the Lord chose well for us, so why don’t you submit to your husband and I’ll submit to mine, thank you very much?”

There was a poster on CA who was of the opinion that household neatness ought to be looked at as part of the duty of hospitality: “Let mutual love continue. Do not neglect hospitality, for through it some have unknowingly entertained angels.” Heb. 13:1-2

If we keep our home in the condition that Martha Cilly (aka The FlyLady) calls “CHAOS” or “Can’t Have Anyone Over Syndrome”, then this poster thought that is when imperfect housekeeping gets to the point of spiritual fault. I would think that managing the refrigerator and pantry so that food does not go to waste is in that category, and the care of clothing and household items so that they are kept ready for use and not wasted by out neglect. I like that way of thinking.

OTOH, we must not neglect “the only necessary thing”, from the familiar story: As they continued their journey he entered a village where a woman whose name was Martha welcomed him. She had a sister named Mary (who) sat beside the Lord at his feet listening to him speak. Martha, burdened with much serving, came to him and said, “Lord, do you not care that my sister has left me by myself to do the serving? Tell her to help me.” The Lord said to her in reply, "Martha, Martha, you are anxious and worried about many things. There is need of only one thing. Mary has chosen the better part and it will not be taken from her. Luke 10:38-42 In other words, we have it from the red letters that exacting standards of hospitality are not something the Lord encourages.

From this we know that there is a point where the details of hospitality can take on too much importance. Certainly, time spent in prayer is a higher priority than care of the home. Both need to be seen to, but if something has to give, it is the housework that gives in first, not the prayer life. Yet how many of our friends inquire and admonish us about how much time we are spending at the feet of the Lord, encouraging us not to worry over other things to the expense of that?

We don’t hear very often how clean and organized the saints were, but we always hear that they were persons with profound lives of prayer. Their lives revolved around love of God and neighbor. Therefore, housework fits into keeping our homes hospitable and peaceful. It is not a primary virtue, but something we do as an expression and help to them.
 
Recently a friend admonished me for not keeping a clean and organized household for myself and my husband, and she asked me if I could think of a Saint who wasn’t clean and organized… admittedly I have never paid attention to this. Also, what exactly is the wife’s role anyhow? I would think to be a man, one would pick up after oneself!

I guess I viewed cleanliness as a human virtue like punctuality? but not necessarily a spiritual one. What do you think?
You’ve already gotten some really good advise…

So I just have to ask, am I the ONLY one that thinks when DH has tossed his underwear on the floor, he surely meant they were for the garbage. No??? I mean, he has a very clean house type of mother. So I KNOW he knows what a laundry basket is for. 😛
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top