Coming into the Church from a Strict WELS Family - Family Issues

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mberg3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mberg3

Guest
I was raised in a very strict WELS family and grew up opposing the Church. After meeting a Catholic girl and looking into things in more depth I have decided to join the Catholic Church and am currently in RCIA. The problem is that I have not told my family yet and I feel as though I would be disowned if I told them of my choice. They are not interested in hearing any arguments for Catholicism because they feel as though the Papacy is the anti-christ and that the Church is the Whore of Babylon. What are my options?
 
You can either tell them (gently and charitably, but boldly) and take the risk of them distancing themselves from you, or you can try to keep it a secret. If you really live your Catholic faith and you make the choice to keep it a secret, eventually that will fail, unless you simply quit seeing your family.

If I were in your place, I would rather make the hard, right decision rather than the easy, wrong decision, and I feel like trying to keep it a secret is the wrong thing to do.

Good luck and God bless! I will pray for you.
 
I definatly want to tell them… its just the how that is bothering me. Are there any strategies to bringing it up or should i just do it. I know that there are several converts on this site and maybe some could give me advice.
 
I am in very much the same situation and when I tell my family over Christmas, I will tell them I want to talk about something a few days ahead of time, and not to be worried (I’m not dropping out of school, on drugs, etc…). I’ll tell them my news, show them how happy I am about this decision, and tell them I will be willing to answer any questions if I am able, but I do not wish to get into any arguments. I will listen to any concerns they have, but I will not get defensive.

If your family brings up legitimate concerns you have not heard before, research their questions and/or ask a priest about them. Show your family that you DO care about them and want them to be comfortable with your decision, but don’t let them take away the joy that is in you and your desire to know God even better.

I’ve also considered writing my parents a letter, but I am not sure about that.
 
I DO want them to understand, but I feel like they wont take the effort to even ask questions. To them it would be like selling my soul to the devil or turning my back on the family. It doesn’t help that I am living with them at the moment: if there was the distance I think it would make telling them easier.
 
I definatly want to tell them… its just the how that is bothering me. Are there any strategies to bringing it up or should i just do it. I know that there are several converts on this site and maybe some could give me advice.
Tell them that you love them and always will, without qualification. Thank them for raising you in a faith filled environment and for always supporting your journey. Ask for their understanding, if not acceptance, of your journey as it has led you to an unexpected and surprising path to the Catholic Church.

They may surprise you, but be prepared for anger and hurt. Reiterate that you love them and are not trying to convert them, that you continue to respect their faith, but this is your path. Answer their questions or get back to them if you don’t know the answer.

Eventually they will accept it, maybe quickly or maybe not. Eventually they may change some of their anti-Catholic misconceptions.

BTW - I converted from the ELCA after 56 years as a “cradle Lutheran”. Of course, ELCA and WELS are worlds apart.
 
Thank you Lutherlic
Yes they defiantly are WORLDS apart. My family already knows that I am going to RCIA classes and some of that hurt and anger is already building over that. I had hoped that they would respect my decision early on, but if the early reactions are anything to go by, they wont react well at all.
 
Well, I pretty much told my family I wanted to be Catholic from my Christmas list this year. 😃 But I wouldn’t bring it up unless religion is talked about and you’re brought into it. Then I’d bring it up and explain why to your family. Luckily for me, I’m in the ELCA. 😉 Good luck on your journey and God bless. 🙂
 
I was raised in a very strict WELS family and grew up opposing the Church. After meeting a Catholic girl and looking into things in more depth I have decided to join the Catholic Church and am currently in RCIA. The problem is that I have not told my family yet and I feel as though I would be disowned if I told them of my choice. They are not interested in hearing any arguments for Catholicism because they feel as though the Papacy is the anti-christ and that the Church is the Whore of Babylon. What are my options?
Can you please tell me what WELS stands for?
 
Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod?

Not a catfish, nor a river in Austria, at any rate! 🙂
 
Well, if it makes it any easier, if they know you are in RCIA, they may be expecting this (granted, a lot of folks who attend RCIA do it just as an inquiry, but still…)

You need to tell them about your entering the Church. For one thing, it’s the right thing to do (Jesus said that whoever denies Him before men, He will deny before the Father…don’t be afraid of professing your Catholic faith!) Also, they’re going to find out about it eventually, one way or another, and if they find out that you’ve been hiding it from them, that would probably go over worse than if you simply be frank and tell them.

I would suggest avoiding getting into a debate with them when you tell them. I imagine that emotions would be running high, and a debate could easily get out of control, and, as you said, they don’t seem to be open to discussing things. There will be plenty of other occasions to witness the Catholic faith to them and explain your reasons/convictions for converting. In the long run, if they seem resistant to discussing things, you could always write a letter discussing your reasons for converting (David Currie did that, and it ended up turning into a rather good apologetics book 👍 ) People tend to be more receptive to books, recorded talks, and other forms of pre-recorded media that they can’t get into an argument with.

They may see it as turning your back on the family or abandoning your faith, but perhaps it would be helpful to turn that reasoning on its head and, first, thank them for giving you a solid Christian upbringing. Explain that you are doing this out of obedience to that same Christian faith, that you have become intellectually convinced that the Catholic Church is, in fact, the Church that Jesus founded, and that you feel compelled by conscience and obedience to Christ to join it (but, again, don’t let it turn into a heated argument).

I converted to the Catholic Church after leaving the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. However, I had it pretty easy; my parents were pretty supportive of me (one of them still attends the LCMS, the other hasn’t been a church attendee since his childhood). It also helped because I had stopped being Lutheran 5 1/2 months earlier, and my parents knew that I was looking to convert to either the Catholic Church or the Orthodox Church.
 
Well, if it makes it any easier, if they know you are in RCIA, they may be expecting this (granted, a lot of folks who attend RCIA do it just as an inquiry, but still…)

You need to tell them about your entering the Church. For one thing, it’s the right thing to do (Jesus said that whoever denies Him before men, He will deny before the Father…don’t be afraid of professing your Catholic faith!) Also, they’re going to find out about it eventually, one way or another, and if they find out that you’ve been hiding it from them, that would probably go over worse than if you simply be frank and tell them.

I would suggest avoiding getting into a debate with them when you tell them. I imagine that emotions would be running high, and a debate could easily get out of control, and, as you said, they don’t seem to be open to discussing things. There will be plenty of other occasions to witness the Catholic faith to them and explain your reasons/convictions for converting. In the long run, if they seem resistant to discussing things, you could always write a letter discussing your reasons for converting (David Currie did that, and it ended up turning into a rather good apologetics book 👍 ) People tend to be more receptive to books, recorded talks, and other forms of pre-recorded media that they can’t get into an argument with.

They may see it as turning your back on the family or abandoning your faith, but perhaps it would be helpful to turn that reasoning on its head and, first, thank them for giving you a solid Christian upbringing. Explain that you are doing this out of obedience to that same Christian faith, that you have become intellectually convinced that the Catholic Church is, in fact, the Church that Jesus founded, and that you feel compelled by conscience and obedience to Christ to join it (but, again, don’t let it turn into a heated argument).

I converted to the Catholic Church after leaving the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. However, I had it pretty easy; my parents were pretty supportive of me (one of them still attends the LCMS, the other hasn’t been a church attendee since his childhood). It also helped because I had stopped being Lutheran 5 1/2 months earlier, and my parents knew that I was looking to convert to either the Catholic Church or the Orthodox Church.
I hope so. Unfortuately my parents are very devout in the WELS and I was seen as an expert on Lutheran apology and I was highly pushed into trying to be a pastor. Because of this I think they will take it harder than most.
 
I was raised in a very strict WELS family and grew up opposing the Church. After meeting a Catholic girl and looking into things in more depth I have decided to join the Catholic Church and am currently in RCIA. The problem is that I have not told my family yet and I feel as though I would be disowned if I told them of my choice. They are not interested in hearing any arguments for Catholicism because they feel as though the Papacy is the anti-christ and that the Church is the Whore of Babylon. What are my options?
WELS: Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod

I had no idea what WELS was & had to Google it.

Loving honesty with your family. I am the only person in my side of the family to have become a Catholic and am currently in the living room with very devote non-Catholic Christians. They really feel that the Catholic Church isn’t even Christian. And a relative by married here with me now sats that he actually left the Catholic Church to become a Christian. There was so much tension and hurt feelings on both sides; however, honesty is the best way to approach the required change of family.
 
If they already know you are in RCIA, they are kind of already prepared for this. One way you can show them that you still care about them is to invite them to your confirmation. This is an important time of your life. Some people have told me it’s like getting married in a way. You’d want your family at your wedding!

I was anti-Catholic for a long time. With a lot of prayer from a friend I eventually turned around. It takes time for hearts to be softened. Keep praying for your family.
 
I wish you the best! I really have no concrete advice for you, but I am (was raised) WELS, but half of my family and a lot of my friends are Catholic, and I find the WELS, though they will never admit it is very similar to the Catholic church when it comes to the liturgy and such. Perhaps it would help to point out the similarities between the churches?

Just a suggestion. But in my experience, some people refuse to see this. That’s why I can’t tell my friends and family who are WELS that I am involved in the Catholic student ministry at my university (long story, I have CP and the campus priest worked at a therapy camp I attended as a child so it provides me with an amazing community and support system!).

God Bless!
 
I wish you the best! I really have no concrete advice for you, but I am (was raised) WELS, but half of my family and a lot of my friends are Catholic, and I find the WELS, though they will never admit it is very similar to the Catholic church when it comes to the liturgy and such. Perhaps it would help to point out the similarities between the churches?

Just a suggestion. But in my experience, some people refuse to see this. That’s why I can’t tell my friends and family who are WELS that I am involved in the Catholic student ministry at my university (long story, I have CP and the campus priest worked at a therapy camp I attended as a child so it provides me with an amazing community and support system!).

God Bless!
Hey
Thanks for your advice. Is there any reason in particular you have not become catholic as of yet?
 
Hey
Thanks for your advice. Is there any reason in particular you have not become catholic as of yet?
Umm, I get that question a lot on here, though not at all from my friends in CCM. Lots of personal reasons, a main reason is I’d be lying if I said I believed all that is required to believe to become Catholic. I won’t go into details as I don’t want to get into a debate over doctrine. I highly respect Catholic belief and doctrine but I can’t in good conscience convert.
 
PS. My parents do know I am involved in CCM and they are supportive as they know it helps me feel a sense of belonging since having a obvious disability on a campus of 7,000 and there are only 2 other students who have the same category of disability, it is very isolating. Also everyone at CCM respects my decision not to convert which is nice as there is no pressure.
 
I think you should just consider telling them. I was raised LDS and I can tell you my decision to join one of the most conservative (read Catholic by my family) Lutheran Synods caused no small amount of trepidation. But with time things have sett;ed down because all of my family can see that my closer walk has much improved, I am happier my family is happier than before. So tell the truth, trust God, and be satisfied in doing the right thing.

“Unto thine own self be true and then it must follow, as the night the day, that no man will find you false.”

As far as why have I not joined?

There are some core Catholic beliefs that ZI walk right up to the edge of but have not jumped into. I intended to take RCIA this year but I have been really sick for a while now and that fell through. So I would say I am open to the Church I just have some questions I need answered.

God Bless
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top