Commentary on Daniel

  • Thread starter Thread starter COPLAND_3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

COPLAND_3

Guest
litteralchristianlibrary.wetpaint.com/page/Daniel+7

Here is the beginning of a project that I am doing right now on Daniel. It will be a commentary on Daniel much like the Catena Aurea of the Gospels done by St. Thomas, which are citations from the Early Church Fathers for every verse. Right now I am working on Daniel 7-12. I did similar works on Revelation, Jonah, James, etc.

Any suggestions would be great!
 
I appreciate this offer and look forward reading tour notes/commentatry on Daniel.
However, I would like to know whether or not Fr. John Corapi received my wuestion. in other words, did you forward my question to him?
 
I appreciate this offer and look forward reading tour notes/commentatry on Daniel.
However, I would like to know whether or not Fr. John Corapi received my wuestion. in other words, did you forward my question to him?
On the other hand, if you can rpovide his correct email so i can sent it myeslf, I’ll appreciate it.
 
Very helpful, thanks!

If you add footnotes saying where you found the quotes in the fathers that would be even more helpful I think
 
Very helpful, thanks!

If you add footnotes saying where you found the quotes in the fathers that would be even more helpful I think
Your right. I always did provide that in my other catenas, and i think I will do the same here. I wasn’t sure whether anyone would care about it or not, but thanks for the heads up! 👍
 
I find it interesting that Ephrem the Syrian said the “little horn” was antiochus epiphanes… if that is the case, then how does Christ fit into the prophecy, and who is the “Ancient of Days”?
 
I find it interesting that Ephrem the Syrian said the “little horn” was antiochus epiphanes… if that is the case, then how does Christ fit into the prophecy, and who is the “Ancient of Days”?
That is the argument that the great Theodoret makes, that I need to add. Theodoret makes that case at the end of chapter 7.

Great observation Neil!
 
:onpatrol:

Hi Copland, is that a photo of you – “JohnLitteral”>?

:idea:

I am not sure exactly how you intend the resource to be used. But I was thinking that, although individual verses were explained in various ways, that unless one was trying to examine a specific verse and already had an idea of what the text was about – that it would be easy to get lost in the overall flow of the passage.
So, perhaps you might thing about an overview or outline; eg: use some of the ECF’s general remarks about the chapter or general vicinity, as well as comments on individual pericopes/passages.

I only have a limited selection of the ECF – and was surprised at the texts from Origen, as I don’t remember ever seeing those before; I thought I had all his writings!
(Not that he is considered orthodox, eg: by Jerome… but his views are important historically)

One of things that I am noticing, and I would have to dig for the references, is that there is a distinct lack of the interplay of pagan ideas/symbols in what I read.
Eg: The four winds show up in divine Greek mythology; (not that I suggest you paganize anything) – but I also seem to recall that OT Jewish sources similarly attributed there being four directions (winds). eg: those that blow throughout the day.

These seem to be related to the passage at hand; eg: The wind blew above the waters in the creation account (Genesis) and then the waters were divided, the heavens from those below – and Here we have 4 winds dividing the Macedonian empire up into four parts ( a similar divine theme ) – and they are over the “sea”, which in many OT references is made to the Pagans. (the world of people not specifically chosen, but mixed together.) The river from the Holy temple being that which makes fresh water of everything (am I remembering correctly?) – either Daniel or Ezekiel, and also there are references to the the sea/rivers flowing UP the hill to zion in reference to the conversion of the Gentiles.

It seems to me, that there ought to be more in the ECF on some of these points – if perhaps not on these passages specifically, at least to the general idea and meaning of images which recurr throughout the bible. eg: He makes his angels rushing winds (is a psalm also…I think) etc. The angels are viewed as guardians of nations, Michael being originally assigned to israel. So perhaps the theme could be expanded by locating the ECF’s who perhaps speak somewhat about whether or not angels also guided the Pagans (inasmuch as they would allow God to do so.)

I remember St. Paul, speaking at Athens, talking about the altar to the God with no name – and following the reference back historically, I came across Pagan prophecy involving the unusual sacrifice of sheep. etc. which shows quite strongly why st. Paul would sieze on the use of “dio” (merely meaning divinity, but which often meant Zeus) in the text as a reference to the God of Israel.

Daniel was in a foreign land, at this time, babylonian? I think?; and some of this imagery may also be related to the context he was in. Just as Revelation was hidden language to avoid the wrath of the Romans by John the Apostle; John was copying the literary style of Daniel (including the horns, and 10 of them which interprets Daniel retroactively) – and also the , oh, diptych type format – the first half being of one kind of narritive, and the second part being the prophetic imagery.
etc.

I Only have limited ECF texts – but I would almost bet that there is more if one were to dig/search across a wider body of them.

Keep going, I enjoy your stuff.
–Andrew.
 
Huiou Theou

Thanks for your suggestions and thoughts, as I always value them. The reference from Origen is found in his writing to Celsus 8.13; 10:34.

I have 2 collections of the Fathers, one from the Catholic University of America Press and the other being Hendrickson Pusblishers. I also have many commentary series from Bede and I have the Anient Christian commentaries series, etc, etc. That is from my home library, not including the resources I have on my website. I have gleaned from all my resources. There are other resources that I would like to use, but at the present time I don’t have access to. I would like to have Nicholas of Lyra’s commentary on Daniel, but I’m even sure if it has been translated into English yet or where to get it if it has, though I have looked for it. Also, if anyone can provide me with resources or citations that I don’t have already, then I would be very grateful!

I plan to provide Josephus, but he did not record chapter 7, but I will provide him in other chapters.

As for the flow of the commentary, I guess I could arrange it better to have a better flow, but the purpose of it is to provide a verse by verse commentary that gives you what the Church Fathers said about it to where you can view them all at one glance. I am also doing something that you won’t find in other catenas, and that is I am breaking down the verses in small sections.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top