By your standard, of course. The word “your” means the Catholics. It is Catholics that assert that God is almighty, God can do whatever he pleases (some Catholics - not all - even say that God can do logical impossibilities). From that it follows logically that God cannot be coerced. If God does not tolerate “sin”, that is his own choosing.
That is fine by me. It is again the apologists who wish to say all sorts of “good things” about God, but they do not like when atheists use those same arguments and show the logical errors in them. Why not use the same standard? If the atheists are “unqualified” to say problematic things about God, then the believers are also unqualified to say good things about God.
Yes, I can see that. Far be it from me to “force” you to change your priorities. If you follow Luther, who said that “reason must be made the handmaiden of faith”, or even stronger “reason must be trampled underfoot”, that is your business. In one aspect I agree with you, even if you did not say it outright: “reason and faith cannot mix”. If something is reasonable, there is no need for faith. If one needs faith then it is unreasonable.

Have fun my friend. Our differences are irreconcilable. Wishing you the best.