A
Alex246
Guest
After reading on these forums, without fail, that “Mere Christianity” by C.S. Lewis was a great book, I decided to read it. I’m going through a pretty tough, emotionally confusing time in my life, and I thought it would be a great book to get me through it. But for some reason, it’s only been trouble throughout the entire thing.
First I was just having issues with the ways he proved God. I personally don’t find the arguments he uses very persuasive, but I expected that my own experiences would dissuade any troublesome thoughts. For some reason this kept haunting me though. And it didn’t end there. Almost EVERY point he makes disturbs me for some reason, even to the point that I would call it terrifying. I have no idea what’s going on. And it only got worse once he got into theology. his descriptions of God just seemed to disturb me more than almost anything has ever done. It seemed to turn upside down every single thought I’ve ever had about God. And his chapter on pride seemed to plant a now unshakable doubt of the morality of sports, which is devastating since those are some of my favorite pastimes and bring me closer to God. I know this seems completely backwards, but it’s horribly difficult to deal with.
The worst thing is that EVERYONE seems to love this book! I’m afraid my perceptions of Christianity have been so wrong that everything I thought was the work of God in my life has been a naive assumption of mine. Everything I thought I understood about Christianity seems now to have been wishful thinking. I find it extremely difficult to believe that Lewis is really talking about the faith I’ve been trying so hard to follow. Maybe he’s just using language that throws me off for some reason, but I doubt it. I already struggle with scrupulosity and this is just the last straw. After reading about some converts’ experiences with revulsion to the Catholic faith near the end of RCIA, I think I’m going through a similar spiritual attack, as this very much is a “coming back to the faith” for me after some time. Please, any advice and prayers would be appreciated.
First I was just having issues with the ways he proved God. I personally don’t find the arguments he uses very persuasive, but I expected that my own experiences would dissuade any troublesome thoughts. For some reason this kept haunting me though. And it didn’t end there. Almost EVERY point he makes disturbs me for some reason, even to the point that I would call it terrifying. I have no idea what’s going on. And it only got worse once he got into theology. his descriptions of God just seemed to disturb me more than almost anything has ever done. It seemed to turn upside down every single thought I’ve ever had about God. And his chapter on pride seemed to plant a now unshakable doubt of the morality of sports, which is devastating since those are some of my favorite pastimes and bring me closer to God. I know this seems completely backwards, but it’s horribly difficult to deal with.
The worst thing is that EVERYONE seems to love this book! I’m afraid my perceptions of Christianity have been so wrong that everything I thought was the work of God in my life has been a naive assumption of mine. Everything I thought I understood about Christianity seems now to have been wishful thinking. I find it extremely difficult to believe that Lewis is really talking about the faith I’ve been trying so hard to follow. Maybe he’s just using language that throws me off for some reason, but I doubt it. I already struggle with scrupulosity and this is just the last straw. After reading about some converts’ experiences with revulsion to the Catholic faith near the end of RCIA, I think I’m going through a similar spiritual attack, as this very much is a “coming back to the faith” for me after some time. Please, any advice and prayers would be appreciated.