COMPLETELY unexpected faith crisis

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alex246
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Alex246

Guest
After reading on these forums, without fail, that “Mere Christianity” by C.S. Lewis was a great book, I decided to read it. I’m going through a pretty tough, emotionally confusing time in my life, and I thought it would be a great book to get me through it. But for some reason, it’s only been trouble throughout the entire thing.

First I was just having issues with the ways he proved God. I personally don’t find the arguments he uses very persuasive, but I expected that my own experiences would dissuade any troublesome thoughts. For some reason this kept haunting me though. And it didn’t end there. Almost EVERY point he makes disturbs me for some reason, even to the point that I would call it terrifying. I have no idea what’s going on. And it only got worse once he got into theology. his descriptions of God just seemed to disturb me more than almost anything has ever done. It seemed to turn upside down every single thought I’ve ever had about God. And his chapter on pride seemed to plant a now unshakable doubt of the morality of sports, which is devastating since those are some of my favorite pastimes and bring me closer to God. I know this seems completely backwards, but it’s horribly difficult to deal with.

The worst thing is that EVERYONE seems to love this book! I’m afraid my perceptions of Christianity have been so wrong that everything I thought was the work of God in my life has been a naive assumption of mine. Everything I thought I understood about Christianity seems now to have been wishful thinking. I find it extremely difficult to believe that Lewis is really talking about the faith I’ve been trying so hard to follow. Maybe he’s just using language that throws me off for some reason, but I doubt it. I already struggle with scrupulosity and this is just the last straw. After reading about some converts’ experiences with revulsion to the Catholic faith near the end of RCIA, I think I’m going through a similar spiritual attack, as this very much is a “coming back to the faith” for me after some time. Please, any advice and prayers would be appreciated.
 
After reading on these forums, without fail, that “Mere Christianity” by C.S. Lewis was a great book, I decided to read it. I’m going through a pretty tough, emotionally confusing time in my life, and I thought it would be a great book to get me through it. But for some reason, it’s only been trouble throughout the entire thing.

First I was just having issues with the ways he proved God. I personally don’t find the arguments he uses very persuasive, but I expected that my own experiences would dissuade any troublesome thoughts. For some reason this kept haunting me though. And it didn’t end there. Almost EVERY point he makes disturbs me for some reason, even to the point that I would call it terrifying. I have no idea what’s going on. And it only got worse once he got into theology. his descriptions of God just seemed to disturb me more than almost anything has ever done. It seemed to turn upside down every single thought I’ve ever had about God. And his chapter on pride seemed to plant a now unshakable doubt of the morality of sports, which is devastating since those are some of my favorite pastimes and bring me closer to God. I know this seems completely backwards, but it’s horribly difficult to deal with.

The worst thing is that EVERYONE seems to love this book! I’m afraid my perceptions of Christianity have been so wrong that everything I thought was the work of God in my life has been a naive assumption of mine. Everything I thought I understood about Christianity seems now to have been wishful thinking. I find it extremely difficult to believe that Lewis is really talking about the faith I’ve been trying so hard to follow. Maybe he’s just using language that throws me off for some reason, but I doubt it. I already struggle with scrupulosity and this is just the last straw. After reading about some converts’ experiences with revulsion to the Catholic faith near the end of RCIA, I think I’m going through a similar spiritual attack, as this very much is a “coming back to the faith” for me after some time. Please, any advice and prayers would be appreciated.
Hi, Alex. It would be very helpful if you would provide some examples, even just one quote from the book. If you are able to articulate what about the quote bothers you, then do so; otherwise, just post the quote(s).

Remember that C.S. Lewis was Anglican, not Catholic (although he was pretty close to Catholic in many of his beliefs). You may also be misinterpreting some of the things he’s saying because of your state of mind - for instance, I am pretty sure that C.S. Lewis did NOT think sports were immoral!

This is what struck me most about your post: “I’m going through a pretty tough, emotionally confusing time in my life”. Me too! Emotionally confused about sums it up. I’m also one of those struggling converts you read about … we are vulnerable, hurting and confused right now and sometimes apologetics doesn’t penetrate the cloud of painful emotion. I have to remind myself again and again that it is not a good idea to make decisions when I am tired, depressed and bewildered. See if you can rest in God… just talk to Him and tell Him your fears.

And again, if you could post some of the specific things that bother you, that would help us to be more specific in helping you. 🙂
 
Hi Alex,

We live in a world that doubts faith. People believe in themselves, and that’s just about it. There are influences out there to get you away from the faith, and many of them. It is very discouraging to read some of the things, because they can make you think that somebody just made everything up. I’ve felt it, I know. I reccomend that you read some Scripture and maybe the Catechism of the Catholic Church instead of other books like the one by CS Lewis. If you build up your faith, and you begin to know your personal truth, you won’t feel so discouraged.

Lord God,
Please help Alex seek you in truth and in faith. Please let them know that You are God, and begin to fall in love with Your Catholic Church. Please take away all discouragement and hurt and replace it with peace in what You have in store for them. I ask this through the intercession of Our Lady of Mt. Carmel.

Amen!
 
Alex,

I agree that it would help if you provided an example or two 🙂 or maybe you could describe, in your own words, what you believe about God? maybe it’s just the wording or the style that you had an issue with! Personally, “Mere Christianity” was the book that brought me to Christianity, before then I was agnostic. However, I haven’t read it as a Catholic and don’t know how it would seem from another person’s perspective. Remember that this is a work on apologetics, and written for a specific audience at a specific time in Britain. Maybe it’s just not your type of book, and other books would fit better…maybe it’s not your style. So it would really help if you provided an example 🙂

I don’t think that Lewis would have any problem with sports… he lived a very ‘normal’ life, he was a university professor and met up a lot with his friends, like JRR Tolkien, and even smoked! So I don’t think he’s talking about that, but about spiritual pride.

Maybe also scrupulosity is an issue here… try to trust God and - if you feel like all your ideas about God are false, there are only two alternatives - either they are, or you’re just worrying too much. Maybe it would help if you told us what your beliefs are, or spoke to a priest 🙂 are your beliefs in line with Catholic teaching?* then they are true *🙂 so don’t worry any further, if the Church would agree with your beliefs on God!

Personally, what has been really important to me about God is His love and mercy. Try to grow deeper in your understanding and trust in that. It’s only stressful to live the Christian life when we havent yet totally grasped how much God loves us… once that becomes a constant reality, we’re protected from so many doubts/spiritual attacks.

Try to just pray, or better yet - go to Adoration and just be there with Him 🙂

God bless you.
 
Dear Alex,

This book may be loved by some, but that doesn’t give it any authority.

It doesn’t bear an imprimatur.
It is one man’s perspective of Christianity.
It is not referred to in the bible, or the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
It is not required Christian or Catholic reading.
You do not need to regard it as anything by which you need to live your life,
or the means to measure the Church or God.

The writer is a good man, a fine man,
but there are many good men, and many books,
and you may need to read more books,
including again, the Bible, including the Catechism, which is readliy available online

vatican.va/archive/catechism/ccc_toc.htm

And writings which deepen your faith and understanding of the faith.

Please dear Alex, don’t allow a single book to distract you from your full embracing of the Sacraments and the Church, and God’s truth, not man’s perspective!

With best wishes and prayer,

Trishie
 
After reading on these forums, without fail, that “Mere Christianity” by C.S. Lewis was a great book, I decided to read it. I’m going through a pretty tough, emotionally confusing time in my life, and I thought it would be a great book to get me through it. But for some reason, it’s only been trouble throughout the entire thing.

First I was just having issues with the ways he proved God. I personally don’t find the arguments he uses very persuasive, but I expected that my own experiences would dissuade any troublesome thoughts. For some reason this kept haunting me though. And it didn’t end there. Almost EVERY point he makes disturbs me for some reason, even to the point that I would call it terrifying. I have no idea what’s going on. And it only got worse once he got into theology. his descriptions of God just seemed to disturb me more than almost anything has ever done. It seemed to turn upside down every single thought I’ve ever had about God. And his chapter on pride seemed to plant a now unshakable doubt of the morality of sports, which is devastating since those are some of my favorite pastimes and bring me closer to God. I know this seems completely backwards, but it’s horribly difficult to deal with.

The worst thing is that EVERYONE seems to love this book! I’m afraid my perceptions of Christianity have been so wrong that everything I thought was the work of God in my life has been a naive assumption of mine. Everything I thought I understood about Christianity seems now to have been wishful thinking. I find it extremely difficult to believe that Lewis is really talking about the faith I’ve been trying so hard to follow. Maybe he’s just using language that throws me off for some reason, but I doubt it. I already struggle with scrupulosity and this is just the last straw. After reading about some converts’ experiences with revulsion to the Catholic faith near the end of RCIA, I think I’m going through a similar spiritual attack, as this very much is a “coming back to the faith” for me after some time. Please, any advice and prayers would be appreciated.
Lewis is not for everyone…nor are his arguments the only ones 🙂 So set him aside.

In any case

As. St. Catherine points out Virtue is made strong by its opposite. Temptations are temptations…let us hold fast in the midst of them by the grace of God…remembering a thousand difficulties do not equal one doubt.

Sometimes one has to stand almost silently before such temptations…with ones Faith in Christ…as a martyr under their attack…

So hold fast to your confession.

Set Lewis aside and read the New Testament…and the Catechism…and Pope Benedict …his writings as Pope are particularly good!
 
Don’t be so anxious, my friend! Although, I know how you are feeling. For me, all it takes is one person’s contrary opinion to send me into a tailspin of doubt.

Just remember; this books is just the view OF ONE MAN. It’s HIS take on teachings. You, as a well rounded Catholic, know full well what is taught and expected. And you know how to apply those things to your everyday life. Lewis may have had the same truths, but just a different way of applying them. My dear, I know plenty of priests who love rooting for their favorite football team! There’s nothing prideful about some fun competition! If you aren’t crossing the line of being arrogant and overly indulgant in your prowess as an athlete, you’re doing no one any harm!

If you were to pick up another book written on the same topics by another person, you would have a whole new book! We have SO many answers, but they aren’t ALL the answers. There is SO MUCH left open for speculation and opinion. Lewis’s interpriations aren’t any more perfect than yours.
 
Alax

Please don’t be unsettled regarding your sports interests, your harmless recreations. Remember that Jesus went to parties, eg, a wedding reception [wedding feast of Cana] and he visited friends. Jesus’ first known miracle wasn’t anything lofty. He acted to prevent the hosts’ parents the embarrassment of running out of wine. Jesus is God but if you read scripture again carefully you will see again how natural He was…He cried over a friend’s death, he showed a range of human emotions. To be wholesomely human is not unholy. God made us human beings in His image and likeness.
If your sport meant that you neglected others well-being or neglected your current duty, or during sport you acted uncharitably, that would be wrong.

Alex, you will find the Church’s attitude to recreation embedded on this page of the Catechism of the Catholic Church

vatican.va/archive/catechism/p3s2c1a3.htm

2185 On Sundays and other holy days of obligation, the faithful are to refrain from engaging in work or activities that hinder the worship owed to God, the joy proper to the Lord’s Day, the performance of the works of mercy, and the appropriate relaxation of mind and body.

2187 Sanctifying Sundays and holy days requires a common effort. Every Christian should avoid making unnecessary demands on others that would hinder them from observing the Lord’s Day. Traditional activities (sport, restaurants, etc.), and social necessities (public services, etc.), require some people to work on Sundays, but everyone should still take care to set aside sufficient time for leisure. With temperance and charity the faithful will see to it that they avoid the excesses and violence sometimes associated with popular leisure activities. In spite of economic constraints, public authorities should ensure citizens a time intended for rest and divine worship. Employers have a similar obligation toward their employees."

Be at peace, Alex
 
Keep in mind that CS Lewis was a heretic. He was aware of the Catholic Church, but never converted. Therefore, I wouldn’t worry too much if what he wrote strikes you as odd.
 
Hi Alex,

I can totally relate to being upset about a book that was highly recommended. I have often heard great reviews and was highgly recommended a book that someone though could help me. And the only thing reading those books did made me feel worse for 2 reasons. 1-) I did not like the book 2-) if the book helps so many what is wrong with me for not being able to get help

The only thing you can do is get rid of the book. Not all books are for everyone. God is for everyone. Pray to God and ask him ‘Lord, what book do you want me to read or better yet God, is reading the tool You wish to use to help me or is there another tool for me. Lord, show me Your way for me’

As for sports, I think it is OK to practice sports at whatever level you are comfortable. There is nothing wrong with challenging yourself to do your personal best. The problem I have with sports is when Olympic Atheletes break their bones, continue to compete and after they win the medal, go to the hospital and wear the cast for 1 month. And then, they are used as a example to follow to prove the point to never give up. That is where I think sports are getting sinful. we are human and have the right to go easy on ourselves

CM
 
You said you were disturbed by Lewis’s arguments for proving the existence of God, but you don’t need that proved to you anyway. You already believe in and know God. Man’s attempts to describe God are almost always confusing and theoretically rebuttable. That doesn’t mean He’s not there. Nor does it mean that you don’t know him.
 
Keep in mind that CS Lewis was a heretic. He was aware of the Catholic Church, but never converted. Therefore, I wouldn’t worry too much if what he wrote strikes you as odd.
I dont think any of his beliefs are heretical… his theology is very similar to Catholic theology. Maybe what the OP has trouble with is just how it was phrased, and the whole style.

also the way we use the word “heretic” is to describe someone who had the truth and then knowingly started proclaiming heresies (like the Reformers)… CS Lewis was never a Catholic and from what I read about him, I believe he was writing based on what he knew and understood. I wouldn’t call him a “heretic”.
You said you were disturbed by Lewis’s arguments for proving the existence of God, but you don’t need that proved to you anyway. You already believe in and know God. Man’s attempts to describe God are almost always confusing and theoretically rebuttable. That doesn’t mean He’s not there. Nor does it mean that you don’t know him.
👍
 
The one thing that can disturb people is if they take some of the things he says literally. For example, he attacks the idea of Jesus being a good moral teacher but this is merely his criticism of the separation of the man Jesus from the God Jesus that scholars and people have tried to do. He thinks Jesus is a good moral teacher but more importantly Jesus is God.

The Trilemma can get to some people as the concept is very alien to many. Many do not want to think of Liar, Lunatic or Lord. It means making a hard choice between about the truth of the Christian religion. Some people have modified the trilemma into the pentalemma which is liar, lunatic, legend, or Lord. It isnt an easy question to ponder but it is right since because of the claims of Christ, no other explanation is possible other than those 4 or 3 for Lewis.
 
Keep in mind that CS Lewis was a heretic. He was aware of the Catholic Church, but never converted. Therefore, I wouldn’t worry too much if what he wrote strikes you as odd.
CS Lewis was a Christian respected by many in the Church. He is not labeled a heretic. One may read J. Pierce on his relation with the Catholic Church…and about conversion…

In any case…Lewis is not for everyone…so just set him aside and turn to the homilies of Pope Benedict XVI or his audiences on the Apostles or Paul 🙂
 
Thank you all for your support. After a good bit of prayer and scripture, I’ve calmed down quite a bit. Just so you all know, I do tend to struggle quite a bit with scrupulosity, and sometimes (like last night) it reaches almost “panic attack” levels. I really just needed to vent a little. I’ve decided that this book’s obviously not for me, and I don’t have any reason to keep reading it if it bothers me so much. Thank you so much.🙂
 
Thank you all for your support. After a good bit of prayer and scripture, I’ve calmed down quite a bit. Just so you all know, I do tend to struggle quite a bit with scrupulosity, and sometimes (like last night) it reaches almost “panic attack” levels. I really just needed to vent a little. I’ve decided that this book’s obviously not for me, and I don’t have any reason to keep reading it if it bothers me so much. Thank you so much.🙂
Yeah, I understand how one can get into frames of mind like that! Glad you’re feeling better. Scripture is a good resort.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top