confession and Eucharist

  • Thread starter Thread starter mariam1976
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mariam1976

Guest
I went to confession on thursday and yesterday i sinned by lying to my friend…
i want to go for mass today and take the holy eucharist. will i be committing a sin by doing so?
 
I went to confession on thursday and yesterday i sinned by lying to my friend…
i want to go for mass today and take the holy eucharist. will i be committing a sin by doing so?
I don’t want to quiz you about the exact circumstances of the lie. Without them it’s impossible to make a judgement over the internet.

If you’re really unsure, then don’t receive. You’re not going to suffer for showing this extra concern about receiving unworthily. I think Our Lord would be pleased that you did so.
 
A lie is sinful because it deforms the truth. There are varying degrees of importance of truths, and lies vary in their gravity.

If the lie you told to your friend is going to cause some serious harm, then, yes, you should confess before receiving Communion again.

If the lie was in a matter of lesser importance, say, whether or not you really like her new haircut, then it is probably a venial sin, and you can go ahead and receive Communion.

Please don’t tell us what the lie was.

Betsy
 
why do you think i should not tell you the lie?

i think it is a venial sin… as described by the PPP.

did not harm her.
 
What’s PPP?

I don’t think you should tell us what the lie was because it’s not really a good idea to confess your sins on a public forum such as this. You know, nothing ever really disappears from the Internet.

Betsy
 
PP = previous post right?
so i said ppp = previous previous post

sorry if that was offensive…
anyways it was a venial sin, i think.
 
LOL - not offensive at all. I just thought it was a reference of some sort, like the CCC!

If you think it was a venial sin, there’s nothing to keep you from Communion. God bless you.

Betsy
 
another question… so does that mean that venial sins are ok? like i can lie if it is not going to harm anyone? my husband used to lie a lot to me… about what he was doing and sometimes to avoid conflict… would that be considered ok?
i used to think that lying was in itself not right and should be avoided. It did not matter how big or small a lie
 
another question… so does that mean that venial sins are ok? like i can lie if it is not going to harm anyone? my husband used to lie a lot to me… about what he was doing and sometimes to avoid conflict… would that be considered ok?
i used to think that lying was in itself not right and should be avoided. It did not matter how big or small a lie
All sin should be avoided, but not all sins need to be confessed to a priest, and not all will be serious enough to prevent you from receiving Communion. Only mortal sins need be sacramentally confessed before one can receive communion.

Now lying is an extremely broad category of sin, like stealing. Some lies and instances of stealing are venial sins - the matter of such sins just isn’t grave enough.

Stealing $5 from your mom’s change jar will in most circumstances be a venial sin and won’t prevent you receiving communion. Same with, for example, telling your friend that you like her new shoes when you really don’t.

Surely you can see that these are very different in severity to, for example, stealing $5 million from a bank, or lying about your qualifications to get a job you’re completely unsuited for and unable to do properly. These two would certainly be grave sins and probably mortal.
 
if i had known this before, a lot of problems in my marriage could have been avoided i think. i could not lie to him even when i knew that it would make him feel good as i thought that i was sinning.
 
if i had known this before, a lot of problems in my marriage could have been avoided i think. i could not lie to him even when i knew that it would make him feel good as i thought that i was sinning.
No, don’t think of it that way. Venial sin, and people who constantly tempt or demand that you commit venial sins, really should be avoided too.

If the only way to keep your husband feeling good about himself/yourself/your relationship is to frequently lie, even if they’re only small lies, you’re better off away from him.
 
Being a venial sin does not make something OK to do. It is still a sin, but not one that severs your relationship with God as a mortal sin does.

Some lies are mortal sins. Some lies are venial sins. A lie to a spouse that destroys trust is probably a mortal sin. Trust in a marriage is very important, a good that must be preserved. A lie to avoid conflict could go either way. When you ask, “Do I look fat in this,” do you want him to be brutally honest, or do you want him to reassure you, especially if it’s too late to change your clothes!

Sometimes, another person does not have the right to the truth. A common example is the Nazi’s question, “Are you hiding Jews in your home?” Because the Nazis are going to do harm to the Jews if you turn them in, they do not have the right to the correct answer. While you should not tell an outright untruth, you may answer in an ambiguous way that will lead to the Nazi drawing an incorrect conclusion. Like, “Good heavens, I hardly have room for my own family in this tiny house!”

The truth is very important, and we should strive always to honor the truth, and to be truthful in our words. The fact that some lies are less serious than others does not make it OK to form the habit of lying about small things. That can lead to lying about big things and mortal sin.

Betsy
 
That something is a Venial Sin doesn’t make it Not Sin.

Lying is always still a sin, but there are different degrees of sin.

Venial Sins (little sins that don’t hurt anyone) are forgiven when we make the Sign of the Cross or use Holy Water, or pray the Rosary, or go to Mass - we say we are sorry directly to God while doing these things, and God forgives them then.

You are right not to lie to your husband, but at the same time, it is not necessary to fill him in on every nitpicking detail of your life, either.
 
u r right… there were times when i could have not said things but i felt that i had to be completely honest with him so would tell him… and i could see that it had hurt him. Ijust wanted him to know that i would be truthful to him even if it was hurting me as i knew that it would lower me in his eyes…

i dont know but i am so confused right now… anyways… thanks for the information. you are the best
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top