Confession over the Telephone

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nelka

New member
I just wondered if it would ever be allowed to have confession over the telephone?

I am thinking in the scenario that you are dying and a priest will not be able to get to you on time would you be able to have confession over the telephone. I don’t mean in a manner where you can’t be bothered to go to the church but just in this instance?

Thanks.
 
I’m quite sure it has to be done in person. One who’s in mortal sin and about to die should say a perfect Act of Contrition and hope a priest can see them before death.

I’ve also wondered what a priest in a remote area who needs to say a Mass but thinks he might be in mortal sin would do if there were no other priests around to hear a confession.
 
Awhile back DH and I watched a documentary on Father Damien, who worked with the lepers of Molokai. He was without a priest for years at a time…wanted so much to go to Confession, but no priest was sent to him for a long, long time. So he would go into the church, kneel in front of Jesus in the tabernacle and confess his sins.

This put a lump in my throat…that he hungered so much for the sacrament, but couldn’t receive it, so did what he could. I’m sure God smiled down on him.
 
It is my understanding that because (1) there is no guarantee of privacy and (2) it is not done in person so there’s no guarantee that the person confessing is actually the person confessing and the person hearing the confession is actually a priest, confession via telephone is not allowed. Not just cell phones, Skype, etc., but land-lines as well.
 
I know that the Church does not currently allow confession over the phone.

I think it did back in the old days. As a child, I remember seeing phones in the confessional for the hearing impaired. We were behind screens. The priest and the person confessing could not see other. The confession was heard over the phone.
 
I don’t think it is possible at least in the near future. The security and the spirituality is exposed to technlogy which brings down the original intention of the sacrament.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top