A
Athanasius
Guest
First, I should state that I am scrupulous, and how I am describing my problem is by describing the “worst case scenario”, just to be on the safe side. I try to do that, just in case. Anyway, I have some questions about past confessions…
How I used to approach confession was this way: in between confessions, if I happened to remember a mortal sin from way back in my past that I had forgotten to confess (or one I had confessed but forgotten to confess relevant details), I would write it down on a piece of paper, and “file it away” for the next time I went to confession. So that when I started to prepare for confession, I would just go to my “files” of sins I had written down, and prepare my confession that way, and not even do an examination of conscience for anything in my “past”;
I would only do an examination of conscience for everything since my previous confession.
However, I was thinking today, and I’m afraid that there may have been times in the past when I was doing this process, that whenever I remembered sins from my past like I described as above, I may have deceived myself into thinking they were not mortal sins, so I didn’t have to confess them, when in fact they were mortal. I rationalized them away. So in fact I never recorded these sins in my “files” to be retrieved later when preparing for confession.
Then later on, when I started to prepare to go to confession (whether that was days or weeks or months later, or however short or long of a time it was), when I was going to prepare the list of sins to confess from the past, I wouldn’t even bother doing an examination of conscience for the “past”, and just do it for stuff since my last confession. For the “past”, I would just go to my “files”, assuming I had everything there I needed. When I went to confession, I was doing it in good faith. I tried to make good confessions. But due to the fact that I had previously never recorded those sins described above, because I rationalized them away as not being mortal, and because when actually preparing for confession, I honestly wasn’t thinking it necessary to examine my conscience for anything in the past, and only doing it for stuff since my last confession, when I did go to confession, I ended up never confessing those sins, though later on I did. (Again, when I went to confession itself, it was in good faith, and I did try to make a valid confession.).
Similarly, there were many times in the past where the scenario would be this way: where between one confession and the next, I might have committed mortal sin, and rationalized it away, thus not recording it so as to make sure to confess it at my next confession. Then when I actually got ready to go to confession, even after doing an examination of conscience, I would think I had already "covered’ all those particular sins, and since before I had decided they were not sins, I would not bother mentioning them (honestly not remembering that I had rationalized them away when reviewing them before, and that I really should have confessed them). So again, I went to confession in good faith, and tried to make a good confession, but ended up not confessing certain sins for reasons mentioned above.
There may have even been times where in preparing for confession and making a list, I might have engaged in rationalizing certain sins away, thus not including them on the list. But by the time I actually went into the confessional (which could have half an hour up to a few days later), I did try to make a good confession, and just automatically trusted that my list included everything on it I needed to confess, and so just read the list without really paying attention (due to my general nervousness when going to confession).
Now, I should point out that in the above scenarios, it is also possible that I did not in fact rationalize anything away. It might have been that when above I was “rationalizing” away mortal sins, in reality I honestly thought I had not committed mortal sin (and perhaps I wasn’t). In fact, I think that is quite possibly the case. (Especially I think it likely I did not “rationalize” anything away right before my preparation for confession, just a half hour away, though now I am worried, probably unnecessary).
It might be simply my present scrupulosity making me assume the worst about what I did in the past. (In any case, I have since confessed all of those sins in subsequent confessions, just to be on the safe side).
(continued in another post)
How I used to approach confession was this way: in between confessions, if I happened to remember a mortal sin from way back in my past that I had forgotten to confess (or one I had confessed but forgotten to confess relevant details), I would write it down on a piece of paper, and “file it away” for the next time I went to confession. So that when I started to prepare for confession, I would just go to my “files” of sins I had written down, and prepare my confession that way, and not even do an examination of conscience for anything in my “past”;
I would only do an examination of conscience for everything since my previous confession.
However, I was thinking today, and I’m afraid that there may have been times in the past when I was doing this process, that whenever I remembered sins from my past like I described as above, I may have deceived myself into thinking they were not mortal sins, so I didn’t have to confess them, when in fact they were mortal. I rationalized them away. So in fact I never recorded these sins in my “files” to be retrieved later when preparing for confession.
Then later on, when I started to prepare to go to confession (whether that was days or weeks or months later, or however short or long of a time it was), when I was going to prepare the list of sins to confess from the past, I wouldn’t even bother doing an examination of conscience for the “past”, and just do it for stuff since my last confession. For the “past”, I would just go to my “files”, assuming I had everything there I needed. When I went to confession, I was doing it in good faith. I tried to make good confessions. But due to the fact that I had previously never recorded those sins described above, because I rationalized them away as not being mortal, and because when actually preparing for confession, I honestly wasn’t thinking it necessary to examine my conscience for anything in the past, and only doing it for stuff since my last confession, when I did go to confession, I ended up never confessing those sins, though later on I did. (Again, when I went to confession itself, it was in good faith, and I did try to make a valid confession.).
Similarly, there were many times in the past where the scenario would be this way: where between one confession and the next, I might have committed mortal sin, and rationalized it away, thus not recording it so as to make sure to confess it at my next confession. Then when I actually got ready to go to confession, even after doing an examination of conscience, I would think I had already "covered’ all those particular sins, and since before I had decided they were not sins, I would not bother mentioning them (honestly not remembering that I had rationalized them away when reviewing them before, and that I really should have confessed them). So again, I went to confession in good faith, and tried to make a good confession, but ended up not confessing certain sins for reasons mentioned above.
There may have even been times where in preparing for confession and making a list, I might have engaged in rationalizing certain sins away, thus not including them on the list. But by the time I actually went into the confessional (which could have half an hour up to a few days later), I did try to make a good confession, and just automatically trusted that my list included everything on it I needed to confess, and so just read the list without really paying attention (due to my general nervousness when going to confession).
Now, I should point out that in the above scenarios, it is also possible that I did not in fact rationalize anything away. It might have been that when above I was “rationalizing” away mortal sins, in reality I honestly thought I had not committed mortal sin (and perhaps I wasn’t). In fact, I think that is quite possibly the case. (Especially I think it likely I did not “rationalize” anything away right before my preparation for confession, just a half hour away, though now I am worried, probably unnecessary).
It might be simply my present scrupulosity making me assume the worst about what I did in the past. (In any case, I have since confessed all of those sins in subsequent confessions, just to be on the safe side).
(continued in another post)