Confession to heretical priest

  • Thread starter Thread starter MilesVitae
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MilesVitae

Guest
My pastor seems to believe that homosexuality is morally permissible, to name one of several areas which he seems to be in heresy.

This being so, is it wrong for me to go to confession to him?
 
Seems to think and does think are two very different ball games.

As long as he is not censured then it is fine to go to him. But it is always best to go to a good and holy Priest who is faithful to the Church, that way you know his advice is good.
 
He has never said it explicitly, although I am very sure he does, from other things he has said. He has also said Christ did not know who he was until later in His life, and holds to a liberal notion of conscience (the Church teaches what it teaches, but you have to follow your own conscience).
 
As long as he is an ordained priest then your confession is valid. This goes for receiving the Holy Eucharist from him as well, along with any of the sacraments. The sacraments are not dependent on the holiness of the priest performing them. I forget exactly where in the Catechism this is stated, but the Church does state that the sacraments are not invalidated simply because the priest is not a good priest. Now were a priest to be stripped of his faculties then this would be a different story, but so long as this has not happened then you have nothing to worry about. However, as the other poster mentioned you might want to go to another priest for the sacrament of reconciliation if you are worried about your priest’s orthodoxy so that you may get more sound advice. No one is required to go to their parish priest for confession.

Lastly, it may be a good idea to make an appointment to just sit and chat with your priest and truly find out where he stands instead of making assumptions. You very well may be correct in your assumptions, but until you’ve given the man a chance to explain himself clearly you can’t be certain. Also, remember that priests are people too. They sin, make mistakes, and can fall into error just like the rest of us. When this happens they need help just like we do and so this could also be an opportunity for you to help a fellow Christian along the path to Christ. 🙂
 
My pastor seems to believe that homosexuality is morally permissible, to name one of several areas which he seems to be in heresy.

This being so, is it wrong for me to go to confession to him?
No. As long as he has faculties, he has the authority to forgive sins. Ultimately its Jesus who forgives sins. A sinful priest does not affect the power of God. If you shine a light through a dirty and rusted pipe, the light shines through to the other side still pure. Such is the power and love of God.
 
He has never said it explicitly, although I am very sure he does, from other things he has said. He has also said Christ did not know who he was until later in His life, and holds to a liberal notion of conscience (the Church teaches what it teaches, but you have to follow your own conscience).
While he is validly hearing your confession and validly giving you absolution, any advice he gives you beyond the penance might be suspect. Keep in mind, though, that St. Teresa of Jesus was able to turn one of her confessors away from a sinful attachment by her good example and prayers. If your have any sort of friendly relationship with him beyond the confessional, you might like to find some books or articles to give to him that might help him be better formed and informed in his priestly vocation.
 
Thank you.

I understand that the personal holiness of the minister has no effect upon the sacraments. My fear was, if he is in heresy, could he have excommunicated himself (and, thus, would it be impermissible to go to him for confession).
 
Thank you.

I understand that the personal holiness of the minister has no effect upon the sacraments. My fear was, if he is in heresy, could he have excommunicated himself (and, thus, would it be impermissible to go to him for confession).
If you are unaware of their excommunication, I think the Church may supply the faculties for your benefit. Its the same if you are in danger of death, any valid priest with no faculties will have the faculties supplied automatically by law for the benefit of the penitent, not the priest.
 
The church does not condemn homosexuality, it condemns those who practice it sexually. I have a good friend who is homosexual, but is celibate. Is he to be condemned? :confused:

Your confession is valid. But if you feel uncomfortable, go to another priest. If you don’t know who is hearing confession when you want to go, just call the rectory and ask who is hearing confession that day. They will know. If he is the only priest in your parish, you may certainly go to another parish for confession.
 
My pastor seems to believe that homosexuality is morally permissible, to name one of several areas which he seems to be in heresy.

This being so, is it wrong for me to go to confession to him?
It probably wouldn’t be wrong, per se, but it might not be the greatest idea either.
 
The church does not condemn homosexuality, it condemns those who practice it sexually. I have a good friend who is homosexual, but is celibate. Is he to be condemned? :confused:
When I said “homosexuality” I meant the practice of homosexuality, not same-sex attraction of itself.
 
My pastor seems to believe that homosexuality is morally permissible, to name one of several areas which he seems to be in heresy.
Knowing that SSA is a personal preference - is not a sin. How a person acts upon those desires is what is important. Noncelibate SSA (man on man and female on female sexual acts) are a sin.

The same rule applies to single heterosexuals, separated or divorced heterosexuals, etc.

God blesses the sexual acts of one man and one woman inside the Sacrament of Marriage.
 
My pastor seems to believe that homosexuality is morally permissible, to name one of several areas which he seems to be in heresy.

This being so, is it wrong for me to go to confession to him?
Why then, do you write “seems to believe”. Either he does or he doesn’t.

As above, ask to sit down and find out his views. Tell him about your concerns with what you heard he say.

What people hear a priest say, may not be at all correct with what he actually said or meant to get across.
 
I understand that the personal holiness of the minister has no effect upon the sacraments. My fear was, if he is in heresy, could he have excommunicated himself (and, thus, would it be impermissible to go to him for confession).
From my reading of canon law, I don’t think that excommunication makes the celebration of a sacrament invalid, unless explicitly specified by the judge.

Especially, however, heresy must be an obstinate denial.

Further, a canon does not apply if there is doubt. You have doubt as to his excommunication, therefore, as it relates to you, he is not excommunicated.
 
Especially, however, heresy must be an obstinate denial.
Forgive me for my lack of technical terms, but isn’t there two types of heresy?
  1. The kind where you know what you are doing (Formal Heresy?)
  2. The kind where you don’t (Material Heresy?)
 
My pastor seems to believe that homosexuality is morally permissible, to name one of several areas which he seems to be in heresy.

This being so, is it wrong for me to go to confession to him?
If you’re confessing that particular sin, I can see where you should look for a different confessor.

Otherwise, I can’t see it to be a particularly problem.
 
From my reading of canon law, I don’t think that excommunication makes the celebration of a sacrament invalid, unless explicitly specified by the judge.
It does with Confession. Because a priest would need faculties. If a priest is excommunicated, then he cannot have faculties unless the Church through law would supply it as an act of mercy towards the penitent. This only happens in cases of necessity such as danger of death.
 
The church does not condemn homosexuality, it condemns those who practice it sexually. I have a good friend who is homosexual, but is celibate. Is he to be condemned? :confused:

Your confession is valid. But if you feel uncomfortable, go to another priest. If you don’t know who is hearing confession when you want to go, just call the rectory and ask who is hearing confession that day. They will know. If he is the only priest in your parish, you may certainly go to another parish for confession.
If one is celibate, then one is not homosexual. Homosexual means homo = same and sexual = well, sexual. So if you are not sexual, then you cannot really qualify as homosexual. I think the term is SSA, or same sex attraction. It distinguishes those who are attracted to the same sex but doesn’t act on it, to those who do.
 
If one is celibate, then one is not homosexual. Homosexual means homo = same and sexual = well, sexual. So if you are not sexual, then you cannot really qualify as homosexual. I think the term is SSA, or same sex attraction. It distinguishes those who are attracted to the same sex but doesn’t act on it, to those who do.
By your logic, a celibate priest who is otherwise “normal” couldn’t be considered “heterosexual” either. So what would he be? Your example exhibits a flawed understanding of human nature. We are sexual beings apart from how we act - or don’t act - on that sexuality.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top