Confused - what exactly IS scandal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zynxensar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

Zynxensar

Guest
From what I’ve read, scandal is when your actions cause or influence someone else to sin and some obvious examples are getting drunk, using profane language, and immodest dress. Cool, there’s that but what about more uncommon stuff?

What if I read a fantasy novel about magic in public and it causes a child who notices what I’m reading to then develop a fascination for witchcraft in the future?

What if I watch an action movie with a moderate amount of violence and my friends (who know I’m Catholic) interpret it as “oh so u approve of violence”?

I know I’m sounding kinda scrupulous about this right now but I don’t really understand scandal fully so would appreciate if anyone could shed some light onto this.
 
As I said in your other thread:
We’re to avoid creating scandal for others. Scandal is when our actions have the probable effect of leading others into sin. Scandal does not exist because of the hypothetical possibility that someone may be led into sin as a result of our actions.
Seeing someone read Harry Potter is not likely to lead another into sin. You need to clarify regarding your violent movie example.
 
Scandal implies intent. Direct scandal has the deliberate intention to induce another to sin. In indirect scandal a person does something that he or she foresees will at least likely lead another to commit a sin. Avoiding indirect scandal is a matter of being conscientious about foreseeing the possible consequences of one’s actions. If a person foresees that his actions, even if not morally wrong, can or will lead to an evil consequence, such as scandal, then that person should refrain from the action at issue.
 
If my friends or others around me were likely to assume something harmful or be led to accept certain sin as permissable, or otherwise led to commit sin (due to ignorance, immaturity, lack of formed conscience, etc.), then I would watch what I do around them. In some cases it may be possible to clear things up, e.g. if they may assume I am doing something sinful due to a misunderstanding.

But yeah, it has mostly to do with being aware of and able to foresee the effects of your actions, while also being realistic enough to avoid freaking out over hypotheticals that there is no real reason to think will occur. Your other thread on conscience/scrupulosity relates to this well; an active, alert conscience is a good thing, and it should not be taken as a shock that people around you might not think twice about some of the things you may notice, but going overboard with it to the point of leaving reality is dangerous.
 
Last edited:
What if I read a fantasy novel
Reading fantasy novels is not inherently sinful. Therefore you cannot give scandal by doing something that is not immoral. If you do thing A, which is morally good or neutral, and somebody else does thing B, which is immoral, that is not scandal.

If I teach you to hunt with a rifle to shoot deer, and you shoot joe with the rifle, I did not give scandal.

If I do something sinful or approve of something sinful or encourage you to do something sinful, that is scandal.
What if I watch an action movie with a moderate amount of violence
That is also not inherently sinful.
 
Last edited:
Jesus taught, it is not what goes into a man that is corrupt, it is what comes out of him. In your conscience, if you believe your actions might cause another to “wander off the reservation” than maybe you best moderate that action. If that action is something that is controversial, you need to have a good rationale for your behavior if you are confronted or questioned. CAjun Joy’s answer about premarital cohabitation is a good one, that is objectively scandalous. Reading certain books or watching movies I think falls into a more “gray” area and is more dependent on your own conscience.
My two cents.
 
Therefore you cannot give scandal by doing something that is not immoral.
While true, isn’t there scandal taken in many scenarios like this (not necessarily these specific ones) which is to be avoided where possible?
 
Scandal of the weak is a thing and is to be avoided when it can be done conveniently.
 
Scandal of the weak is a thing and is to be avoided when it can be done conveniently.
Again doing something that is moral, is not scandal. So give me an example of what it is that you believe would be scandal here.
 
That isn’t an example. That is an encyclopedia article. Which I’ve read. Again if you read the very first sentence it talks about doing something that is intrinsically evil.
 
“To prevent another’s sin one may even be bound to forego an act which is sinful neither in itself nor in appearance, but which is nevertheless the occasion of sin to another, unless there be sufficient reason to act otherwise.”
 
To prevent another’s sin one may even be bound to forego an act which is sinful neither in itself nor in appearance, but which is nevertheless the occasion of sin to another, unless there be sufficient reason to act otherwise
Right, so don’t take it alcoholic to a bar.
 
I see. So using this example: if I read a novel about magic, introduce it to person B who develops a fascination of witchcraft (which is sinful) through reading this, I am not responsible for this person’s sin?
 
Unless you gave it to them wanting them to develop the fascination or knew there was a high probabilty of them developing it no sin.
 
No to the first one. As for the latter, would it be sin if we don’t know? I.e just recommending a book to a friend, while not knowing whether it would cause him to develop a fascination for witchcraft (even if the book portrayed magic in a neutral manner)
 
No, it would be a sin (or at least unwise) if you did know that they were they type that had a high probability of developing a fascination with the occult after reading a book. I’m also assuming that the book was Harry Potter like and not an occult book.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top