confused

  • Thread starter Thread starter Haviland
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Haviland

Guest
I confronted a friend about something that happened about 10 months ago. It has bothered me for a long time. We went back to the restaurant where it happened so I told her about why it was bothering me.
Three of us were taking each other out for our birthdays and buying a present. During a year we did it for my two friends but when my birthday came around they didn’t pay for my lunch. It made me feel unimportant, like they didn’t care, or thought that it was o.k., she won’t remember it. It had been bothering me for a long time. So I told my friend and she got defensive. She said that she didn’t remember what happened 10 months ago, and that I told her in a rude way. I remember telling her the story as calmly as I could and then her saying that she didn’t do it and that I probably forgot. I told her that I told my husband about it at the time and said, " would you like to talk to him", but she said: “Are you trying to give this off to him, and not talk to me?” ??? I told her that I was sorry for my approach but that this thing really bothered me. The next day she told me that it upset her and that she had been crying all day. We talked again but I don’t feel like anything was resolved, and that I was the bad guy. She turned this thing on me and it is hard to forget about it and move on. I just wanted an explanation, that was all. If she said that she didn’t realize that it was done, then we could have moved on…I have been looking at the Bible for what to do and it says to bring someone else into this conversation…however, I think that it would make it worse to bring it up again. Sorry this is so long, I hope you can understand it.
 
ISorry this is so long, I hope you can understand it.
it is not too long but I do not understand it
this is my reading, correct me if I am wrong
10 months ago, or more, you did a kind act for a friend, out of friendship, giving a gift, which by definition requires no reciprocation or condition. If it did, it would not be a gift, it would be a trade. 10 months later, or more, your friend did not make a gesture of any kind on your birthday. So what? big deal? why would you even bring it up, except for one motive, to make her feel guilty. That is not the action of friends, to manipulate each other, to demand gifts and tokens of affection, to coerce, to elicit bad feelings, to “demand explanations” for random actions or omissions. since you post the story I assume you are asking for (name removed by moderator)ut. mine is, look in the dictionary under “friendship” and revise your working definition
 
I am sorry to confuse you but all three of us agreed to take each other out and buy a gift for our birthdays. Read my amended post.
 
I still don’t get it. So what? apart from the rather unrealistic demands you and your friends seem to place on each other, I don’t get involving husbands in the discussion at all. My own would certainly not care, can’t imagine a husband who would welcome involvement in such a minor issue.
 
It happened you vented to your hubby why are you holding on to the bad feelings, you either have to drop the feelings or the friend. Is this coming to the surface because your friends want to go out for bdays again and you don’t want to be a part of it?
 
Sorry to say it, but I agree with puzzle as well. This is such a minor thing. So awhile ago you had a little agreement that was probably forgotten amongst your friends or there was probably some misunderstanding about it. Then its your birthday and they don’t get you what you’re expecting and you think they owe you and harbor anger against them for 10 months? Let it go. I’d go to confession for haboring anger and resentment over something so petty. I’d also apoligise to my friend for bringing it up so much after the fact and at the particular resteraunt. Taking her to the resteraunt seems rather inappropriate and spiteful.
 
Sometimes when things like this happen, I take it personally and feel awful. But then I think about all the times that I messed up with my friends, and that they forgave me, and I let it go.

The older I get, the more my friends and I are involved with stuff which is just convoluted. Our lives become like trying to gather up an octopus, and things slip through the cracks; stuff happens. Assume they didn’t mean it personally and let it go…
 
Yeah just let it slide. Just assume all forgot about the agreement. don’t take it personal. I’m of the impresssion folks put too much importance on birthdays anyway, from the time they are children and into adulthood seems folks expect special treatment on their birthdays; and when they don’t get it their day is ruined.
 
For my friends, I try to concern myself with all the ways in which I can serve them, because I always feel so bowled over by their generosity. I want to love them and reach out to them. The way to get friends and keep them is to be a friend first. Meaning, you must be more focused upon what you can be doing for them than concerned with what they are doing for you. I think you owe your friend an apology. You also should reconsider how and why you have been holding onto such resentment for so long. Then, assuming your friend forgives you and your friendship can recover from her hurt over your long-held resentment, do everything you can to serve her needs and be the best friend you can possibly be to her. Then, next time when any friend does anything nice for you, express your gratitude, not only to that particular friend, but also in talking about that friend to your husband and your other friends. Focusing upon other’s generosity helps us develop our own humility and gratitude. It prepares our hearts to begin to notice things that others have always done for us that we were overlooking or forgetting about. It is very eye-opening.
 
Are you aware that people that do not make a big deal out of their birthday live longer. I am a little wary of people who expect to have “their day” equal Christmas. I stopped having birthday’s 20 years ago:o guess you are too young to appreciate that:p
PS Happy belated birthday!
 
i think the birthday oversight should have been forgotten a long time ago. but from this side of the screen, the friend’s defensive response was ungenerous and unhelpful.

seems there are several aspects of this relationship that function badly.
 
You both sound like you are feeling insecure with each other. If it bothers you that your friends didn’t treat you for your birthday, maybe you should reconsider being their friends. Also, why wait 10 months to bring it up? The thing about going to the same restaurant doesn’t make sense by itself. Also, the fact that she would get so upset that she’d cry a lot - I have the feeling there is more to this story regarding ways that you both feel unappreciated and/or sensitive and defensive with each other.
 
You said you spoke to one friend about your disappointment. What about the other friend?
Did you communicate with her as well?

Birthdays can be very sentimental for some people, for others it’s just a regular day. It sounds like by the time it came to your turn the agreement just fizzled out.

It’s very hard for casual friends or even good friends to keep up these kinds of obligations. Maybe money was tight, maybe the last restaurant date was boring, I don’t really know but I wouldn’t push the birthday idea with them again. Just let it go.

If you can- just tell your friend that you were having an over sensitive moment and tell her that you hope she will forgive you.

I just had a similar conversation with my mom about birthdays. Unfortunately the conversation turned sour when I mentioned that I would like her to say happy birthday to me when I mention it’s my birthday. She flipped out on me, got very defensive. (I have a bit of a disfunctional relationship with my mom) but the following week she invited me for dinner and I accepted. We had a very nice time. That was her way of making up to me. I was very grateful for this gesture.
I hope that your friends show you that they value you in other ways. Please try to look at the other ways that your friends show that they care. I guess the point of your friend telling you that she was so upset that she cried was meant to show you that she does value your friendship.

Best wishes to you in your friendships.👍
 
Hi Haviland,

I’m new here but thought perhaps I could offer my insight on the issue (not to be presumptuous by any means however…). 🙂 It seems to me that this is simply an issue of divergent values. You placed a lot of value on the act of getting together with your two friends and celebrating each others’ respective birthdays by going out to eat and sharing gifts. It sounds like a great idea to me too! Obviously this meant a lot to you as you didn’t forget your friends’ birthdays. As it meant a lot to you, you assumed it meant equally as much to your friends. But obviously they didn’t share your feelings regarding the subject, as they forgot yours. 😦 Obviously you were hurt and took this as a personal slight…why wouldn’t you? In your mind this was an important occasion! But the thing to understand is, that for whatever reason, your friends didn’t view the act of going out to eat and exchanging gifts with as much weight as you did…and who knows why? People have their reasons…maybe they were busy, maybe they had other things going on in their lives…whatever. But the point is - this does not mean they don’t value YOU! Clearly your friend cares very much about you as she wouldn’t have been so hurt to realize how she had hurt you by forgetting! She would not have spent the whole day crying if she hadn’t cared…people don’t cry over things they don’t care about. Obviously your friend cares a lot for you and probably loves you very much…I don’t doubt she felt very sad to learn how forgetting had hurt you. People get defensive when they realize they’ve made a mistake…it’s a knee-jerk reaction. Your friend got defensive because your reaction took her by surprise…you hadn’t mentioned it was bothering you for 10 months! I think what would be best would be too forgive your friend for forgetting…realize that she DOES care about you…and perhaps explain to her how you viewed the celebration to her…what it meant to you through YOUR eyes so she could see/understand how you felt about it. Doing this allows her into your world a bit more, and allows her to see how other people view the world…and sharing your feelings with her shows her you trust her enough to do so. I think it would help to only further the bond of your friendship. Good luck! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top