Considering Leaving the Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kevin12
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Catholicism is not inherently legalistic. It has many safeguards, but that is not the same thing as putting unfair restrictions on people just for the sake of it. Why does a parent build a fence around the yard? To restrict his children’s freedom or to keep them safe from wandering onto a busy road? Why do we have traffic rules? To keep us from having fun while driving or to keep everyone on the roads safe? You see where I’m going with this. There are so many ways human beings mess up it’s only right that the Church have laws to tell us when we are messing up, so we don’t mess up. It’s not to spoil anyone’s fun or limit freedom but to give us the freedom to do what is right and good–those things that are pleasing to God, so that we end up with him for all eternity instead of some other unpleasant place. 😉
You are probably right that Catholicism itself is not inherently legalistic - I suppose it is more or less that this forum seems to be home to a great deal of very vocal Catholics who are very legalistic, not to mention puritanical, in their faith.
 
I was adding, but ran out of time to edit…

There seem to be, for example, several posters of more than a few thousand posts who have memorized every reference in scripture or the words of the saints to the fewness of the saved, and half of whose posts are about people not wearing the right clothes to Mass. I really have to say, such people…I know I am not a good person, but there are many times when I feel like, if heaven is primarily occupied by such people, Hell would be preferable. I don’t really believe this, but it is hard for me to understand how such people came to view the world and God the way they do.
 
You are probably right that Catholicism itself is not inherently legalistic - I suppose it is more or less that this forum seems to be home to a great deal of very vocal Catholics who are very legalistic, not to mention puritanical, in their faith.
Not just this forum. Which is a shame.
 
You are probably right that Catholicism itself is not inherently legalistic - I suppose it is more or less that this forum seems to be home to a great deal of very vocal Catholics who are very legalistic, not to mention puritanical, in their faith.

There seem to be, for example, several posters of more than a few thousand posts who have memorized every reference in scripture or the words of the saints to the fewness of the saved, and half of whose posts are about people not wearing the right clothes to Mass. I really have to say, such people…I know I am not a good person, but there are many times when I feel like, if heaven is primarily occupied by such people, Hell would be preferable. I don’t really believe this, but it is hard for me to understand how such people came to view the world and God the way they do.
If you go to any forum that is as open as this one, and there are some that aren’t, you will find that a certain type of poster loves to hang out and do nothing more than stir the pot. Such people need to get a life! You will find that parish life is not like a forum, although people are people and no parish consists of all saints ready for canonization.

Part of following Christ in his Church is accepting that it is more a hospital for sinners than a hotel for saints. We meet all sorts in the Catholic Church–which is proof, IMHO, that God is really in it. It’s not a club, it’s a lifeboat. We take on board anyone and everyone who wishes to be saved and we don’t throw anyone overboard simply because we find them annoying or silly or puritanical. Just let them be and let God deal with them. You and I are responsible before God for ourselves. Just getting that right is enough for us to think about. 😉
 
Not just this forum. Which is a shame.
This is very true. What is it about the internet that, in spite of it being the medium that has made pornography and other graphic material more widely available than any other, ironically attracts the people who tell others to stop watching television and movies altogether because they might contain a dirty jokes or the barest mention of premarital sex?
 
This is very true. What is it about the internet that, in spite of it being the medium that has made pornography and other graphic material more widely available than any other, ironically attracts the people who tell others to stop watching television and movies altogether because they might contain a dirty jokes or the barest mention of premarital sex?
That is not what I meant.
 
We meet all sorts in the Catholic Church–which is proof, IMHO, that God is really in it. It’s not a club, it’s a lifeboat. We take on board anyone and everyone who wishes to be saved and we don’t throw anyone overboard simply because we find them annoying or silly or puritanical. Just let them be and let God deal with them. You and I are responsible before God for ourselves. Just getting that right is enough for us to think about. 😉
This is true enough, but I think these people spread the message that spiritual pride is okay - is, indeed, a virtue, rather than a vice. I am not perfect or probably even a good person, and I have certainly looked askance at the sort of person who leaves Mass right after communion and thought about how bad they were and by implication how good I was. But I am not proud of those thoughts, and I certainly think anyone who goes onto an internet forum to criticize this sort of thing and say how it reflects the unique degeneracy of the modern Church that has forgotten how great it was before Vatican II when everyone dressed to the nines and no one but the priest knew what the Mass even meant.

The main thing is, like I said, for people who struggle with their faith, for me personally, the things these people say often are more damaging to my faith than anything I have ever read or heard from an atheist or other skeptic.
 
I’m sorry if I mistook you. Could you explain what you did mean then?
I meant that the ‘legalism’ being spoken of in this thread is also evident in real life, not just on forums.
 
This is true enough, but I think these people spread the message that spiritual pride is okay - is, indeed, a virtue, rather than a vice. I am not perfect or probably even a good person, and I have certainly looked askance at the sort of person who leaves Mass right after communion and thought about how bad they were and by implication how good I was. But I am not proud of those thoughts, and I certainly think anyone who goes onto an internet forum to criticize this sort of thing and say how it reflects the unique degeneracy of the modern Church that has forgotten how great it was before Vatican II when everyone dressed to the nines and no one but the priest knew what the Mass even meant.

The main thing is, like I said, for people who struggle with their faith, for me personally, the things these people say often are more damaging to my faith than anything I have ever read or heard from an atheist or other skeptic.
Reading these people can only be damaging if you take them seriously. Whenever someone presents himself as more pious than the pope, just give them a pass. I feel sorry for folks who have to push their own ideas onto others in order to feel good about themselves. It’s sad. No one ought to be judging anyone else on such trivial matters.

You will note, as well, that people who write such things get infractions or their posts are pulled or they end up banned. As in any other venue in life, there are going to be people who have to put in their oar no matter how much doing so only muddies the water. It’s one of the things we must expect on a public forum, but no one has to follow their advice or take them seriously.

As I have said before, do what your bishop and your pastor tells you and be at peace. If reading online forums disturbs your peace, then don’t do it. At some point we all have to take responsibility for our own decisions and actions. Live the faith and let it go for your own peace of mind. 🙂
 
I’m certain your right. I am just going to go with what my priest already told me, that there is much more hope about salvation than many in the Church thought in the past (as opinion, rather than doctrine) and leave it at that.
 
Of course racism existed and still exists–it’s one of the many evils in our world. And it goes both ways, I can tell you. I worked in a Espanic church and trust me, those people had as low an opinion of the Anglos as the Anglos had of them.

The economics of the thing is really secondary. It’s cultural. It’s like the English hating the Irish or Norwegians being thought second class citizens in MN–that’s right in MN by the Germans and the Norwegians hating the Germans, even though both were mostly Lutheran.

A simple list of who gave how much is hardly a good example of racism. If you want to find evil, you will find it–in the human heart. It’s why we need to look past such things to Christ, who is our only remedy for all the evils of mankind.
Yes. If you read carefully what I wrote, I was describing my reaction to the church as a 16-year old boy. I agree that racism is a HUMAN CONDITON; and that racism exists in all societies and all a races.
 
Jesus’ words are living words and have same meaning and impact as today.

He told us to beware of the leaven of the pharisees. Jesus is about new life. And the more the sinner, the greater the mercy afforded him. There are threads here about the Divine Mercy devotion that was promulgated by John Paul II.

The devotion says its graces will work for us provided we are merciful.

Another thing to watch out for, St. Catherine of Siena one of my favorite studies…said we are not to keep our eyes on sinners and scandals. If we do, we become hypocrites.

We are to keep our eyes on Jesus Christ and not on the failings of men. When we take our eyes off of Christ in the Church, Who is the life and essence of the Church, and then turn to man – be it admiration or scorn – we will begin to fail, because all humans do, including those we admire. Give the attraction time, and eventually you will see that person’s brokenness, and you will walk away empty and scornful.

So in all things we must focus on Christ and avoid those behaviors that take away our faith.

Sr Faustina wrote a most beautiful prayer to Mary Mother of Suffering, and in it she prays that we be protected from those who hide their malice with the veil of religion.
 
Well, it seems there are two camps that are perceived here:

The self-righteous, “I know my salvation is secure because I’m so pious and perfect” kind,

and the

“It makes me feel a lot better about the world if everyone, or nearly everyone, is saved.”

Neither is correct.

As for the first, as we all know, the physician heals the sick, not the well. This is not to say that we should do whatever we want and claim sickness, but that the healing is an ongoing process, and each individual needs to understand that within their humanity is that constant need to be healed, and the humility each person must have in recognition that that healing is offered to them without consideration as to whether or not they deserve it. It is offered out of love, not because we’ve done everything right - the latter is impossible. I’ve been on numerous websites and Facebook pages of staunchly traditionalist Catholics who spit venom out at the “false” and “puppet” pontiffs and bishops and priests of today, with the self-assurance that they’re the ones in the right. It’s all “God help them”, not “God have mercy on me, a sinner.” I don’t see that person as particularly ready to face God, no matter how much they think otherwise.

I find that the more spiritual pride a person has, the more skeletons they have in their closets. Think of all the televangelists out there who portray themselves as holy men/women of God, only to have a huge scandal befall them when their sins are brought to light. Sometimes I wonder if that pride is a cover-up for the shame they feel. It could very well be.

That being said, I’ve noticed that people often get on the “invincible ignorance” train and think that anyone with a half-decent excuse - not a reason, an excuse - is relieved of any responsibility of sin or rejection of Christ. That is not the case. We cannot forget our duty to extend Christ’s healing to others, no matter how uncomfortable it makes us. Invincible ignorance is only the case when the ignorance is impossible of being overcome. And even then, the church does not say that they will be saved, only that they may. We must always keep in mind that it is God’s prerogative to judge, not ours - and that goes for positive as well as negative judging. Just as well cannot look at someone and say, “I won’t waste with evangelizing that person, he’s hopeless”, we cannot either say “I’m sure she’s a good enough person to be saved even if she’s an atheist”.
 
Well, it seems there are two camps that are perceived here:

The self-righteous, “I know my salvation is secure because I’m so pious and perfect” kind,

and the

“It makes me feel a lot better about the world if everyone, or nearly everyone, is saved.”

Neither is correct.

As for the first, as we all know, the physician heals the sick, not the well. This is not to say that we should do whatever we want and claim sickness, but that the healing is an ongoing process, and each individual needs to understand that within their humanity is that constant need to be healed, and the humility each person must have in recognition that that healing is offered to them without consideration as to whether or not they deserve it. It is offered out of love, not because we’ve done everything right - the latter is impossible. I’ve been on numerous websites and Facebook pages of staunchly traditionalist Catholics who spit venom out at the “false” and “puppet” pontiffs and bishops and priests of today, with the self-assurance that they’re the ones in the right. It’s all “God help them”, not “God have mercy on me, a sinner.” I don’t see that person as particularly ready to face God, no matter how much they think otherwise.

I find that the more spiritual pride a person has, the more skeletons they have in their closets. Think of all the televangelists out there who portray themselves as holy men/women of God, only to have a huge scandal befall them when their sins are brought to light. Sometimes I wonder if that pride is a cover-up for the shame they feel. It could very well be.

That being said, I’ve noticed that people often get on the “invincible ignorance” train and think that anyone with a half-decent excuse - not a reason, an excuse - is relieved of any responsibility of sin or rejection of Christ. That is not the case. We cannot forget our duty to extend Christ’s healing to others, no matter how uncomfortable it makes us. Invincible ignorance is only the case when the ignorance is impossible of being overcome. And even then, the church does not say that they will be saved, only that they may. We must always keep in mind that it is God’s prerogative to judge, not ours - and that goes for positive as well as negative judging. Just as well cannot look at someone and say, “I won’t waste with evangelizing that person, he’s hopeless”, we cannot either say “I’m sure she’s a good enough person to be saved even if she’s an atheist”.
I really would be content with letting this thread die. I would agree about atheists - unless you were raised in Maoist China or contemporary North Korea where the government made and makes it impossible or nearly impossible for Christ’s message to reach people, there is little excuse. But I can’t accept that we should hold that most or all Protestants will go to Hell - for example, that C.S. Lewis or T.S. Eliot are probably in Hell.

But again, I would rather just let this one rest.
 
Oh I don’t consider Protestants as lost, unless they’re so liberal or disinterested that they’re not truly Christian. I’m concerned mainly with pagan and other non-Christian groups.

Just wanted to make that clear. It’s okay with me if this thread dies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top