Converted to catholicism/ former catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter guardian1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I really hope so. I just want to be sure that I’m no longer Catholic. Sometimes people say “Once a Catholic, Always a Catholic”, which bothers me so much, since I don’t want to be Catholic at all, let alone a Christian. I was worried that I may have had to convert to another religion or had to go through the process of being excommunicated. I didn’t know it was as simple as it is to leave.

Yes, it is a permamnet thing, now that I know that I no longer am Catholic for sure. I became aware of certain facts over a year ago that will prevent any future return to the Church, and any/all denominations of Christianity. Facts that I only perceived from a very early age, but now I know are certain.

I re-read what I had posted just a little while ago and I should have clarified that I joined the forum today. I was baptized Catholic as an infant. Just to eliminate any future confusion if this be the case. Thank you very much for answering my question.
Just to be sure that you really are apostate, write a letter to your Bishop renouncing your Catholic faith.

That should do the trick.

Of course, “there is no salvation outside the Church”…but that doesn’t seem to worry you.

Now, if you’d like to discuss the issues that have brought you to the precipice, we’d be happy to discuss them.

One topic per thread, please. 😛
 
I’m so glad a question/topic like this one has come up. I actually just joined today to find out exactly how I can leave the Catholic Church permanantly (and all of Christianity and religions), as I’m not exactly sure how I can do this, and I’ve heard different people say different things about it. My beliefs are non-religious and contrary to what the Catholic Church teaches, let alone all of Chrisitanity. I have no fear at all of leaving the Church as I don’t believe in things like hell or sin, but I still believe in God, but only not in the Trinity.
In order to be allowed to marry polygamously or invalidly, you would want to send a letter to your Bishop to let him know that you no longer wish to be considered Catholic. You would then not be bound by any Christian laws of marriage.

Before taking that step, make sure you have thought it through, and won’t be wanting to have a “death-bed conversion” or anything, because what this will do is also ensure that no priest would be called to pray with you at the time of your death, and of course you would also not be able to receive the Absolution in the Sacrament of Reconciliation, since only Catholics can receive that.

You would also not receive a funeral, other than just whatever social gathering your friends decide to do in your memory. (I’m assuming you wouldn’t want them to do anything elaborate, if you don’t believe in an afterlife, and don’t expect to be there in spirit.)
 
Matthew 28: 18-20. History proves the Church He was talking to became known as the Catholic Church with the See of St. Peter in Rome - He did not say He would support schism or reform or protest , He said He would be with THIS Church until the End. I do NOT believe in Bible Alone (Sola Scriptura), I DO believe in God’s Word alone. 2Thessalonians 2:15, Matthew 4:4 -God’s Word is Scripture, Tradition and the Magisterium of the Church as directed by the Holy Spirit. I believe in Apostolic authority and succession; and the Real Presence in the Eucharist.
 
If I write to the Bishop in my area to renounce my Catholic upbringing, I’m not sure who the Bishop of my area is nor were
I would be sending the letter. Not sure If there’s only one bishop per country or do some countries have more than than one. I currently live in Chicago, and was raised in the Chicago suburbs.
 
If I write to the Bishop in my area to renounce my Catholic upbringing, I’m not sure who the Bishop of my area is nor were
I would be sending the letter. Not sure If there’s only one bishop per country or do some countries have more than than one. I currently live in Chicago, and was raised in the Chicago suburbs.
The person to whom you can write is Cardinal Francis George. You can Google the address of the archdiocesan headquarters, or the chancery office. Or you could write your letter and give it to any parish priest and ask him to forward it along. You seem very confused.
 
Ok, thanks. Just looked it up and found the Chicago Archdiocese web site. Was only confused about where and who to send the letter to, that’s all. I’ll address it to Cardinal Francis George then, the addres of where to send it to should be loctaed/mentioned within the site. Thanks for all of your help.🙂
 
Ok, thanks. Just looked it up and found the Chicago Archdiocese web site. Was only confused about where and who to send the letter to, that’s all. I’ll address it to Cardinal Francis George then, the addres of where to send it to should be loctaed/mentioned within the site. Thanks for all of your help.🙂
It’s only of concern in that, if you didn’t know who your Bishop was, then what else might have slipped past you during your Catholic education?

Once you send that letter, that’s the final good-bye to Heaven, if there is one, so just make sure you are completely certain that there is no such place - that there is absolutely nothing you could possibly have mis-heard, or didn’t understand correctly.
 
Yes, it is a permamnet thing, now that I know that I no longer am Catholic for sure. I became aware of certain facts over a year ago that will prevent any future return to the Church, and any/all denominations of Christianity. Facts that I only perceived from a very early age, but now I know are certain.
Just out of curiosity, what are the facts that you speak of?
 
I can point to a website that talks about this, but I really don’t want to give it because I don’t want to interfere with people’s spiritaulity in a negative way, so I prefer not to say. Only that what the website mentions, and it’s articles therein, were more than a confirmation of beliefs and things I felt and hinted at all along. Some things were new to me, but most of it I wasn’t as surprised as I thought. If people went to look at the site many wouldn’t believe what it says anyway, but some people may start gettting doubts of their own beliefs, which is something I may be uncomfortable with.
 
I can point to a website that talks about this, but I really don’t want to give it because I don’t want to interfere with people’s spiritaulity in a negative way, so I prefer not to say. Only that what the website mentions, and it’s articles therein, were more than a confirmation of beliefs and things I felt and hinted at all along. Some things were new to me, but most of it I wasn’t as surprised as I thought. If people went to look at the site many wouldn’t believe what it says anyway, but some people may start gettting doubts of their own beliefs, which is something I may be uncomfortable with.
Well, thank you for your concern. Instead of providing a web site, perhaps you could just mention, in your own words (or even just hint at) what one of the issues is.
 
Guess it really would be easier in someway to mention the website. Here it goes.

jesusneverexisted.com/
skepticsannotatedbible.com/

Since I’ve received the answers to the questions that I asked from those on this forum, I will no longer be using this site in the future, as I’ve previously indicated I would only be on it for a short while. For those who have answered my questions, I thank you very much and wish you all and everyone else here a very happy and prosperous life. Take care. 🙂
 
Guess it really would be easier in someway to mention the website. Here it goes.

jesusneverexisted.com/
skepticsannotatedbible.com/

Since I’ve received the answers to the questions that I asked from those on this forum, I will no longer be using this site in the future, as I’ve previously indicated I would only be on it for a short while. For those who have answered my questions, I thank you very much and wish you all and everyone else here a very happy and prosperous life. Take care. 🙂
You realize, of course, that the bible was never intended to be a science book. And that the books of the bible were written in many styles, with the purpose of teaching a moral lesson, and not a historical lesson or science lesson?
 
I was raised in the Catholic church, although not formally. My mother is non-denominational, although my father was a cradle Catholic. I spent most of my childhood attending mass with my grandmother and grandfather. I memorized the prayers to please my grandmother and thought the traditions within the Church were beautiful. I also prayed, but had my own idea of God and religion growing up. I decided to officially join the Church when my husband and I began attending mass. My husband was an atheist. The first time my husband came with me to mass, our parish priest, Father Dan, seemed to continually look our way during the homily…the mass was about non-believers and conversion. It was about how God is always calling us closer to Him. It touched my husband so much that right then and there, he decided to convert. So I finally became an official part of the Church, and my husband did too. It was a dream come true for me. --The only reason my hubby came with me was because our parish was having a special mass and a reception in honor of our beloved passed Pope John Paul, and he felt he wanted to pay his respects to the pontiff.

My sister is Baptist. She is a part of a completely different church. It’s like night and day. I find that in mass we hear a lot about helping others in need, those who are sick, in pain, or less fortunate. At my sister’s church service, all they mostly talk about is money. How rich they are getting, and how much the church-goers still “owe” the church on their pledge. I don’t have a lot of money, and it’s intimidating to me to go to a place where you are glared at for showing up in jeans or don’t throw a few twenties in the collection box. I felt very uncomfortable there. I felt instead of coming into a place where I was free to worship with my brothers and sisters and pray quietly, that I was there to socialize and testify. I don’t like the “big band” music they play in protestant churches, and I don’t like their approach to ministering youth. I could go on and on…but the most important reason I went with the Catholic church as my community of choice was because I WAS NOT JUDGED.

I was looked down upon at the baptist church and other denominations that I visited. I was a single teenage mother who smoked. Then, I lived with my significant other out of wedlock and had another child. They wanted nothing to do with me, and I was whispered about. Especially since my sister was so involved. When I began attending RCIA class, I was completely and unconditionally accepted by every single person I encountered. Instead of telling me I was a sinner and that I needed to pay up, I was encouraged to come into a closer and loving relationship with God, and do what I could. It was a loving community that was bent on helping others even if the monthly electric bill for our parish went without being paid. That I admire, and that is why I am a part of the Catholic Church. As far as beliefs go, I always believed that the Catholic Church must be right about everything. Look at all the people they’ve commissioned to research every little detail of any religious discover or finding. It is a scholarly religion, and after all, it’s the Church that Jesus left in His place.
 
You realize, of course, that the bible was never intended to be a science book. And that the books of the bible were written in many styles, with the purpose of teaching a moral lesson, and not a historical lesson or science lesson?
I noticed that the first web site makes a lot of assertions, but does very little to substantiate them.

For example:
Christianity was the ultimate product of religious syncretism in the ancient world. Its emergence owed nothing to a holy carpenter. There were many Jesuses but the fable was a cultural construct.
At this point, you would expect him to provide some evidence for this; instead, he changes the subject.
Nazareth did not exist in the 1st century AD – the area was a burial ground of rock-cut tombs.
We are not actually given the location of the Biblical Nazareth. If it was not in the same location as the modern-day Nazareth, this is not evidence that it didn’t exist.
Following a star would lead you in circles.
Tell that to the mariners who set their compasses by the North star.
The 12 disciples are as fictitious as their master, invented to legitimise the claims of the early churches.
Yet, we have their both their writings and their graves. (If they were forged in the Middle Ages, how is it that they were already being quoted by philosophers during the lifetime of St. John?)
The original Mary was not a virgin. That idea was borrowed from pagan goddesses.
Did he give her a gynecological exam? How does he know this?
Scholars have known all this for more than 200 years but priestcraft is a highly profitable business …]
He apparently doesn’t know very many priests, most of whom would make better money as elementary school teachers, with less than half the education.
“Jesus better documented than any other ancient figure” ? Don’t believe a word of it. Unlike the mythical Jesus, a real historical figure like Julius Caesar has a mass of mutually supporting evidence.
We have eye-witness reports and archaeological evidence of Christ. The only question we have to ask ourselves is whether His claim to divinity was valid, or not. Everything else has been proven.
 
Guess it really would be easier in someway to mention the website. Here it goes.

jesusneverexisted.com/
skepticsannotatedbible.com/

Since I’ve received the answers to the questions that I asked from those on this forum, I will no longer be using this site in the future, as I’ve previously indicated I would only be on it for a short while. For those who have answered my questions, I thank you very much and wish you all and everyone else here a very happy and prosperous life. Take care. 🙂
Why not give the Christian religion a fair chance. It’s been around for 2000 years–maybe there’s something to it. Why not listen to the other side. Try reading reading GK Chesterton or CS Lewis.

chesterton.org/

bookshop.blackwell.co.uk/jsp/id/Mere_Christianity/9780006280545

What do you have to lose.

And just to let you know, no matter how far you stray from the Catholic Church, you’ll always be welcomed back.
 
for those of you who don’t know, i was raised a protestant and am one today. i came to this forum to learn about catholicism and i am also learning about the faith from some books as well. but i am curious as to why those of you who have swam the tiber decided to convert. what was it about the catholic faith that made you decide to become a catholic. i’m also wondering why those who have left the church decided to leae. what was it about the church or it’s teachings? please, if you can list scripture and or ccc as to the reasons for leaving / joining the church. oh, and please, no fighting over who’s right and who’s wrong. Santa doesn’t like it when we fight! and thanks to everyone who posts too!
Here is a great cite with many conversion stories.
chnetwork.org/

Of particular interest to you may be the conversion stories of Protestant Clergy who were very well versed in Scripture.
Two very well informed (and well known) converts are Tim Staples, an Evangelical Protestant minister, and Leona Choy a world renown evangelist and Christian author.

This Rock magazine has the conversion stories of prominent Protestant Bible Scholars and ministers every month.
Here’s the link catholic.com/magazines.asp

Grace and peace to you.

Your brother in Christ.
 
Here is a great cite with many conversion stories.
chnetwork.org/

Of particular interest to you may be the conversion stories of Protestant Clergy who were very well versed in Scripture.
Two very well informed (and well known) converts are Tim Staples, an Evangelical Protestant minister, and Leona Choy a world renown evangelist and Christian author.

This Rock magazine has the conversion stories of prominent Protestant Bible Scholars and ministers every month.
Here’s the link catholic.com/magazines.asp

Grace and peace to you.

Your brother in Christ.
Coming Home is a good site. You can listen to a lot of testimonies here, including a lot of atheists or skeptics who become Catholic.

ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/seriessearchprog.asp?pgnu=3&SeriesID=-6892289

You should listen to the roundtable discussion from 4/17/6.

Also, here are some other good stories of people who went through a skeptical or atheistic phase:

7/23/7–Donald Calloway
7/9/7–John Pridmore
4/17/6–Roundtable discussion
4/3/6–Scott McDermott
8/22/5–Ronda Chervin
5/2/5–Steven Mosher
11/15/4–Jean Francois Thibeault (probably my favorite story)
 
I’m so glad a question/topic like this one has come up. I actually just joined today to find out exactly how I can leave the Catholic Church permanantly (and all of Christianity and religions), as I’m not exactly sure how I can do this, and I’ve heard different people say different things about it. My beliefs are non-religious and contrary to what the Catholic Church teaches, let alone all of Chrisitanity. I have no fear at all of leaving the Church as I don’t believe in things like hell or sin, but I still believe in God, but only not in the Trinity.
Not to worry, dk, if you ever were a member of the Church, you are not any longer! Go in peace. 😉
I really hope so. I just want to be sure that I’m no longer Catholic. Sometimes people say “Once a Catholic, Always a Catholic”, which bothers me so much, since I don’t want to be Catholic at all, let alone a Christian. I was worried that I may have had to convert to another religion or had to go through the process of being excommunicated. I didn’t know it was as simple as it is to leave.
No, spurning the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed in Baptism is sufficient to separate you from the Body of Christ.
 
I was a protestant for about 30 years. Preached and taught in protestant churches for a great deal of that time. History is a passion of mine - and not just a little bit. It can best be summed up in the words of another longtime protestant student of history: “To be deep in history is to cease being protestant.” - John Newman.

Learn church history from the early church fathers rather than “trusted” sources who try to tell you what those early church fathers believed. I think you’ll find it quite convincing.

Some of my recent blogs have some more details if you’re interested:
Kata Stratiotes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top