CONVERTS, do you have a moment?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CleverUserName
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi…!
Converters are as a general meaning for all human beings. . In particular, many persons are at the stage at which they unanswered questions and perhaps need the support of believer…
 
I had two moments, though I couldn’t really call the second a “conversion”. I was baptised, but not really raised in the Catholic life. My stepmother was divorced and married to my divorced father. They lived together for many years before being married, and mass was a “Christmas and Easter” thing rather imposed on us. I came to Faith with a brush of the Spirit in a Southern Baptist church, and immediately began to feel the strength of the newly converted. But after a few years, the same message every single sunday was wearing on me. The megachurch that I was attending was beautiful, but in the way that a well-made theatre can be beautiful. When, at college, a friend invited me to the small but very traditional St. Patrick’s, I went on a whim.

Stepping through the door I saw, felt, heard and smelled the weight of history and faith. Nowhere to be found was the blank spaces of protestism, all replaced by doves, sheep, and all sorts of reminders of God. I couldn’t escape from theology even if I’d wanted to. So I started attending and finally found the real “meat” of faith that I’d been looking for. I began researching, asking questions and learning more about the faith that I’d been baptised into. As the years went I saw more and more of the liturgical abuses that we’re all familiar with. I had a problem with the way some churches seemed to be losing the strength of tradition that had been a very real reason that I’d connected in the first place. It wasn’t until I enlisted that I’d heard about Eastern Catholicism (From my Knights of Colombus agent). I got a bit lost on my way to my first service, as I thought the church was a mosque. When I crept in, I was again flooded by the weight of history, of tradition, and of the unbroken line of faith.

Now, my biggest problem is that I’ve found one of the smaller Churches here in the States, and it’s hard to find one that hasn’t been closed down! I’m looking at YOU, Buffalo, NY!😛
 
I feel like I could spend 20 years in the religion and still be learning. 😃
Umm…if you can cram 100years of history into each year of those twenty years, you’d still fall short! And that’s just the history; nevermind the theology!

As far as I know, no Catholic has ever died having learned the fullness of Truth (Catholicism) accept the Blessed Mother of Our Founder!

Welcome Home and God Bless

:cool:
 
My Aha moment was when for a reason I can’t remember a month or so ago I started researching Catholic beliefs online. ( I had attended regularly at a Catholic church years ago and even began RCIA classes.)

I couldn’t get past the Confession to a priest. When I asked why, the priest just said, “Look at me as if I am Jesus Christ.”

Well that didn’t settle well.

Anyway back to my Aha moment…I was reading a Catholic forum online and a Catholic and Protestant was having a discussion about this very thing. Protestant of course was none to friendly. The gentleman giving the Catholic perspective not only explained what going to Confession offers but also gave biblical references and explained the meanings of those bible veres in detail.

I was like Aha…and I was already questioning where and why I was attending the church I presently attend…Then, I showed up one Sunday to hear a woman is bringing the message.

Then I said okay it’s time…So back to the Catholic faith I went. Lord Willing I will begin RCIA classes again this Fall and be brought into the church next Easter Vigil.

Sorry for the lengthly Aha moment explanation.
 
I went to an Evangelical Christian college, and considered myself Evangelical. I had this professor of medieval history who challenged me to read some Aquinas and Bonaventure when I bashed Catholicism in his class.

I developed a taste for liturgy and went to an Anglican Church for a while, still not wanting to take the jump into Catholicism because of the Mary dogmas. I was baptized and married in the Anglican tradition. “I will become Catholic when they stop worshiping Mary” I would tell my wife at the time.

After graduation, my wife and I moved. I checked out all the protestant churches in my new area. Something just felt like it was lacking. Finally I agreed to attend a Catholic church. I was sitting in the back, and this guy came up and asked if I would bring up the wine for consecration during that time in the Mass. I told him that I was not Catholic, only curious. He said, not to worry, all are welcome here. During the Gloria, I wept. I knew that I was finally home. I joined RCIA and was received into the Church in 2008. That singing of the Gloria was my “moment” I suppose.

5 years ago, I wrote to my professor telling him how the Pope is the antichrist, and Catholics worship Mary. Now, as I write this, I am wearing a Brown Scapular.
You actually brought tears to my eyes. I am looking through them as I type this response. What glorious testimony this is. Oh my goodness…
 
Hi…!
Converters are as a general meaning for all human beings. . In particular, many persons are at the stage at which they unanswered questions and perhaps need the support of believer…
Certainly! I hope we can be that support.
 
I had two moments, though I couldn’t really call the second a “conversion”. I was baptised, but not really raised in the Catholic life. My stepmother was divorced and married to my divorced father. They lived together for many years before being married, and mass was a “Christmas and Easter” thing rather imposed on us. I came to Faith with a brush of the Spirit in a Southern Baptist church, and immediately began to feel the strength of the newly converted. But after a few years, the same message every single sunday was wearing on me. The megachurch that I was attending was beautiful, but in the way that a well-made theatre can be beautiful. When, at college, a friend invited me to the small but very traditional St. Patrick’s, I went on a whim.

Stepping through the door **I saw, felt, heard and smelled the weight of history and faith. Nowhere to be found was the blank spaces of protestism, all replaced by doves, sheep, and all sorts of reminders of God. **I couldn’t escape from theology even if I’d wanted to. So I started attending and finally found the real “meat” of faith that I’d been looking for. I began researching, asking questions and learning more about the faith that I’d been baptised into. As the years went I saw more and more of the liturgical abuses that we’re all familiar with. I had a problem with the way some churches seemed to be losing the strength of tradition that had been a very real reason that I’d connected in the first place. It wasn’t until I enlisted that I’d heard about Eastern Catholicism (From my Knights of Colombus agent). I got a bit lost on my way to my first service, as I thought the church was a mosque. When I crept in, **I was again flooded by the weight of history, of tradition, and of the unbroken line of faith. **

Now, my biggest problem is that I’ve found one of the smaller Churches here in the States, and it’s hard to find one that hasn’t been closed down! I’m looking at YOU, Buffalo, NY!😛
Boy, could I relate to your post. I could have bolded the whole thing haha. But your descriptions really resonated with me. I felt the same way.

I hope hope hope you find an open Church in your area quickly!
 
My Aha moment was when for a reason I can’t remember a month or so ago I started researching Catholic beliefs online. ( I had attended regularly at a Catholic church years ago and even began RCIA classes.)

I couldn’t get past the Confession to a priest. When I asked why, the priest just said, “Look at me as if I am Jesus Christ.”

Well that didn’t settle well.

Anyway back to my Aha moment…I was reading a Catholic forum online and a Catholic and Protestant was having a discussion about this very thing. Protestant of course was none to friendly. The gentleman giving the Catholic perspective not only explained what going to Confession offers but also gave biblical references and explained the meanings of those bible veres in detail.

I was like Aha…and I was already questioning where and why I was attending the church I presently attend…Then, I showed up one Sunday to hear a woman is bringing the message.

Then I said okay it’s time…So back to the Catholic faith I went. Lord Willing I will begin RCIA classes again this Fall and be brought into the church next Easter Vigil.

Sorry for the lengthly Aha moment explanation.
No need to apologize- I enjoyed every line! Thanks for sharing your story with us!
I think it’s so cool that your moment happened in a forum (such as this one?). We never know how our words can affect a person. Best of luck to you in your RCIA classes. We’ll be here to support you 100% ! I’m really excited for you!
 
No need to apologize- I enjoyed every line! Thanks for sharing your story with us!
I think it’s so cool that your moment happened in a forum (such as this one?). We never know how our words can affect a person. Best of luck to you in your RCIA classes. We’ll be here to support you 100% ! I’m really excited for you!
Thanks a million Sadie…I need all the help I can get.
 
The whole Lamb of God thing made no sense. You would have Christians talking about being in a new covenant, which is why homosexuality was okay. And then you have conservatives saying “the law is not abolished”. I just did not understand how the covenants were related. It was only when Iearnt of the Eucharist, todah and Passover I could understand the covenant and eating His flesh and blood. You HAVE to eat the sacrificial lamb. Protestants talk of the Lamb of God but deny eating the sacrificial Lamb. I don’t see they how can believe in an all-powerful God who did so many miracles yet deny that He can transfigure bread and wine into flesh and blood without changing its appearance.

The Eucharist is the heart of Christianity.
 
The biggest stumbling-block for me was probably a misunderstanding of indulgences. (Typical Protestant, you know.) But when JPII died, I watched the funeral. And we were at Mass within the month. My husband at first said, “You convert if you like, and you may take the children, too. I will go with you to Mass, but I don’t want to convert.”

After the first Mass we attended, he wanted to convert, too.
👍
 
When I was younger, I was raised like a lot of other Protestant children whose parents don’t go to church. Sure, I knew stories like Creation, the Deluge, Moses…

Now that I think about it… God and the Old Testament were mentioned quite a bit, but Jesus wasn’t :hmmm:. Are my parents secretly Jewish…?

Anyway, because of this non-exposure to Christianity, I grew up not knowing what Christianity was. Even at school, unless you declare otherwise, (and, of course, whispering something to someone at school is the equivalent to shouting into the intercom system) everyone simply assumes you to be the same as them: an Evangelical Protestant, usually of the Baptist persuasion.

**It is worth noting here that I did hear about Catholics once, after the Blessed Pope John Paul II died, but I thought Catholic was an Italian thing (like Hinduism is to Indians, Shinto to the Japanese).

As I got older, and everyone started attaching themselves to one church group or another, I was out of place. It felt strange to see lines drawn where they hadn’t been before. I then asked the question of a lifetime, ‘what is Christianity?’.

Shortly after, however, my parents divorced and I took to the whole teenaged-Atheist-angry-with-the-world thing. That lasted a few months, when the question came to me again, ‘what is Christianity?’.

Sure, as an Atheist I could argue against ‘Christianity’… of the Evangelical Protestant, Baptist Persuasion. Being a teenager of the modern age, I consulted the great, seemingly omniscient Google. The answer I found was astounding. I learned of Benedict, Ambrose, John of Chrysostom, Basil, Cyril, Methodius, and a load of other people of whom I’d never heard.

As one can deduce from the saints mentioned, my encounter was with Byzantine Christianity, and it set the stage for the next great question: ‘Orthodox or Catholic?’. By becoming Orthodox, I would be able to keep my (as far as I’m concerned) native Byzantine status. But the word… Catholic … resonated deeply within me. After hearing an interview on EWTN’s Journey Home, I had accepted that the Bishop of Rome is the Papa of the Church Universal.

Of course, I still wanted my precious Byzantine spirituality, the faith of Basil, John of Chrysostom, Justianian, and every other Byzantine who ever lived. And then I learned of the Eastern Rite Churches.

My greatest illuminated moment, however, came when I learned that the word ‘Byzantine’ put in front of the word ‘Catholic’ effectively neutralises all anti-Catholicism… since it’s not the ‘Roman’ (as far as they know) Church, and opens up a path for discussion. Living in the Deep South, that can be a metaphorical life-saver. 😃
 
When I was younger, I was raised like a lot of other Protestant children whose parents don’t go to church. Sure, I knew stories like Creation, the Deluge, Moses…

Now that I think about it… God and the Old Testament were mentioned quite a bit, but Jesus wasn’t :hmmm:. Are my parents secretly Jewish…?

Anyway, because of this non-exposure to Christianity, I grew up not knowing what Christianity was. Even at school, unless you declare otherwise, (and, of course, whispering something to someone at school is the equivalent to shouting into the intercom system) everyone simply assumes you to be the same as them: an Evangelical Protestant, usually of the Baptist persuasion.

**It is worth noting here that I did hear about Catholics once, after the Blessed Pope John Paul II died, but I thought Catholic was an Italian thing (like Hinduism is to Indians, Shinto to the Japanese).

As I got older, and everyone started attaching themselves to one church group or another, I was out of place. It felt strange to see lines drawn where they hadn’t been before. I then asked the question of a lifetime, ‘what is Christianity?’.

Shortly after, however, my parents divorced and I took to the whole teenaged-Atheist-angry-with-the-world thing. That lasted a few months, when the question came to me again, ‘what is Christianity?’.

Sure, as an Atheist I could argue against ‘Christianity’… of the Evangelical Protestant, Baptist Persuasion. Being a teenager of the modern age, I consulted the great, seemingly omniscient Google. The answer I found was astounding. I learned of Benedict, Ambrose, John of Chrysostom, Basil, Cyril, Methodius, and a load of other people of whom I’d never heard.

As one can deduce from the saints mentioned, my encounter was with Byzantine Christianity, and it set the stage for the next great question: ‘Orthodox or Catholic?’. By becoming Orthodox, I would be able to keep my (as far as I’m concerned) native Byzantine status. But the word… Catholic … resonated deeply within me. After hearing an interview on EWTN’s Journey Home, I had accepted that the Bishop of Rome is the Papa of the Church Universal.

Of course, I still wanted my precious Byzantine spirituality, the faith of Basil, John of Chrysostom, Justianian, and every other Byzantine who ever lived. And then I learned of the Eastern Rite Churches.

My greatest illuminated moment, however, came when I learned that the word ‘Byzantine’ put in front of the word ‘Catholic’ effectively neutralises all anti-Catholicism… since it’s not the ‘Roman’ (as far as they know) Church, and opens up a path for discussion. Living in the Deep South, that can be a metaphorical life-saver. 😃
Wow, quite a journey!
Deep south Byzantium…now that’s a mouthful lol.

Yes it sounds like a perfect fit for you.
 
I love this thread. Thank you Sadie.

Totally off topic.

My very favorite dog was named Sadie. She was a Dalmatian and had the sweetest nature of any dog I have ever had the pleasure to house.
 
Sometimes it’s not passionate theological debates that shifts the position of people who are against Catholicism. Sometimes it’s just a poignant…moment.

Will you share yours?

Example: I was a new Christian, going from church to church, never fully comfortable in any. I was studying scripture voraciously. My Reformed Episcopal Priest said to me, in conversation : “I love Protestant theology”. :newidea: That was a “moment” for me, when something shifted. Because I realized at that very moment the crux of my problem: I did NOT love Protestant theology. This sent me in an entirely new direction…

That was a very significant moment for me personally.

Please, folks, this is not a place for debate or judgment. I would just really love to hear your “moments” when something shifted…

Thank you in advance for sharing.

God bless
I was in a similar situation as you were. I grew up in the Church of Christ. Grandfather was a minister in that denomination and I had a uncle and cousin who are ministers in the same denomination (my family no longer communicate with them due to differences once my grandfather passed away). So to me I grew up with that form of Protestant theology.

Once I got into college, I started going to Baptist Churches because I was going to a Baptist University and thought it would be cool to hang around other students I go to school with. It was ‘cool’ for a while, but then that ‘moment’ ended and I started going to different other Protestant Churches then gave up all together because I got stuck at jobs that made me work on Sundays and never gave me time off to actually go to church or I procrastinated in going and just sat down with a bowl of popcorn and a soda and watched some mega-church service on TV from either Houston or Dallas.

Eventually I got tired of not going to church and didn’t want to go back to the church my family went to because they recently had a shift in staff and I didn’t want to feel awkward being around people I don’t know, I decided to go to a Sunday Mass at the main Catholic Church in my home town. To be honest when I sat down before services started I literally started crying cause I had a feeling that the Holy Ghost was present and welcomed me back to the faith. After mass I went online, did some research, went to facebook and found out several of my friends were Catholics as well and started digging into what Catholics really do believe in. Later on I went to RCIA and one of the people in class was a student at the same university I went to so we connected really well and we had several funny stories about what some Protestants thought of concerning Catholics.
 
Sometimes it’s not passionate theological debates that shifts the position of people who are against Catholicism. Sometimes it’s just a poignant…moment.

Will you share yours?

Example: I was a new Christian, going from church to church, never fully comfortable in any. I was studying scripture voraciously. My Reformed Episcopal Priest said to me, in conversation : “I love Protestant theology”. :newidea: That was a “moment” for me, when something shifted. Because I realized at that very moment the crux of my problem: I did NOT love Protestant theology. This sent me in an entirely new direction…

That was a very significant moment for me personally.

Please, folks, this is not a place for debate or judgment. I would just really love to hear your “moments” when something shifted…

Thank you in advance for sharing.

God bless
I never had a moment. I just studied it and took the steps, I still doubt my decision but here I am.
 
Today is my 25th birthday! :dancing: :extrahappy: :bounce:

I grew up Evangelical and had almost no knowledge or understanding of the Catholic faith growing up. I just assumed that it was sort of a cultish thing that started in Mexico. The religious education I received in private Christian school dealt with the apostles of the New Testament, and then skipped about 1500 years and went to the puritans. That was the extent of my knowledge about the history of Christianity.

I became an agnostic in college and had stopped going to church. When I was 21, I was reading Wikipedia articles about the Bosnian war, and came across a link about Serbian Orthodoxy, which linked to Eastern Orthodoxy, which linked to apostolic Christianity. I think my “moment” was when I realized that Catholicism was apostolic, that is, was passed down to us from the apostles. This completely and utterly changed the way I looked at Christianity forever. I had always assumed that the different denominations had always been there. I was also intrigued by sacramental spirituality; although at the same time this set off red flags because it was kind of the exact opposite of what I was brought up believing. But I think the sacraments were what drew me back to Christianity; I felt as though I were missing something, I knew that God existed but didn’t know Him. I was drawn to Catholicism as a way of knowing God and being in communion with Him. I studied Catholicism constantly for the next two years and came into the Church April 2011.
 
Happy Birthday CompSciGuy! 🍰 How blessed you are to share the day with the holy parents of Our Blessed Lady, Sts. Joachim and Anne. 😃 God bless you on your special day!

Even though I was brought up in the Episcopal Church before we migrated to the Assemblies of God, I knew very little about Church history, either. I knew something about the Apostles and that the ECUSA claimed to apostolic, but I never made the connection until I was nearly 35. I suppose 20 years in a Pentecostal body that denied most of the realities of Church history didn’t help matters. I even took a course in Church history in an AoG Bible college, but it was quite skewed, skipping over most history from Apostolic times until the Reformation, just like many other Protestant bodies do. Isn’t it amazing how we just let that slide? As members of our individual denominations we never questioned what happened in all the time between the end of the Apostolic Era and the Reformation. We actually believed that God let his Church fail. We never wondered why the Catholic Church was so prominent if God was not with it. We were caught up in what our parents believed and a subculture in which ignorance was bliss, I guess.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top