Converts: Give us five reasons you became a Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter MatthewCrossman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was thinking about this the other day and realized I hadn’t used this reason (which I had submitted in a paper on revelation) Suffice to say that at some point in my life, I came to the foot of the cross and a choice was made. I have recognized that place where I was in this story that Thomas Merton tells of his life when his father died and later when he came to understand what suffering did to the non-believer. It had a powerful effect on me when I read it the first time:

"We went into the ward. Father was in his bed, to the left, just as you went in the door.
And when I saw him, I knew at once there was no hope of him living much longer. His face was swollen. His eyes were not clear but, above all, the tumor had raised a tremendous swelling on his forehead.

I said: “How are you, Father?”

He looked at me and put forth his hand, in a confused and unhappy way, and I realized that he could no longer even speak. But at the same time, you could see that he knew us, and knew what was going on, and that his mind was clear, and that he understood everything.

But the sorrow of his great helplessness suddenly fell upon me like a mountain. I was crushed by it. The tears sprang to my eyes., Nobody said anything more.

I hid my face in the blanket and cried. And poor father wept, too. The others stood by. It was excruciatingly sad. We were completely helpless. There was nothing anyone could do…

What could I make of so much suffering? There was no way for me, or for anyone in the family, to get anything out of it. It was a raw wound for which there was no adequate relief. You had to take it, like an animal. We were in the condition of most of the world, the condition of men without faith in the presence of war, disease, pain, starvation, suffering, plague, bombardment, death. You just had to take it, like a dumb animal. Try to avoid it if you could. But you must eventually reach the point where you can’t avoid it any more. Take it. Try to stupefy yourself, if you like, so that it won’t hurt so much. But you will always have to take some of it. And it will all devour you in the end.

Indeed the truth that many people never understand, until it is too late, is that the more you try to avoid suffering, the more you suffer, because smaller insignificant things begin to torture you, in proportion to your fear of being hurt., The one who does most to avoid suffering is, in the end, the one who suffers most: and his suffering comes to him from things so little and so trivial that one can say that it is no longer objective at all. It is his own existence, his own being that is at once the source of his pain, and his very existence and consciousness is his greatest torture. This is another of the great perversions by which the devil uses our philosophies to turn our whole nature inside out, and eviscerate all our capacities for good, turning them against ourselves."

For the longest time I existed as that kind of dumb animal who exalted himself with cynicism and ignorance. It did devour me but when I read this I knew exactly what Merton was talking about.

And from Fr Guardini:

My existence draws on the core of my being but simultaneously on others in order to exist. Plantlike, we sprout from our own seed, but we grow by feeding upon other growth. In the same way we arrive at truth through personal recognition; the ‘ingredients’ which go into that recognition, however, are brought us by others. Man is humanity’s way to life — and of course, to death. Man is humanity’s way to God, and it befits us that God’s word personally penetrate each of our hearts, but that it be brought to us by others.

More here:

payingattentiontothesky.com/2009/06/18/romano-guardini-on-revelation/

God bless. I’ve done two now (anyone counting?)

DJ
 
I love this thread!!! I have had a hard time explaining why I converted, but I have read all of the reasons given and they are mine as well. But here is my firm list
  1. Authority. I could no longer accept a church whose authority came from anyone except Christ. I had brought this up time and time again with pastors, church members, and anyone I could think of, but the only true explanation I received was from a Catholic that Peter was the rock and upon that rock Christ’s Church was built.
  2. Continuity. I dont like when there is contradiction or waffling. I do that too much on my own and I find that particular weakness exceptionally frustrating. I tried over many years (Im only 25 now, so not TOO many, but enough for me ;-)) to find an excuse to disbelieve what was taught in the Church. I could not. There was also a wonderful knowledge that no matter where I went in the world, Christ was in the Mass, and all Masses in union with Rome were relatively the same. At least the same structure. I could not bring myself to believe any longer that Christ would institute a Church on earth that would allow for everyone to do as they see fit and believe as they see fit. It was His way or the Highway (at least in my mind).
  3. The Sacraments. Only in the Catholic Church was there such a thing as the Sacraments. Only in the true Church was there real POWER in the things I was taught were done merely in memory of Christ. Christ did not tell people to be baptized to mimic him, he gave the Baptismal waters power. Without the Grace of God present in the Sacraments, the mimicry in protestantism is less than worthless (in my humble estimation).
  4. The Eucharist. The Eucharist. I cannot get over the Eucharist. Christ said “This IS my body” and “This IS my blood”. He did not say this is a symbol of my body. He was so emphatic about this that most of the people who loved him and followed him and believed him ran away!!! How could I, such a lowly sinful man, POSSIBLY be wiser than those that were with Christ? How could I pretend to understand (for i can only pretend at understanding) the Eucharist better than Peter? It was only in the Catholic Church that I could meet, see, feel, practically smell Christ himself. It was the best thing that ever happened to me. And the scariest.
  5. Home. I have moved every six months, or very nearly every six months, for as long as I can remember. The longest I have ever lived in one place was an apartment I had after I graduated college for two years, and that was nothing more than a place to sleep and keep my stuff. I have never had what many people would think of as a “home”. The first time I actually dragged myself to Mass, I was dating a relatively firm Catholic woman. She never asked me to go, in fact I think she preferred going to Mass without me (I reminded her of her sinful nature I think). I asked if I could go. From the moment I stepped into that Church (St. Annes Parish in Shrewsbury Mass) I felt the most wonderful sense of home. I finally knew what it felt like, and I couldnt understand it. It was not particularly comfortable, nor was it overly welcoming, but like a sailor long at sea, I had returned to port from storm tossed waters. I felt like the prodigal son finally in view of my Fathers house, but not quite there yet. I finally felt welcomed and loved, despite the fact that I soon went to Mass alone, sat alone, and was unable to receive communion, in a way that was unlike anything I had ever felt before. Pentecostal churches made me feel like I should be buying a sham-wow (sorry, but thats how I felt) and baptist churches felt like a courthouse without any authority. Non-denominational churches were too wishy washy and too “everyone is correct in their own way”. Christ did not say that there are many paths to God. He said there is ONE way.
I suppose that you could count all the other reasons everyone else has given as my own as well. And you could count the myriad of Catholics who have lead me down this path by example. But these are five of the reasons that I became Catholic and I thank God for bringing me home. And I thank God for people like you. The people whose stories I read here, and whose apologies (in the explanation sense) help me to deepen and explain my faith.

Thank you all for being here and thank you for providing a place like this!!!
 
I love this thread!!! * * * Thank you all for being here and thank you for providing a place like this!!!
Agreed! This is one of the most inspirational threads I’ve read in a while, especially these last few posts, I mean wow! :grouphug:
 
Would be interested in a concise list of your reasons…anyone?
  1. God made me. 😃
  2. Unity in doctrine, no matter which parish you attend. (One Holy, Catholic Church) which brings me to #3…
  3. Same doctrines for 2000 years. (Apostolic)
  4. The Eucharist.
  5. Liturgical worship. sigh
 
1 Beauty of the some churches
2 Beauty of the Liturgy

Those brought me towards the Church, great apologist and their books brought me into the Church.

It just pains me to go into a modern design parish thats ugly and to hear priests mess with the liturgy by ad-libing. But what can I do but pray.
 
Would be interested in a concise list of your reasons…anyone?

Here are 41:​

  • The 40 Martyrs of England & Wales (1535-1680)
  • the realisation that before 1535, England & Wales had been part of the Roman Church
Neither reason is impregnable - but they do count for something, such as they are.
 
Agreed! This is one of the most inspirational threads I’ve read in a while, especially these last few posts, I mean wow! :grouphug:
Agreed again! Thanks so much everyone…really interesting and inspirational stuff.
:blessyou:
 
I joined Easter of 2008 after fighting it for many years. My reasons:
  1. One - Unity under the Pope, as established in Matthew 16:18. Unity with the early church in respect to unchanging doctrines regarding matters such as divorce, abortion, and birth control.
  2. Holy - Mary, the Apostles, and the countless saints through the ages. The scriptures which have come to us through the Church. The Eucharist and other sacraments. This list could go on forever.
  3. Catholic - Universal. The Catholic Church is the same throughout the world and throughout time.
  4. Apostolic - After growing up wandering through the endless maze of protestant churches, each with the “clear meaning of scripture” being taught, I couldn’t take it anymore. I yearned for a connection to the original church. I found it in the Catholic Church.
  5. Gregorian Chant. OK, this is going to surprise some people but I just simply adore it. It has a quality to it which transforms me. I wish it were more widely practiced in today’s church. I’m thankful to live in an area where I can enjoy it each week if I want.
 
Five reasons why I became Catholic, in no particular order:
  1. Discovering the Church Fathers, beginning with St. Ignatius of Antioch who, writing around 105 AD, clearly believed in the Real Presence in the Eucharist and the absolute authority of the bishop. As an Evangelical Protestant, I had only a vague sense of these holy Christians, and had never read anything they wrote. Once I began to pour over their writings, my Protestantism was extinguished. Incidentally, my confirmation name is Ignatius, after Ignatius of Antioch. Hence my handle here as well.
  2. My wife’s prayers. She is a cradle Catholic who, unbeknownst to me, had unceasingly prayed for my conversion. As a Protestant, I admired Catholics (in fact, I often wished I had been raised as a Catholic, as I don’t think I made a very good Evangelical!), but I figured they were just “another” Christian tradition. As a Protestant, I remember being mildly surprised when my wife said she would be hurt if our children someday converted to Protestantism (I had agreed to raise our children Catholic, of course). Now I get it. I can’t imagine leaving the Church.
  3. The Eucharist. Once I believed in it, I couldn’t wait to become Catholic. I wish I could have skipped the entire RCIA process.
  4. Scott Hahn. It was one of his books that opened the door for me to seriously investigate the claims of Catholicism. A couple of years ago, I began to worry what our young children would begin to think when they went up to receive Holy Communion with my wife while I sat behind (and went to a different Church after Mass to boot). For years I thought that I should try to determine, once and for all, who was right and who was wrong, but the process just seemed so daunting (I mean, people much smarter than me had been split over this for hundreds of years – like I was going to solve the riddle?). Well, thinking about my children convinced me that I had to at least try. Within weeks of devouring Catholic books (e.g., Scott Hahn, Karl Adam, John Henry Newman), the writings of the early Church Fathers, and past issues of This Rock magazine, my Protestant wall was crumbling, and within a few months I was totally converted.
  5. Based on all the data – scriptural and historical – I concluded that the Roman Catholic Church has the best claim to being the true Church. My confidence in this conclusion has only increased over time. All the so-called defeaters of Catholicism (e.g., the Immaculate Conception, purgatory, praying to saints) can be adequately explained from Scripture and Tradition, and the evidence in favor of many of Rome’s claims (e.g., the sacraments, the Real Presence, baptismal regeneration, apostolic succession, the visible Church, the primacy of Rome, etc.) is simply overwhelming.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top