D
dogtorbill
Guest
This is my first post and first thread.
I am a 50 year old cradle Catholic with what I had considered a very strong, unshakable faith. I listen to EWTN daily and make a yearly Ignatian retreat. I have five children.
Three months ago, my 19 year old son was tragically killed in an accident while studying in China. A daughter and I went to retrieve him, much like the last movie we watched together, “The Way.” (please watch this movie) He was a beautiful Christ filled young man, unlike most of his contemporaries - a truth seeker who enjoyed Mass, Adoration and serving God. Our last journey together was 2 months before he left, when we went to Haiti on a mission.
I have many questions, but three are consuming. How do we as Catholics reconcile the statement of “God’s Plan?” Was he brought into this world with the Providential plan that he would slip and fall to his death? Or did he truly have free will to make the dumb decision to climb in the first place? Just seems to me a real waste of a huge amount of effort to form this wonderful person, who was just beginning to touch his contemporaries in awesome ways - how many lives/souls could he have saved in the next 70 years?
I suppose we can all recall many, many times in our lives when we really should have died, many times doing dumber things than my son - and thanked our “Guardian Angel,” or decided the “Lord must have more plans for me,” or whatever. Does that mean He had no plans for my own son? Do guardian angels even exist? Seems unlikely today.
And if God causes all to happen, how do we reconcile this “all loving God” we worship with natural disasters, crimes, and suffering, etc. So, “today” this is my theology:
I have decided God is omniscient, knowing all that will happen, all the calamities we will experience, all of our choices that we make, and allows us to make our own choices, and judging us by them. - But this does not support “God’s loving hand orchestrating all.”
Question two. Do our beloved departed appearing in dreams, etc. really represent “apparations,” or special messages for us? Has the Church addressed this?
And why are some people “blessed” with this phenomenon, but not others, often excluding those most desiring that “message.” Part two of this second question concerns meeting with genuine spiritual advisors. I’ve been told that this is forbidden because we lack the ability to discern good vs evil spirit communications. Can’t the case be made that we open ourselves up to this while in deep contemplative prayer?
Question three:“Lord I do believe, help my unbelief.” I truly feel that I am living the opera song by Helen Sjöholm - You Have To Be There (youtube it); which basically says, "What the heck? Why would you let this happen? What am I doing wrong? but then again, I vow to continue, because - “Lord, where would we go?” Basically Pascal’s wager.
Thanks for everyone’s help. I hope I’ve posted this correctly! Is this the best forum? Should I also cross post to a different forum? Much Love.
I am a 50 year old cradle Catholic with what I had considered a very strong, unshakable faith. I listen to EWTN daily and make a yearly Ignatian retreat. I have five children.
Three months ago, my 19 year old son was tragically killed in an accident while studying in China. A daughter and I went to retrieve him, much like the last movie we watched together, “The Way.” (please watch this movie) He was a beautiful Christ filled young man, unlike most of his contemporaries - a truth seeker who enjoyed Mass, Adoration and serving God. Our last journey together was 2 months before he left, when we went to Haiti on a mission.
I have many questions, but three are consuming. How do we as Catholics reconcile the statement of “God’s Plan?” Was he brought into this world with the Providential plan that he would slip and fall to his death? Or did he truly have free will to make the dumb decision to climb in the first place? Just seems to me a real waste of a huge amount of effort to form this wonderful person, who was just beginning to touch his contemporaries in awesome ways - how many lives/souls could he have saved in the next 70 years?
I suppose we can all recall many, many times in our lives when we really should have died, many times doing dumber things than my son - and thanked our “Guardian Angel,” or decided the “Lord must have more plans for me,” or whatever. Does that mean He had no plans for my own son? Do guardian angels even exist? Seems unlikely today.
And if God causes all to happen, how do we reconcile this “all loving God” we worship with natural disasters, crimes, and suffering, etc. So, “today” this is my theology:
I have decided God is omniscient, knowing all that will happen, all the calamities we will experience, all of our choices that we make, and allows us to make our own choices, and judging us by them. - But this does not support “God’s loving hand orchestrating all.”
Question two. Do our beloved departed appearing in dreams, etc. really represent “apparations,” or special messages for us? Has the Church addressed this?
And why are some people “blessed” with this phenomenon, but not others, often excluding those most desiring that “message.” Part two of this second question concerns meeting with genuine spiritual advisors. I’ve been told that this is forbidden because we lack the ability to discern good vs evil spirit communications. Can’t the case be made that we open ourselves up to this while in deep contemplative prayer?
Question three:“Lord I do believe, help my unbelief.” I truly feel that I am living the opera song by Helen Sjöholm - You Have To Be There (youtube it); which basically says, "What the heck? Why would you let this happen? What am I doing wrong? but then again, I vow to continue, because - “Lord, where would we go?” Basically Pascal’s wager.
Thanks for everyone’s help. I hope I’ve posted this correctly! Is this the best forum? Should I also cross post to a different forum? Much Love.
