Copyright law and homework

  • Thread starter Thread starter McatholicN
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How should citations be given then? Just slap some sources on a bibliography page? Put an in-text citation next to every fact?

I’m doing a report on something I don’t know much about, so most of the substance is going to be facts I got from sources. How do I avoid sinning by breaking the law here?
What level of schooling is this for? That will likely affect how much information your teacher wants. If you’re not sure, ask your teacher.

Do you know what style formatting your teacher wants? MLA and APA are probably the most common.

www.mlahandbook.org/

apastyle.org/

The books reviews copyright and plagiarism and how to avoid problems. I’m not certain of the online sources but I suspect they probably go over it as well.
 
Remember, demonstrating your learning by repeating facts is not breaking copyright. Neither is using a short excerpt from someone else’s work in order to illustrate or back up a point you’re making in your own work. Academics do that all the time.

When I was at school I was taught not to copy, but write things out in my own words. At that point you cannot possibly be breaking copyright and sinning, otherwise ALL learning would be breaking copyright and sinning, and that’s certainly not the case.
 
Remember, demonstrating your learning by repeating facts is not breaking copyright. Neither is using a short excerpt from someone else’s work in order to illustrate or back up a point you’re making in your own work. Academics do that all the time.

When I was at school I was taught not to copy, but write things out in my own words. At that point you cannot possibly be breaking copyright and sinning, otherwise ALL learning would be breaking copyright and sinning, and that’s certainly not the case.
But you still have to give citations for things that you put in your own words, right? Isn’t the only exception common knowledge? Most of my report will come from sources, so is that going to mean I’ll have to litter the paper with citations? Would I still be breaking some plagiarism law even if I give the citations?

I don’t think that my teacher expects much for a bibliography, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that It wouldn’t be breaking the law.
 
But you still have to give citations for things that you put in your own words, right? Isn’t the only exception common knowledge? Most of my report will come from sources, so is that going to mean I’ll have to litter the paper with citations? Would I still be breaking some plagiarism law even if I give the citations?

I don’t think that my teacher expects much for a bibliography, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that It wouldn’t be breaking the law.
Check out the links I gave; they really ought to go over stuff. The MLA one has a section called “Plagiarism and Academic Integrity.”

Additionally, Duke University Libraries explains, (library.duke.edu/research/citing/)
"Whenever you quote, paraphrase, summarize, or otherwise refer to the work of another, you are required to cite its source, either by way of parenthetical citation or by means of a footnote, as well as a complete reference in a bibliography. "
 
So citation is needed for every fact or paraphrase/summary (according to The Watcher’s last link). Would it still be illegal in some way to use such information, even if you gave citation.
 
Also, do I have to use an official style of citation or can I just put a spuerscript number next to each fact leading to the source in the bibiliography?
 
How should citations be given then? Just slap some sources on a bibliography page? Put an in-text citation next to every fact?

I’m doing a report on something I don’t know much about, so most of the substance is going to be facts I got from sources. How do I avoid sinning by breaking the law here?
Ask your teacher. That’s all you have to do.

Peace,
Ed
 
If you’re paraphrasing, you’re most definitely not breaking copyright, since literary copyright consists of the precise wording of the original author and copyright cannot subsist in pure facts.

You don’t need to cite the source if you’re paraphrasing what you read in a designated text book.

Depending on the level at which you’re being taught, you might be expected to include a bibliography so your tutors can see where you got your information from, but not including it is not sinful. You might get marked down, but you wouldn’t be sinning.

I think you’re being exceptionally scrupulous and also you should really be going to talk to your tutor about it rather than going round in circles here. Trust in the judgement of your teachers.
 
If you’re paraphrasing, you’re most definitely not breaking copyright, since literary copyright consists of the precise wording of the original author and copyright cannot subsist in pure facts.
Could it be committing plagiarism, however?
 
I will give you a very definitive answer: Provide citations for absolutely everything that you are summarizing, paraphrasing, or quoting, and provide a reference for any fact that you did not know before starting the paper.

Is this overkill? Maybe. But you cannot go wrong with this system. Problem solved. If you do not like it, I highly recommend you speak to your teacher, who is no more fallible than we are.
 
Could it be committing plagiarism, however?
No.

Not in the slightest.

If recounting facts that you have learned from other people were plagiarism then every person on the planet would be plagiarising with pretty much every word they speak.

Plagiarism is the act of** copying** another person’s work** and passing it off as your own**. Since you will be doing neither, there is no problem.

You are going beyond scrupulosity here.
 
Is it legal to leave out a citation for a paraphrase of facts that I got from a source? How would one cite a paraphrase? Is citation always necessary? Even on tests or talking about something with a friend five years after you learned the fact?

When is it actually legal to quote a source?

I am so frustrated! It seems I’ll have to fail all my classes to avoid sinning by breaking plagiarism and copyright law!

:eek:
 
Grr… this is so frustrating!

Please help! What can I do? :bighanky:
 
Is it legal to leave out a citation for a paraphrase of facts that I got from a source? How would one cite a paraphrase? Is citation always necessary? Even on tests or talking about something with a friend five years after you learned the fact?

When is it actually legal to quote a source?

I am so frustrated! It seems I’ll have to fail all my classes to avoid sinning by breaking plagiarism and copyright law!

:eek:
If you are paraphrasing, you are putting it into your own words. No in text citation is necessary.

Citations are not necessary on test as a general rule.

If you are talking about a subject with a friend after you learned the fact, you do not need to cite sources!! When have you EVER heard people citing sources during a friendly conversation? People may say, “I heard on the news that …” Five years later, you might be saying, “Remember that class with Mr. Jones and that paper we wrote on puppies biting their tails? That was so interesting. My dog does not bite his tail at all.” You would not have to cite your sources on where you got information on puppies biting their tales during your conversation.

You MUST talk to your teachers. Have you taken a writing class? If not, please do so. Also, discuss this scrupulosity with your confessor.

See below for examples:

Here is the original article:
*33 whales shot in New Zealand after rescues failed
Associated Press – 1 hr 52 mins ago
WELLINGTON, New Zealand (AP) — Conservation staff in New Zealand have put down 33 stranded whales after several attempts to refloat them failed. The pilot whales shot Thursday were the last of 99 that stranded themselves Monday on Farewell Spit on the South Island. Department of Conservation area manager John Mason says staff and hundreds of volunteers had tried all week to get the whales refloated. He says they thought they were successful Wednesday when they got the whales into deep water — but were saddened Thursday to find that they had swum back ashore. He says the condition of the whales had significantly deteriorated.
As well as the 33 whales that were shot, 36 had died naturally since Monday and 17 were successfully refloated. Thirteen remain unaccounted for.
Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Copyright © 2012 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved. | Yahoo! - ABC News Network | / *

If I wrote this in a paper, I would have to cite my source:
“Conservation staff in New Zealand have put down 33 stranded whales after several attempts to refloat them failed.” I would have to attribute it to the Yahoo cite. news.yahoo.com/33-whales-shot-zealand-rescues-failed-013504738.html

If I paraphrased and wrote it like this, I am putting it in my own words:
“Several people working with wildlife in New Zealand had to euthanize 33 pilot whales that were stranded and were not able to be rescued.” That is not plagiarism, but generally at the end of papers, you write a bibliography. You would include the source there.

If you met with a friend and said, “Hey, did you hear about those whales in New Zealand? 33 had to be euthanized,” you might mention you read it on Yahoo, but you would not have to recite the exact web address.

If on a test, a question was “Write what you know about stranded whales in New Zealand,” you would write what you know. You might say, “I read in a Yahoo new article that whales were stranded and euthanized.” You again would not need to cite the exact address on a test. No teacher is going to expect you to have memorized the exact source details.
 
If you are paraphrasing, you are putting it into your own words. No in text citation is necessary.
It seems all the websites I read claim that it is necessary: umuc.edu/cip/vail/students/citation/quote.html

This is rather urgent right now because I have a lot of points at stake and the semester ends today. I’m supposed to do a worksheet where I answer questions from the book and answer more questions from a different source. I cited direct quotes but not paraphrases.

Would it be legal to say at the bottom something along the lines of: “most of this information came partially from the textbook”?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top