Could Mormons practice polygamy in a country that doesn't forbid it>

  • Thread starter Thread starter benjammin
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

benjammin

Guest
I heard an expert on Mormonism say they don’t find polygamy wrong, they just don’t practice it out of respect for Civil Law in countries that forbid it. But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?
 
I heard an expert on Mormonism say they don’t find polygamy wrong, they just don’t practice it out of respect for Civil Law in countries that forbid it. But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?
The LDS Church abstains from the practice of polygamy because it has been officially prohibited by the LDS Church. It is not something they avoid simply because of secular laws; however it has not been completely removed from Mormon theology, since a man can still be sealed to multiple women if he remarries after the death of a spouse, whereas women cannot be sealed to more than one man.
 
I heard an expert on Mormonism say they don’t find polygamy wrong, they just don’t practice it out of respect for Civil Law in countries that forbid it. But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?
The question should not be “could Mormons practice polygamy” but “should Mormons practice polygamy.” Polygamy is a mortal sin.
 
The LDS Church abstains from the practice of polygamy because it has been officially prohibited by the LDS Church. It is not something they avoid simply because of secular laws
Yes, and the reason it was officially prohibited is due to pressure from secular law and the threat of disenfranchisement of the LDS Church.
 
I heard an expert on Mormonism say they don’t find polygamy wrong, they just don’t practice it out of respect for Civil Law in countries that forbid it. But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?
the LDS changed it’s teaching on polygamy right around the time Utah wanted to become a state. the fundamentalist LDS claim this was wrong and still try to practice it. Laws only recognize one spouse so even if they are “married” to others, the law only recognizes one spouse. The reality show Big Love which featured a man with 4 wives was about this issue. To avoid being persecuted, they moved to Nevada. Legally, Corey was married to the first wife only. This comes into play upon his death when the laws of inheritance would be followed. That is why there has been such a push to change marriage laws to allow homosexual marriages. Polygamy which is considered less socially acceptable is not far behind. Reality shows like Big Love was to make it more acceptable.
 
the LDS changed it’s teaching on polygamy right around the time Utah wanted to become a state. the fundamentalist LDS claim this was wrong and still try to practice it. Laws only recognize one spouse so even if they are “married” to others, the law only recognizes one spouse. The reality show Big Love which featured a man with 4 wives was about this issue. To avoid being persecuted, they moved to Nevada. Legally, Corey was married to the first wife only. This comes into play upon his death when the laws of inheritance would be followed. That is why there has been such a push to change marriage laws to allow homosexual marriages. Polygamy which is considered less socially acceptable is not far behind. Reality shows like Big Love was to make it more acceptable.
Actually, the TLC series that you are referencing is called “Sister wives.”

“Big Love” was an HBO drama that focused on polygamy in the LDS religion.
 
I heard an expert on Mormonism say they don’t find polygamy wrong, they just don’t practice it out of respect for Civil Law in countries that forbid it. But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?
A couple of years ago I was hearing from Catholics serving in African countries, where tribal beliefs and practices include polygamy, that Mormon converts were not required to end their polygamous relationships in order to convert.

So, I asked this same question on a Mormon forum and received no definitive answer. Some LDS members who responded believed polygamy was not allowed anywhere. Others thought that a Mormon convert who had more than one wife would be allowed to remain polygamous. I couldn’t find any official stance at lds.org.

Historically, the LDS church put out a manifesto, officially ending the practice of polygamy. Within the LDS church itself, at this time, some leaders believed it only applied to Mormons living in the U.S. Polygamous marriages continued to be performed by the LDS church for a few more years after the manifesto, in Mexico and Canada. When pushed on the issue, by the U.S. federal govt., they issued a second manifesto that declared polygamy in the Mormon church could not be practiced anywhere.

The existing polygamous relationships continued until all parties involved had died. Because of this, I suspect that polygamous Mormon converts outside of the U.S. continue in their polygamous relationships, but cannot enter into any more marriages than they have/had at the time of their conversion to Mormonism.
 
A couple of years ago I was hearing from Catholics serving in African countries, where tribal beliefs and practices include polygamy, that Mormon converts were not required to end their polygamous relationships in order to convert.

So, I asked this same question on a Mormon forum and received no definitive answer. Some LDS members who responded believed polygamy was not allowed anywhere. Others thought that a Mormon convert who had more than one wife would be allowed to remain polygamous. I couldn’t find any official stance at lds.org.

Historically, the LDS church put out a manifesto, officially ending the practice of polygamy. Within the LDS church itself, at this time, some leaders believed it only applied to Mormons living in the U.S. Polygamous marriages continued to be performed by the LDS church for a few more years after the manifesto, in Mexico and Canada. When pushed on the issue, by the U.S. federal govt., they issued a second manifesto that declared polygamy in the Mormon church could not be practiced anywhere.

The existing polygamous relationships continued until all parties involved had died. Because of this, I suspect that polygamous Mormon converts outside of the U.S. continue in their polygamous relationships, but cannot enter into any more marriages than they have/had at the time of their conversion to Mormonism.
In these same contries, converts to Catholicism who are in polygamous relationships must agree that only their first marriage is valid in the eyes of the Church. They are not allowed to continue living with the other wives as husband and wife, but are required to support them and all of their children. Seems to make more sense.
 
Actually, the TLC series that you are referencing is called “Sister wives.”

“Big Love” was an HBO drama that focused on polygamy in the LDS religion.
Thanks, I had a brain freeze at the time. I didn’t watch either but have seen interviews with Corey and his wives.
 
I heard an expert on Mormonism say they don’t find polygamy wrong, they just don’t practice it out of respect for Civil Law in countries that forbid it. But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?
Actually, I was surprised to find there exists a Christian movement for polygamy. I fear that with the passage of same sex marriage laws, polygamy will be come legal. They have a stronger case for marriage than gays, in my humble opinion.

Just google Christain Polygamy
 
Mormons do not disavow polygamy. They disavow the PRACTICE of it because of the problems it caused them.
 
On the LDS.org website you can find this statement:

“More than a century ago God clearly revealed unto His prophet Wilford Woodruff that the practice of plural marriage should be discontinued, which means that it is now against the law of God. Even in countries where civil or religious law allows polygamy, the Church teaches that marriage must be monogamous and does not accept into its membership those practicing plural marriage.”
lds.org/ensign/1998/11/what-are-people-asking-about-us?lang=eng
 
Actually, the TLC series that you are referencing is called “Sister wives.”

“Big Love” was an HBO drama that focused on polygamy in the LDS religion.
The sister wives are from a different sect of Mormonism not connected with the main line. They are called the FLDS or Fundamentalist LDS.
Mormons do not disavow polygamy. They disavow the PRACTICE of it because of the problems it caused them.
Exactly, A seminarian in our diocese is the son of a Mormon bishop and clarified the practice to us. Mormons believe in multiple levels of heaven and the top is called exaltation. To be exalted means to be installed as your own supreme god of another planet. The criteria for this level is polygamy and at least 5 successfully reproducing offsprings. Other lower levels would be non-polygamy. People in the process of conversion. Non temple worthy Mormons. And a limbo like state of all worthy Christians (Catholics not include automatic Hell for us :D)
 
I think ANYONE can practice polygamy where it is not prohibited by law, not just Mormans. 🤷
 
I think ANYONE can practice polygamy where it is not prohibited by law, not just Mormans. 🤷
The OP’s question was, “But say A mormon moved to a country that didn’t forbid it. Then according to the Rules of the LDS church would they be okay to practice polygamy?”

And the answer, according to the LDS website, is no.
 
The LDS Church abstains from the practice of polygamy because it has been officially prohibited by the LDS Church. It is not something they avoid simply because of secular laws; however it has not been completely removed from Mormon theology, since a man can still be sealed to multiple women if he remarries after the death of a spouse, whereas women cannot be sealed to more than one man.
Could you explain the sealed thing for me? I remember reading about the guy who abducted the young girl…
…Then claimed what he sealed on earth was sealed in heaven.
…But the guy already had a wife as I remember.
 
Brigham Young clearly taught that polygamy was required for exaltation, as the Mormon God the father has multiple wives. However, this is another one of those Brigham Young teachings that modern LDS now call “opinion”, and have replaced with “official statements” posted to LDS.org that say otherwise.
 
My understanding from a couple of decades ago is that the current “prophet” would have to re-instate it. Probably have to proclaim it as some revelation.

That being said, there are LDS men who are alive right now who are sealed to more than one woman. IE his wife dies, and he marries another.

I do believe 2 members of the Quorum of the 12 are in such a situation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top