Could not feel like participating in Shouting prayers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter sepgs2004
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

sepgs2004

Guest
Mostly Catholic Churches does not do this continuous shouting prayers. Many of my family (relative) members are divided in Assembly of God, Pentecost, Seventh Day Adventist, etc.
Sometimes, due to benevolence act, I end up going to prayer meetings with them.
I tried my best to mix in the shouting prayer.

Example: Last week, there was a pentecostal prayer meeting. I was happy while listening to the preaching. Then the Pastor and the group started the shouting prayer. The bible verse, the pastor took to fuel the loudness are, the words from Luke 18:38, where a blind man shouts - “And he cried out, saying: Jesus, son of David, have mercy on me”.
Pastor kind of indirectly putting all those, who are not loud enough, to a guilty state, by saying: are you reserved to call out the Lord, etc?

I still think, something is inappropriate, at least to my personal soul. Please pardon me if I am wrong. My kind God, please give me wisdom.

Here are my thoughts:
Taking those words from Luke 18:38 - our Lord Jesus was physically present in flesh in the crowd. This poor blind man, being blind first, and somehow realized there is a huge crowd surrounding our Lord with lots of noise may be, he might have thought, Jesus may not be able to hear his calling for help. So he cried out louder.
Now when we are sitting in a group that prays and to pray, will the same situation arise?
I mean, can not our Lord hear all of our and my audible prayers at the same time?, when we are amongst a group of prayers.
Why do we want our prayer to stand out by crying out loud? Are we drawing our Lord’s attention towards our-self from others? I do not know.

At the same time, I ask myself to shut down from thinking on this too much, and be the way I am in prayers, etc.

Please share your thoughts.
 
I mean, can not our Lord hear all of our and my audible prayers at the same time, when we are amongst a group of prayers.
Why do we want our prayer to stand out by crying out loud? Are we drawing our Lord’s attention towards our-self from others? I do not know.
You are correct in believing that God knows our silent as well as our verbal prayers.
I believe you are also correct in believing that the blind man shouted to be heard over the crowd of people. He couldn’t see Jesus so perhaps shouted the louder to be heard over the clamour of people.

Jeremiah 17:10 “I the LORD search the heart and examine the mind, to reward a man according to his conduct, according to what his deeds deserve.”

If God can do this how can we doubt that God hears even our most hidden prayers.

1 John 3:20 “even if our own feelings condemn us, that God is greater than our feelings and knows all things.”

Remember Psalm 139

“Lord, you examine me and know me,
2 you know when I sit, when I rise, you understand my thoughts from afar.
3 You watch when I walk or lie down, you know every detail of my conduct.
4 A word is not yet on my tongue before you, Lord God, know all about it.
5 You fence me in, behind and in front, you have laid your hand upon me.
6 Such amazing knowledge is beyond me, a height to which I cannot attain.
7 Where shall I go to escape your spirit? Where shall I flee from your presence?
8 If I scale the heavens you are there, if I lie flat in Sheol, there you are.
9 If I speed away on the wings of the dawn, if I dwell beyond the ocean,
10 even there your hand will be guiding me, your right hand holding me fast.
11 I will say, ‘Let the darkness cover me, and the night wrap itself around me,’
12 even darkness to you is not dark, and night is as clear as the day.
13 You created my inmost self, knit me together in my mother’s womb.
14 For so many marvels I thank you; a wonder am I, and all your works are wonders. You knew me through and through,
15 my being held no secrets from you, when I was being formed in secret, textured in the depths of the earth.
16 Your eyes could see my embryo. In your book all my days were inscribed, every one that was fixed is there.
17 How hard for me to grasp your thoughts, how many, God, there are!
18 If I count them, they are more than the grains of sand; if I come to an end, I am still with you.
19 If only, God, you would kill the wicked!-Men of violence, keep away from me!-
20 those who speak blasphemously about you, and take no account of your thoughts.
21 Yahweh, do I not hate those who hate you, and loathe those who defy you?
22 My hate for them has no limits, I regard them as my own enemies.
23 God, examine me and know my heart, test me and know my concerns.
24 Make sure that I am not on my way to ruin, and guide me on the road of eternity.”

But why are you going to services where you can be spiritually misled? As a Catholic, Mass, Adoration, Rosary, visits to the Blessed Sacrament, Catholic prayer groups…
God’s most kind and loving blessings to you
🙂
 
I still think, something is inappropriate, at least to my personal soul. Please pardon me if I am wrong. My kind God, please give me wisdom.

Please share your thoughts.
Those pentecostal denominations rely far too much on emotions. Relying on feelings can eventually lead to loss of faith when the continuous spiritual/emotional “highs” wear off. There has to be something deeper and more stable.

As Trishie says: God knows our silent prayers. In fact, He knows all of us better than we know ourselves.
 
Nothing wrong with praying silently, praying loudly, or anything in between.

I prefer silent prayer myself, so I probably would have done what you did too.
 
One can be brought to the Lord by groups that pray vocally, but growth and spiritual maturity comes from silent, listening prayer.
 
sepgs2004,

You are not wrong…And truly, neither are they…Just different.

Each person is drawn to that style of worship that brings them closer to God.
Yours seems to be more quiet and contemplative. Good for you. 👍

Other people are more boisterous - out going and indeed want to “shout”. This to can be good…

Of course there are always dangers and as you point out it can be more about a person drawing attention to themselves than to God…but this can be true in quiet prayer as well as in “shouting” prayer.

About all I can tell you is that if the spirit does not move you to pray in this way, then don’t.
While the example of the blind man shouting is a fine example, so is the example of the woman with the hemorrhage (Mt 9:20-21)
And behold, a woman who had suffered from a hemorrhage for twelve years came up behind him and touched the fringe of his garment; for she said to herself, “If I only touch his garment, I shall be made well.”
She did not shout, or call out in any way, but simply and quietly drew close to Him so that she could touch, just His garment…

So - do not be too hard on your bothers in Christ for their exuberance. Just recognize that their way of practice is not yours…

Peace
James
 
Those pentecostal denominations rely far too much on emotions. Relying on feelings can eventually lead to loss of faith when the continuous spiritual/emotional “highs” wear off. There has to be something deeper and more stable.

As Trishie says: God knows our silent prayers. In fact, He knows all of us better than we know ourselves.
I agree with this. But I do wish to recognize that diversity with which God has bestowed on His Church. God has contemplative children and He also has boisterous children. This is why I am glad that His Catholic Church is large enough to encompass both ends and still provide the deep and stable aspects that you mention above.

Peace
James
 
Good point.
i suppose if theyre all shouting and carrying on, no one of them is any worse than the others. :shrug: Not my thing, though. Wheres the reverence…the sense of awe in the presence of God?
The reverence, the sense of awe in the presence of God is the Catholic Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.
 
The reverence, the sense of awe in the presence of God is the Catholic Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.
As long as it`s not turned into a circus, at which point it can become a celebration of self, and/or loss of self-control. :eek:

Anyway, i cant stand that stuff, and theres no point in pretending otherwise. 🤷
 
I think it is important to take a close look at the motive behind both the blind man and the pentecostals.

From the perspective of the blind man, we can see the reason that he was so vocal in his calling of the Lord stems from the very practical desire for the Lord to come to his aid. He calls to Christ despite the crowd trying to hush him up because he trusts in Jesus to help him. It seems to me that he was not calling to the Lord for the benefit of the bystanders but in spite of the bystanders.

In the case of the pentecostals, we have established that Jesus says that the father hears you in secret. Thus it seems that there are only two to cry out loudly to the Lord in the manner that was advocated. For the benefit of ones own emotions, or for the beneifit of bystanders. In the case of the latter, it seems that there is an objective danger in this approach towards making oneself like the Pharisees. Of course there could be legitimate reasons for public praying that others might see, indeed the most central prayer we have as Catholics is expressed as a public act in the mass. However when a desire to be seen by others whilst praying is combined with what might be labelled attention seeking behaviour, one has a dangerous recipe for pride.

In the case of the latter, that is for the benefit of one’s emotion. Once again this could be legetimate. However, this approach is troubling to me for two reasons. Emotions can obviously be used for both good and bad. As Augustine says, “They are evil if our love is evil; good if our love is good”. However, as the rational intellect is higher than the emotional intellect, it seems that it is a misordering of the intellect to stir and provoke our emotional intellect and to redirect our thought process away from the rational intellect. Furthermore it seems that it is shallow to do this as the emotive intellect arises naturally from our rational intellect from when we see good or evil. To deliberately arouse the emotional intellect is to break this natural bond and to make it artificial.

The second troublesome part of using prayer for the benefits of one’s own emotion is that the center of all prayer should be God and an emptying out of one’s self. It seems to me that there is the danger of prayer becoming self-centric rather than self emptying. This is not to say that emotion has no place in prayer, far from it! However, as I alluded to before it must come naturally out of a intense love of a good rather than a self stimulated end in of itself. That is, the emotive intellect arises out of the rational intellect directed a purposes of further driving the rational intellect. It should not be an end in of itself.
 
I think it is important to take a close look at the motive behind both the blind man and the pentecostals.

From the perspective of the blind man, we can see the reason that he was so vocal in his calling of the Lord stems from the very practical desire for the Lord to come to his aid. He calls to Christ despite the crowd trying to hush him up because he trusts in Jesus to help him. It seems to me that he was not calling to the Lord for the benefit of the bystanders but in spite of the bystanders.

In the case of the pentecostals, we have established that Jesus says that the father hears you in secret. Thus it seems that there are only two to cry out loudly to the Lord in the manner that was advocated. For the benefit of ones own emotions, or for the beneifit of bystanders. In the case of the latter, it seems that there is an objective danger in this approach towards making oneself like the Pharisees. Of course there could be legitimate reasons for public praying that others might see, indeed the most central prayer we have as Catholics is expressed as a public act in the mass. However when a desire to be seen by others whilst praying is combined with what might be labelled attention seeking behaviour, one has a dangerous recipe for pride.

In the case of the latter, that is for the benefit of one’s emotion. Once again this could be legetimate. However, this approach is troubling to me for two reasons. Emotions can obviously be used for both good and bad. As Augustine says, “They are evil if our love is evil; good if our love is good”. However, as the rational intellect is higher than the emotional intellect, it seems that it is a misordering of the intellect to stir and provoke our emotional intellect and to redirect our thought process away from the rational intellect. Furthermore it seems that it is shallow to do this as the emotive intellect arises naturally from our rational intellect from when we see good or evil. To deliberately arouse the emotional intellect is to break this natural bond and to make it artificial.

The second troublesome part of using prayer for the benefits of one’s own emotion is that the center of all prayer should be God and an emptying out of one’s self. It seems to me that there is the danger of prayer becoming self-centric rather than self emptying. This is not to say that emotion has no place in prayer, far from it! However, as I alluded to before it must come naturally out of a intense love of a good rather than a self stimulated end in of itself. That is, the emotive intellect arises out of the rational intellect directed a purposes of further driving the rational intellect. It should not be an end in of itself.
This is written well in regard to some forms of pentecostalism. Thank you.

From a Catholic position, may I respectfully point out that the Catholic Charismatic Renewal cannot be assumed to be the same as the charismatism/pentecostalism seen in other faith systems.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top